Key Takeaways
- Subdued demand, cautious tone: Revenue was pressured by a tepid retail environment as consumer spending shifted to travel and leisure, with management describing the outlook as "not so buoyant" and "very, very cautious."
- Margins held despite top-line miss: EBITDA margin of 18.6% was just shy of the 19-21% comfort zone, protected by lower fabric costs and operational expense control even as digital and marketing investments continued.
- Athleisure inventory overhang persists: Excess inventory across the industry, built up after a post-pandemic demand surge, is driving discounting and depressing ASPs, with the Athleisure correction expected to take longer than innerwear.
- Women's innerwear is the structural bet: Management is treating the category as an independent company within the company, targeting far lower penetration levels versus men's innerwear through dedicated innovation and marketing.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the Eid-linked Q4 demand lift materializes, the pace of distributor inventory normalization under the new ARS system, and any sign that Athleisure discounting intensity is structurally easing.
Demand Environment
- A weak quarter, bottoming late: October was tepid, festive and wedding demand concentrated in November, and December saw a noticeable bottoming out. The innerwear and Athleisure industry faced a decline in sales volume, with overall retail demand subdued as consumers prioritized travel and leisure spending.
- Consumer behavior tightened: Footfalls in exclusive brand outlets (EBOs) reduced generally, with only small recent improvements, and basket sizes shrank. Consumers are buying only what they need, while directing more discretionary spend toward luxury segments and easy-loan/EMI purchases.
- Premium held up better than entry-level: Men's innerwear showed growth, with premium products and multipacks outperforming economy and entry-level products, signaling value-seeking rather than pure down-trading.
- Q4 hopes are measured: Eid demand is factored into Q4 budgets, but management expects growth won't be as high as in past years because the market remains generally subdued. The current stance is to brace for the worst, control expenses, and protect margins.
V.S. Ganesh: "the current outlook is not so buoyant, and we are very, very cautious."
Inventory & Channel Health
- Excess inventory is an industry problem: The entire ecosystem is carrying high inventory due to competition, leading to discounting, liquidation, and clearance activity that impacts sales. The intensity was much higher in Q1 and Q2 and came down drastically in Q3.
- Athleisure is the pain point: After the pandemic, distribution and retail partners built inventory based on a sudden demand surge that has since faded. The Athleisure segment is taking longer to correct than innerwear, and the speed of normalization depends entirely on how fast demand picks up.
- Distributor inventory is not obsolete: The issue is the level of holding, not the age of stock. Year-to-date, the difference between primary and secondary sales performance is only about three days of inventory, an improvement management attributes to the newly implemented auto-replenishment system (ARS).
- ARS and distributor systems are the fix: The ARS is showing early improvement in distributor inventory levels and is on track. A much-improved distributor management system is also being implemented for better frontend supply chain visibility and real-time insights.
- No clearance fire sale: When asked whether management would take aggressive clearance measures, the company declined, stating it believes in sustainable growth and right practices, preferring system-based correction over short-term measures that would "boomerang back in the long term."
V.S. Ganesh: "we always believed in sustainable growth and we believe in the right practices. And we truly believe it is better that we take measures wherein the system helps to correct rather than taking short-term measures which may bring us immediate results because it will always boomerang back in the long term."
Margins & Cost Structure
- Margin held near the comfort zone: EBITDA margin of 18.6% was just shy of the 19-21% target band, impacted by investments in digital transformation and marketing but largely balanced by favorable fabric costs and operational expense optimization.
- Production costs are falling: Fresh fabric procured at lower cost, combined with significant production efficiency improvements, has reduced inventory cost per piece. New production over recent months is at a lower cost base, which should flow through as older, higher-cost inventory is consumed.
- Employee cost decline is structural, not volume-driven: The reduction in employee cost is not simply because production is lower. Operational efficiency has kicked in through smarter outsourcing, higher overall efficiencies, producing more with fewer people, and initiatives to reduce throughput times by more than three weeks from order to delivery.
- In-house manufacturing share rose: When demand was down, the company optimized operating costs by spreading assets. The percentage increase in in-house manufacturing is across categories, while outsourcing provides flexibility to gear up or down with demand.
- Pricing stability expected: Management sees no requirement for any price adjustments for the next month or even the next year, given current raw material cost trends. Only a tremendous increase in input costs would trigger a rethink.
V.S. Ganesh: "we are very comfortable at 19% to 21% zone and we are just shy of that."
Category & Channel Dynamics
- ASP decline is a mix story: Average selling price was down 4% YoY due to category mix, with the impact more pronounced in Athleisure. Aggressive expansion in Athleisure distribution led to a mix change that eroded ASP, compounded by final selling prices to consumers being much lower than stated MRP due to industry-wide discounting.
- MBO rationalization was planned: The drop in multi-brand outlet count from ~120,000 to 114,000 is a deliberate initiative, involving a minor drop in non-traditional outlets brought in during the pandemic plus some small outlets with lower throughput given subdued market conditions.
- EBO additions continue, women's stores consolidated: The reduction in women's exclusive stores from 78 to 62 reflects consolidation of stores operating near each other into single-roof Jockey outlets. Overall EBO additions remain on pace for 150-200 stores this fiscal year, though the quarterly run-rate slowed to 18 stores.
- EBO like-to-like growth is muted: Performance is more or less in line with overall modest volume growth, which management described as not encouraging.
- Online investment strategy unchanged: Management does not foresee a change in its approach to online channel investments.
Strategic Initiatives
- Women's innerwear as a standalone unit: Penetration levels in women's innerwear are far lower than in men's, creating a structural growth opportunity. The strategy is to treat it as an independent company within the company, with dedicated focus on new product introduction, innovation, and marketing investments.
- Karthik Yathindra appointed CMO: An eight-year veteran who was instrumental in launching Jockey Juniors, he now oversees marketing, product development, product management, and supply chain, and has additionally taken on sales functions.
- Supply chain digitization underway: Beyond ARS, a much-improved distributor management system is being implemented to deliver better frontend supply chain visibility, more robust processes, and real-time information.
- Sales incentives are seasonal, not abnormal: The level of sales incentives and schemes in Q3 is not disproportionately high; the quarter carries seasonal products with historically attached incentives, and the delta versus past years is not abnormal.
Karthik Yathindra: "The focus for this category and the strategy in treating it independent as a company of its own within the company is the strategy that we will be following to try and enhance our penetration levels within the women's innerwear market."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| EBITDA margin | Comfortable in the 19% to 21% zone | Ongoing |
| EBO additions | 150 to 200 new stores | Current fiscal year |
| Pricing | No price adjustments required | Next month to next year, barring a tremendous input cost increase |
| Athleisure inventory correction | Normalization depends on demand pickup; if current trajectory continues, it will become healthy | Conditional on demand recovery |
| Q4 demand | Growth won't be as high as in the past; market generally subdued | Q4 FY24 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ₹1,228.8 cr, +2.4% YoY |
| Sales volume | 5.52 cr pieces, +4.6% YoY |
| EBITDA | ₹235.2 cr, +19.1% YoY |
| EBITDA margin | 18.6% |
| PAT | ₹152.4 cr, +23.1% YoY |
| ASP | down 4% YoY, driven by category mix shift |
| Employee cost | declined 9% YoY, on operational efficiencies |
| E-commerce growth | ~39% in Q3; 28% YTD December |
| MBO network | over 110,000 outlets |
| EBO network | 1,394 stores; 18 added in Q3 |
| LFS network | 2,300-plus outlets |
| Exclusive women's outlets | 62, consolidated from 78 |
| In-house manufacturing mix | 80%, up from 70% |
| Capacity utilization | ~80%, same as pre-COVID levels |
| Distributor inventory | improved ~3 days from start of FY24 |
| Cash balance | ₹300 cr as of December '23 |