Key Takeaways
- Revenue surged, losses narrowed sharply: Revenue grew 89% YoY to ₹1,680 crores while EBITDA loss before ESOP improved by ₹93 crores QoQ, putting the company ahead of its six-quarter breakeven plan.
- Payments margin transformed: Net payments margin jumped from 17% to 35% YoY, driven by structural cost reductions, subscription revenue, and account rationalization, not one-offs.
- Lending scaled 9X YoY: Loan disbursements hit ₹5,554 crores, run-rating close to ₹24,000 crores annually, with stable asset quality and collection incentives now adding to take rates.
- Commerce rebounded, cloud softened: Commerce revenue grew 168% YoY on travel and entertainment recovery, while cloud advertising faced industry-wide headwinds from reduced marketing spends.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the UPI incentive gets recorded, the pace of lending growth as the base normalizes, and if advertising revenue begins to recover.
The Payments Margin Reset
- Net payments margin tripled: Improved from 17% a year ago to 35% this quarter (₹108 crores to ₹382 crores) because of higher MTU, subscription revenue growth, and a substantial reduction in payment processing costs.
- Processing costs dropped ₹80 crores QoQ: Driven by three structural factors: negotiations with banks to reduce rates for credit cards and other instruments, account rationalization for unprofitable online merchants, and an ongoing trend of customers adding money via UPI to the Paytm wallet which costs less.
- Systemic tailwind on credit card costs: Network schemes introduced lower interchange rates for certain merchant categories, causing overall MDR to drop; Paytm, as a large processor, commands better negotiated pricing and incentives from this shift.
- Account rationalization trade-off: The company shed ₹29 crores in quarterly revenue from unprofitable online merchants, which removed slightly more in payment processing cost, making the net payments margin math work.
- UPI P2M now profitable on a line-item basis: Government incentives and subsidies effectively make this MDR-bearing GMV, though zero incentive revenue was recorded this quarter because the final MeitY notification has not yet been received.
- Platform fee experiment succeeded: The company started charging a platform fee on select use cases where Paytm provides significant value; no consumer inertia was seen, and it has become a fairly decent revenue item, though management expects it to remain relatively small, not reaching a few ₹100 crores per quarter.
Deora: "There are no one offs in there. So you should not feel like hey, that 30 bps dropped down now at 23 basis points because of something that happened only in this quarter, and will not happen in the future. There is no such thing. These are structural opportunities that we saw to go and reduce some of our processing costs..."
Lending: Scale, Quality & Unit Economics
- Disbursements grew 56% QoQ to ₹5,554 crores: Growth was broad-based across personal loans, merchant loans, and postpaid, with the company now run-rating close to ₹24,000 crores annually.
- Personal loans scaled substantially QoQ: Predominantly came from postpaid customers who have matured more than six months on the platform and received lender approval.
- Merchant loans grew from ₹565 crores to ₹827 crores QoQ: This was the first quarter with no Covid impact in roughly five months; markets and shops were fully open and GMV grew strongly.
- Portfolio quality remained stable: Bounce rates and ECLs showed no material deterioration versus lender expectations; actual net credit losses ran below ECL ranges: personal loans sub-4%, merchant sub-5%, postpaid sub-1%. Postpaid bucket one resolution improved to the 90+ range.
- Take rate stabilized near 4–4.5%: Management does not expect significant improvement going forward, though collection incentives on prior-year books are running 100–200 bps better than expected, and could swing the take rate 25–50 bps QoQ.
- Collection incentives are a growing tailwind: Incentive income on the prior-year personal loan and merchant loan books is better than expected, based on the difference between lenders' loss expectations and actual static pool losses. As the large current-year book matures, this income stream should build.
Gupta: "My personal view is that it will only improve and not go down from where it stands today, just because our collection incentives will kick in on the back of very large business that we're doing this year into the next year."
Contribution Profit & the Path to Breakeven
- Contribution profit hit a record ₹726 crores: That is 43% of revenue, up from 35% last quarter and growing 200% YoY, driven by net payments margin improvement and operating leverage.
- EBITDA loss narrowed by ₹93 crores QoQ: Loss before ESOP fell to ₹275 crores from ₹368 crores, a 25% improvement, because contribution profit grew 35% QoQ while indirect expenses grew only 10%.
- Management says it is ahead of plan: A quarter ago, the company laid out a six-quarter path to EBITDA breakeven; this quarter's improvement puts it ahead of that trajectory, with breakeven still targeted by the September quarter next year.
- Incremental contribution margin runs around 50%: Per an analyst's math, management sees levers for gradual improvement through mix shift toward higher-margin financial services, commerce growth, and advertising recovery, even if net payment margins stay roughly at current levels.
- Employee costs rose 10% QoQ: Driven by appraisals and select investments in sales and technology teams; no significant headcount increases are expected going forward, though the sales team may grow 5–15% if device business performance warrants it.
- Marketing spend bumped up: The increase was almost entirely due to seasonal IPL sponsorship spend.
Deora: "A quarter ago we said we were at Rs. 368 crores and we said we are going to hit EBITDA breakeven in six quarters. So, compared to that we are ahead of plan in that sense."
Device & Merchant Ecosystem
- 0.38 crore devices deployed: Nearly 0.1 crore devices were added in the last three months, with subscription revenue continuing to grow as more devices go live.
- Merchant retention is improving: On the card machine side, retention cohorts are improving every quarter by about a percent; on Soundbox, retention is stable between 85% and 86%.
- Soundbox zero-rental offers are narrow, not broad: A very, very small percentage of merchants are being given zero-rental offers, linked to behavior and credit potential; this does not materially change rent per device generated today or in the future.
- Competition is not expected to dent subscription revenue: Management believes GMV through Soundbox will go up, installations will go up, and merchant lending outcomes will significantly go up, adding to the bottom line rather than hurting it.
Gupta: "I think that pricing is more of a marketing thing that we keep doing. At this point in time because of whatever competition sentiment is, it seems to have picked up in a manner where everybody's thinking that every Soundbox will become zero. That's not the case. A very, very small percentage of merchants are being given the offer from our perspective, because we want to value those merchants..."
Commerce, Cloud & New Initiatives
- Commerce revenue grew 168% YoY and 35% QoQ: Driven by resurgent travel demand after the Mini-Omicron wave in January and early February, plus a seasonally strong entertainment quarter with big movie releases.
- Cloud revenue grew 29% YoY but declined QoQ: Advertising saw industry-wide headwinds from reduced marketing spends, particularly from consumer internet companies; management is confident advertising revenue will recover over time.
- Credit card distribution is gaining momentum: A recent partnership with India's largest card issuer is driving strong traction on new card issuance, spend per active card, and activation; the business is expected to start adding material revenue and EBITDA to the cloud business on a quarter-on-quarter basis.
- EMI product in build: A product similar to contemporaries' personal credit card EMI use cases is currently being built and is expected to launch sometime this fiscal year.
- Commerce business gained share: The company gained share across flights, buses, trains and movie ticketing during the reopening.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| EBITDA breakeven | Achieve EBITDA breakeven before ESOP cost | September quarter next year (Q2 FY24) |
| Loan disbursement run-rate | Continue at ₹24,000 crores annual run-rate or better, especially merchant and personal loans | Ongoing |
| UPI incentive recognition | Record government UPI incentive revenue once final MeitY notification received | Q3 or Q4 FY23 |
| Payment processing cost | 23 bps level is structural with no one-offs; net payment margin uplift maintainable | Ongoing |
| Lending partnerships | Add more lending partners; announcements expected | This quarter and next quarter |
| EMI product launch | Launch credit-card-style EMI product | Sometime this fiscal year |
| Credit card contribution | Start adding material revenue and EBITDA to cloud business | Quarter-on-quarter basis |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue from operations | ₹1,680 cr, up 89% YoY and 9% QoQ |
| Contribution profit | ₹726 cr, 43% of revenue, up from 35% QoQ and 27% a year ago |
| EBITDA loss before ESOP cost | ₹275 cr, improved by ₹93 cr QoQ; 16% of revenue vs 37% a year ago |
| Net payments margin | 35%, up from 17% a year ago; ₹382 cr vs ₹108 cr a year ago |
| Value of loans disbursed | ₹5,554 cr, run-rating close to ₹24,000 cr; ~9X YoY, 56% QoQ growth |
| Financial services revenue | ₹271 cr, up from ₹55 cr a year ago; credit is 70–80% of this |
| Payment services to merchants revenue | ₹557 cr, up 67% YoY; includes ₹29 cr impact from account rationalization |
| Payment services to consumer revenue growth | 73% YoY |
| Commerce and cloud services revenue | ₹331 cr, up 64% YoY; commerce up 168% YoY and 35% QoQ; cloud up 29% YoY but down QoQ |
| Average monthly transacting users (MTU) | >7.5 cr as of June 2022, grew ~49% YoY |
| GMV | ₹3 lakh cr, doubled YoY (101% growth) |
| Payments devices deployed | 0.38 cr, 0.28 cr added in last 12 months, nearly 0.1 crore added in last 3 months |
| Personal loan disbursements | ₹1,344 cr in the quarter |
| Merchant loan disbursements | ₹827 cr, up from ₹565 cr QoQ |
| Personal loan bounce rate | 11–12% range |
| Postpaid bounce rate | 11–12% range |
| Postpaid bucket one resolution | 89–92%, vs 82–85% last quarter |
| Personal loan ECL | 4.5–5%, actual net credit loss sub 4% |
| Merchant loan ECL | 5–5.5%, actual net credit loss sub 5% |
| Soundbox retention | 85–86%, stable |
| Employee cost increase | 10% QoQ, due to appraisals and select investments in sales and technology teams |
| Payment processing charges | ₹694 cr, down ₹80 cr QoQ from ₹774 cr |
| UPI incentive recorded | Zero, pending final notification from MeitY |