One 97 Communications Ltd Q3 FY2024 Concall Summary & Transcript Notes

Source transcript PDF: https://www.stockscans.in/document/6cilg49226dxdt29e35n3xie.pdf

# 1. Financial Performance

## A. Key Figures
   * Revenue: 38% YoY growth
   *   **EBITDA before ESOP:** **₹219 Cr** (QoQ)
   *   **PAT:** **-₹222 Cr** (improved by ₹170 Cr YoY)
   *   **Other Operating Revenue:** **₹24 Cr** → **₹50 Cr** (+108% YoY)
   *   **Payment Processing Charges:** +~20% sequentially
   * Payment Processing Margin: 7-9 bps (-100 bps QoQ)

## B. Revenue Growth
   *   **Accelerating Top-Line Momentum:** Revenue growth accelerated to 38% YoY, supported by festive season tailwinds and sustained underlying demand across payment and non-payment segments.
   *   **Diversified Revenue Expansion:** Sharp increase in other operating revenues reflects strong traction in **device subscriptions and incentive-based income**, signaling monetization beyond core payments.
   *   **Revenue Recognition Pattern:** Upcoming revenue run-rate is expected to be **largely back-ended**, with a shift toward monthly recognition patterns influencing quarterly visibility.

## C. Profitability Trends
   *   **Margin Resilience Amid Seasonality:** Contribution margin expanded to 51%, demonstrating operating leverage despite seasonal pressures from higher cash back, payment margin compression, and events business scaling.
   *   **Core Payment Economics Intact:** Despite a QoQ dip in reported payment margin to 7 bps, **core processing margin remains stable in the 7–9 bps range**, excluding UPI incentives and promotional adjustments.
   *   **Path to Profitability Clear:** EBITDA before ESOP reached ₹219 Cr with consistent sequential improvement; management reiterates near-term **PAT positivity** as a key priority amid strong business momentum.

---

# 2. Payment & Lending Volume

## A. Key Figures
   *   **Net Payment Margin:** **₹748 Cr** (+63% YoY)
   *   **Merchant GMV:** **>₹5 Lakh Cr** (quarterly, first-time cross)
   *   **Loan Disbursements:** **₹15,500 Cr** (+56% YoY)
   *   **Credit Card Acquisitions:** **10 Lakh Users** (+125% YoY)
   *   **High-Ticket Loan Disbursements:** **₹490 Cr** (Q3, first disclosure)
   *   **Postpaid Disbursements Decline:** **50–60%** down from peak (Dec)

## B. GMV & Transaction Trends
   *   **Payments Momentum:** Strong GMV and net margin growth achieved despite absence of Q4 UPI incentives, reflecting resilient demand and platform monetization.
   *   **Festive Share Gains:** Tactical reduction in device rental rates boosted GMV and MDR capture, prioritizing ecosystem value over short-term rental income.
   *   **UPI Credit Card Inflection:** Early adoption of credit cards on UPI is robust, with **RuPay cards capturing dominant share** of new issuances and signaling major GMV upside potential.
   *   **Postpaid Contraction:** Decline in Postpaid disbursements has outpaced expectations, with **gross revenue impact material**, though offset by growth in other segments.

## C. Lending Platform Dynamics
   *   **Lending Scale & Diversification:** Loan disbursements grew strongly year-on-year, driven by personal and merchant loans, even as Postpaid volumes were deliberately calibrated with partners.
   *   **High-Ticket Loan Traction:** New high-ticket loan segment scaled rapidly from mid-Q2, with **disbursements exceeding ₹200 Cr in December** and low rejection rates, indicating strong product-market fit.
   *   **Lending Partner Expansion:** Platform adding **two new personal loan partners per quarter**, with strong interest from banks and NBFCs, supporting future loan book diversification and capacity.

## D. Credit Product Strategy
   *   **Strategic Pivot to High-Ticket Loans:** Future personal loan growth will be anchored in high-ticket loans, which are showing **strong momentum and better underwriting alignment** than low-ticket segments.
   *   **Merchant Loan Discipline:** Eligibility focused on device-using merchants with **minimum 6-month transaction history**, enhancing credit quality and portfolio resilience.
   *   **Portfolio Isolation:** High-ticket loans remain outside current incentive structures; **collection obligations exist**, but performance metrics will be reported as the book matures.

---

# 3. Merchant & User Metrics

## A. Key Figures
   *   **Deployed Devices:** **~1 Cr** base (~12–13 Lakh added last quarter) · **Normal run rate: 11–12 Lakh/quarter**
   *   **Merchant Subscriptions:** **14 Lakh** added this quarter (+INR 100/month per sub)
   * Monthly Transacting Users: 100 million (monetizable user focus)

## B. Device Deployment Strategy
   *   **Scaled & Sticky Network:** Near-1-crore device base shows strong adoption, with high retention despite competition—**only 1.5–2k monthly deactivations due to competitor swaps** out of 1 crore active devices.
   *   **Product-Led Differentiation:** Sound Box leadership driven by **superior performance** (early settlements, speed, reliability), not free pricing—merchants resist switching even for free alternatives.
   *   **Sustainable Growth Trajectory:** Confident in adding **4–5 million net new devices over next 4–5 quarters**, supported by in-house manufacturing and iterative product innovation in a crowded market of **19 rivals**.
   *   **Festive Bump Normalizing:** Recent **14–15 lakh device addition** was seasonally inflated; forward run rate remains robust at **11–12 lakh/quarter** on a large base.

## C. Merchant & User Monetization
   *   **Subscription Momentum:** Merchant subscription growth accelerating to **14 lakh additions** this quarter, reflecting increased platform stickiness and recurring revenue potential.
   *   **High-Quality Credit Funnel:** **50% of 6 crore device users** already whitelisted or loaned, forming a deep pool for credit expansion, with **approval rates >40% for high-ticket loans**—nearly 3x higher than sub-INR 2L loans.
   *   **Whitelist Expansion Underway:** High-ticket whitelist expected to grow from **2 crore to 3–5 crore** over next year; **credit card whitelist near 5 crore** and rising with new banking partners.
   *   **Lender Dynamics Improving:** Entry of **low-cost lenders (e.g., Axis Bank)** and stronger borrower profiles expected to boost conversion from whitelisted to funded loans, especially in high-ticket segments.
   *   **Unmatched Credit Visibility:** **10 crore users see the credit icon** on Paytm—scale comparable only to Google and Facebook—dramatically expanding access to formal credit.

---

# 4. Product & Segment Mix

## A. Key Figures
   *   **Marketing Services Revenue:** **₹500 Cr+** (first time) (+22% YoY)

## B. Marketing Services
   *   **Strategic Rebranding:** Commerce & Cloud renamed to **Marketing Services** to clarify focus on merchant marketing solutions and reduce confusion with cloud computing.
   *   **High-Margin Growth Engine:** Revenue surpassed ₹500 Cr on the back of strong monetization, driven by brand marketing, advertising, and loyalty services.
   *   **Traffic-to-Value Conversion:** Marketing services leveraged **high consumer app traffic** to create customer acquisition and branding opportunities for merchants and credit card partners.

## C. Financial Services
   *   **AI-Driven Transformation:** Management sees AI as a **transformative force** in financial services, enabling deeper integration and innovation across payments and credit.
   *   **Credit Expansion Focus:** Prioritizing **merchant credit, personal loans, and high-ticket loans** over postpaid, supported by **1 crore+ subscribed merchants** and strong lending partner demand.
   *   **Postpaid Offset by Diversified Growth:** Decline in BNPL being compensated by acceleration in **insurance, wealth management, and payments**.
   *   **Paytm Money Scaling Up:** After two years of development, achieving **decent-scale customer acquisition** and deeper engagement in equity and F&O trading; poised for further investment.
   *   **Organic, Platform-Led Acquisition:** Client growth driven by **integration with Paytm’s 10 crore MAUs**, not incentives—critical advantage under regulatory constraints.
   *   **User-Centric Differentiation:** Despite being a discount broker, competes via **best-in-class tech interface** and seamless UX, enhancing conversion and reducing platform inertia.

## D. Insurance & Mutual Funds
   *   **Insurance Gaining Traction:** Embedded and merchant insurance products now in **execution phase**, delivering results **better than expected**; elevated to key growth KPI.
   *   **Monetization Inflection in Mutual Funds:** New **commission-earning distribution** launched via ARN, offering SIPs and direct funds—early trends show **strong growth** despite small current AUM.
   *   **Scalable Distribution Advantage:** Monetization leverages **10 crore MAUs** for rapid customer acquisition, with incentives driving adoption of SIP and one-time investments.

---

# 5. Cost & Efficiency Levers

## A. Key Figures
   *   **People Costs:** **Reduced** through technology-led efficiency and tighter expense controls, with **ground sales team** as primary focus  
   *   **Collection Expenses:** **Rose recently** due to high volume of postpaid loans; expected to **moderate** as scale declines  
   *   **Payment Processing Costs:** **Higher YoY** driven by concentrated Q3 festive activity vs. prior-year spread  
   *   **Depreciation & Amortization:** **Increased** in line with Sound Box deployments

## B. People Cost Control
   *   **Stable Field Force:** On-ground sales team remained largely unchanged in Q3 after Q2 hiring surge for festive demand, with only **moderate expansion planned for Q4 and next year** given sufficient coverage across **500+ cities**.  
   *   **Efficiency Over Layoffs:** Management denies reports of **1,000 layoffs**, but confirms a sustained focus on operational efficiency; cost discipline driven by structural optimization, not abrupt reductions.  
   *   **Cost Discipline Embedded:** Strategic emphasis on **tightening people costs**, particularly in high-spend areas like ground sales, supported by scalable systems and reduced reliance on linear hiring.

## C. Collection Expenses
   *   **Cost Pressure from Postpaid Scale:** Other direct expenses rose due to intensive collection efforts for low-value postpaid loans, which carry **lower profitability and take rates**.  
   *   **Margin Tailwinds Ahead:** As postpaid volume declines, collection burden is expected to ease, enabling shift toward **higher-margin financial products** with improved EBITDA contribution.

## D. Tech-Led Efficiency
   *   **AI as Force Multiplier:** AI is accelerating code development, QA, and deployment via co-pilots, while automating operations to reduce manual work and **limit headcount growth**.  
   *   **System-Led Scaling:** Leadership prioritizes enhancing machine capabilities over expanding teams—**AI-driven efficiencies** are enabling more output with fewer people, particularly in sales and ops.  
   *   **No Direct AI-Layoff Link Confirmed:** While AI has improved efficiency and coincided with workforce scrutiny, management does not confirm **causal relationship between AI deployment and staffing changes**.

---

# 6. Risks & Credit Trends

## A. Key Figures
   *   **BNPL Customer Base:** **15% reduction** in whitelisted customers
   *   **ECL Range:** **65%–85%** for Postpaid portfolio (stable)
   *   **NPL Estimate (ANR):** **6%–7%** annualized based on current ECL
   *   **GCL/NCL Impact:** Minimal, estimated at **~₹1 Cr** from customer blocks
   * Bounce Rate Change: 0.5%–0.6% marginal increase post-December

## B. BNPL Contraction
   *   **Regulatory-Led Calibration:** Paytm is proactively aligning Postpaid with **regulatory expectations and lender risk appetite**, including eliminating high-risk use cases in lifestyle and high-ticket offline spending.
   *   **Conservative Stance Maintained:** No plans to shift to lenient lending partners or alter product strategy; company will **maintain a technology platform model** without building its own balance sheet.
   *   **Downward BNPL Trajectory:** Contribution to lending business expected to decline over next two quarters, with stabilization possible by **Q1 FY25**, though macro uncertainty persists.
   *   **Marginal P&L Impact:** BNPL’s low margins versus merchant/personal loans mean it has **minimal effect on EBITDA guidance**, allowing strategic flexibility.
   *   **Lender Collaboration Model:** Customer movement between BNPL lenders is feasible via mutual agreement, not contract, reflecting **relationship-driven partnerships**; current lenders also taking conservative stance.

## C. Macro Stress Exposure
   *   **Selective Risk Mitigation:** While broader stress observed in sub-₹50,000 loans, Paytm’s portfolio remains **robust and stable**, with proactive cohort pruning driven by bureau data, not delinquency.

## D. Portfolio Calibration
   *   **Proactive Credit Tightening:** Monthly user removals increased from **3%–4% to ~15%** due to elevated leverage signals, but portfolio quality, GCL, and ECL remain **within healthy, stable ranges**.
   *   **Performance Resilience:** Bounce rates improved for Paytm despite ecosystem-wide pressure, signaling potential **future improvement in ECL and GCL metrics**.
   *   **Loan Mix Shift:** Expected enhancement in portfolio quality as mix transitions from **low-ticket, high-delinquency loans** to **higher-ticket, better-quality originations**.
   *   **Stronger Approvals Ahead:** Higher approval rates for whitelisted users reflect dual filtration by Paytm and lenders, with further refinement expected to boost conversion.

---

# 7. Guidance & Outlook

## A. Key Figures
   *   **Contribution Margin:** **Mid-50s** (~56–57%) excluding UPI incentives
   *   **Net Payment Margin:** **4–8 bps** (card linking) · **5–20 bps** (merchant)
   *   **Profitability Timeline:** **12 to 18 months** to potential profitability

## B. Margin Trajectory
   *   **Stable Contribution Margins Ahead:** Contribution margin expected to stabilize in the **mid-50s**, supported by core operating model strength, despite temporary pressure from festive incentives.
   *   **Structural Margin Advantage:** Long-term margin outlook remains positive due to **dominance in acquiring** and high card-linking performance, with net payment margins becoming increasingly relevant at scale.

## C. Growth Compensation
   *   **High-Ticket Loans to Offset Postpaid Decline:** Revenue and EBITDA shortfall from postpaid will be compensated by high-ticket personal loans, which offer **significantly higher contribution margins**.
   *   **Quality Over Penetration:** No volume targets set; strategy prioritizes superior product experience and strong lending partnerships to ensure sustainable growth.

## D. Profitability Timeline
   *   **Near-Term Bottom-Line Improvement Expected:** Next quarter anticipated to show better profitability, with clear focus areas defined for the next four quarters.
   *   **Path to Profitability Clear Within 12–18 Months:** Financial services segment poised to become a **meaningful contributor**, driven by two-stage revenue model and **Paytm's "right to win"** via distribution and innovation.
   *   **Postpaid EBITDA Loss to Be Offset in One Quarter:** While revenue compensation may take up to two quarters, EBITDA impact is expected to normalize faster due to stronger performance in alternative products.
   *   **No PAT Guidance Provided:** Despite strong monthly metrics and cost control, company refrains from formal profit guidance, citing **high analyst coverage quality** and model transparency.