Key Takeaways
- Steady execution, capex catch-up needed: Q3 income grew 8% and PAT grew 11%, but FY23 capex stood at ₹5,429 cr against an ₹8,800 cr target, requiring a sharp Q4 push.
- TBCB competition is compressing returns: Management acknowledged margins are under "severe strain" from intense bidding and is willing to "forego some amount of returns to maintain market share."
- A ₹2.44 lakh cr renewable transmission pipeline is forming: CEA's plan for 500+ GW RE integration by 2030 identifies massive ISTS investment, with ~₹57,000 cr in projects already bid or approved for bidding.
- Monetisation strategy pivots from InvIT to securitisation: ~₹3,000 cr expected via securitisation of cashflows before FY23-end; InvIT is not ruled out for FY24 but faces unresolved pricing and tax questions.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the full-year ₹8,800 cr capex target is met, resolution of the Raigarh-Pugalur receivable blockage, and any TBCB award wins from the ₹40,000–50,000 cr pipeline expected over the next 12 months.
Financial Performance & Receivables
- Topline and bottomline: Q3 income grew 8% and PAT grew 11%; 9M topline grew 8% and bottomline grew 11%.
- Finance cost pressure: Driven by rising capitalisation, FERV on foreign currency borrowings from rupee depreciation, and higher interest rates on floating-rate debt linked to MCLR and repo.
- Tax reduction in 9M P&L: Management attributed apparent PBT flattishness to unadjusted regulatory deferral balances related to exchange rate variation; EBITDA gross margin grew ~6% after proper adjustment.
- Receivables blockage: Tamil Nadu, Andhra Pradesh, and Telangana are withholding payment on Raigarh-Pugalur system billing pending its reclassification as a national transmission scheme; beyond 75 days, no other entities are holding up amounts.
- LPS receivables conversion: One-time conversion of ₹2,400 cr outstanding receivables under LPS rules completed; ₹600 cr already received.
- Consultancy realisation: 86% realisation (~₹30,000 cr) against billing of ₹34,000 cr, with the shortfall primarily from past Raigarh-Pugalur dues yet to be realised.
- Debt-equity improvement: Deleveraging is occurring from repayment of debt previously deployed for construction projects, with further improvement expected.
K. Sreekant: "Otherwise, beyond 75 days nobody is holding up any amount."
Capex, Capitalisation & Works in Hand
- FY23 capex: ₹5,429 cr achieved by end of Q3 against a target of ₹8,800 cr; management stated all efforts are being made to achieve the full-year target by 31 March 2023.
- FY23 capitalisation: Expected at ₹10,000–12,000 cr on a consolidated basis.
- FY24 capitalisation: Expected at ~₹10,000 cr, much of it from TBCB projects.
- FY24 capex: Expected at ~₹8,000–8,800 cr, with potential upside if more TBCB projects under bidding are won.
- Works in hand: ₹47,000 cr total; the ex-Leh portion (~₹22,000 cr) is executable in 2–3 years, while the Leh scheme will take 5–6 years.
- Operational availability: 99.81%, above the 99.75% threshold required for incentive eligibility; trippings improved to 0.21 per line from 0.28 in the prior-year period.
TBCB: Competition, Pipeline & Margin Strain
- Intense competition acknowledged: Management described a race-to-the-bottom dynamic where bidders undercut by 0.25% increments, putting margins under "severe strain."
- Market share prioritised over returns: Management is willing to forego some returns to maintain market share in the current competitive environment.
- FY23 wins: Won 2 out of 5 TBCB projects bid during the fiscal year, including a small project won in a reverse auction on the day before the call.
- Near-term award pipeline: ~₹22,000 cr worth of projects where bids are already submitted (14 projects); another ~₹33,000 cr approved and expected to come for bidding shortly; management expects ₹40,000–50,000 cr in awards over the next 12 months.
- Equity IRR undisclosed: Management did not provide a specific IRR figure when asked about TBCB project return expectations, instead discussing margin strain and market share focus.
K. Sreekant: "The moment you see a bid, you feel that if somebody else can do it at this price, I can always do it less than 0.25% and then the race starts. So, there is this issue which we are facing."
Renewable Energy & Future Growth Opportunities
- ISTS renewable integration plan: CEA's plan for 500+ GW RE capacity integration by 2030 identifies ₹2,44,200 cr in ISTS investment and 51,070 km of transmission lines from RE zones in Rajasthan, Gujarat, Tamil Nadu, and Karnataka.
- Bids submitted and upcoming: Bids submitted for ~₹23,000 cr; ~₹34,000 cr approved and to be bid shortly.
- Ladakh transmission project: Finance Minister announced project cost of ₹20,700 cr and a central grant of ₹8,000 cr the day before the call; capex expected to start from FY24, with ~5 years to execute after bidding out; does not include a battery storage component.
- Intra-state transmission opportunity: Rule of thumb suggests investment quantum similar to ISTS is warranted, but the opportunity set is limited as some states execute on their own; UP, Rajasthan, and MP are doing bidding but the pace is "not commensurate with the requirement."
- Longer-horizon growth areas (5–7 years): Battery storage (though costs remain high and pump storage offers less opportunity for POWERGRID), transmission for green hydrogen, and offshore wind on the Tamil Nadu/Gujarat coast expected to crystallise in 5–7 years.
K. Sreekant: "But, the opportunity set there is a bit limited, because some of the states are doing it on their own. They're doing it at a slow pace, but they're doing it on their own, they're now doing any bidding process. Few states like UP, Rajasthan, MP are doing bidding, but again, the pace is not commensurate with the requirement, in my view."
Monetisation, Capital Raising & Dividend
- Securitisation pivot: Instead of InvIT, management is pursuing securitisation of cashflows to raise funds; ~₹3,000 cr expected before the end of FY23 through this route.
- InvIT not ruled out for FY24: Issues to resolve include fair price discovery, yield expectations, balancing shareholder interests, fund requirements, and raising funds at optimal cost; management declined to answer a question on tax impact.
- Short-term loans: Repaid in the period but described as temporary; may need to raise again.
- Dividend continuity: Last year's pay-out was ~60%; management sees no reason to reduce it, balancing capex needs and distribution.
- PTC India stake: Exit described as "an option on the table," with no specific timeline given.
K. Sreekant: "I think instead of monetisation through InvIT, we are looking at securitisation of the cashflows and raising funds. So, that is something which we are doing, and hopefully about 3,000 crores we would raise before the end of this fiscal through this route."
New Ventures: Smart Metering, Solar & Data Centre
- Smart metering: Targeting 1–2 cr meters directly, starting with two Gujarat discoms under an existing MOU; also looking at Mizoram and other states once experience is gained; 1 cr meters to be completed in ~2 years, generating ~₹700 cr in annual revenue when fully operational.
- Solar plant Nagda: Financial bids opened for an 85 MW plant; work expected to start next year.
- Data centre: Received CERC approval for use of land at the Manesar substation to set up a data centre.
- OPGW network expansion: Expanding own OPGW network through agreements with other state utilities to increase reach.
- Patents received: Two patents granted for energy-efficient roof-screening and a Smart Socket/Smart Home Energy Manager developed with IIT Kharagpur; described as demonstration projects with uncertain commercial potential.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| FY23 capex | Achieve ₹8,800 cr target | By 31 March 2023 |
| Securitisation raise | ~₹3,000 cr via cashflow securitisation | Before end of FY23 |
| FY23 capitalisation | ₹10,000–12,000 cr on consolidated basis | FY23 |
| FY24 capitalisation | ~₹10,000 cr, much from TBCB projects | FY24 |
| FY24 capex | ~₹8,000–8,800 cr; upside if more TBCB wins | FY24 |
| Smart metering | 1 cr meters completed, ~₹700 cr annual revenue | ~2 years |
| Ladakh transmission capex | Capex to start; ~5 years to execute post-bidding | Starting FY24 |
| Dividend pay-out | Continue at ~60% pay-out level | Ongoing |
| TBCB award pipeline | ₹40,000–50,000 cr in awards expected | Next 12 months |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated income | ₹11,530 cr, +8% YoY |
| Consolidated PAT | ₹3,645 cr, +11% YoY |
| 9M consolidated revenues | ₹34,048 cr, +8% YoY |
| 9M consolidated PAT | ₹11,097 cr, +11% YoY |
| EBITDA gross margin growth | ~6% YoY, adjusted for regulatory deferral balances |
| Incentive income | ₹130 cr for Q3; ₹408 cr for 9M |
| Surcharge income | ₹146 cr for 9M |
| Debt-equity ratio | 61:39, steady; improvement expected from deleveraging |
| FY23 capex target | ₹8,800 cr; ₹5,429 cr achieved by end of Q3 |
| Consolidated capitalization (9M) | ~₹5,190 cr by end of Q3 |
| FY23 capitalization target | ₹10,000–12,000 cr |
| FY24 capitalization target | ~₹10,000 cr, consolidated including TBCB |
| FY24 capex guidance | ₹8,000–8,800 cr, could increase with more TBCB wins |
| Works in hand | ~₹47,000 cr, including Leh scheme at ~₹22,000 cr |
| Operational availability | 99.81%, above 99.75% incentive cut-off |
| Trippings per line | 0.21, improved from 0.28 in prior-year period |
| Telecom revenues | ₹187 cr for Q3; orders received ₹68 cr |
| Consultancy income | ₹142 cr for Q3; realisation 86% against billing of ₹34,000 cr |
| Smart metering capex | ₹5,500–6,000+ cr per 1 crore meters |
| Smart metering annual revenue | ~₹700 cr when 1 crore meters fully on |
| TBCB projects won in FY23 | 2 out of 5 projects bid |
| TBCB awards expected next 12 months | ₹40,000–50,000 cr (₹22,000 cr under bidding + ₹33,000 cr approved) |
| CEA transmission plan investment | ₹2,44,200 cr for nearly 51,000 ckm of lines |
| Ladakh transmission project cost | ₹20,772 cr excluding IDC; ~₹22,500 cr including IDC |
| Central grant for Ladakh project | ₹8,000 cr |
| LPS rules fair value charge | ₹94 cr in Q3, vs ₹127 cr in Q2 |
| Receivables converted under LPS | ₹2,400 cr total; ₹600 cr received so far |
| Expected fundraise via securitisation | ~₹3,000 cr before end of FY23 |
| Dividend pay-out (last year) | ~60%; ₹10 of ₹15 standalone EPS already paid in FY23 |