Key Takeaways
- Revenue surged, margins lagged: Consolidated income from operations jumped to ₹876.58 cr YoY, but blended margin stayed under pressure because low-margin domestic EPC work dominated the mix while high-margin exports shrank to just 17% of revenue.
- Order book is overwhelmingly domestic: The ₹3,346 cr backlog is 87.5% domestic, and Q2 order intake was 92.8% domestic; the export order book is not growing at the same speed, which keeps the margin mix unfavorable.
- Commodity volatility cost at least 100 bps: Residual commodity price swings eroded margins by roughly 1% in H1, though management believes the worst of that volatility is now behind.
- The 2G ethanol showcase is approaching: The IOCL Panipat plant was unveiled, and two more projects will commission by end of next calendar year, creating a definitive anchor for the 2G opportunity over the next ~15 months.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the promised H2 pickup in export order booking materializes, any margin recovery from easing commodity prices, and progress on CBG ecosystem policy details.
Margin Mix & Profitability
- Domestic EPC dominance diluted blended margin: Domestic sales, which include the lower-margin construction component, grew much faster than exports; export revenue fell to only 17% of the quarter from a historical 25–30%, and that export portion carries no construction component, so the mix shift mechanically compressed the blended margin.
- Commodity headwind persisted: Volatile commodity prices and global inflation softened but did not disappear; management estimates the residual impact on margins was at least 1% in H1, and believes that 1% can potentially come back in H2.
- Working capital absorbed cash: Operating cash flow turned negative because of a calculated inventory build on the commodity side; payables also reduced partly due to early vendor payments to secure cash discounts as a counter-measure to commodity price increases.
- Other expenses are project-linked: Other expenses run at roughly 20% of revenue and are mainly onsite costs, labour, travel and freight; the absolute number will move with project count but the percentage should stay in a similar range.
- Management declined to reaffirm margin guidance: When asked whether the 10%+ margin target for the year still holds after a sub-8% first half, management said only that H2 should be better than H1 and that highly volatile commodity price changes are "hopefully behind us," without quantifying the exit rate.
Joshipura: "So we are not giving any guidance on what exactly it will look like, except to tell you that, #A, we believe that the highly volatile commodity price changes that we saw are hopefully behind us and that should have a clear bearings on what we do forward."
Export Order Book & International Outlook
- Export intake was low in H1: Only 7.2% of Q2 order intake came from international markets; management expects H2 to be different on the order booking side, with international sales reflecting over the next four to six quarters.
- Global blending mandates are the demand driver: Mexico and Canada have blending mandates in place; Europe's RED directive mandates 2G ethanol capacity by 2030; America's low-carbon ethanol market mechanisms are active; Brazil has introduced a renewable bio-program but is in a temporary gap due to its political and election situation.
- 2G ethanol discussions in Europe are active and advancing: The Russia-Ukraine war pushed timelines somewhat, but heightened energy security awareness and the need to fulfil the RED3 program by 2030 are driving very active and very advanced dialogue with a few European developers.
- Brazil project on track: The first project in Brazil is on schedule for commissioning at the end of this year, and performance-enhancer solutions have been successfully demonstrated in trials at select plants there.
2G Ethanol: The Anchor Opportunity
- IOCL Panipat plant unveiled, pipeline building: The Prime Minister unveiled the IOCL 2G plant in August 2022; two more projects are expected to commission towards the end of the next calendar year, which will showcase the technology's possibilities to the world over the next ~15 months.
- Feedstock is abundant and underutilised: Lignocellulosic feedstock such as agricultural residue is currently burned off with no alternative use; management sees no current worries around feedstock availability.
- Viability depends on carbon pricing: In markets where carbon is priced and valued, 2G is already viable; in India, 2G ethanol rates have not yet been notified, and that pricing will determine domestic viability.
- 85% GHG reduction is the unique selling point: 2G technology is the only ethanol pathway that cuts emissions by 85%; when the focus shifts to GHG and carbon footprint reduction, cost dynamics change, and aviation fuel will require very low carbon intensity fuel.
Joshipura: "Purpose of technology would be what so for example stubble burning is a problem we're trying to solve, this is one way to solve it. If we want to address the CO2 emission, ethanol is the way to solve it, and 85% reduction in GHG emission is a very definitive way of solving it."
Domestic Ethanol & Post-EBP-20 Demand
- Balance capacity for EBP-20 still ~500 cr litres: Some of that capacity was ordered during the quarter; the domestic order book is progressing at a much faster speed than exports.
- Flex-fuel vehicles extend the demand runway: Flex-fuel vehicles can run on up to 85% ethanol, removing the 20% blending ceiling; ethanol-driven DG sets, mobile diesel engine applications for railways and automotive, and telecom towers shifting from diesel to ethanol are additional demand drivers beyond EBP-20.
- Feedstock mix may rebalance: Indications are that as world sugar supply stabilises, more sugar diversion for ethanol production may occur, bringing balance back toward a higher share of sugary feedstocks; next year, lignocellulosic feedstocks may also begin contributing as plants commission.
- Domestic market share now exceeds 66%: Customers are returning to Praj after experiencing difficulties with cheaper alternatives, valuing experience, technology and knowledge over the lowest first price.
Joshipura: "Sometimes the first price may become attractive, but then experience is not attractive and then that's when you come back and say, no maybe I do understand that there is a value in your experience and technology and knowledge that we deploy and that's the phenomenon that we're seeing."
CBG, SAF & Emerging Verticals
- CBG environment is becoming visibly more favourable: The Uttar Pradesh biofuels policy issued roughly two weeks before the call aims to attract big-ticket investments in compressed biogas projects; the broader environment for setting up CBG plants is improving, but last-mile connectivity issues around byproduct pricing, off-take agreements and fertilizer policies still need resolution.
- CBG ecosystem will take years, not quarters: Management drew a parallel to ethanol, which took over 30 years with the 2018 biofuel policy as the key enabler; ethanol took four to five years and maybe a couple more after the 2018 policy before becoming a robust operating system, partly because India is not yet a gas economy and automotive OEM gas-engine rollouts must move in tandem.
- SAF is still very early days: The ICAO net-zero 2050 goal and the US Inflation Reduction Act are definitive positive steps, but even if a plant is built there must be an agreement to buy and use SAF in aircraft; the US is targeting roughly 5–6% capacity by 2030 but has no capacities today.
- CPES and hydrogen are incremental opportunities: The CPES modularisation business is seeing demand for blue and green hydrogen projects and is also finding traction for Praj's own ethanol technologies in advanced markets; Praj is working closely with several leading global technology providers but agreements do not permit naming them.
Joshipura: "We have been at this ethanol for over 30 years and we have seen that this ecosystem development does take time. We know that in that scale hopefully it will not take that long. But the fact is that it has also taken four, five years and maybe a couple more before it becomes a very robust operating system, just the way ethanol market is today."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Margin improvement | H2 margins to be better than H1; commodity-driven ~1% headwind can potentially come back | H2 FY23 |
| Export order book pickup | H2 expected to be different from H1 on international order booking; international sales to reflect | Next four to six quarters |
| 2G plant commissioning | Two more projects beyond IOCL Panipat to commission | End of next calendar year (~15 months) |
| CBG ecosystem readiness | Too early to discuss; environment becoming more favourable but last-mile issues remain | "Maybe next quarter" for update; 4–5+ years for robust ecosystem |
| SAF capacity build-out | Dialogue ongoing; US IRA and ICAO steps are positive but market is still very early | No timeline given |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated income from operations | ₹876.58 cr, vs ₹532.41 cr in Q2 FY22 |
| PBT | ₹65.78 cr, +40.6% YoY vs ₹46.77 cr in Q2 FY22 |
| PAT | ₹48.13 cr, vs ₹33.34 cr in Q2 FY22 |
| H1 FY23 income from operations | ₹1,606.45 cr, vs ₹918.67 cr in H1 FY22 |
| H1 FY23 PAT | ₹89.39 cr, vs ₹55.54 cr in H1 FY22 |
| Export revenue share | 17% of total revenue, vs ~30% historically |
| Revenue mix | Bio-energy 74.7%, Engineering 19.5%, PHS 5.7% |
| Order intake | ₹981 cr, 92.8% domestic |
| Order intake mix | Bio-energy 85.1%, Engineering 10.8%, PHS 4.1% |
| Order backlog | ₹3,346 cr, 87.5% domestic, execution timeline 12–15 months on average |
| Cash in hand | ₹514 cr as of Sept 30, 2022 |
| Domestic market share (bioenergy) | >66%, moved up significantly during the quarter |
| Commodity volatility impact on margins (H1 FY23) | At least 1%, lower than the >1% impact in the prior year |
| Ethanol blending achieved | 10%, halfway to the EBP-20 target |
| Balance ethanol capacity creation needed | ~500 cr liters |