Key Takeaways
- Volume growth lagged peers again, but a fix is underway: Management acknowledged the shortfall with unusual candor, attributing it to delayed HDPE capacity and over-premiumization in some markets. Corrective pricing actions and new HDPE capacity are expected to restore industry-level growth from Q4.
- Margins rebounded to normalized levels: Improved product mix, cost control, and a normalized pipe-fitting ratio drove a healthy margin recovery, despite a negligible inventory gain. Management reiterated its long-term 12%-14% operating margin guidance.
- Bathware launched, early traction reported: The maiden quarter saw positive sales feedback and distributor build-out in North and West India, with a target of ₹8 Crore in sales for the December quarter. Segmental reporting begins next quarter.
- New product partnerships signal a premiumization push: Tie-ups with Ostendorf and Hauraton for low-noise drainage and recycled PP surface drainage, plus investment in industrial CPVC, show a strategy of deepening the portfolio with higher-value, concept-led products.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the pricing-led volume recovery materializes in Q3, the scale-up of Bathware sales toward the ₹8 Crore target, and the initial volume contribution from new HDPE capacity in Q4.
Volume Growth: The Lag and the Recovery Plan
- The core problem: Volume growth has trailed the industry for two to three quarters. Management cited being a laggard in HDPE capacity and a need for pricing corrections after an over-premiumization drive in certain markets left the company uncompetitive against the largest player.
- The HDPE catch-up: Investments in HDPE capacity were made in the September quarter. The volume impact will only begin to reflect from the March quarter, with a target of scaling HDPE to 7%-8% of total volumes.
- Pricing action underway: Price corrections have been taken in core PVC and CPVC segments in specific markets, not pan-India, to realign with peers. Post-action, PVC products will be at parity with the industry leader, while CPVC will carry a slight discount.
- The recovery bet: Management expects to return to industry-leading or at least in-line volume growth from the December quarter onwards, driven by pricing actions and operating leverage. HDPE volumes will add a further leg from Q4.
- A commodity-plus mindset: Management pushed back on pricing as the sole lever, insisting that sharper execution across multiple factors, not just price, is needed in a business that is "not purely a commodity."
Nihar Chheda: "I do not want to put this all down to pricing I think pricing is just one aspect, but we need to be sharper and more aggressive with this and I am confident that overall apart from pricing there is a lot of other factors, that go into growth, this is not purely a commodity business."
Margin & Profitability
- Q2 margin rebound: Operating margins recovered to normalized levels, driven by an improved product mix from the building materials segment, a normalized pipe-fitting ratio after Q1 dispatch challenges, and rigorous cost control. Inventory gain was less than ₹5 Crore and not material.
- Long-term guardrails: Management stuck to its 12%-14% long-term operating margin guidance, stating it is sustainable even with the pricing actions, as volume growth and resulting operating leverage should partially offset the impact.
- The growth-over-margin trade-off: The company explicitly prioritizes volume growth leadership over margin maximization, accepting the 12%-14% band as the right zone for competitive positioning.
- Cost absorption to cushion pricing: The margin impact of pricing actions will not be overnight; operating leverage from higher volumes and cost absorption is expected to provide a partial offset over a couple of quarters.
Nihar Chheda: "I would much rather have 12% to 14% operating margin and growth which is leading in the industry."
Bathware: The New Growth Vector
- Maiden quarter launch: The Bathware segment launched in June 2023, with products well-received and positive sales traction. The company is building a distributor base in Northern and Western India, with brand launches in tier-2 and tier-3 markets like Srinagar, Jaipur, and Varanasi.
- First project win: The first project installation was completed in Mumbai during the quarter, marking an early institutional reference point.
- Near-term targets: Management is targeting ₹8 Crore in Bathware sales for the December quarter and will begin reporting segmental revenues from that quarter.
- Eastern India entry planned: A launch in Eastern India is targeted for Q4 FY2024, expanding the geographic footprint.
- Dealer build-out still early: When pressed for a target number of dealers, management deflected, asking for at least one more quarter before quantifying the distribution target.
Product Portfolio Deepening
- Premium drainage partnerships: Prince tied up with Ostendorf (Germany) for low-noise PP drainage and sewage systems, and with Hauraton for PP surface drainage made from 100% recycled polypropylene. First project orders for both products were received and installed this quarter.
- Industrial CPVC: a long game: The company invested ₹8-10 Crore in capacity for industrial CPVC using Corzan technology via its Lubrizol tie-up. Management sees the next 3-5 years as a concept-selling phase, with the product becoming more than a niche only in 5-7 years.
- Depth over breadth: The strategy is to give each new product significant mindshare, time, and investment rather than rushing into multiple launches. PPR/composite pipes will be added for brand identity but are not expected to exceed 3%-5% of the overall CPVC market.
- OPVC evaluation: The company is evaluating OPVC but prefers products with acceptance in both retail and infrastructure, rather than infrastructure-only products.
Nihar Chheda: "...depth is more important than breadth and whichever product we take we will really give it a lot of mindshare and time and efforts and investment in terms of people as well as branding as well as capacities."
Raw Material & Supply Chain
- Domestic sourcing shift: PVC resin sourcing is now 50% domestic and 50% imported, a deliberate increase in domestic contracts with Reliance and Chemplast at the start of the year. Management cited prudence in an uncertain environment as the driver.
- Working capital pressure: The shift to domestic sourcing, which operates on advance payment or cash-and-carry terms, reduced payables and increased working capital. This pressure may continue for the next couple of months.
- PVC price stability: After a correction in early October that caused some destocking, PVC prices have stabilized with a slight uptick, supporting restocking and volume growth in Q3. Management expects PVC to remain range-bound for the next couple of quarters, creating a growth-conducive environment.
- Lubrizol Grasim plant: a structural shift: The local CPVC resin plant is expected to commence from 2025. Management sees this as transformative, giving Prince a dominant position with local capacity, local cost structure, and the FlowGuard brand.
Nihar Chheda: "Absolutely and this was one of our incentive to sign with Lubrizol when they had approached us few years ago there have been some delays unfortunately, but we still believe that once the plant is operational we will be on a strong footing because local capacity, local cost structure with the flow guard brand will put us in a dominant position especially for CPVC."
CPVC: Growth vs. Margin Dynamics
- Aggressive growth mandate: Management stated the CPVC portfolio must and will grow aggressively. The coming local resin capacity from Lubrizol Grasim is seen as an enabler, not a threat, because 95% import dependence is unsustainable for the industry's long-term growth.
- Margin compression acknowledged: When pressed, management conceded that over the long term (3-4 years), CPVC margins, currently at roughly 2x normal PVC margins, will likely narrow as domestic supply increases. However, the volume growth is expected to more than offset the margin compression, making it net-net positive.
- Anti-dumping duty uncertainty: The existing CPVC anti-dumping duty expires around August/September. Management declined to speculate on renewal but noted that as local capacities increase, the case for duties becomes stronger.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Volume growth recovery | Return to industry-leading or in-line volume growth | From December quarter onwards |
| HDPE volume contribution | New HDPE capacity to reflect in operational volumes | From March quarter |
| Bathware sales target | ₹8 Crore in sales | December quarter |
| Bathware segmental reporting | Begin reporting Bathware revenues separately | December quarter |
| Bathware Eastern India launch | Launch in Eastern India | Q4 FY2024 |
| Debtor days reduction | Bring down to ~50 days | Next two quarters |
| Debtor days sustainable target | Mid-40s | Next year |
| Long-term operating margin | 12% to 14% | Long-term, sustainable annually |
| HDPE volume target | 7% to 8% of total volumes | No specific date given |
| Bihar facility | Phase one work to start post-Diwali; long-term vision to be one of the largest facilities | Phase one underway; 5-year vision |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ₹656 Crore, +3% YoY |
| Finished goods sales volume | 41,529 MT, +8% YoY |
| EBITDA | ₹94 Crore, margin of 14.3% |
| EBITDA margin guidance | 12% to 14%, long-term sustainable range |
| A&P spend | ₹15 Crore, +7% over previous fiscal period |
| Finance cost | Reduced by around 50% YoY, due to lower short-term borrowing cost |
| Exceptional item: net gain on property settlement | ₹17.93 Crore, from registration of corporate office |
| Channel finance credit limits | ₹126 Crore, up from ₹105 Crore in Q1 FY24 |
| Inventory days | 62 days, stable |
| Creditor days | 59 days |
| Debtor days | 63 days; target to reduce to ~50 days in next two quarters, mid-40s by next year |
| CPVC revenue share | 20% to 25% of revenue |
| HDPE volume share | Less than 3% of overall volumes; target to reach 7% to 8% |
| Overall capacity utilization | ~50% |
| Telangana facility capacity utilization | ~40% |
| Bathware sales target (Q3 FY24) | ₹8 Crore |
| Bathware branding cost (Q2 FY24) | ₹3 to 4 Crore |
| Bathware employee cost (Q2 FY24) | ₹1.5 Crore |
| Total capacity | 3,28,000 MT |
| Net capacity addition in Q2 | 5,000 to 6,000 MT |
| Bihar plant total capex | ₹150 Crore; ₹60 to 70 Crore in FY24, balance in FY25 |
| Full-year capex guidance (including Bihar) | ₹150 to 160 Crore |
| Normalized capex guidance (ex-Bihar, ex-Ruby) | ₹80 to 100 Crore for FY24 |
| Investment in industrial CPVC | ₹8 to 10 Crore |
| PPR processing volume | 400 to 500 tonnes per month |
| Inventory gain in Q2 | Less than ₹5 Crore |
| Lubrizol Grasim CPVC plant first phase capacity | 48,000 MT |