Key Takeaways
- Volume held up, but PVC price collapse crushed margins: 4% Y-o-Y volume growth was led by Plumbing and SWR, yet a 16% fall in PVC prices triggered severe channel destocking and a margin wipeout from inventory losses and forced trade incentives.
- ~4.5% of EBITDA margin was given away this quarter: ~2–2.5% from inventory loss and another ~2% passed to the channel as trade incentives to protect volumes in a weak demand environment, plus a ~0.5% drag from Bathware.
- The PVC price cycle is turning, and with it, pricing power: November brought a reversal on anti-dumping duty news, management is already passing through price hikes, and restocking should normalize channel inventory, setting up a stronger H2.
- Bathware losses are contained and on a breakeven clock: Losses held at ~₹4 cr/quarter, pan-India distribution build-out is underway, and management committed to breakeven by Q3 FY26.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the PVC price uptrend holds and trade incentives can be phased out, the pace of inventory-day normalization from 88 toward 70, and any volume acceleration beyond the 4% Q2 print.
PVC Price Cycle & Margin Mechanics
- The Q2 margin shock: A 16% Y-o-Y fall in PVC prices caused channel partners to destock aggressively, which both depressed volumes and forced the company to book an inventory loss of ~2–2.5% of revenue. On top of that, management passed an additional ~2% to the channel as trade incentives to sustain volume flow in a weak sentiment quarter. The result was an EBITDA margin far below the normalized 12% ex-inventory-gain/loss expectation.
- Pricing power is returning: PVC prices reversed in November after provisional anti-dumping duty findings were announced. Prince, as a market leader, has already passed through the first price hike and expects to pass the second by next week. Management sees the channel normalizing inventory as the price trend turns positive, which should lift realizations and restore operating leverage.
- Trade incentives are not permanent: Management characterized the incentives as a tactical response to weak demand and destocking, not a structural margin reset. With PVC pricing now reversing, the company expects to phase them out slowly, though it declined to rule out their presence in Q3 entirely.
- The three margin levers: EBITDA margin is a function of pricing power (which improves when PVC prices rise), product mix (CPVC continues to do well), and operating leverage (absent in Q2 because realizations fell and volume growth was low single-digit; when realizations improve and volume growth returns to high single-digit/low double-digit, operating leverage plays a big part).
Nihar Chheda: "The first part has been passed on and the second part will be passed on by next week. So the way we pass through decreases, we are -- it's a pass-through for increases as well, which is being the market leaders, we are first to announce the price increases."
Volume Growth & Demand Environment
- Plumbing and SWR carried the quarter: Q2 volume grew 4% Y-o-Y, with CPVC continuing to grow well, mainly in the Plumbing division. PVC struggled and Agri was a weak quarter. H1 volume growth stood at 9% Y-o-Y, again led by Plumbing and SWR.
- Demand was weakest early in the quarter: The first two months of Q2 were challenging; September saw good recovery and better growth. End-product demand across plumbing and agriculture is expected to do well, supported by a strong real estate cycle and affordability in polymer prices.
- Channel inventory dynamics amplified the weakness: Q1 channel inventory was higher because demand sentiment was not as weak as Q2. CPVC prices do not change often, so the main restocking and destocking volatility is concentrated in PVC. Over 12 months, destocking and restocking usually even out.
- Full-year volume target maintained at 8–10%: Management reiterated the FY25 volume growth target, implying a meaningful H2 acceleration from the 4% Q2 run-rate, though it declined to quantify October performance or give a specific H2 volume estimate.
Competitive Dynamics
- One player was more aggressive in Q2: A competitor with capacity additions over the past two years and headwinds was more aggressive. Prince responded with trade incentives but characterized its own actions as measured, not irrational or predatory pricing. The stated focus remains on profitable growth.
- Management rejects the market-share-loss narrative: When an analyst suggested Prince may have lost market share over the years, management explicitly disagreed, pointing to an industry with enough room for everyone to grow, evidenced by new players continuing to enter.
- Competitive intensity is not seen as a structural challenge: Management argues that both supply and demand are increasing, with the industry growing at a high single-digit CAGR including the unorganized segment. The tank business has always had high competitive intensity, with 65% of the market unorganized due to freight cost sensitivity, though larger players entering has increased brand consciousness.
Nihar Chheda: "We are in an industry where there is enough and more room for growth, and there is room for everyone to grow. And that is why you're seeing so many new players also come in, looking at the kind of growth potential in the piping industry."
Capacity Expansion & Capex
- Begusarai delayed but on track: The Bihar plant, previously guided for January, is now expected by March due to extended monsoons. Management remains confident of Q4 commercialization and has preponed the second phase, taking total Bihar capacity to ~55 KMT, up from an initial 45 KMT and then 50 KMT.
- Debottlenecking continues: 12,000-odd tonnes of capacity were added over the last quarter and this quarter. The company holds significant land banks: more than 80 acres at Jaipur, ~50 acres at Telangana, with only 20–30 acres currently used at each, and ~35 acres at Begusarai.
- Post-Begusarai decentralization is the next horizon: Management intends to continue decentralizing manufacturing and will look at the next facility, but current focus is on completing the Aquel transaction and bringing Bihar capacity online as soon as possible. No roadmap for the next 2–3 years was provided, despite a commitment in the prior quarter's call to do so.
- Aquel asset purchase progressing: The first phase of the asset purchase agreement is complete; the second phase involves a cash outflow of ~₹43 crores, subject to regulatory approvals. Maintenance capex of ₹5–7 crores is anticipated over 12 months.
- Capex spillover: Total capex will spill over two years, with part completed this year. An analyst flagged a discrepancy between reported H1 capex of ₹127 cr and the change in fixed assets plus CWIP plus depreciation of ~₹92 cr; management declined to reconcile it on the call.
Nihar Chheda: "So by March, our capacity at Begusarai will be more than 50,000 tonnes."
Bathware: Build-out & Loss Trajectory
- Pan-India distribution taking shape: The first Aquel by Prince retail showrooms launched in Haryana and New Delhi during Q2. The company has expanded into South India and is now building a team in East India, with revenue expected to lag team setup by one quarter. A dedicated website and virtual presence are now live.
- Losses are contained and predictable: Bathware losses held at ~₹4 cr/quarter at the EBIT level (after gross margin and up to depreciation), consistent with the ~₹16–18 cr per annum guided at entry. Manpower costs will rise in H2 as the South and East India expansions add headcount before revenue follows.
- Breakeven committed by Q3 FY26: Management stated that by Q3 of the next fiscal year, the bathware division will achieve no losses. It declined to guide on when the business would become cash-accretive overall, calling it too early. FY25 revenue is expected to close higher than ₹25 cr.
Nihar Chheda: "I think by quarter 3 of next fiscal, we will break even, but it's not that we are really haemorrhaging cash. The bathware losses are very much in control."
Working Capital & Return Ratios
- Receivables improved sharply: DSO fell to 55 days from 83 days in March 2024, with a further correction of 3–4 days expected next quarter and a year-end target below 50 days. Channel finance has been shifted to distributors, with the sanction amount significantly increased and over 150 channel partners now enrolled.
- Inventory days ballooned on weak Q2 volumes: Inventory days jumped to 88 from 62 in March 2024, and rose further to 93 days by September. The build-up is a mix of finished goods and raw material, driven by supply security needs (domestic plus import), positions taken 2–3 months in advance assuming 10–15% growth, and a weak Q2 volume quarter. Normal guided inventory is 65–70 days; the current excess is ~15–20 days, and a correction of 10–12 days is expected.
- Return ratios depressed by the capex cycle: ROE fell from pre-COVID 20%+ to high single-digit, weighed down by aggressive capacity expansion across Telangana, Bihar, Jaipur, Haridwar, and Silvassa, plus challenging quarters from raw material volatility and ERP issues, and bathware capex and opex. Management expects a long-term return on capital of 15–20% to resume once capex normalizes.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Volume growth | 8–10% Y-o-Y for FY25 | FY25 |
| Begusarai commercialization | Capacity >50,000 tonnes; production start | Q4 FY25 (by March) |
| Bihar total capacity | ~55 KMT after second phase preponed | Q4 FY25 |
| Bathware pan-India presence | Distribution build-out complete | End of H2 FY25 |
| Bathware revenue | Close higher than ₹25 cr | FY25 |
| Bathware breakeven | No bathware losses at EBIT level | Q3 FY26 |
| DSO | Below 50 days | By year-end FY25 |
| Inventory days | Correction of 10–12 days from 88 toward ~70 | No date (expected as volumes recover) |
| Return on capital | 15–20% consistently | Long-term (post capex normalization) |
| Ad spend | Continue in 2–2.5% of revenue range | Ongoing |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY25 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ₹622 cr, vs ₹656 cr in Q2 FY24 |
| Volume | 43,301 metric tonnes, +4% YoY |
| EBITDA | ₹46 cr |
| PAT | ₹15 cr, vs ₹71 cr in Q2 FY24 (which included ₹18 cr exceptional gain) |
| EBITDA margin | 7.4% (per an analyst's math), impacted by ~2–2.5% inventory loss, ~2% trade incentives, ~0.5% Bathware loss |
| H1 FY25 revenue | +1% YoY, vs ₹1,210 cr in H1 FY24 |
| H1 FY25 volume growth | +9% YoY |
| H1 FY25 EBITDA | ₹104 cr, vs ₹139 cr in H1 FY24 |
| FY25 volume growth guidance | 8% to 10% |
| Inventory loss | ₹12 cr to ₹15 cr |
| Bathware (Aquel) revenue | ₹7 cr |
| Bathware (Aquel) loss | ₹3 cr to ₹4 cr (EBIT level) |
| Water tank revenue | ₹12 cr |
| Working capital days | 93 days, vs 80 days in June and 95 days in March 2024 |
| Receivables (DSO) | 55 days, improved from 83 days in March 2024 |
| Inventory days | 88 days, vs 62 days in March 2024 |
| Channel finance partners enrolled | Over 150 |
| Ad spend | 2.5% of revenue, for Q2 and H1 FY25 |
| FY25 total capex plan | ₹330 cr to ₹350 cr |
| Begusarai plant capacity by Q4 FY25 | More than 50,000 tonnes |