Key Takeaways
- Bathware leap via Aquel acquisition: Prince acquired the Aquel brand and Bhuj plant for Rs.55 crores, a deal management calls "extremely lucrative" given the brand equity and a replacement cost of Rs.35-40 crores for the facility alone.
- Core pipe business hit a soft patch: An ERP transition and supply chain disruption cost market share; corrective pricing is now in place and management expects the growth engine to return from the June quarter.
- Bathware is the long-term margin story: Management sees bathware as the most profitable vertical over time, targeting 13%-15% operating margins in 4-5 years, though near-term profitability will be suppressed by aggressive brand and manpower investment.
- Aquel was a distressed asset with strong bones: The brand, once benchmarked against Jaquar on quality and innovation, was starved of working capital under previous owners, collapsing revenue to ~Rs.7 crores last fiscal on 10-15% capacity utilization.
- What to watch next quarter: Specific FY25 revenue and EBITDA projections for bathware, promised on the Q4 call, and any evidence that the core pipe business has stopped losing share ahead of the June quarter restart.
The Aquel Acquisition: What Prince Bought
- Asset purchase, not a company takeover: Prince acquired the brand, land, building, equipment, molds and dies from Klaus Waren Fixtures, explicitly avoiding any legacy balance sheet liabilities. The promoters are out and subject to a 10-year non-compete.
- Two-tranche closing: The Aquel brand and associated molds/dies transferred immediately; the Bhuj manufacturing unit (land, building, equipment) will close over the next few months pending regulatory approvals.
- The Bhuj facility is underutilized and expandable: Only 2.5 of 8 acres are currently used; management estimates the plant can reach peak revenue of Rs.100-120 crores with just Rs.2-5 crores of incremental capex, and capacity can triple on the existing land.
- Aquel's brand equity survived the neglect: When launched in the early 2000s, Aquel was the first to introduce special-coloured faucets to India and was benchmarked at par with Jaquar on quality and innovation. Management says the brand still commands respect despite years of under-supply.
Nihar Chheda: "from a quality and an innovation point of view was actually benchmarked in level with Jaquar, if not higher"
Bathware Strategy: Brand, Distribution, and the Long Game
- One brand, pan-India: All bathware (faucets, sanitaryware, showers, accessories) will now be sold under the Aquel brand; packaging and collaterals will carry "Aquel by Prince" once existing inventory clears.
- Distribution is the immediate bottleneck: Aquel had only 35 distributors, concentrated in Maharashtra, Gujarat and North Karnataka, because the previous owners could not supply smaller distributors. Prince's own bathware network has 27 active distributors, some cross-selling from pipes and some new exclusive outlets.
- Sanitaryware stays outsourced: Prince will continue to fully outsource sanitaryware with no plan to set up a plant in the near future. Faucets will be manufactured at Bhuj, with certain parts outsourced per industry practice.
- Pricing will undercut the incumbent: Management explicitly plans to benchmark the market leader's pricing but sell at a discount, calling it "delusional" to think they can price at parity and still grow.
- Profitability is a 4-5 year story: Near-term margins will be suppressed by aggressive branding and manpower investment before sales scale. Management targets 13%-15% operating margins over the long term and expects bathware to eventually be the most profitable of Prince's three verticals, because product differentiation through design and service is far greater than in pipes or water tanks.
Nihar Chheda: "in pipes and water tanks, it's all standardized products where product differentiation actually is fairly limited... But in a product like bathware, there is more product differentiation that is possible because of designs that you can be ahead of the curve with."
Core Pipe Business: A Reset Quarter
- ERP transition caused self-inflicted damage: The shift to a new ERP system created supply chain disruptions that cost Prince market share. Management says those challenges are now behind them and corrective pricing action was taken in December and January.
- Flattish near-term, rebound promised: Q3 was flattish year-on-year, and Q4 is expected to be similar to last Q4. Management states it will take one quarter to regain lost market share, with the growth engine returning from the June quarter, and confidence in delivering industry-leading growth thereafter.
- Underlying demand is healthy: Real estate continues to do well, PVC prices are range-bound and expected to stay that way, and management remains bullish on piping demand.
- No specific growth guidance: When pressed for a growth percentage for next year, management declined, stating "the numbers will talk for themselves."
Nihar Chheda: "the growth engine will be back from the June quarter"
Capacity Expansion Beyond Bathware
- Bihar facility scaled up: Proposed capex increased to Rs.220 crores; pipe capacity raised from 35,000 to 48,000 metric tonnes; fittings capacity preponed to phase one; water tank capacity of 60 lakh liters per month to be added. Commercialization is expected in Q4 of next fiscal.
- Water tank manufacturing footprint: Manufacturing already started at Silvassa, Jaipur, Telangana and Haridwar; Chennai is expected to start in the next few quarters.
- Inorganic appetite is selective: In bathware, the Aquel acquisition is enough for now and the focus is on execution. For pipes and water tanks, management explores opportunities that arise from stress at the bottom of the pyramid but will be "extremely selective and prudent."
What Management Declined to Answer
- Aquel's historical earnings: When asked what earnings the previous owners derived from the facility, management described low current revenue and historical revenue from a decade ago but provided no profit figures.
- Revised FY25-26 cash flow and EBITDA loss: Management declined to give specific numbers for the investment phase, deferring visibility to the Q4 earnings call.
- Aquel order book: Management explained the business is distribution-driven, not B2B with large contracts, and did not provide a specific order book figure.
- Replacement cost breakup: The Rs.35-40 crore replacement cost estimate was not broken down, with management citing too many variables.
- ROCE on the acquisition: Management redirected, saying the first few years will not show 14-15% EBITDA margins due to higher investment and that the focus for 2-3 years should be on market share.
- Specific growth guidance: Management explicitly refused to give a growth percentage for next year.
Nihar Chheda: "I have never been a fan of the number game and I will continue to stay away from that, and the numbers will talk for themselves."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Core pipe growth recovery | Growth engine returns; expects to be among the fastest growing in the industry | June quarter (Q1 FY25) |
| Bihar facility commercialization | Expanded capacity of 48,000 MT pipes, plus fittings and water tanks | Q4 next fiscal (Q4 FY25) |
| Aquel revenue materiality | Revenue becomes a "relevant number" | Q2 next financial year (Q2 FY25) |
| Aquel peak capacity | Rs.100-120 crores p.a. with Rs.2-5 crores incremental capex | No date; capacity available |
| Bathware margin target | 13%-15% operating margins | Long-term, 4-5 years |
| Bathware vertical primacy | Bathware becomes the most profitable of the three verticals | Five years from now |
| Bathware projections update | Specific FY25 revenue and EBITDA plans for bathware | Q4 FY24 earnings call |
| Non-compete on Aquel sellers | Promoters out of the business | 10 years |
| No new faucet facility needed | Bhuj capacity sufficient | Minimum next 3-4 years |
| No sanitaryware plant | Continue to outsource | Near future |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Revenue (pipes business) | Flattish YoY, matching projections |
| Volume growth outlook | Growth engine expected to resume from June quarter; Q4 FY24 similar to last Q4 |
| Pipes market share | 7% to 8% |
| Pipes distributor count | More than 1,500 |
| Bihar facility proposed CAPEX | ₹220 cr, increased from earlier plan; capacity raised to 48,000 metric tonnes from 35,000 |
| Bihar water tanks capacity | 60 lakh litres per month |
| Bihar commercialization timeline | Q4 of next fiscal |
| Bathware acquisition cost | ₹55 cr, funded through internal accruals |
| Aquel installed capacity | ~1,00,000 pieces per year, revenue potential of ₹100 cr to 120 cr p.a. |
| Aquel revenue (last fiscal) | ₹7 cr, depressed due to working capital constraints |
| Aquel peak historical revenue | ₹40 cr to 50 cr, about a decade ago |
| Aquel current capacity utilization | 10% to 15% |
| Aquel active distributors | 30 to 35 |
| Prince active bathware distributors (pre-acquisition) | 25 to 30 |
| Bathware revenue expected to become relevant | From Q2 of next financial year |
| Overall addressable market | ₹60,000 cr (Pipes ₹40,000 cr, Water tanks ₹8,000 cr, Bathware ₹15,000 to 20,000 cr) |
| Bathware segment organized share | 65% organized, 35% unorganized |
| Long-term bathware operating margin target | 14% to 15%, expected to be the most profitable vertical in 5 years |
| Maintenance CAPEX on Aquel plant | ₹2 cr to 4 cr |
| Replacement cost of similar faucet facility | ₹35 cr to 40 cr (including land) |
| Non-compete period | 10 years |
| Water tank manufacturing locations | Silvassa (Jul '20), Jaipur (May '22), Telangana (Jun '22), Haridwar (Feb '24), Chennai (next few quarters) |