Key Takeaways
- Strong H1, cautious full-year guide: Revenue grew 38% YoY in Q2, with H1 at ~₹340 crore, yet management kept the FY24 forecast at 22% growth, implying a sharp H2 deceleration that was not directly addressed.
- Lumel SA margin surge masks Alucast stress: Lumel SA EBITDA nearly doubled on lower raw material costs and sustained pricing, while Lumel Alucast posted an actual EBITDA loss after ESOP and contingency provisions.
- Alucast margin recovery is a 12-18 month story: New EV project learning curves and sticky energy costs have compressed margins to 13%-15%; management targets a return to ~18% EBITDA but only over a year to 1.5 years.
- Analog panel meters are a durable cash cow: The company is the largest global producer in a declining market where competitor exits are driving consolidation-led growth of a few percent annually, with management expecting volumes to stay within ±5% for at least a decade.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the implied H2 slowdown materializes or H1 momentum continues, any inorganic announcement by quarter-end, and stabilization in Alucast's new EV project execution.
The H2 Growth Puzzle
- H1 run-rate vs FY24 guide: H1 revenue of ~₹340 crore against a ~₹700 crore full-year target implies only 9-10% growth in H2, despite H2 typically being stronger. Management did not reconcile the math, stating only that they will "definitely do better" than 22% and will revisit at Q2 results.
- Segment momentum argues against a slowdown: Metering, control and protection grew 47%, aluminium die casting grew 32%, and electrical automation in Europe grew 32%. Management expects future growth rates to remain similar.
- Export strength as a buffer: Indian export revenue grew 55% versus 19% domestic, and new capacity being added in India is planned for a 50-50 export-domestic split, suggesting international demand is the primary growth driver.
Narendra Goliya: "That doesn't mean we are going to slow down in the second half. We may do better, but our yearly commitment, we are not changing, in the sense that we have forecasted 22% growth. Going by the present rate, we will definitely do better."
Lumel Alucast: The Margin Drag
- Headline loss, adjusted reality: Lumel Alucast reported an EBITDA loss of ₹1.8 crore, but this included two notional charges: a ₹5.17 crore ESOP cost (majority awarded to Dinesh Musalekar) and a ₹3.64 crore contingency provision for a 2018 tax audit on a dividend payment. Adjusted EBITDA grew only 5%.
- Contingency provision is contested: The ₹3.64 crore relates to a tax authority notification that the company has not accepted; strong legal opinion suggests the liability will not hold, and no order has been passed.
- Core profitability compressed by two forces: Energy cost increases in Europe are being addressed through indexation with customers, but automotive supply chains take longer to approve price corrections. Simultaneously, 4-5 new EV projects (with Mallian, Valeo) for on-board charging are first-time products with learning curve costs and higher scrap rates.
- Recovery path is gradual: Management expects stressed margins of 13%-15% for 1-2 quarters, then a climb back to ~18% EBITDA over a year to 1.5 years as energy indexation kicks in and new project execution stabilizes.
- Capacity expansion underway: Die casting process utilization is at ~80% against ~60% overall. An 18-month project for a new production hall will expand capacity, after which utilization will fall back to ~50%.
Management: "These are so innovative that in the entire supply chain everybody is struggling. It is I'll give you an example it is like launching a rocket. So, these are all first-time products which nobody has experienced."
Analog Panel Meters: Consolidation Play
- Market decline, company growth: The analog panel meter market is not growing, but Rishabh is growing a few percent annually as smaller competitors shut down and customers consolidate with the largest global producer.
- Longevity of the franchise: Management expects analog volumes to remain within plus/minus 5% of current levels for at least the next 10 years, drawing a parallel to analog watches that coexist with digital.
- New customer opportunity: The company is eyeing one large European customer for white-label analog panel meters, though management cautioned "let us wait and watch until it happens."
Management: "So, analog panel meter by technology itself, of course, it's a older technology compared to digital meters and this phasing out of analog meters we have been hearing for last 20 years and it's not that it is not happening, but at the same time it is not going to be phased out totally."
Inorganic & Strategic Initiatives
- Acquisition in sight: Management is working on an acquisition opportunity and hopes to announce something by the end of this quarter, though they declined to speculate on timing, noting "until they happen, they don't happen."
- M&A focus by geography and segment: The current five-year strategy targets Asia (particularly India) for aluminium die casting, while electronics acquisition searches span India, Europe, and the USA. America is not being considered for die casting before post-2025.
- Grant funding in play: The company has applied for two European Union grant schemes from both Polish entities, with grants covering 30%-40% of total investment. The first sanction under India's MSIP scheme has been received, with disbursement awaited.
- IIT Jodhpur collaboration: A three-party arrangement with Yuan Trust (Mr. Narendra Goliya's personal philanthropic money) and IIT Jodhpur has established the Rishabh Centre for Innovation in Green Energy, focused on generation and storage research. Rishabh Instruments is not committing financially but cooperating on technology.
- Capacity build-out: A third SMT line in Poland will be available by end of October, with plans for one or two more. Greenfield construction and machinery expansion is ongoing at both Lumel and Rishabh.
Narendra Goliya: "Inorganic, as it is, there is always a probability. We are working very hard, but until it has happened, it has not happened. In the sense that let us hope that by the end of this quarter, we should be able to announce something, but let us wait and watch."
Business Model & Competitive Position
- Deliberate customer concentration: Lumel Alucast limits itself to ~20 customer groups (10 large, 10 moderate) to maintain economies of scale, alloy specialization, and management bandwidth. The company responds to only 15%-20% of RFQs received.
- Production fungibility as a moat: SMT lines, plastic injection moulding, die casting machines (400-1050 tons), CNC machines, and mould design are all fungible across projects. Only ~1% of test devices may be project-dedicated, limiting asset stranding risk.
- Export-domestic balance: The mix hovers around 50-50, which management considers ideal. Exports carry slightly better margins, but the balanced split is a deliberate risk-management choice.
- Solar inverter: large potential, no profit yet: The product is not yet profitable as imports from China dominate. The company is investing in cost reduction to make it a viable line, with management claiming "growing 100% 200% every year on the solar inverter is not a big thing" once development is complete.
Management: "We are not chasing everything and anything that is coming across our way. In fact, we are responding to only about 15%, 20% of the RFQs that we get here."
ESOP & Non-Cash Charges
- ESOP amortization schedule: The charge is a non-cash provision under Indian accounting standards, not a cash expense. The schedule runs through FY27: ₹21 crore in FY24, ₹11 crore in FY25, ₹6 crore in FY26, and ₹2 crore in FY27.
- Medium-term margin target is post-ESOP: The 18%-20% EBITDA margin ambition is stated after adjusting for ESOP costs, meaning reported margins will be lower until FY27.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| FY24 revenue growth | 22% growth; management says will "definitely do better" at current rate | FY24 full year |
| Medium-term organic revenue growth | 20%-25% top-line growth | Medium-to-long term |
| Medium-term organic EBITDA margin | 18%-20% (post-ESOP adjustment) | Medium-to-long term |
| Lumel Alucast EBITDA margin recovery | Return to ~18% from current stressed 13%-15% | 1 to 1.5 years |
| New EV project stabilization | Learning curve costs to dissipate | 1-2 quarters max |
| Analog panel meter revenue stability | Volumes within ±5% of current levels | At least next 10 years |
| ESOP amortization | ₹21 cr (FY24), ₹11 cr (FY25), ₹6 cr (FY26), ₹2 cr (FY27) | Through FY27 |
| R&D spend | 2.5%-3% of total revenues | Ongoing |
| Inorganic announcement | Hope to announce something | By end of current quarter |
| New production hall (Alucast capacity) | 18-month project to expand capacity | ~18 months |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated revenue | ₹172.4 crore, +38% YoY from ₹124.6 crore |
| Consolidated EBITDA (as reported) | ₹20.7 crore, up from ₹20.5 crore YoY |
| Consolidated adjusted EBITDA | ₹30.3 crore, +48% YoY from ₹20.5 crore |
| Rishabh India standalone revenue | ₹56.7 crore, +37% YoY from ₹41.3 crore |
| Rishabh India export revenue | ₹31.9 crore, +55% YoY from ₹20.5 crore |
| Rishabh India domestic revenue | ₹24.8 crore, +19% YoY from ₹20.8 crore |
| Rishabh India adjusted EBITDA | ₹14.9 crore, up from ₹9.8 crore YoY |
| Aluminium high pressure die casting segment revenue | ₹68.3 crore, +32% YoY from ₹52.8 crore |
| Lumel SA electronic business revenue | ₹40 crore, +43% YoY from ₹28 crore |
| Lumel SA EBITDA | ₹7.72 crore, up from ₹3.77 crore YoY |
| Lumel Alucast revenue | ₹37.2 crore, +30% YoY from ₹28.2 crore |
| Lumel Alucast adjusted EBITDA | ₹7.01 crore, +5% YoY |
| Lumel Alucast actual EBITDA (after ESOP and contingency) | Loss of ₹1.8 crore, down from profit of ₹6.65 crore YoY |
| ESOP cost (total amortization over 4 years) | ₹48 crore; ₹21 crore in FY24, ₹11 crore in FY25, ₹6 crore in FY26, ₹2 crore in FY27 |
| Contingency liability provision (2018 audit, withholding tax) | ₹3.64 crore |
| Overall production capacity utilization | ~60%; one production area stressed at ~80% |
| R&D spend | 2.5% to 3% of total revenues, last 3 years |
| Export vs domestic revenue mix | 55:45 in Q1; ideal ratio 50:50 |
| Alucast adjusted EBITDA margin target | 18%, from ~13% currently; historically 15%–20% |
| Consolidated growth (first six months) | ~28% |
| Rishabh standalone growth (first six months) | ~31%–32% |
| Lumel and Alucast growth (first six months) | ~28% |
| FY24 revenue growth forecast (management commitment) | 22%; Q1 actual 38%, H1 ~28% |
| Solar string inverter growth | +9% YoY |
| Metering, control and protection devices growth | ~47% in first 3–6 months |
| Electrical automation growth | 10% in first 3–6 months |