Key Takeaways
- Revenue up 16% YoY, but profits dipped: EBITDA fell 5% and PAT fell 7% as unusual salary hikes, higher power costs, and catch-up maintenance spending hit the P&L.
- Occupancy is maxed out at 78%: With occupancy near the 80% ceiling, future RevPAR growth must come from ARR increases, which management guides at 7-10%.
- The 100-hotel milestone is imminent: The company opened 13 hotels this quarter, including its first international property in Sri Lanka, and expects to cross 100 hotels within 1-2 months.
- Revenue-share mix will compress margins: Absolute EBITDA will grow, but percentage margins may dip slightly as the company adds more revenue-share hotels, which carry structurally lower margins than owned properties.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the 7 new hotel openings scheduled by September stay on track despite weather delays, and whether the promised H2 demand uptick materializes after a rain-dampened July.
Profitability Headwinds
- Unusual employee cost spike: Salary increments to control attrition in a reopened market made this quarter's employee cost increase "unusual" compared to other years; management states this is not a recurring quarterly event.
- Power, fuel, and maintenance catch-up: High power and fuel costs combined with INR3 crores in deferred maintenance spending, after three years of COVID-era under-investment, further compressed margins.
- Borrowing cost pressure: RBI repo rate hikes since September 2022 increased the cost of borrowing, adding to the profit decline.
- Renovation took owned-room inventory offline: Owned hotel revenue dipped from INR21 crores to INR20 crores YoY because upliftment work, such as painting, took rooms out of service for at least a week at a time.
Chander Baljee: "This is why this quarter when the increments came up, they were a little unusual as compared to any other year and this can be verified everywhere, but then we have managed. But now this is not going to be every quarter or every year."
Revenue Drivers & Occupancy Dynamics
- ARR is the only growth lever left: The company is operating at 78% occupancy, near the practical ceiling of 80%, so RevPAR growth must come from ARR, guided at 7-10% in coming quarters.
- New hotels drag blended occupancy: 15-20 hotels opened during COVID and last year are still ramping up, pulling down the average occupancy even as older hotels run at 75-90%.
- F&B is a bright spot: Banquet revenue has grown substantially as weddings shift from marriage halls to hotels, and conference business has bounced back with what management calls "revenge meeting" demand.
- In-house guest capture focus: Operations are targeting in-house guests for breakfast and encouraging them into bars and restaurants for dinner to increase per-room yields.
- July rains hurt leisure demand: Heavy rains caused a downturn in hill station and beach resort business; Goa suffered, Shimla roads were blocked for a week, and Manali roads washed away, dampening travel sentiment.
Chander Baljee: "Earlier it was revenge travel, now it's a revenge meeting. People like to meet. Socially we are social animals. We like to meet and discuss and talk and over a drink also, we like to have coffee or whatever."
Expansion Pipeline & Milestones
- 100-hotel milestone within reach: The company operates 94 hotels and expects to cross 100 within 1-2 months, though the September target may slip slightly due to weather-related construction delays.
- Seven new hotels in the pipeline: Openings scheduled for Gangtok, MacLeod Ganj, Varanasi, Shogi, Raipur, Gulbarga, and Nellore, targeted by September but possibly slipping to October-end.
- First international property opened: The company entered Sri Lanka this quarter, marking its first hotel outside India.
- Room count targets restated: Management clarified it is targeting 6,500 rooms by March 2024 and 8,000 rooms by March 2025, after some confusion on the call about whether the 7,500-room guidance had been revised.
- Goa and Bangalore resort expansions in the works: Applications filed for adding rooms at the Goa resort, though permission difficulties persist; Yelahanka resort to add 32 cottages once permission issues are resolved.
Chander Baljee: "I don't want to now give you a date and then next quarter you hold me to it, but we'll definitely cross very, very soon we'll cross these 100 numbers."
Margin & Balance Sheet Outlook
- Revenue-share mix will dilute percentage margins: As the company adds more revenue-share hotels, where lease rent must be paid from the profit share, percentage EBITDA margins may come down slightly even as absolute EBITDA grows.
- Maintenance spend tapering: INR3 crores spent this quarter on property upliftment, with INR1 crore more expected next quarter before spending tapers down.
- Debt held steady: The company is trying not to increase borrowing this year, funding planned capex from internal generation; the promoter loan for the Icon Property stake buy will be repaid within two years from internal accruals.
- Icon Property stake buy: The company plans to buy its partner's 49% stake using INR19 crores from internal accruals and a short-term promoter loan, now that the property is profit-making and depreciation is declining.
Operations & Quality Control
- New COO onboarded: Philip Logan joined nine weeks ago from Accor and Starwood, bringing development and operations experience to drive the company toward its room-count goals.
- Quality measured, not guessed: The new COO's approach centers on operational metrics, staff ratios, cost control, and purchasing, with a focus on streamlining management systems and processes.
- Management training pipeline built: A program started during COVID trains heads of department to become general managers for future hotels, reducing costs at both the sending and receiving properties.
- Staff-to-room ratio optimization underway: The effort is to optimize staff strength toward roughly 1.3 overall, though management says there is no fixed formula and did not provide the current ratio or a timeline.
Philip Logan: "The answer to the question is you can only manage what you measure."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Hotel count milestone | Cross 100 operating hotels | Within 1-2 months (by October-end at latest) |
| Room count target | 6,500 rooms | By March 2024 |
| Room count target | 8,000 rooms | By March 2025 |
| ARR growth | 7% to 10% average growth | Coming quarters |
| Revenue target | INR400 crores top line | FY24 |
| EBITDA target | INR120 crores | FY24 |
| Maintenance spending | INR1 crore more, then tapering down | Next quarter |
| Promoter loan repayment | Repaid from internal accruals | Within 2 years |
| Seven new hotel openings | Gangtok, MacLeod Ganj, Varanasi, Shogi, Raipur, Gulbarga, Nellore | By September, possibly slipping to October-end |
| Icon Property stake buy | Acquire partner's 49% stake | Funded this year via internal accruals and promoter loan |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated revenue from operations | ₹73.72 cr, +16% YoY |
| Consolidated EBITDA | ₹22.92 cr, -5% YoY |
| Consolidated PAT before exceptional item | ₹10.73 cr, -7% YoY |
| Average room rate (ARR) | ₹5,227, +7% YoY |
| RevPAR | ₹4,123, up from ₹3,883 in Q1 FY23 |
| Occupancy | 78%, same as Q1 FY23 |
| Owned hotel revenue | ₹20 cr, down from ₹21 cr in Q1 FY23 |
| Managed property RevPAR | ~₹2,600 |
| FY24 revenue guidance | ₹400 cr |
| FY24 EBITDA guidance | ₹120 cr |
| Hotels operating | 94 |
| Hotels opened during quarter | 13, with 755 keys |
| Room count | 5,600 |
| FY24 room addition target | 1,000 rooms, to reach 6,500 by March 2024 |
| FY25 room addition target | 1,500 rooms, to reach 8,000 by March 2025 |
| F&B to room revenue ratio | 67%, up from 63% |
| Staff-to-room ratio target | ~1.3 |
| Management fees income (FY23) | ₹24 cr |
| Promoter loan interest rate | 14%, reduced from 18% |