Key Takeaways
- Deliberate volume sacrifice, margin defense: Volumes fell 7% YoY as management chose price over volume in a subdued quarter, a trade that kept cement realization nearly flat sequentially and EBITDA per ton at an industry-leading ~₹780.[7-8]
- Cost tailwinds are materializing: Total cost per ton dropped 8% YoY (₹4,503 to ₹4,122), and fuel costs will reflect the current purchase price of ₹1.51 only by Q4 or early Q1 FY26, promising further relief ahead.
- Capacity expansion is on the near-term horizon: All four ongoing projects are on track for commissioning between April and June 2025, which will take total capacity to 70 MTPA, the next milestone on the path to 80 MTPA by FY28.
- The premium-product engine is being rebuilt: After stabilizing new brands, management reinstated legacy premium brands (Roofon, Bangur Shree Jung Rodhak) and aims to hold the premium mix at ~15% before pushing higher.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether demand recovers as budgeted government spending converts to purchase orders, the pace at which lower fuel costs flow into the P&L, and any update on the Bangalore expansion’s regulatory clearance.
The Price-Over-Volume Trade
- A deliberate strategy for a weak quarter: Management entered Q2 knowing demand would be very subdued because of a delayed union budget (presidential assent on August 16), a prolonged intense monsoon, slower government infrastructure spending, and an eight-month low in the manufacturing PMI. It explicitly chose to protect price over chasing volume. [3-4]
- The volume cost: Total sales dropped from 96 to 76 lakh tons QoQ, with clinker sales falling from 5.26 to 3.63 lakh tons. Regionally, North volumes fell 6%, East 8%, and South 10% YoY.
- The pricing payoff: Cement realization was nearly flat sequentially (₹4,464 in Q1 vs ₹4,447 in Q2), outperforming the industry average. Revenue per ton dropped only 0.4% sequentially.
- Trade-channel shift in the North: Management reduced non-trade sales in the North from 41% to 35% and increased trade sales from 59% to 65%, a structural move to protect pricing in its home market.[8-9]
- Lead distance as a pricing lever: Average lead distance fell from 475 km to 433 km because the company sold less in far-off markets, a direct consequence of the price-over-volume strategy. Management intends to keep lead distance around current levels but may return to markets where price attractiveness is high.
- The trade-off, stated plainly: Management acknowledged the classic tension between volume and pricing, noting that chasing volume forces everyone to drop prices to capture the same demand.
Ashok Bhandari: "Please understand that there is a classic disconnect between increasing volume and increasing pricing. If you want to increase volume, you have to give up some pricing because everybody else will drop the prices to chase the same value."
Cost Structure & Margin Dynamics
- Total cost reduction: Cost per ton excluding depreciation and interest fell 8% YoY from ₹4,503 to ₹4,122, driven by operational efficiency and durable international fuel prices. Average CV fuel cost reduced from 2.05 to 1.71 YoY.
- Fuel cost lag still to play out: The current purchase price of fuel is ₹1.51, but this will only reflect in the P&L in Q4 FY25 or partly in Q1 FY26, meaning a further cost tailwind is already locked in.
- EBITDA dilution mechanics: Blended EBITDA was diluted because the cost reduction was relatively smaller than the realization drop, other operating income declined slightly, and capacity utilization fell to 56%, reducing fixed cost recovery.
- Other expenses drop partly accounting-driven: A major reason for the decline in other expenses was the reclassification of royalties (~₹100 cr impact) from other expenses to raw material cost, aligning with industry practice. Logistics costs also improved due to lower lead distance, and stabilization expenses reduced as units stabilized.
- Depreciation nearly doubled in H1: The sharp YoY increase came from commissioning 0.6 crore tons of new capacity plus WHR and other small capitalizations. Management declined to provide a depreciation number for next year, saying it depends on whether commissioning happens on April 1 or June 30.
- Cash profit over net profit: Management explicitly asked investors to focus on cash profit, not net profit, arguing that accelerated depreciation is converting non-fungible fixed assets into fungible cash assets at a faster rate.
Ashok Bhandari: "I always maintain that Shree is cash profit centric, not net profit centric and I shall be indeed very happy if you pass the same message to the investors that please don't look at net profit of Shree, look at cash profit of Shree."
Capacity Expansion & Growth Projects
- Four projects on track for mid-2025: Expansion projects at Jaitaran, Kodla, Baloda Bazaar, and Etah are running on schedule and expected to be commissioned between April and June next year. Management will try to prepone if possible.
- The 70-to-80 MTPA pathway: Current capacity will reach 70 MTPA in June 2025 once these four projects are commissioned. The next milestone is 80 MTPA, with the company remaining committed to over 8 crore tons by FY28. The 70 MTPA phase is brownfield-heavy, while the 80 MTPA phase will be greenfield-heavy.
- Bangalore expansion awaiting clearance: A 0.3 crore ton capacity addition in Bangalore is still awaiting regulatory clearances, with no certain timeline.
- CAPEX run-rate: The company expects to spend approximately ₹4,000 crore every year for the next four years.
- RMC foray ahead of plan: In its first year in the ready-mix concrete business, the company has already commissioned 7 plants (5 in Mumbai, 2 in Hyderabad), exceeding its initial target of 5 plants. It expects to reach double-digit plant count by FY25 year-end.
- Middle East unit now cash-profitable: The UAE operation has reached the point of making cash profits.
Premium Products & Brand Strategy
- A two-track premium strategy: After stabilizing volumes of new premium brands, management reinstated some of its time-tested legacy premium brands (Roofon, Bangur Shree Jung Rodhak) to the market with some tweaks. Results have been favorable to estimates.
- Premium mix target: The company will stabilize its premium product share at around 15% for the next few quarters, then take the next jump to a higher level once stabilized.
- The logic: Management sees this as a calibrated approach: first lock in the new brands, then bring back proven legacy brands to strengthen the portfolio, and only then push for a higher mix.
Neeraj Akhoury: "Once we have stabilized the volumes of the new premium brands, then we have also bought back some of our most tested brands back to the market. So, that is the strategy that we are following and I think it is working quite well."
Sustainability & Green Power
- Industry-leading green power share: Green power reached 54.8% of total power use, the highest in the cement industry. An additional 90 MW of green power capacity is under construction and expected to be completed by March 2025.
- 60% target by mid-2025: Management expects to reach 60% of total energy from green sources by June 2025 and is exploring hybrid wind-solar installations at the same site for better plant load factors.
- Water and ESG milestones: All facilities are zero liquid discharge, the company achieved over 7 times water positivity last year, and aims to improve further after plentiful rains this year. The DJSI score improved from 62 to 73, the highest in the construction material sector in India.
Demand Outlook & Regional Expectations
- Near-term demand catalysts: Management expects demand growth to turn positive in the next 2-3 months and over the next 6 months because most budgetary allocations will convert into purchase orders across states, the festive season will provide a boost, and an improved Kharif crop should support rural demand.
- Sustained price recovery conditional on demand: Management cautioned that sustained price improvement depends on steady demand recovery across segments, not just a seasonal uptick.
- Regional divergence expected: The company expects relatively better growth in the North and South, with more muted growth in the East.
- Volume growth to track the industry: Management expects volumes to be broadly in line with industry demand growth, sometimes a little higher, sometimes a little lower. It declined to comment on whether it lost market share in Q2.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Capacity expansion commissioning | All four ongoing projects (Jaitaran, Kodla, Baloda Bazaar, Etah) to be commissioned | April to June 2025; management will try to prepone |
| Green power capacity addition | 90 MW additional green power capacity completed | By March 2025 |
| Green power share | Reach 60% of total energy from green sources | By June 2025 |
| Capacity target | Reach over 8 crore tons (80 MTPA) | By FY28 |
| Annual CAPEX run-rate | Approximately ₹4,000 crore per year | Next 4 years |
| Premium product mix | Stabilize at ~15% before pushing higher | Next few quarters |
| Fuel cost reflection | Current purchase price of ₹1.51 to reflect in P&L | Q4 FY25 or partly Q1 FY26 |
| RMC plant count | Reach double-digit plants | By FY25 year-end |
| Volume growth | Broadly in line with industry demand growth | Ongoing |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY25 |
|---|---|
| Cement realization | ₹4,447 per ton, flattish QoQ from ₹4,464 in Q1 |
| Revenue per ton change | 0.4% decline sequentially, outperforming industry average |
| Volume growth | -7% YoY |
| EBITDA per ton | ₹780, highest in the industry |
| Total cost per ton (excl. depreciation and interest) | ₹4,122, down 8% YoY from ₹4,503 |
| Average CV fuel cost | 1.71, down from 2.05 YoY |
| Cash EPS | ₹196-197, compared to ₹260 in Q1 and ₹478 in H1 FY24 |
| Net EPS | ₹25 |
| Capacity utilization | 56%, down from Q1 on lower volumes |
| Total sales volume (incl. clinker) | 76 lakh tons, down from 96 lakh tons QoQ |
| Premium products share in trade segment | 15%, up from 9% in Q1 |
| Trade sale proportion (all India) | 74%+ |
| Green power share | 54.8% of total power use, highest in the cement industry |
| Lead distance | 433 km, down from 475 km YoY and 453 km in Q1 |
| Blended cement sales ratio | 70% |
| Pet coke in fuel mix | 88%, balance alternative fuel |
| Regional sales mix | North 58%, East 31%, South 11% |
| Regional volume growth (YoY) | North -6%, East -8%, South -10% |
| Regional capacity utilization | North 58%, East 63%, South 40% |
| Clinker sales | 3.63 lakh tons, down from 5.26 lakh tons in Q1 |
| Other operating income | ₹66 cr, up from ₹45 cr in Q1 |
| Treasury income | ₹130-135 cr |
| Half-year depreciation | ₹1,311 cr, full-year expected at ~₹2,700 cr |
| Half-year CAPEX | ₹1,860 cr, full-year guidance ~₹4,000 cr |
| RMC plants operational | 7 plants (5 Mumbai, 2 Hyderabad), targeting double digits by FY25 end |
| Dow Jones Sustainability Index score | 73, highest in construction material sector in India, up from 62 |