Key Takeaways
- NIMs surged to 8.93%, but guidance stays conservative: A 60 bps sequential jump was driven by lower negative carry and a mix shift toward higher-yield products, yet management reiterated an 8.5% NIM target as new vehicle demand is expected to dilute the mix.
- AUM growth is accelerating beyond the core CV franchise: While commercial vehicles grew 12%, the fastest growth came from passenger vehicles, MSME, gold, and personal loans, pushing the company toward an 18-20% AUM growth trajectory for the year.
- The personal loan book is a closed ecosystem, not open-market: 100% of personal loans go to existing customers with a completed loan cycle, and 85% are small self-employed businessmen using funds for working capital, insulating the book from broader unsecured lending stress.
- Asset quality is stable, but ECL conservatism masks the improvement: Stage-1 coverage was hiked 20 bps to 3.1% based on stress tests, and management expects the benefit of better asset quality to reflect only in subsequent periods due to the 5-year data window.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the seasonal shift to lower-yield new vehicles compresses NIMs as guided, the pace of the Super App rollout to customers, and any clarity on the Housing Finance Stage-2 ECL spike that went unanswered.
Margin Dynamics & Product Mix
- NIM expansion had two drivers, but the split is undisclosed: Management attributed the 60 bps sequential improvement to reducing liquidity cover from 4-5 months to 3 months and a product mix shift toward higher-yield segments, but declined to quantify each component on the call.
- Yield rose without rate hikes: No rate increases were taken in the last 3-6 months for CV and PV segments; the 30-40 bps yield improvement came purely from a greater share of MSME, gold, and personal loans in the portfolio.
- Cost of funds provided a tailwind: While yields rose, the cost of funds decreased, and lower negative carry from deploying excess liquidity added a further advantage. Incremental funding costs are expected to stay around 8.75% to 9% in the coming months.
- The margin outlook is deliberately cautious: Management expects more demand for new vehicles in the second half, which are lower-yield products, and therefore stands by the 8.5% NIM guidance, with a possible range of 8.5% to 9% depending on market conditions.
Umesh Revankar: "We would like to continue with our guidance on 8.5, but yes, depending upon the market situation, it can vary a little. So, it should be anywhere between 8.5 and 9."
Asset Quality & Credit Costs
- Write-offs appear elevated due to settlement timing, not stress: The ₹839 cr write-off looks high because June quarter settlements were lower; this quarter saw close to 0.15 crore contracts closed with an average write-off of around ₹5,500 per ticket, a range that has held steady for many years.
- ECL coverage was tightened preemptively: Stage-1 ECL cover increased 20 bps from 2.9% to 3.1%, based on historical data and stress tests linked to inflation and CPI. Management expects to maintain coverage around the 3% level.
- The 5-year ECL window delays recognition of improvement: Because the calculation uses a 5-year lookback that includes stressful periods, any improvement in current asset quality will only flow through in subsequent periods. A shift to a shorter window would produce a different result, but no change is planned until next year.
- Credit cost guidance is 1.5% to 2% for the full year: Asset quality is anticipated to remain stable and improve by a few more basis points.
- Housing Finance Stage-2 ECL doubled without explanation: An analyst flagged that Stage-2 provisioning in the housing finance subsidiary jumped from 3.5% to 7.3% in one quarter. Management said no ECL assumption change was made and promised to check and revert.
Personal Loans: A Differentiated Risk Profile
- The book is built entirely on existing relationships: Personal loans are 100% targeted at customers who have finished at least one loan cycle with the company. 35% of disbursements go to repeat customers who have closed two loans and returned for a third; the remainder are two-wheeler customers who completed their loan cycle.
- The customer base is small self-employed businessmen, not salaried consumers: 85% of personal loan customers are self-employed or small businessmen such as milk vendors, plumbers, electricians, and vegetable sellers, with most of the money going toward small working capital needs rather than discretionary consumption.
- Higher GNPA versus two-wheelers is structural, not a red flag: Personal loan GNPAs are higher than two-wheelers because two-wheeler loans are secured and the customer fears losing the asset, while personal loans require more persuasion. Management frames this as the nature of unsecured lending.
- The company is explicitly not in open-market personal loans or BNPL: Management stressed that it does not compete with open-market personal loan players or platforms, and has no presence in the buy-now-pay-later segment.
Y S Chakravarti: "85% of my personal loan customers are either self-employed or small businessmen, so most of this money goes towards small working capital use. These are basically could be your milk vendor, could be your plumber, electrician, your vegetable, fruit seller, these kinds of small businessmen."
Growth Drivers & Franchise Expansion
- CV remains the mainstay, but other products are growing faster: Commercial vehicle growth was 12%, within the 12-15% guided range, while passenger vehicles, MSME, gold, and personal loans posted the highest growth over the last six months. The strategy is for CV to continue at 12-15% while other products accelerate.
- Passenger vehicle growth is driven by ticket size and reach: Retail prices have risen 30% to 40%, boosting portfolio growth, and the number of branches offering PV and CV has increased. PV is an easy cross-sell for erstwhile SCUF branches.
- MSME growth came from distribution, not larger tickets: Ticket sizes have not grown; an additional 10-12% growth came from introducing MSME loans in commercial vehicle branches.
- Used vehicle market share is not being lost: Management stated it is actually gaining share in used vehicles. The shift toward new vehicles this quarter was seasonal, with some used vehicle owners upgrading.
- Branch network is set to expand further: The company plans to convert some of its 800 service centers into full-fledged branches, adding to the distribution reach that is already driving MSME and PV growth.
Operating Efficiency & People
- Cost-to-income improved to 25.68% from 27.34% sequentially: The previous quarter carried a higher gratuity charge due to an assumption change; this quarter is more normalized. The full-year cost-to-income is expected to be around 26% to 27%.
- 5,030 employees were added, almost all in sales: 95-97% of new hires are feet-on-street for the sales role, and the company may add another 1,500 to 2,000 people in the next six months.
- Operating leverage is still 3-4 quarters away: Management indicated at least another 3-4 quarters before capping manpower and pushing for operating leverage, implying the current investment in distribution will continue through most of FY25.
- Pricing discipline is maintained even where premiums exist: For two-wheeler and MSME loans, the company charges 100 to 150 bps more than competitors and sees no reason to increase rates further unless NIMs come under pressure.
Y S Chakravarti: "We feel the products are priced right. So, we don't find a reason why we should increase those rates, push the rates up and we also have to keep the market in mind... Two-wheeler vehicle is a very competitive product. We are at least 100 to 150 basis points more than what our competitors charge. I think we are rightly priced."
Digital & Partnerships
- The "Shriram One" Super App was launched: Available on Google Play Store and iOS App Store, the app covers loan repayment, investment, insurance, credit score checks, social networking, shopping, and utility payments. Rollout will start with employees, then existing customers, before a wider launch.
- Paytm partnership is two weeks from going live: Tech integration is in process and should be completed in the next two weeks, after which business will commence.
- Fintech tie-ups target new-to-credit and supply chain segments: The company has tied up with one fintech for extending credit to new-to-credit customers and a couple of fintechs for supply chain funding. No scaling targets have been set; management wants to observe performance for at least 2-3 quarters before committing to numbers.
- Personal loan cross-sell to Shriram Transport customers has not yet begun: The company already offers products for tires, batteries, and fuel, but pure-play consumption personal loans to transport customers will depend on earning and repayment ability, not a pre-approved push.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| NIM | 8.5%, with a range of 8.5% to 9% depending on market conditions | Ongoing |
| AUM growth | 15% from year beginning; 18-20% is a good indication for the rest of the year | FY24 |
| CV growth | 12% to 15% | Ongoing |
| Credit cost | 1.5% to 2% | Full year FY24 |
| Cost-to-income | Around 26% to 27% | Full year FY24 |
| Stage-1 ECL coverage | Around 3% | Ongoing |
| Incremental cost of funds | 8.75% to 9% | Next few months |
| Liquidity cover | Strictly 3 months, around 6-6.5% of borrowings | Ongoing |
| Employee additions | Another 1,500 to 2,000 people | Next 6 months |
| ROE | 16% next year, improving to 18% thereafter | FY25 and beyond |
| Paytm partnership | Tech integration complete, business to start | Within 2 weeks |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY24 |
|---|---|
| AUM | ₹2,02,640.96 cr, +19.65% YoY and +4.88% QoQ |
| Disbursements | ₹34,605.61 cr, +30.91% YoY and +13.63% QoQ |
| Net interest income | ₹4,818.18 cr, +17.38% YoY and +8.55% QoQ |
| Net interest margin | 8.93%, vs 8.26% in Q2 FY23 and 8.33% in Q1 FY24 |
| Profit after tax | ₹1,750.84 cr, +12.59% YoY and +4.5% QoQ |
| Earnings per share | ₹46.67, vs ₹41.53 in Q2 FY23 and ₹44.73 in Q1 FY24 |
| Cost to income ratio | 25.68%, vs 24.2% in Q2 FY23 and 27.34% in Q1 FY24 |
| Gross stage 3 | 5.79%, improved from 6.31% in Q2 FY23 and 6.03% in Q1 FY24 |
| Net stage 3 | 2.8%, improved from 3.32% in Q2 FY23 and 2.96% in Q1 FY24 |
| Credit cost | 2.02%, vs 1.73% in Q2 FY23 and 1.62% in Q1 FY24 |
| Write-offs | ₹839 cr, with provisions of ₹289 cr totaling ₹1,128 cr |
| Total debt | ₹1,65,547 cr, increase of ₹3,500 cr QoQ; cost of debt 8.87% |
| Employee count | 71,373, increased by 5,030 QoQ |
| Dividend declared | ₹20 per share (200%) |
| Shriram Housing Finance AUM | ₹10,816.03 cr, +65.23% YoY and +13.38% QoQ |
| Shriram Housing Finance PAT | ₹48.21 cr, +41.7% YoY and +5.67% QoQ |