Key Takeaways
- Merger complete, one-off charges mask underlying trends: The merger of Shriram Transport and Shriram City Union concluded in FY23, but Q4 PAT fell sharply to ₹1,308.31 cr due to a ₹295 cr one-time stress test provision and ₹302.58 cr in catch-up intangible amortization.
- AUM growth on track, NIM stable: AUM grew 4.61% QoQ to ₹1,85,682.90 cr, while NIM improved marginally to 8.55%, calculated on a daily average basis.
- Asset quality improved despite a higher credit cost: Gross stage 3 declined 8 bps QoQ to 6.21%, but reported credit cost rose to 2.24% for the quarter solely because of the one-time stress test provision.
- Cost-to-income spike is a non-cash, recurring item: The ratio jumped to 28.29% from 22.23% QoQ, driven by a ₹302.58 cr intangible amortization charge that will recur at ₹75 cr per quarter for the next four years.
- What to watch next quarter: The trajectory of cost of funds, which management expects to rise at least 10 bps, and whether the 15% AUM growth guidance holds.
Merger Integration & One-Off Financial Impacts
- Merger fully operational: IT and HR functions are fully integrated, and the majority of branches now offer at least one additional product from the combined entity's portfolio.
- Stress test provision: A one-time, portfolio-wide stress test conducted by a Big Four firm resulted in a ₹295 cr provision hit. The exercise recalculated PDs using data up to December, removed a previously used fifth year, and incorporated macroeconomic variables, leading to marginally elevated PD/LGD assumptions across almost all products.
- Intangible amortization: An intangible asset of ₹1,513 cr was created on merger, related to tax benefits from using the SCUF branch network. The full-year impact of ₹303 cr was taken entirely in Q4 FY23 because it was not accounted for in earlier quarters. This will be a recurring charge of ~₹75 cr per quarter for the next four years.
- Tax rate elevation: The higher effective tax rate in Q4 was due to the disallowance of ECL provisions previously claimed as expenditure. This timing difference will keep the tax rate elevated at approximately 26% for the next couple of years, per a post-call management clarification.
- COVID provision utilization: COVID-related provisions were reduced from ₹1,650 cr to ₹1,100 cr, used to provide waivers to customers impacted during the pandemic.
S. Sunder: "The stress testing was done by a Big Four and the impact of the same was Rs. 295 crores in the current quarter. It is a one-time hit which we have taken in the book, and hence the credit cost for the year has gone up about 2%, which is 2.01, stands at 2.01%."
Asset Quality & Credit Cost
- Stage 3 improvement: Gross stage 3 declined 8 bps QoQ to 6.21% and net stage 3 declined 1 bp to 3.19%, reflecting better portfolio performance and robust resale prices for vehicles, equipment, and property.
- Credit cost breakdown: Full-year credit cost was 2.01%, in line with the 2% guidance. The Q4 spike to 2.24% from 1.75% QoQ was entirely attributable to the one-time stress test provision.
- Guidance maintained: Management explicitly stated that the 2% credit cost guidance will continue to remain going forward, despite the recalculated PD assumptions from the stress test.
- Shriram Housing Finance quality: Gross stage 3 for the housing finance subsidiary improved to 0.93% from 1.15% QoQ, supported by robust demand and distribution expansion.
Umesh Revankar: "I am very happy to say that all the segments which Shriram Finance represents as an industry leader and has significant presence have seen healthy growth, and we expect with the resale price of vehicle, equipment and property being robust, that will create a better credit demand plus which will also help in credit costs significantly."
Margins, Cost of Funds & NII
- NIM calculation nuance: Reported NIM of 8.55% is calculated on a daily average AUM, not simple opening or closing averages. Loan booking is typically very high in the last few days of the quarter, inflating end-of-quarter AUM relative to the daily average.
- NII one-offs: Q4 NII included a ₹145 cr positive impact from merger-related accounting changes, compared to ₹138 cr in Q3. When an analyst asked why core NIM appeared to have declined after adjusting for these one-offs, management did not explain the movement on the call and directed the query offline.
- Cost of funds rising: Cost of funds increased 5 bps QoQ to 8.82% due to the RBI's 25 bps policy rate hike in February 2023. Incremental borrowing for the quarter of ~₹20,000 cr was at close to 9%.
- Near-term trajectory: Management expects at least a 10 bps increase in cost of funds in the next quarter, but not the full 25 bps RBI policy transmission.
Parag Sharma: "I don't expect the full 25 basis point RBI policy increase to be there for us for next quarter. There will be at least 10 basis point increase in the cost of fund for sure from the current level."
Growth Strategy & Portfolio Shifts
- Bottom-line over top-line: Management explicitly stated that the focus will be on improving net profits and bottom line rather than top-line growth, even while committing to a 15% AUM growth target for the next three years.
- Retail acceleration via STFC branches: Retail products from the erstwhile SCUF portfolio are expected to grow faster by leveraging the much larger erstwhile Shriram Transport branch network. The reverse is not expected to be as accretive for the CV business.
- Personal loan de-risking: The legacy market-sourced personal loan book is almost fully run down. Current personal loans are entirely to in-house database customers who have completed a cycle or at least 75%+ of their loan tenure, with only ~4.5-5% of the eligible database mined so far.
- MSME focus: Confidence in growing the MSME book faster stems from the availability of the network and people with vintage within the group, with MSME being a focused product.
- Two-wheeler ambition: Nearly 0.12 crore two-wheelers were disbursed in FY23, with a focus on the number of units funded rather than the amount. Management expects two-wheeler disbursements to grow by about 10% to 12%.
Umesh Revankar: "Gaurav, the focus will be to improve on the net profits bottom line rather than the top line growth."
Subsidiary & Liability Management
- Shriram Housing Finance growth: Disbursements grew 29.98% QoQ and AUM grew 12.10% QoQ, driven by distribution expansion with 19 branches added in H2 FY23, taking the total to 131. The subsidiary is a dominant player across southern states and Gujarat and plans to expand in selected focused geographies.
- Liquidity policy unchanged: The policy of maintaining three months of liability repayment as liquid cash will not be diluted; the buffer will increase if liabilities go up.
- Bond market activity: Offshore bond maturities in July and August are being evaluated, and the company will look at market opportunities for both domestic and offshore issuances, with domestic private placements continuing.
Parag Sharma: "I think we always had a policy of maintaining three months of liability repayment as liquid cash, and that has not been changed. ... So, that we are not going to dilute."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| AUM growth | 15% AUM growth target maintained | Next three years |
| Credit cost | Guidance of 2% will continue to remain | Going forward |
| Intangible amortization | ~₹75 cr per quarter (₹300 cr per year) | Next four years |
| Cost of funds increase | At least 10 bps increase from current level | Next quarter (Q1 FY24) |
| Effective tax rate | Approximately 26% (post-call clarification) | Subsequent years |
| Two-wheeler disbursement growth | 10% to 12% growth expected | FY24 |
| Bottom-line focus | Improve net profits rather than top-line growth | Ongoing |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY23 |
|---|---|
| AUM | ₹1,85,682.90 cr, up 4.61% QoQ; FY22: ₹1,27,040.80 cr |
| Disbursements | ₹31,054.10 cr, up 6.19% QoQ; Q4 FY22: ₹25,054.08 cr |
| Net interest income | ₹4,445.89 cr, up 0.41% QoQ; Q4 FY22: ₹2,627.82 cr |
| Net interest margin | 8.55%, vs 8.52% in Q3 FY23 and 6.96% in Q4 FY22 |
| Profit after tax | ₹1,308.31 cr, degrew vs ₹1,776.97 cr in Q3 FY23 |
| Earnings per share | ₹34.94, vs ₹47.46 in Q3 FY23 and ₹40.15 in Q4 FY22 |
| Gross stage 3 | 6.21%, down 8 bps QoQ; Q4 FY22: 7.07% |
| Net stage 3 | 3.19%, down 1 bp QoQ; Q4 FY22: 3.67% |
| Credit cost (quarter) | 2.24%, vs 1.75% in Q3 FY23; includes ₹295 cr one-time stress test provision |
| Full-year credit cost | 2.01%, after stress test hit; guidance of 2% to continue |
| Cost to income ratio | 28.29%, vs 22.23% in Q3 FY23; includes ₹302.58 cr intangible amortization |
| Cost of funds | 8.82%, up from 8.77% in Q3 FY23 |
| Debt equity | 3.65x, vs 3.61x in Q3 FY23 |
| AUM growth guidance | 15%, maintained for next three years |
| Effective tax rate guidance | ~26%, for subsequent years (management clarification post-call) |