Key Takeaways
- Walter Pack margin recovery drives the quarter: EBITDA margins at the acquired subsidiary rebounded from 12.8% to 20.4% QoQ as OEM volume disruptions eased, pulling consolidated EBITDA margin to 25.5%.
- Full-year guidance held, with PAT caveat: Management reaffirmed consolidated revenue growth near 45% Y-o-Y and organic growth over 1.5x the industry, while PAT growth near 30% excludes acquisition-related amortization and one-time costs.
- Optical cover glass is the next big bet: The new technology could increase standalone SJS's kit value per passenger vehicle by nearly 10x, with orders expected in the next one to two quarters.
- Debt paydown on track: Management is confident of reaching negligible net debt by FY2024 end, with most remaining loans repaid in Q1 FY2025.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether optical cover glass orders materialize, the pace of Walter Pack's continued margin normalization, and any FY2025 pro forma growth guidance.
Walter Pack Turnaround
- Margin snapback: EBITDA margins recovered to 20.4% in Q3 from 12.8% in Q2, as key OEM volumes that had been disrupted by launch issues at the customer end gradually picked up and stabilized.
- Revenue still climbing back: Q3 revenue of ~₹33 crore was up sequentially from ~₹28 crore of actual revenue in Q2 (which included ~₹11 crore of tooling revenue), but management noted the key OEMs' volumes were flattish QoQ, not yet back to Q1 levels.
- Startup cost drag fading: New technologies introduced for the first time in India carried learning curve costs, internal trial expenses, and startup rejections, all of which management expects to stabilize within a quarter or two.
- Q4 set to be stronger: Robust orders are in hand not only for existing models but with increased content per vehicle from new product wins, giving management confidence that Q4 will be even better than Q3.
Sanjay Thapar: "So, what I guided in the last quarterly call was that margin should come back to somewhere midway between what it finally should be and where we are. So we have demonstrated that robust growth in margins at Walter Pack India and moving forward it should normalize in Q4 and early Q1 FY2025."
Optical Cover Glass & New Technologies
- A potential game changer: Management called the addition of optical cover glass a complete game changer that will reduce two-wheeler dependence even in the standalone SJS business and increase standalone kit value in the passenger vehicle segment by nearly 10x.
- Certification milestone achieved: SJS became the first printing company in India to be awarded the quality system certificate for optical cover glass technology.
- Order timeline: The business is currently in the auditing phase where processes are being verified; proof of concepts have been given to customers and evaluated, with management hoping to have orders in the next one or two quarters.
- Broader technology push: SJS is also working with OEMs to introduce innovative premium products like IML wheel caps and complex IML and IMD parts for consumer companies, which management acknowledged may pressure near-term gross margins but serve the business better in the long run.
Sanjay Thapar: "Optical cover glass is a very high value part and that is there I said if you talk of standalone SJS, this is going to increase our content per four-wheeler by almost 10x, that is for standalone SJS."
Exotech Performance
- Record margins since acquisition: Exotech posted its highest-ever EBITDA margin at 18.4%, improving 224 bps QoQ and 588 bps Y-o-Y, driven by enhanced growth margins, operational efficiency, lower raw material consumption, and a better product mix.
- Steady-state margin target: Management guided that 15% is a sustainable margin floor, with efforts underway to push steady-state margins into the 15%-16% region.
- New business contributing: The Whirlpool chrome plating badge business won earlier began contributing from last quarter, adding to the top line.
Demand & Industry Outperformance
- 17th consecutive quarter of outperformance: Consolidated revenue grew 51% Y-o-Y, with two-wheeler sales up 21.6% versus industry production growth of 19%, and passenger vehicle sales up 56.7% versus industry volume growth of just 5%, the latter boosted by Walter Pack and an increasing PV share.
- Exports recovering toward peak: Exports grew 39.7% Y-o-Y in Q3, with management expecting to return to FY2022 export levels by year-end, though a slow-paced recovery in certain pockets of Europe partially offset new business wins.
- New business wins broad-based: Key wins came from M&M, Tata Motors, Autoliv, Whirlpool, Ola, Royal Enfield, Honda Motorcycles, and TVS, among others, with new businesses starting from Q3 onward supporting growth into Q4.
- Customer expansion: Standalone SJS added a telecom player, Atomberg, and Autoliv in the last couple of quarters, though management emphasized that growth is driven more by winning new businesses from existing customers than by adding new logos.
Sanjay Thapar: "The guidance of course is that maybe over the next two to three years almost export should increase from about 7% to close to about 10%-11% of our consolidated revenues."
Margins & Profitability
- Consolidated EBITDA improved QoQ: Margins rose to 25.5%, primarily on the back of the Walter Pack recovery, though PAT margin was slightly impacted by lower other income, increased interest cost on Walter Pack acquisition debt, and higher amortization of intangible assets at ₹2.15 crore per quarter.
- Standalone gross margin dipped on mix: Gross margin declined both Y-o-Y and QoQ due to the product mix impact of launching new technologies, a trade-off management accepted at the start of the year and is not worried about given demonstrated resilience in recovering margins.
- Interest cost anomaly: Despite debt repayment during the quarter, interest cost did not decline proportionally because deferred processing costs on term loans were charged off in the quarter upon repayment, offsetting the saving.
- ROCE to improve gradually: Return on capital employed was impacted by the Walter Pack acquisition and will recover over the next one to two years as utilization of the new investment improves.
Sanjay Thapar: "We are not so worried about the gross margin because we have demonstrated considerable resilience in getting back to margins. So, the idea was what we guided in the beginning of the year as well that we are going to enter into new technologies which are going to serve our purpose better in the long run."
Balance Sheet & Capex
- Net debt nearing zero: Management expressed confidence that by the conclusion of FY2024, SJS will have negligible debt on its books, with some loans repaid in Q4 FY2024 and the bulk of the remainder in Q1 FY2025.
- Capex plan for FY2025: ₹40-45 crore is planned, plus expansion for Exotech and Walter Pack on land already acquired; detailed plans will be shared around Q2 or Q3 FY2025.
- Capacity utilization at Walter Pack: Utilization was 70%-75% in Q3 on expanded capacity (up from 65%-70% at acquisition), with room to grow further in Q4 and beyond.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Consolidated revenue growth | Near 45% Y-o-Y | FY2024 |
| Organic revenue growth | Over 1.5x industry growth, close to ~20% Y-o-Y | FY2024 |
| Consolidated PAT growth | Near 30% Y-o-Y, excluding ₹2.15 cr/quarter intangible amortization and one-time acquisition costs | FY2024 |
| Net debt | Negligible debt on books | By FY2024 end |
| Walter Pack margin normalization | Normalize from Q3's 20.4% toward steady state | Q4 FY2024 and early Q1 FY2025 |
| Optical cover glass orders | First orders received | Next one to two quarters |
| Organic growth (pro forma) | 20%-25% CAGR, assuming Walter Pack in base for full year | FY2025 |
| Industry outperformance | Outperform market by 1.5x to 2x | Ongoing |
| Export share of consolidated revenue | Grow from ~7% to 10%-11% | Over next two to three years |
| Capex | ₹40-45 crore plus Exotech/Walter Pack expansion | FY2025 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated revenue | ₹160.59 cr, +51% YoY |
| Organic revenue growth (SJS + Exotech) | +21.8% YoY |
| Consolidated EBITDA | ₹41.24 cr, +45.2% YoY |
| Consolidated EBITDA margin | 25.5%, +266 bps QoQ |
| Organic EBITDA margin (SJS + Exotech) | 26.7%, +53 bps YoY and +63 bps QoQ |
| Consolidated PAT | ₹20.85 cr, +32.7% YoY |
| Consolidated PAT margin | 13% |
| Organic PAT | ₹20.24 cr, +28.8% YoY with margin of 15.6% |
| FY2024 consolidated revenue growth guidance | ~45% YoY |
| FY2024 organic revenue growth guidance | ~20% YoY (over 1.5x industry growth) |
| FY2024 consolidated PAT growth guidance | ~30% YoY, excluding higher amortization cost and one-time acquisition costs |
| Consolidated automotive sales growth | +36.9% YoY; organic automotive growth +16.4% YoY |
| Two-wheeler sales growth (consolidated) | +21.6% YoY vs industry production volume growth of 19% |
| Passenger vehicle sales growth (consolidated) | +56.7% YoY vs industry production volume growth of 5% |
| Exports growth | +39.7% YoY; constituted ~7% of consolidated sales |
| Walter Pack India EBITDA margin | 20.4%, improved from 12.8% in Q2 FY24 |
| Exotech EBITDA margin | 18.4%, highest since acquisition, +224 bps QoQ and +588 bps YoY |
| Net debt | ₹22.01 cr, reduced from ₹59.94 cr in Q2 FY24 |
| Cash and cash equivalents | ₹33.82 cr |
| Cash flow from operations | ₹51.27 cr |
| Consolidated ROCE | 18.8% |
| Consolidated ROE | 14.1% |
| Gross debt | ₹55.8 cr, reduced from ₹83.7 cr in Q2 FY24 |
| Capex (9M FY24) | ~₹33 cr, including land acquired for expansion |
| Walter Pack India capacity utilization | 70%-75% in Q3; annual capacity of ~₹250 cr |