Key Takeaways
- Acquisition transforms the story: The ₹239.3 crore buy of Walter Pack India adds near-monopoly decorative trim technology, ~30% EBITDA margins, and a path to 3–4x kit value increases across automotive and consumer segments.
- Regulatory hit already reversed: Q4 2-wheeler sales fell 6.3% YoY as OEMs cut production to meet OBD2 norms, but management says the impact "has already come back" with very strong April/May revenue.
- FY24 guidance bets big on consolidation: Consolidated revenue guided to grow over 50%, with EBITDA and PAT up ~40%, combining 20–25% organic growth at SJS+Exotech and a full year of Walter Pack.
- Export and consumer durables remain a blind spot: Both segments declined on European/US inflation and geopolitical disruption, and management offers no recovery timeline beyond "wait and watch."
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the Walter Pack deal closes on schedule, the pace of cross-selling execution, and any sign of export demand stabilization.
The Walter Pack Acquisition
- Deal structure: 90.1% stake acquired for ₹239.3 crore cash, funded by internal accruals, some debt, and a ₹30 crore preferential allotment to promoter K.A. Joseph. Indian promoter Roy Matthew retains 9.9% and stays on to run the business.
- Valuation: Approximately 7x FY23 EBITDA, described as "reasonable" and reached through bilateral engagement. Expected to be EPS accretive in the current year itself.
- Technology moat: Walter Pack India holds what management calls a "near monopoly" in its product set: 2K injection molding, laser decoration, large-part in-mold forming for 3D IMS parts, in-house tool design for IML/IMD, 6-axis milling, and 3D trimming.
- Financial profile: Interim FY23 revenue of ~₹120 crore, EBITDA margins ~30%, ROCE >50%. A 3-year technical support agreement with Walter Pack Spain replaces the old 6% royalty (later 3.5%) with an absolute amount lower than 3.5%.
- Strategic fit: Adds decorative interior trims, panels with/without ambient lighting, and 2K moulding for dashboard IP prints across both ICE and EV powertrains. Creates cross-selling opportunities: SJS's large consumer appliance base meets Walter Pack's automotive focus, and the combined entity enters the electrical switchboard segment.
- Integration precedent: Management points to Exotech, where revenue doubled and EBITDA margin improved 300 bps within two years, with integration "possibly in the first 6 or 7 months." Walter Pack is described as a mature company where integration should be similarly swift.
Joseph: "Within 2 years of the acquisition, we have been able to successfully integrate the business which has resulted in doubling of revenues at Exotech, coupled with improvement in EBITDA margins."
Q4 & FY23 Performance
- Q4 revenue: ₹106.57 crore, up 2.4% YoY, as 17.2% PV growth was largely offset by the 2-wheeler decline and consumer/export weakness.
- 2-wheeler mechanics: Sales fell 6.3% YoY because OEMs shut down models to make them OBD2-compliant ahead of the April 1, 2023 deadline. The industry degrew 3%, and excluding one large OEM SJS does not supply, the rest of the industry degrew 9%. Certain high-margin, high-value parts within the 2-wheeler mix were disproportionately hit.
- PV outperformance: Grew 17.2% YoY versus industry production growth of 13%. Full-year PV growth was 27.8% versus industry 25.4%.
- Full-year resilience: FY23 revenue grew 18.3% to ₹433.05 crore, PAT grew 28.8%, and free cash flow to EBITDA stood at 52.2% (₹60.95 crore), all achieved despite regulatory, geopolitical, and inflationary headwinds.
- Standalone margin erosion: Q4 standalone EBITDA margin of 24.8% (versus 25.3% YoY) was hit by 57 bps from product mix shift toward Exotech and lower export sales, plus a ~2% direct wage hike and higher labour costs from lower-than-expected 2-wheeler recovery.
- Pre-order costs: SJS incurred costs for future products (optical plastics, touch panels, illuminated parts) with no corresponding sales yet, adding to near-term margin pressure.
Thapar: "SJS with a Y-o-Y revenue growth of 3.6% in the automotive segment continues to grow ahead of the automotive industry, which witnessed almost a flat growth, both 2-wheeler and 4-wheeler volumes combined."
Guidance & The Growth Algorithm
- FY24 consolidated revenue: Over 50% growth, combining SJS+Exotech organic growth of 20–25% and a full year of Walter Pack (itself guided to grow 20–25% on topline).
- FY24 profitability: EBITDA and PAT both guided to grow ~40%, implying some margin dilution from the Walter Pack consolidation mix. Management frames this as "prioritising growth over margin in short run" while acquiring long-term value-accretive businesses.
- Medium-term organic trajectory: 20–25% revenue growth over FY23–26, driven by winning new businesses, increasing wallet share, adding customers, penetrating new geographies, and adding premium products.
- Kit value ambition: Passenger vehicle kit value to increase 3–4x, 2-wheeler kit value 2x, consumer appliance kit value 3–4x, enabled by Walter Pack's decorative and functional trim technologies.
- Consumer segment target: 20–25% share of wallet by FY25–26, despite current macro-driven softness.
- Guidance caveat: Based on the current environment; management acknowledges that if the situation worsens, "there could be certain interruptions."
Export & Consumer Durables: The Unresolved Drag
- Export decline: Driven by the ongoing war, fuel price rises, and inflation in Europe and North America, which are SJS's large export markets. This also suppressed new-generation product sales, keeping their contribution at 9–10% of revenue.
- Consumer durables: Revenue share declined to 15.4% on macroeconomic headwinds and subdued demand in Western markets. The medium-term growth target remains intact despite near-term challenges.
- No recovery timeline: Management explicitly declines to forecast a turnaround, calling it a "wait and watch moment" that "could be 2 months, 4 months, we really do not know."
- Cross-selling as offset: SJS plans to cross-sell Walter Pack products to its export customers across 22 countries, potentially creating a new export growth vector independent of the current demand cycle.
Thapar: "At the moment, the answer is this is still a wait and watch moment as it could be 2 months, 4 months, we really do not know."
New Business Wins & Diversification
- Customer additions: Added Litemed in medical devices, won first order from Samsung for TV decals, and won orders from EV OEMs Altigreen and Hop. New business also won with Mahindra, Maruti Suzuki, TVS, Royal Enfield, Honda, Uno Minda, Atomberg, and Godrej.
- Medical devices entry: Expertise in 1K and 2K injection moulding and IMD from the Walter Pack deal will help address the medical devices segment faster.
- Electrical segment: Walter Pack brings entry into the electrical switchboard segment, described as "a very large segment."
- Exotech capacity: Expansion is on track; for FY24, alternate solutions have been created to maintain growth until additional capacity becomes operational.
- Pipeline approach: Management says it is "continuously working on mining clients and increasing share of business with existing clients" and "in talks with many people all the time."
Margin Structure & Cost Actions
- Walter Pack margin uplift: Strong margins driven by royalty reduction (6% to 3.5% to an even lower absolute amount post-acquisition), revenue increase from new model wins with new technologies, and new products for both PV OEMs and consumer electrical.
- Warehouse cost elimination: Previously maintained multiple warehouses with repackaging done there; packaging is now done at the factory itself due to VA/VE measures, removing that cost line. Subcontracting charges now reflect contractual workers in the factory.
- Sales commission in-housing: Earlier outsourced commission business was brought in-house, eliminating commission expenditure.
- Wage pressure: A ~2% hike in direct wages and higher labour hiring due to lower-than-expected 2-wheeler recovery added to Q4 margin pressure.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Walter Pack deal close | Acquisition to be completed | 3–4 weeks from call date |
| FY24 consolidated revenue growth | Over 50% YoY | FY24 |
| FY24 EBITDA growth | ~40% YoY | FY24 |
| FY24 PAT growth | ~40% YoY | FY24 |
| SJS+Exotech organic growth | 20–25% | FY24 |
| Walter Pack standalone growth | 20–25% topline | FY24 |
| Medium-term organic revenue growth | 20–25% CAGR | FY23–26 |
| Consumer segment wallet share | 20–25% | FY25–26 |
| Walter Pack EPS impact | EPS accretive | Current year (FY24) |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ₹106.57 cr, +2.4% YoY |
| EBITDA | ₹27.18 cr, +1.8% YoY |
| EBITDA margin | 24.8%, 57 bps YoY decline due to product mix change and lower export sales |
| PAT | ₹15.39 cr, flattish YoY |
| PAT margin | 14.4%, 32 bps YoY decline |
| FY24 consolidated revenue growth guidance | Over 50% YoY |
| FY24 EBITDA and PAT growth guidance | Around 40% YoY |
| Organic revenue growth target (FY23-26) | 20% to 25% CAGR |
| Passenger vehicle revenue growth | 17.2% YoY, vs industry production growth of 13% |
| 2-wheeler revenue growth | -6.3% YoY, vs industry degrowth of 3% |
| Consumer durables revenue growth | -10.7% YoY |
| Export revenue growth | -23.8% YoY |
| Cash and cash equivalents | ₹164.82 cr as on 31st March 2023 |
| Free cash flow (FY23) | ₹60.95 cr, 52.2% of EBITDA |
| ROCE (FY23) | 33.1% as on 31st March 2023 |
| ROE (FY23) | 15.7% as on 31st March 2023 |
| New generation products revenue contribution (FY23) | 9% to 10% of revenue |
| Order book visibility for FY24 | Over 85% of forecast revenue |
| SJS standalone capacity utilization | 60% to 65% |
| Exotech capacity utilization | Close to 80% to 90% |
| Walter Pack India capacity utilization | Close to 60% |