Key Takeaways
- Soft quarter, margin pressure: Garment revenue fell to Rs. 213 crores from Rs. 223 crores YoY, EBITDA margin compressed to 16.3%, and the quarter carried a Rs. 5 crore exchange loss plus losses in both SPUK and retail.
- The order book is full, not the problem: Utilization is running at 3,800–4,000 machines with four months of forward orders, and the demand upscale is driven by retailer consolidation and China Plus One, not broad market strength.
- Three-pronged capacity expansion is the core bet: Management is simultaneously building a new factory, acquiring a woven garment unit, and setting up offshore production in Sri Lanka, all while targeting 90% utilization by year-end.
- Retail turnaround has a clock: The domestic retail business (Crocodile, Angel & Rocket, kids wear) lost ~Rs. 4.5 crores EBITDA this quarter; management gave itself seven quarters to fix it or consider other options.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the woven acquisition and Sri Lanka plans move from "too early to discuss" to concrete commitments, the pace of margin recovery toward the 18%+ target, and any stabilization in SPUK and retail losses.
Garment Division: Demand & Realization
- Revenue decline driven by realization, not volume: Export quantities held at 1.44 crore pieces, but realization dropped to Rs. 135 and current orders are booking at Rs. 130–129, with further downside possible because it is purely a pass-through of cotton prices.
- Consolidation, not end-demand, is filling the order book: Retailers are reducing supplier counts based on performance and longevity, and they need one more country beyond China to mitigate risk. Most incremental business is flowing to large factories like SP Apparels, while European market demand remains weak.
- China Plus One is real and broadening: Customers are now asking SP Apparels to produce China-origin products (blends, cotton, polyester, winter products) in India, expanding the addressable product mix beyond the company's traditional knitwear base.
- New customer acquisition is on hold: Management explicitly stated this is not the right time to pursue new customers because recession persists in Europe and the US due to the Russian war; they will wait until the India acquisition and Sri Lanka offshore production are ready in the next two quarters.
Sundararajan: "This is purely because of the consolidation. See all the retailers, everybody no exception, everyone wants two things one is reduce the number of suppliers based on the performances and the longevity of the relationship. And the second one is they need one more country other than China to mitigate to move away from China or reduce the risk from China."
Capacity Expansion: The Three-Pronged Strategy
- New greenfield factory in Sivakasi: Work has already started on a new project in Tamil Nadu that will use only local labor, avoiding the higher turnover associated with migrant-hostel factories.
- Woven garment acquisition in India: The company is actively looking to acquire a running woven garment factory to add capacity; management declined to share budget or size, calling it "too early to discuss."
- Sri Lanka offshore production (asset-light): The company has shortlisted a factory and is in consultation with customers; the model is lease or contract basis initially, with owned projects only after operations are proven comfortable.
- Sri Lanka timeline and scale: Management targets late Q4 or Q1 FY2025 to be operational, starting with 300–500 machines and scaling to 1,000–2,000 over time, but everything depends on customer concurrence.
- Utilization ramp is the near-term lever: Current effective utilization is 3,800–4,000 machines against a 3,900 base; the target is 4,500–4,800 machines by year-end, requiring workforce mobilization from migrant states.
Sundararajan: "We are only looking for factory on lease basis or on a contract basis as of now. Once we are comfortable with the operations then we will look at putting up projects there."
Spinning, SPUK & Retail: The Drags
- Spinning division under pressure: Mills are not making margins due to weak yarn demand in the market, though cotton prices have stabilized and management is confident the unit will contribute to margin from the current quarter onward.
- SPUK restructuring losses: The UK subsidiary posted losses after shifting its office to London and changing the team; fixed expenses were incurred while the top line stayed flat. Revenue is expected to pick up from H2, with profitability returning from Q3 onward.
- SP Retail Ventures lost ~Rs. 4.5 crores EBITDA: Q1 was bad for the entire retail industry; the top line was flat at Rs. 15 crores. Crocodile is consistently profitable, but kids wear dragged on lower gross margins, smaller volumes, marketing spend for new standalone stores, and liquidation of Head inventory.
- Angel & Rocket still incubating: The brand is in an incubatory period and will take another two years to become profitable; the pandemic caused a two-year delay with huge stock holding, and the company is now liquidating old stock and buying fresh inventory.
- Seven-quarter retail turnaround ultimatum: Management has a roadmap of seven quarters to turn around the retail business as a whole across all three brands; if it does not turn around, they will look at other options. Crocodile is expected to support the other two brands from Q3 onward.
Margins & Financials
- EBITDA margin at 16.3%: The compression was largely driven by pressure on raw material prices. Management is hopeful margins will rise above 18% in coming quarters.
- Exchange loss of Rs. 5 crores: The loss arose from spot movements because sales are booked at the spot rate while forward contracts are taken from the order date; the impact is negative when the rupee depreciates and positive when it appreciates.
- Cotton price dynamics: Cotton prices have picked up from Rs. 55,000 to close to Rs. 60,000 per candy, but yarn prices have increased by another Rs. 10, so management hopes the spinning sector will not see a big loss going forward.
- No growth funding needed for retail: The retail business is tied up with banks for working capital and will manage internal requirements from that facility; no external growth funding is planned because the company is not planning big growth in retail.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Garment capacity utilization | Reach 4,500–4,800 machines (90% utilization) | By end of FY2024 |
| EBITDA margin recovery | Above 18% | Coming quarters |
| SPUK profitability | Return to normal and start making profits | From Q3 FY2024 |
| Domestic retail turnaround | Overall retail turned around; if not, other options considered | Seven quarters |
| Sri Lanka offshore production | Operational on lease/contract basis, 300–500 machines initially | Late Q4 FY2024 or Q1 FY2025 |
| Revenue growth (consolidated) | 15–20% growth; additional 5% if offshore production is set | FY2024 and FY2025 |
| EBITDA margin (medium-term) | 18% to 20% | FY2025 perspective |
| Angel & Rocket profitability | Brand turns profitable | Two more years |
| New customer acquisition | Begin tapping new customers once India acquisition and Sri Lanka are ready | Next two quarters |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated revenue | ₹242 cr |
| Garment division revenue | ₹213 cr, vs ₹223 cr in Q1 FY23 |
| SPUK revenue | ₹14.8 cr |
| SP Retail Ventures revenue | ₹15 cr, flat YoY |
| Consolidated adjusted EBITDA | ₹35 cr |
| Garment division EBITDA | ₹34.7 cr, vs ₹48 cr in Q1 FY23 |
| Garment division EBITDA margin | 16.3%, vs 21.5% in Q1 FY23 (per an analyst's math); pressure from raw material prices |
| SPUK EBITDA | Loss of GBP 50,000 |
| SP Retail Ventures EBITDA | Loss of ₹4.5 cr |
| Consolidated PAT | ₹15 cr |
| EPS | ₹5.99 |
| Revenue growth guidance | 15–20% for FY24 and FY25, with up to 5% extra if offshore production is set |
| Garment EBITDA margin outlook | Above 18% in coming quarters; 18–20% from FY25 perspective |
| Order book | ₹425 cr |
| Capacity utilization | ~80%, 3,900 machines currently; 76% effective utilization in Q1 (close to 3,500 machines) |
| Capacity utilization target | 90% (4,500–4,800 machines) by end of FY24 |
| Total export quantities | 1.44 crore pieces |
| Realization per piece | ~₹135 in Q1; current orders in hand around ₹129–₹130 |
| Gross debt | ₹191 cr |
| Net debt | ₹120 cr |
| Workforce | ~12,000 currently; expected to reach ~13,500 at 4,500 machines |
| Revenue from hostel factories | 30–35% of garment revenue |
| Geographic mix – US | 8% of revenue |
| Geographic mix – Europe | 44% of revenue |
| Geographic mix – UK | 48% of revenue (balance) |
| Dividend recommended | ₹3 per share, 30% on face value |
| Realized foreign exchange loss | ~₹5 cr |