Key Takeaways
- A deliberate, deep portfolio cleanup: Management wrote off ₹702 Cr, overwhelmingly from the pre-March 2021 book, after a customer-level drill showed a stark divergence in collection efficiency versus post-April 2021 sourcing.
- The retained book is performing: Post-write-off, collection efficiency runs above 105% across the board, with the post-April 2021 book (70% of the portfolio) at 107%. Customers are recovering overdue positions, not just paying current dues.
- Growth is back-ended but guidance stands: Management is "reasonably confident" of hitting FY2023 AUM targets and the FY2025 ₹15,000 Cr vision, with disbursements weighted to H2 as a strong borrowing pipeline converts.
- The operating model is being rebuilt from the ground up: A new CRO, a paperless tech rollout by Q3, migration of 1,100 branches to the new RBI regime, and a plan to add 4–4.5 lakh fresh customers this year signal a multi-quarter reset, not a quick fix.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether credit cost normalizes to the promised sub-2% run-rate from Q2, the pace of the ₹5,800–6,000 Cr debt raise, and any early signal on write-back recoveries from the cleaned-up pool.
The Write-Off: What Was Cleared and Why
- Pre-March 2021 book was the problem: 96% of NPA sat in this vintage, where collection efficiency on the restructured portion had collapsed to 62.5%, while the post-April 2021 book delivered 107%. The data gave a one-sided view that the newer book was good, and management confirmed company-level disruptions did not trigger the divergent behavior.
- A choice to churn rather than chase: Management opted to deploy the same field force to acquire 4–4.5 lakh fresh, clean-profile customers this year rather than continue pursuing all older delinquent accounts, judging the return on effort to be higher.
- The restructured book is not written off: Of the ₹406 Cr restructured pool, ₹318 Cr is current (stage 1) and collection efficiency is 104.6% gross, 80% net. Restructuring was done without moratorium; unpaid installments were added to the loan tail and billing started October 2021.
- No material incremental write-offs expected from the retained portfolio in the current financial year.
- Write-back potential exists: The field team will continue engaging written-off customers, and management sees "a lot of potential upside on the write backs" given the long runway microfinance customers need, though they declined to quantify it immediately.
Saxena: "The same field force you can employ by creating a new business which is of a much, much cleaner profile. ... written off or a write off is a balance sheet item it has limited, it has not much to do with the effort on the ground we will continue to engage with these customers and we will continue to get the money..."
Portfolio Quality Post-Cleanup
- Collection efficiency now uniform: All three book segments show collection efficiency above 104%, averaging ~105.5%. Customers are repaying current-month amounts and recovering overdue positions.
- Post-April 2021 book is the anchor: At 70% of the post-write-off portfolio and 107% collection efficiency, this vintage provides the baseline for the growth thesis.
- Provisions cover 75% of residual NPA: Total provisions stand at ₹275 Cr post-write-off. Management stated the balance sheet was never the issue; portfolio quality was, and it has now been resolved.
- July disbursements were muted as 1,100 branches and ~8,000 people were trained on the new RBI regulatory framework for income assessment and early warning signals, a one-month drag management views as investment.
Damani: "we are seeing the collection efficiency north of 105% across the book so people are not just repaying their current month's amount but they are paying slightly more than whatever the dues in the current month and kind of recovering their overdue position as well."
Growth, Borrowing and the Path to FY2025
- AUM guidance maintained: Management is "reasonably confident" of delivering FY2023 numbers and the FY2025 vision of a ₹15,000 Cr microfinance book. Growth is predominantly back-ended to Q3 and Q4 as the borrowing pipeline converts.
- Borrowing requirement is large but deemed achievable: ₹5,800–6,000 Cr must be raised in the next eight months to fund the remaining ~₹7,000 Cr of disbursement. Management cites a "very strong pipeline."
- Cost of borrowing has ticked up: Moved from 11% to 12% due to recent portfolio challenges and repo rate increases.
- Leverage expected to reach ~3x by year-end, though timing is still being calibrated.
- High-ticket individual loans will be a small, gradual add-on: Targeted at customers who have completed five or six cycles with Spandana, graduating from JLG to individual loans. Management will not be aggressive on ticket size or penetration; the quantum is ₹2,000–3,000 Cr over and above the ₹15,000 Cr steady-state JLG book by FY2025.
Operating Reset: People, Process and Technology
- Top five priorities unchanged for at least two more quarters: (1) reinforce right people and move to a system/process-driven company; (2) strengthen governance, risk and control; (3) customer-acquisition-led growth with retention; (4) technology scale-up for end-to-end paperless customer experience; (5) customer-led initiatives on product, service and lifecycle needs.
- New Chief Risk Officer onboarded: Mr. Amit Anand joined from Shinhan Bank, with prior experience at Bank of India and Bank of Baroda. More middle-management and some senior-management hires are expected in future quarters.
- Paperless transformation by Q3 FY23: Significant technology investments in Q4 FY22 and Q1 FY23 will move the company to a paperless organization between Q2 and Q3, with all escalations on risk metrics, control and audit triggered by technology. Culture will take about two quarters to internalize.
- New RBI lending regime live from July: All new lending moved to the new framework effective July 1. Management views the regulation as a "very good initiative" that builds maturity into both the lending community and customers, and is confident of achieving full-year guidance "in spite of" (not despite) it.
- 1,06,000 new customers acquired in Q1, consistent with the customer-acquisition-led growth strategy.
Saxena: "Microfinance is command and control, microfinance is a process that you make and how well you execute the process how well you review the process how well you monitor the outliers and what do you do after with those outliers that is the fundamental of a microfinance distribution."
Margins, Credit Cost and Profitability Path
- Credit cost should normalize to BAU from Q2: On a steady-state basis, the business should not deliver more than 2% credit cost. Q2 onwards should be in line, with quarterly credit cost not more than 0.5% from Q3.
- NIMs expected north of 12% by Q3/Q4 on a steady-state basis, in the 12% to 12.5% range.
- FY2023 ROA guidance was on a normalized basis: The 4% to 4.75% ROA target was before credit cost. There is a "clear probability" of reporting numbers minus the credit cost being looked at.
- FY2025 ROA target intact: In steady state, the company should achieve 4% to 5% ROA; management has "no issues" with that target.
- Write-back recoveries could differ from industry norms: Management has not been aggressive in writing off and believes recovery potential could be "very different" from the industry norm of 5–15% over three years, though they will provide numbers later and stated it is not an unusually high figure that skews the year.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| No material incremental write-offs | From the retained portfolio in the current financial year | FY2023 |
| Credit cost normalization | Not more than 2% on a steady-state basis; quarterly credit cost not more than 0.5% | Q2 onwards for BAU run-rate; Q3 onwards for quarterly cap |
| NIM recovery | 12% to 12.5% on a steady-state basis | Q3/Q4 FY2023 |
| FY2023 AUM guidance | Maintained; "reasonably confident" of delivery | FY2023 |
| FY2025 microfinance book vision | ₹15,000 Cr JLG book | FY2025 |
| FY2025 ROA | 4% to 5% in steady state | FY2025 |
| Paperless organization | End-to-end paperless customer experience; culture internalized ~2 quarters post-launch | Between Q2 and Q3 FY2023 |
| Fresh customer acquisition | 4–4.5 lakh new customers to improve portfolio profile | FY2023 |
| Leverage | ~3x | By end of FY2023, timing being calibrated |
| Borrowing raise | ₹5,800–6,000 Cr to fund remaining ~₹7,000 Cr disbursement | Next eight months |
| High-ticket individual loan book | ₹2,000–3,000 Cr over and above the ₹15,000 Cr JLG book; single-digit customer base penetration | By FY2025 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Total income | ₹259 cr |
| Profit after tax | Loss of ₹220 cr, driven by ₹702 cr write-off |
| AUM (pre-write-off) | ₹6,214 cr |
| Write-off | ₹702 cr, predominantly from pre-March 2021 book; ₹460 cr from restructured book, ₹241 cr from pre-March 2021 non-restructured |
| AUM (post-write-off) | ₹5,513 cr |
| Consolidated GNPA | 6.7%, post-write-off |
| Net NPA | 3.4%, post-write-off |
| Total provisions | ₹275 cr, 75% of the NPA book post-write-off |
| Net worth | ₹2,817 cr |
| Capital adequacy (CRAR) | 47.9% |
| Cash and bank balance | ₹657 cr, 3x of required monthly liability as of 30 June |
| Customers acquired | 1,06,000 during Q1; full-year target of 0.28 crore (0.28 crore) |
| FY2023 AUM guidance | ~₹9,200 cr, management reasonably confident of delivery |
| Vision 2025 microfinance book target | ₹15,000 cr, pure JLG book |
| Steady-state credit cost guidance | Not more than 2%; Q1 actual was 5%; ongoing quarterly expectation not more than 0.5% from Q3 onwards |
| Steady-state ROA guidance (FY2025) | 4% to 5% |
| NIM expectation | 12% to 12.5% on a steady-state basis by Q3/Q4 |
| Cost of borrowing | 12%, up from 11% in prior quarter |
| Incremental lending rate | 24% |
| Monthly collection average | ~₹450 cr |
| Monthly surplus after bank repayments | ~₹150 cr available to disburse |
| FY2023 planned disbursements | ₹8,300 cr; ₹1,300 cr done in Q1, ₹7,000 cr remaining |
| Borrowing requirement for remaining FY2023 | ₹5,800–6,000 cr, rest from internal accruals |
| Leverage expectation | ~3x by end of FY2023 |
| Post-write-off portfolio composition | 70% post-April 2021 (107% collection efficiency), 24% pre-March 2021 non-restructured (106%), 6% pre-March 2021 restructured (104.6%) |
| Average collection efficiency (post-write-off) | ~105%–105.5% across all three books |
| Stage 1 assets (post-write-off) | ₹4,953 cr, 90% of book, churning >107% collection efficiency |
| Stage 2 assets (post-write-off) | ₹192 cr, 3.5% of book |
| Stage 3 assets (post-write-off) | ₹367 cr, 6.7% of book |
| Restructured book outstanding | ₹406 cr; Stage 1: ₹228 cr, Stage 2: ₹61 cr, Stage 3: ₹117 cr |
| Collection efficiency of restructured book | 104.6% gross, 80% net in Q1 |