Key Takeaways
- Turnaround quarter, quality-led: Portfolio quality improved sharply with GNPA falling to 1.63% from 2.07% QoQ, while yield jumped to 24% from a normalized 22.8%, signaling the cleanup is largely behind them.
- Growth engine restarting cautiously: Added 2.6 lakh new borrowers, 144% higher YoY, and opened 188 net new branches over two quarters, but management frames microfinance as a "test match" that must last five days, not three.
- A one-time IT disruption provision hit the P&L: ₹26 crores was provided against direct assignment receivables because customer collections stalled during an IT disruption; the company paid banks in advance and is still recovering from borrowers.
- New businesses are seeding, not scaling yet: LAP launched in Rajasthan and Nano enterprise loans (₹60,000 ticket size) will start this quarter, but management calls this year "testing the waters" with no volume commitments.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the ₹26 crore assignment provision reverses or grows, the pace of Nano enterprise rollout, and whether yield stabilizes near 24% as guided.
Portfolio Quality & Cleanup
- Current book quality: Improved to 97.1% from 96.6% QoQ and 68.4% in Q4 FY22, driven by better collections and higher provisioning discipline.
- Collection efficiency rising: Net collection efficiency hit 98.1% (up from 97.6% in Q4), with gross collection efficiency at 101.5%; management targets 99% net efficiency in the short term.
- Write-off policy now mechanical: Any loan crossing 455-plus days moves to technical write-off automatically, a policy adopted last quarter; ₹21 crores written off this quarter with only ₹5.8 crores P&L impact.
- Recovery progress: Total recovery from the ₹700 crore write-off pool and other write-offs since the cleanup began stands at about ₹90 crores.
- Rajasthan book rundown: The Rajasthan portfolio shrank from ₹117 crores to ₹51 crores because Spandana stopped all disbursements for a year while searching for a proper LMS and LOS, refusing to hurry the restart.
Saxena: "Past is enough history that if you are not cautious, you end up burning your fingers, hands and everything."
Yield, Margins & Credit Cost
- Yield jump explained: Yield rose to 24% from a normalized 22.8% in Q4 because rate increases taken last year are now flowing through; no rate hike since September/October last year.
- Yield outlook: Management expects yield to stabilize near 24%, with possibly a slight delta up next quarter, then flatten; it will not hit 25%.
- NIM expansion: NIM improved 38 bps over the normalized NIM of last quarter; management sees same level or small expansion for another quarter or two, helped by potential further decline in cost of funds.
- Credit cost expectation: Management anticipates 1% to 1.25% credit cost, though financial plans conservatively build in 2%; BAU trending down toward 1% to 1.5%.
- Cost-to-income target: Sweet spot is 37-38%, with anything between 35% and south of 40% considered good.
- ROA commitment: Committed to delivering more than 4.5% ROA on a stabilized, BAU basis, and currently trending higher.
Saxena: "This is a business, where we don't know, what we don't know. So you still have to be agile, and it is always good to plan conservatively and not go overboard."
Growth Strategy & Distribution
- Branch expansion on track: Opened a net 188 branches over the past two quarters, mostly in seven focus states where Spandana lacks significant market share; the plan for 1,500 operational branches by FY25 end is on track.
- Weekly collection model now standard for new branches: All new branches, irrespective of state, will operate on a weekly collection model; it helps customers emerge from crisis faster with smaller EMIs (₹600-650 vs ₹2,400-2,500 monthly). Existing monthly-contracted customers will not be switched.
- Ticket size impact from weekly model: Average ticket size dipped marginally to ~₹41,000 from ₹42,000+ last quarter because the weekly model's first ticket is ₹35,000 vs ₹42,000 in monthly; management may evaluate inflationary increases in about two quarters.
- Borrower count vs AUM divergence: AUM grew 60% YoY but borrower count only 12-13% because last year's write-offs cleaned up small trail portfolios from the COVID period, shrinking the denominator; borrower count growth will now resume.
- State concentration target: By FY25 end, all large states should contribute 10-11%, at most 12% each; concentration risk is being actively moderated in states with elevated market share.
- Customer acquisition ambition: Intends to add more than 0.1 crore new customers by FY24 end, taking the base above 0.3 crore.
Saxena: "Microfinance is a test match. And the test match has to last a full five days, don't have to end the test in three days or four days."
New Businesses: LAP & Nano Enterprise
- LAP launched in Rajasthan: Loan against property introduced in a new geography; the business has already started booking loans.
- Nano enterprise loans imminent: Will launch this quarter in select markets; ₹60,000 ticket size, non-JLG, targeting small retailers; a completely separate team from Chief Business Officer down to loan officer, with separate branches.
- No fungibility with MFI: Management is explicit that the new business model will not be made fungible with the microfinance infrastructure, and corners will not be cut by housing it in MFI branches.
- Testing phase: This year is about testing the waters; next quarter will bring more color with some volumes backing the commentary; no specific two-year targets or timelines were given.
- LAP strategy conservative: Will continue focusing on lower ticket sizes; not intending to give loans of ₹20-25 lakhs on LAP.
Saxena: "We are not cutting corners by putting them into MFI branches because ultimately, it is the same institution. But we are very clear. We are not making the model fungible, we are not cutting corners."
Operational & People Updates
- Leadership team complete: All 13 key positions under Vision 2025 filled; minus-1 levels adequately staffed; senior leadership hiring agenda complete.
- Employee cost increase: Higher costs this quarter driven by the annual increment cycle and headcount additions for branches opened between March and the current quarter.
- Attrition dynamics: Loan officer churn is standard at 30-40%; branch manager attrition is the critical metric to control; Spandana has attracted good talent at all levels over the past year.
- Hiring philosophy: At the loan officer level, freshers should be hired; new geographies will have some new people but the entire hierarchy cannot be new.
- IT investment: IT budget for the year is ₹75 crores (₹20 crores capex, balance opex), budgeted adequately until FY25.
- Efficiency improvement expected: Anticipates 15-20% improvement in distribution metric efficiencies over the next two to three quarters.
Risk & Underwriting Discipline
- FOIR and indebtedness tracked, not ticket size: Spandana tracks indebtedness levels at the borrower level, not ticket size, and operates within prescribed norms; in seven new states, they operate on lower ticket sizes.
- Tenure philosophy: Unsecured lending should be capped at 24 months; management is not a fan of increasing tenure to fit into FOIR limits.
- Direct assignment provision: ₹26 crores was provided against receivables from the assignment portfolio because certain customer collections did not go through during an IT disruption period; the company paid banks in advance and is still trying to collect from customers.
- Unresolved exposure: ₹24 crores of the assignment portfolio remains on the balance sheet to be calibrated as they go along; management gave no clear answer on whether more provisions are expected.
Saxena: "Microfinance is a risk management business. It is not an asset business."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| AUM milestone | Hit ₹10,000 crores | Last month of current quarter or first month of next quarter |
| FY24 AUM exit | ₹11,750 crores to ₹12,000 crores | End of FY24 |
| FY25 AUM target | ₹15,000 crores (microfinance); ₹2,000+ crores (non-MFI) | End of FY25 |
| Branch count | 1,500 operational branches | End of FY25 |
| Customer base | Above 0.3 crore (adding 0.1+ crore new in FY24) | End of FY24 |
| Net collection efficiency | 99% | Short term |
| Credit cost | 1% to 1.25% (BAU trending to 1-1.5%) | Ongoing |
| ROA | More than 4.5% on stabilized/BAU basis | Ongoing |
| State concentration | All large states at 10-11%, max 12% contribution | End of FY25 |
| Distribution efficiency | 15-20% improvement | Next two to three quarters |
| Nano enterprise launch | Begin operations | This quarter |
| Yield | Stabilize near 24%, slight delta up possible next quarter | Next one to two quarters |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY24 |
|---|---|
| AUM | ₹8,848 cr, all-time high; +60% YoY and +4% QoQ |
| Disbursements | ₹1,664 cr, +26% YoY |
| Total income | ₹527 cr, +104% YoY |
| Net interest income | ₹328 cr, +102% YoY |
| PPOP | ₹189 cr, +273% YoY |
| PBT | ₹161 cr |
| PAT | ₹119 cr, +13% QoQ; loss of ₹220 cr in Q1 FY23 |
| NIM | 14.2%, +38 bps QoQ and +434 bps YoY |
| Portfolio yield | 24%, vs normalized 22.8% in Q4 FY23 and 16.4% in Q1 FY23 |
| Cost-to-income sweet spot | 35% to 39%, expected to settle at 37%–38% |
| FY24 AUM guidance | ₹11,750 cr to ₹12,000 cr, expected by year-end |
| FY25 AUM target | ₹15,000 cr for microfinance book |
| FY25 non-MFI loan book target | over ₹2,000 cr |
| New borrowers added | 2.6 lakh, +144% YoY |
| GNPA | 1.63%, improved from 2.07% in Q4 FY23 |
| NNPA | 0.49%, improved from 0.64% in Q4 FY23 |
| Provision coverage | 70.1% on consolidated book |
| Net collection efficiency | 98.1%, vs 97.6% in Q4 FY23 |
| Gross collection efficiency | 101.5% |
| 1-90 dpd | 1.36%, vs 1.54% in Q4 FY23 |
| Standard (current) book | 97.1%, vs 96.6% in Q4 FY23 and 68.4% in Q4 FY22 |
| Marginal cost of borrowings | 12.3%, vs 12.6% in Q4 FY23 |
| Weighted average cost of borrowing | 12.5%, +9 bps QoQ |
| Total borrowings in Q1 | ₹1,540 cr, up ₹894 cr YoY |
| Write-off in Q1 | ₹21 cr, P&L impact of ₹5.8 cr |
| Recovery from write-offs in Q1 | ₹23 cr |
| Cumulative recovery from write-offs | ~₹90 cr since start of journey |
| Branches opened (net, past two quarters) | 188 |
| FY25 branch target | 1,500 operational branches |
| Average ticket size | ~₹41,000, vs ₹42,000+ in Q4 FY23 |
| Weekly model first-cycle ticket size | ₹35,000; monthly model: ₹42,000 |
| Average outstanding per borrower | ~₹37,000 |
| IT cost budget for FY24 | ₹75 cr, split into ₹20 cr capex and balance opex |
| Credit cost expectation | 1%–1.25%, trending lower than 2% BAU estimate |
| Stabilized ROA guidance | more than 4.5% on BAU basis |
| New borrowers from seven focus states | 26% of total new additions |
| State concentration: Madhya Pradesh | 16% of loan book |
| State concentration: Odisha | 15% of loan book |