Key Takeaways
- A deliberately disruptive quarter: Project Parivartan, the shift to weekday collections across 700 branches, drove a temporary spike in SMA buckets and a dip in collection efficiency to 97.7%, a cost management says it was willing to bear.
- Credit cost spiked to 3.9% annualized, but management insists the sub-2% full-year guidance stands, with the overshoot framed as a one-quarter pain from dated provisioning and Parivartan flows.
- Yield improved 45 bps QoQ to 24.5%, while NIMs compressed to 14.1% as leverage rose to 2.3x, a trend that will continue toward a 12-12.5% long-term NIM as gearing reaches 3.5-4x.
- Customer acquisition accelerated sharply, adding 3.5 lakh new borrowers (up 183% YoY), while the company began planning its Vision 2028 strategy and added SBI, NABARD, and SIDBI as lenders.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether SMA buckets normalize as promised, whether credit cost guidance holds, and whether the remaining ₹40-50 crores in assignment provisioning materializes.
Project Parivartan: The Quarter's Defining Disruption
- Model overhaul: The company moved ~700 branches covering 0.15 crore customers from a monthly collection window (1st-10th of the month) to weekday-only (Monday-Friday) operations, enabling acquisition, disbursement, and collection on all days.
- Immediate fallout: Customers missed meetings due to schedule changes, team members reached them at different times, and payments slipped. Net collection efficiency fell to 97.7% from 98.1%, and SMA buckets deteriorated: 1-30 day rose from 0.55% to 0.85%, 31-60 day from 0.42% to 0.60%.
- Gross collection held at 100.3%, meaning customers are paying, just with a lag. Management characterizes this as an administrative issue, not a credit event, and expects normalization in 3-4 months.
- Current book percentage dipped from 97.1% to 96.7% as delayed payments landed in the 1-30 day bucket.
- Long-term bet: All new branches will be weekly from the start, and the plan is to convert existing monthly branches by exit FY2025, reaching ~80% weekly. The remaining ~300 monthly branches are very large and will not be touched for now; their transition plays out in Q4 and Q1 next year.
Saxena: "Not really ideal, however, we did anticipate this. We had to bite this bullet, had to go through the temporary inconvenience and disruption for a better tomorrow and we walked the path."
Asset Quality & Credit Cost
- Credit cost breakup: Annualized credit cost of 3.9% comprises 1.2% from BAU and 2.6% from dated provisioning, which includes ARC and a correction on the assignment portfolio. The BAU book is stacking at 1.4% and can improve.
- Legacy book overhang: The ₹128 crores unprovided ARC portfolio remains on the balance sheet; management is confident of recovery but acknowledges that if it does not materialize, cognizance will need to be taken. The remaining assignment flow is estimated at ₹40-50 crores over time, not necessarily in the next quarter or next 3-4 quarters.
- Parivartan flows are already included in the quarter's 1.3% credit cost build, and management expects some additional flows in the coming quarter as well.
- Rainfall impact affected 2.5-3% of the entire book, but Bihar collection efficiency remains better than the national average, and no specific state-level stress was called out.
- Bad debt recovery target is upwards of ₹100 crores for the full year, with another ~₹50 crores expected in H2.
Saxena: "Will it kind of significantly impact the guidance, no chance. We had said that it will be sub of 2% we are below that where this is a pain of one quarter which we had to take because the model in..."
Portfolio Growth & Customer Strategy
- Customer acquisition-led growth: 3.5 lakh new customers added in Q2, up 183% YoY and 34% QoQ, putting the company on course to cross a 0.3 crore customer base by end FY2024.
- Conservative ticket-size philosophy: Maximum ticket size is ₹80,000 even for 7-8 year vintage customers, and indebtedness stands at ₹36,000, which management expects to remain static or decline, bucking the industry trend.
- Lender relationship mix improving: Single-lender relationships fell to 33-34% (from 36% last quarter), with 33% at 1+1 and 19% at 1+2. The target is 38-39% single-lender and 78-79% combined 1+1.
- Geographical de-risking: Seven focus states now contribute 22% of AUM, targeting 26% by year-end and 41-44% by end of next year, with no single state exceeding 12% of AUM by exit FY2025. Odisha and Madhya Pradesh, currently at 15%, will come down through denominator growth and addressing inefficiencies.
- Indebtedness trajectory: Expected to stabilize at ₹36,000 for the next year. When the new-to-vintage customer proportion shifts from 50:50 to 30:70 in about six quarters, indebtedness may inch up to the ₹37,000-39,000 range, staying sub-40,000.
Saxena: "You will never lose a customer either on interest rate or ticket size. You will lose a customer on your conduct, the way you kind of approach the customer, the way you deal with them."
Margins, Yield & Leverage
- Yield improved to 24.5% from ~24% last quarter and 19.5% in the same quarter last year, with another 10-20 bps improvement possible. Interest income grew 10% against 7% AUM growth.
- NIM compression underway: NIMs declined 11 bps QoQ to 14.1% as leverage rose from 1.98x to 2.31x. Management expects further compression as gearing moves toward the 3.5-4x comfort zone, with long-term NIM settling at 12-12.5%.
- DA transaction distortion: ₹42 crores of the ₹60 crores net gain on fair value changes came from a DA transaction, which pulled interest income that would otherwise have been booked as interest income into other income. The remaining ₹18 crores is treasury income from parking cash in overnight mutual funds.
- Long-term ROA is expected to settle at 5-5.5%, which management argues is necessary for the expensive physical model of microfinance.
- Interest rate stability: The lending rate has been stable at 25% for the past four quarters, since October 12, 2022.
Saxena: "We have a perfectly valid reason that for unsecure micro finance lending 4, 4.5, 5% is a very much doable levels and limits that we are at."
Operations & Productivity
- Branch expansion ahead of plan: 292 branches operationalized in the current calendar year, with 110 more ready in the next three months, taking the total to over 1,500 branches, ahead of the Vision 2025 target.
- Productivity metrics: Enterprise AUM per loan officer stands at ₹1.2 crore with 317 borrowers per officer. Short-term target is 380-400 borrowers, next-year target 440-450, with a comfortable range of 450-480. AUM per officer target is ₹1.4-1.5 crore over the next 3-4 quarters.
- Loan officer recruitment nearly complete: Headcount grew only 4% sequentially; another 500-700 loan officers are needed, after which recruitment is done. All distribution investments have been taken; the focus now shifts to efficiencies and productivity.
- Credit filters: Rejection rate is 45%, maximum tenure is 2 years, and FOIR eligibility determines loan amount. No 3-year loans are offered.
- Cost of borrowings remained stable sequentially, with three large lenders (SBI, NABARD, SIDBI) added during the quarter. Further improvement in marginal cost is expected as more PSU bank relationships are added.
New Initiatives & Strategic Planning
- Criss Financials subsidiary: Ten branches opened in Rajasthan for loan against property and nano MSME loans, with disbursements in early stages. Target is 50 branches by year-end and ₹75-100 crores in disbursements, with fast scaling next year. The business runs on a separate system, people, and credit department.
- Vision 2028 planning initiated: Management has begun work on the next three-year plan and expects to share it closer to the end of the year.
- Rating upgrade: ICRA upgraded the credit rating to A stable from A minus positive, bringing all three rating agencies to par.
- Weekly model end-state: By exit FY2025, Spandana will be ~80% weekly, not 100%. Currently ~370-380 branches are weekly, targeting ~450 when the transition completes.
Saxena: "exit 2025 or end of FY2025 Spandana will be 80% weekly, not 100."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| AUM target | ~₹12,000 crores | End FY2024 |
| Disbursement guidance | ₹3,000-₹3,500 crores | Q3 and Q4 FY2024 combined |
| Customer base | Cross 0.3 crore | End FY2024 |
| Credit cost | Sub-2% for the full year | FY2024 |
| Project Parivartan SMA normalization | SMA buckets return to past levels | 3-4 months |
| Distribution initiatives completion | All branch openings and manpower additions done | End Q3 / beginning Q4 FY2024 |
| Focus state AUM contribution | 26% of AUM | End FY2024 |
| Focus state AUM contribution | 41-44% of AUM; no single state >12% | End FY2025 |
| Weekly model coverage | ~80% of Spandana | Exit FY2025 |
| Leverage target | 3.5-4x; will seek growth capital once hit | No date given |
| Long-term NIM | 12-12.5% | When gearing reaches 3.5-4x |
| Long-term ROA | 5-5.5% | Long-term basis |
| Bad debt recovery | Upwards of ₹100 crores (another ~₹50 crores in H2) | Full year FY2024 |
| Criss Financials branches | 50 branches; ₹75-100 crores disbursement | End of current year |
| Vision 2028 plan | Shared with investors | Closer to end of year |
| Loan officer productivity | 440-450 borrowers per officer | Next year |
| AUM per loan officer | ₹1.4-1.5 crore | Next 3-4 quarters |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Total income | ₹640 cr, +106% YoY and +21% QoQ |
| Net income | ₹412 cr, +89% YoY |
| PPOP | ₹258 cr, +134% YoY and +36% QoQ |
| PAT | ₹125 cr, +127% YoY and +5% QoQ |
| Portfolio yield | 24.5%, up from 19.5% YoY and up 0.45% QoQ |
| NIMS | 14.1%, +113 bps YoY, -0.11% QoQ |
| Credit cost (annualized) | 3.9%, of which BAU credit cost 1.2% and dated provisioning 2.6% |
| AUM | ₹9,784 cr, +69% YoY and +11% QoQ |
| AUM guidance (FY24 exit) | ~₹12,000 cr |
| Disbursements | ₹2,513 cr, +81% YoY and +51% QoQ |
| Disbursement guidance (Q3 and Q4 each) | ₹3,000–3,500 cr |
| New customer acquisition | 3.5 lakh, +183% YoY and +34% QoQ |
| Total customer base | 0.27 cr, +24% YoY and +12% QoQ |
| GNPA | 1.4%, down 23 bps QoQ, down from 7.37% YoY |
| NNPA | 0.42%, down 7 bps QoQ |
| PCR | 70.26% |
| Net collection efficiency | 97.7%, vs 98.1% QoQ |
| Gross collection efficiency (with lag) | 100.3% |
| Leverage | 2.31x, vs 1.98x QoQ |
| CRAR | 36.6% |
| Borrowings mobilized | ₹3,191 cr, +195% YoY |
| Cash position | ₹1,850 cr at quarter end |
| Branches operationalized (calendar year to date) | 292 |
| Branches ready to be operationalized (next 3 months) | 110 |
| Branches moved to weekly collection under Project Parivartan | 700, covering 0.15 cr customers |
| Single-lender relationship (Spandana only) | 33–34% of customer base, vs 36% QoQ |
| Average exposure per customer | ₹36,800 |
| H1 bad debt recovery | ₹54 cr, full-year target upwards of ₹100 cr |