Key Takeaways
- Foods growth stalled, but margins improved: Foods revenue posted zero growth in Q2, below management's own expectations, while gross margin expanded ~500 bps to 24% as strong gross contribution was reinvested into advertising across all four categories for the first time.
- Competitive battle in spreads is being won on price: Faced with a competitor spending an estimated ₹140 Crores on advertising in a ₹200 Crore category, management chose to compete on price rather than ad dollars, sacrificing margin but positioning to double pre-launch volumes and gain pricing power when competitor spending eventually stops.
- New businesses are scaling faster than the old: Breakfast cereals and chocolates are on track to reach ₹50 Crores much faster than the 11-12 years it took peanut butter and popcorn, driven by distribution now at half a million stores and greater manufacturing bandwidth.
- The edible oil anchor is slowly lifting: Foods gross margin is at 46% with a target of 48-50%, and management's stated trigger for structural gross margin expansion is when foods contributes 75-80% of total gross margin, insulating the P&L from commodity oil swings.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the ready-to-cook and spreads turnaround actions restore double-digit foods growth, the November analyst meet roadmap to 15-20% EBITDA margins, and the Q3 launch of plant meats and cocoa-based products.
The Quarter: What Happened and Why
- Zero foods growth: No growth in foods in Q2, which management called below expectations, attributing the softness partly to an unusual base effect where Q2 last year was ~7% higher than Q3, a pattern not seen pre-COVID. Management urged looking at six-month data for a more accurate picture.
- Gross margin jump and its deployment: Gross contribution improved gross margin by about 500 bps, from 19% to 24%, adding an incremental ₹4.5 Crores. That entire incremental gross margin was invested in advertising and promotion across ready-to-cook, spreads, breakfast cereals, and chocolates, the first quarter ever with multi-category advertising.
- Other expenses rose: Higher freight and travel costs drove the increase in other expenses. Employee benefits saw some increase but not a significant one.
- Staples held flat: Total staples volume was flat versus the prior year, supported by mass staples and adjacencies. The rollout of oats and almonds continued, while honey faced product issues and is being regrouped. Adjacencies helped mitigate the impact of lower edible oil prices on total distributor revenue.
- Overall volume at 6%: Volume growth reduced to 6% due to the soft Q2, with all actions in place particularly in ready-to-cook and spreads to get back to double-digit levels.
Sachin Gopal: "I would say clearly the foods growth is less than we expected. We are cognizant of that and clearly the two areas that we are working on and working hard on are the ready to cook and spread."
Category-Level Performance
| Category | Trend | Commentary |
|---|---|---|
| Ready-to-eat | ▲ Strong | 23-24% volume and value growth driven by ready-to-eat popcorn across pack sizes and channels; sweet snacks share of RTE improved from 4% to 8%. |
| Ready-to-cook popcorn | ▬ Mixed | Instant popcorn at mid single-digit volume growth (5-6%), recovering from COVID; microwave popcorn volumes flattish with some pricing; combined effect is low single-digit revenue growth. |
| Non-popcorn RTC | ▼ Weak | Sweet corn and pasta trailing prior year by ~49% because retail demo resources were diverted to fix the popcorn business over the last 12 months; focus is now shifting back. |
| Spreads & dips | ▼ Share loss | Management acknowledged possible share loss 2-3 quarters ago; actions include launching a 300g pack at ₹99 and a ₹10 blister pack. Peanut butter volume at minus 2%, with a strategy to compete on price rather than ad dollars against a competitor spending ~₹140 Crores. |
| Breakfast cereals | ▲ Growing | Rewired architecture for Popz shells well accepted; total cereals distribution reflecting steady growth; four months of continued investment behind Popz completed June to September. |
| Chocolates | ▬ Below expectations | Looking a little lower than desired; had to test how far the business could go without advertising support; Duo continues to steadily gain distribution; media investment started in August to support consumer acquisition; ₹5 pack rollout underway. Year-to-date growth of about 20%. |
- Peanut butter competitive dynamics: Management estimates the competitor's revenues at ₹20-23 Crores on ₹140 Crores of advertising spend, calling the strategy unsustainable. The company's three-year volume CAGR on peanut butter is 17%, and exit volume four years after the competitor's launch will be about 2X of pre-launch volume.
- Pop-up box launched: The microwave popcorn pop-up box is already in market in some parts of the country and will be fully national in about 10-15 days.
- Blister pack traction: The ₹10 blister pack, the first in peanut butter outside North America, is seeing very good acceptance. In general trade, transactions on the blister pack already exceed any of the larger packs, only two to three months in market.
Sachin Gopal: "On Rs.140 Crores spend our estimate is they have got revenues of about Rs.20 Crores maybe Rs.22 Crores to Rs.23 Crores but not much more than that so it is not paying. It is not paying and it cannot pay for them. The strategy cannot pay for them."
The Edible Oil Anchor and Margin Structure
- Gross margin stagnation explained: Gross margin has been in the region of about ₹170-180 Crores for some years because the company chose to move away from edible oil and focus on foods. The trigger for increase will be when the dominant share of foods starts to dominate the share of gross margin.
- Foods gross margin trajectory: Foods gross margin is at a historical level of 46%, with a target to migrate to the 48-50% range over time. Chocolate has to play a very significant role in that migration.
- Edible oil margin as the key risk: The key risk to maintaining 7-8% A&P spend is what happens to edible oil margin. If edible oil margin comes under pressure, the company may not be able to afford that level. The only structural answer is for foods to contribute 75-80% of total gross margin, at which point the impact of edible oil margin will reduce.
- Competitive spending in edible oils has vanished: Across the edible oil category, zero spending by premium players this quarter. ATFL was already at zero, and Marico is now also at zero compared to 100% a decade ago. Smaller players across segments are also spending less and are less visible.
- Volume vs margin trade-off is daily: The volume versus margin trade-off on edible oil is an ongoing day-to-day exercise. Many competitors spend big advertising dollars, and the company has to keep an eye on it.
Sachin Gopal: "When a category has zero share of spending then the answer is in your face. The bottomline not a great category and I think we did absolutely the right thing to be able to focus on foods."
Advertising, Investment and the Growth Algorithm
- 7-8% A&P is structural: Management remains committed to the 7-8% A&P range, the range given for many years, to support the ~18% foods growth CAGR. The rationale: as the company becomes larger, innovation as a percentage of total becomes smaller, so advertising dollars are needed to drive growth.
- The 50:50 shift: Today, the share of business coming from media-driven growth relative to innovation-driven growth is about 50:50. Management does not expect that ratio to hold at ₹2,000 Crores or ₹4,000 Crores; advertising will need to take a larger share over time.
- Media investment threshold: ₹15 Crores is an important milestone; at ₹20 Crores, the company starts to invest media behind a product. Chocolates and breakfast cereals are heading towards that ₹20 Crores mark, which is why investing has started. The company will not invest in brands at ₹5 Crores or ₹10 Crores.
- Business milestone framework: At ₹50 Crores, a business starts to become viable, no longer losing money, out of the base investment phase. At ₹200 Crores, businesses are incredibly profitable. At ₹1,000 Crores, the company needs about five businesses of ~₹200 Crores each.
- New businesses must scale faster: Earlier businesses took 11-12 years to reach ₹50 Crores; breakfast cereals and chocolates look like they will do it a lot faster, partly due to distribution now at about half a million stores versus less than 100,000 at peanut butter's launch, and partly due to greater manufacturing and portfolio bandwidth.
Sachin Gopal: "We remain committed to say 7% to 8% is what we require that is the range that we have always given you for the last many years and it remains our range because we will never make an EBITDA margin out of 15%, out of 12% to 13% A&P business it is just not possible."
Product Pipeline and Distribution Expansion
- Plant meats and cocoa-based products: Launch in Q3 is on schedule, rolling out in the next couple of weeks, and will be available for touch-and-feel at the November analyst meeting.
- Gift packs for sweet portfolio: Rolling out gift packs starting this Diwali, now in the market. The company is working to increase share of the ₹1,000 Crores gifting market with the Moments pack at ₹100, though mastering the gifting business takes time.
- ₹5 portfolio strengthening: Progress made in creating a profitable ₹5 portfolio across snacks, breakfast cereals, and chocolates. As coverage expands from half a million to 0.1 Crore stores, a strong ₹5 portfolio is expected to be a critical distribution driver.
- Capacity expansion: On track for capacity expansion in FY2024 capable of supplying volumes for a ₹100 Crores-plus business. This does not mean ₹100 Crores of chocolate sales next year; it means having that capacity to meet growth effectively. Building out the supply chain takes time for this complex category.
- Two new breakfast cereal products: Launching in Q3 and Q4 to complete the portfolio in breakfast cereals.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Foods growth recovery | Double-digit volume growth restored, actions in place particularly in ready-to-cook and spreads | Ongoing; no specific quarter given |
| Ready-to-cook growth | 8-10% overall growth; instant popcorn at 5-6% volume growth should get back to 8-10% with continued investment and distribution expansion | Ongoing |
| Non-popcorn RTC turnaround | Turn around the non-popcorn business (sweet corn, pasta) after diverting resources to popcorn for 12 months | This winter/ongoing festive season |
| Plant meats and cocoa-based products launch | Q3 launch on schedule | Next couple of weeks |
| Peanut butter volume | Bring current minus 2% volume into positive space | No specific quarter given |
| EBITDA margin roadmap | Roadmap to 15-20% EBITDA margin to be presented | November analyst meeting |
| Foods ₹1,000 Crores roadmap | Roadmap to ₹1,000 Crores of foods to be discussed | November analyst meeting |
| A&P spend | Remain committed to 7-8% of revenue, conditional on edible oil margin not coming under pressure | Ongoing |
| Foods gross margin | Migrate from 46% to 48-50% range; chocolate to play a significant role | Over time; no specific date |
| Capex | ~₹45 Crores every year is a reasonable number to work with | Annual run-rate |
| Capacity expansion | Capacity capable of supplying volumes for ₹100 Crores-plus business | FY2024 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Revenue (foods volume growth, 6-month) | ~6% volume, ~4% value |
| Gross contribution (total company) | ~40% |
| Gross contribution (foods) | ~46%, back at historical level |
| Gross margin | 24%, improved ~500 bps from ~19% |
| Incremental gross margin generated | ₹4.5 cr |
| Profit before tax (Q2) | Lower than prior year |
| Profit before tax (half year ended Sep 30) | ~₹15 cr, up from ~₹11 cr in prior year |
| A&P spend (year-to-date) | ~7.5% of foods revenue; Q2 a little higher |
| Ready-to-cook volume growth (Q2) | ~1%, value down 4% |
| Instant popcorn volume growth | 5–6% |
| Non-popcorn businesses (sweet corn & pasta) | Trailing prior year by ~49% |
| Ready-to-eat volume and value growth | ~23–24% |
| Sweet share of RTE | ~8%, up from 4% |
| Peanut butter volume growth (current) | -2% |
| Peanut butter volume CAGR (last 3 years) | 17% |
| Breakfast cereals growth | ~40–45% |
| Chocolates year-to-date growth | ~20% |
| Total staples volume | Flat to prior year |
| Store coverage | A little under 0.05 crore stores |
| Capex spend (annual run-rate) | ~₹45 cr |