Key Takeaways
- Moderate but steady foods growth, margins recovering: Foods grew ~7% YoY while gross contribution bounced back to the historical 45% level, a combination management calls steady rather than strong.
- Ready-to-Cook is the drag, not the engine: RTC volumes ran ~5% or lower versus the prior year as the business digests a near-doubled monthly selling rate from the COVID era; the non-RTC portfolio grew ~25% and carried the quarter.
- RTE Snacks and Breakfast Cereals are scaling profitably: RTE Snacks volume up 40%, value up 50%, with a significant jump in profitability; Breakfast Cereals up 54% in both volume and value, now absorbing overheads and approaching self-funding status.
- Spreads and Dips share position is solid, but margin was deliberately sacrificed: Volume held steady and lost share was more than regained, but value trailed volume by ~1,500 bps because of a prior-year price reduction in peanut butter; that gross margin check is now written and the gap is closing.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the elevated media investment in Popcorn and the INR 15 price point translate into RTC volume acceleration, whether the second chocolate line achieves stable production rhythm, and whether the spreads value gap narrows to the expected 2–3% in net sales per kilo.
Foods Portfolio: The Growth Mix Shift
- RTC base effect is the core headwind: Volumes were ~5% or lower versus prior year because the average monthly selling rate nearly doubled during COVID; the base is now structural and the business must grow from it, not lap it.
- Non-RTC portfolio is doing the heavy lifting: The rest of the foods business grew ~25%, pulling aggregate foods growth to ~7%; without that diversification, the Ready to Cook business alone could not have delivered moderate growth.
- RTE Snacks profitability inflection: Volume up 40%, value up 50%, and the gap between the two narrowed in Q3 as prior-year price increases were lapped; greater scale in popcorn, increased share of sweet snacks (Caramel Bliss, Sundrop Duo Cruncheez), and overhead absorption by breakfast cereal all contributed to a significant jump in profitability.
- Breakfast Cereals riding competitor advertising: 54% volume and value growth driven by Center Filled Cereals expansion and Value Added Oats rollout; management says the product is good enough that competitor spending by Kellogg's and Tata Soulfull benefits Sundrop.
- Chocolates constrained by supply chain, not demand: Growth was less than desired because the plant struggled to optimize simultaneous production, packing and shipping of multiple SKUs; a second line is installed but scaling up is hampered by machinery supplier challenges in Germany, including energy and labor shortages. Retail display initiatives and gifting shipments are working where executed.
- Spreads and Dips: share won, margin sacrificed deliberately: Volume performance was steady and any share lost 18 months ago has been more than regained; new competitors are struggling for relevance and the number of players physically available has reduced. Value trailed volume by ~1,500 bps because of a prior-year peanut butter price reduction, a gross margin check written to defend share that is now done.
Sachin Gopal: "At the end of the day, the food business, one of the reasons is the great foods is a great business is it got very good moats. Consumers don't move so easily away from you and you are able to, therefore, have a very-very strong share position."
Margins: The Transition From Oil to Foods Is Complete
- Aggregate gross margin was flat for a decade by design: Over 10 years, declining oil margins were compensated for by growing food margins, but food could not fully offset the oil decline; the aggregate stayed flat during this transition. Fifteen years ago, 98–99% of margin came from oil (~INR 60 crores); today the dominant part comes from foods with aggregate margin of ~INR 170 crores.
- Foods gross contribution back to pre-COVID levels: Gross contribution recovered north of 45%, after dipping only in Q1 when commodity prices spiked; at its peak, when RTC share was very high, it probably crossed 50%.
- The 45–50% gross contribution range is the operating model: At 45% gross contribution, if SG&A, manufacturing, A&P, damages, transportation and warehousing are held to 30%, the business delivers 15% EBITDA margin; at 50% gross contribution, the same cost envelope yields 20% EBITDA margin.
- Manufacturing costs are the biggest cost lever still to pull: Currently very high on some categories because of lack of scale; management expects the cost structure to fall into place as each category approaches INR 200 crores. Non-RTC categories carry higher depreciation, more processing and more energy (frying, oven, baking), which drove up other expenses this quarter.
- A&P stepped up to address RTC growth: Investment rose INR 2.6 crores versus prior year; Ready to Cook spending increased from INR 1 crore/month to INR 1.5 crores/month in December. Advertising spend has come down to 4–5% in recent years but hit 6–7% last quarter.
- Staples margin prioritized over volume: Premium Staples volumes declined as the business lagged the downward slope of pricing "probably a little bit, but not so much"; Mass Staples showed negative growth reflecting the exit from Crystal. Oil margins were stable despite the Ukraine war but came at a cost in volume. Management's stance: "Our focus is margin, we need the margin."
Sachin Gopal: "Now that this has happened, that transition has happened, you will see, you have to — we have to see a growth. It's going to happen. It can't be stopped."
Competitive Position & Pricing Philosophy
- Competitive shakeout underway in spreads: Almost any share Unilever has taken has been from other players, not Sundrop; new competitors are struggling to find relevance and the number of players physically available has reduced. Management argues only long-term players who set up their own manufacturing and invest consistently in brands will have a runway ahead.
- Pricing headroom exists but is deliberately not closed: Management sees ~30% pricing difference versus competitors in some categories but chooses not to go to parity pricing; the logic is that consumers need a reason to switch, and the product is already profitable at 45%+ gross contribution.
- Money alone is not the answer in food: Management points to Hindustan Unilever's peanut butter business (INR 100 crores, single-digit share) as evidence that spending cannot simply buy share in this category; the moats are real.
Sachin Gopal: "The best example of that is don't look at our business, look at Hindustan Unilever, peanut butter. It's visible to you, INR 100 crores and single-digit share... So money is not the answer. And that's why it's such a great business. Because nobody can just come and spend money and eat your share of the cake."
New Initiatives & Innovation Pipeline
- INR 15 price point for Instant Popcorn: Establishment underway, supported by retail demonstrations; elevated media investment initiated in December to drive RTC growth into FY '24.
- Pizza and Pasta Sauces rollout commenced: Part of the broader portfolio expansion beyond core RTC.
- Snacking Cookies and Plant Meats in development: Work underway to support RTC growth in FY '24, including a broader Snacking Cookies portfolio and Plant Meats.
- PeAq high-protein variant launched: Rollout started with distribution expansion and gym retailing; will play in blended protein (vegan, rice protein) and lend itself to protein bars over time.
- Breakfast Cereals innovation: Cookie and Crème variant introduced and well accepted; Shells product (like Kellogg's Chocos) reworked and being rolled out to improve the bottom-of-pyramid offering.
- Oats rollout doing well: Procurement scale already achieved a price reduction; expansion will improve margins across the foods business.
- Chocolates automation investment coming: Capacity expansion, productivity increase and automation work underway; next year's capital expenditure plan will likely include more investment in automation than in earlier years.
Staples & Oil: Margin Anchors, Not Growth Engines
- Premium Staples volume declined on margin discipline: The cost of being focused on margin; the business lagged the downward slope of pricing "probably a little bit, but not so much." Working on broader-based execution to help procurement scale and reduce total cost of manufacture for foods.
- Mass Staples negative growth reflects Crystal exit: Only one month of Q3 had Crystal in the prior year.
- Oil margins stable despite Ukraine war: But higher margins came at a cost in terms of volume; management's priority is margin, not volume at any cost.
- Staples margin not correlated with volume in the short term: Competitors have reduced prices; the company tracks this and will deal as appropriate, but focus remains on sustainable margin.
- No capital deployment in Staples manufacturing: Only packaging machines at third-party packers; the role of Premium Staples is to provide sustainable margin, not to drive volume growth.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| RTC growth target | 10–15% growth in RTC; non-RTC at 25–30%; aggregate in line with historical ~19% CAGR | FY '24 |
| Foods gross contribution | 48–49% ballpark, driven by media investment (pricing power) and procurement scale | FY '24 |
| EBITDA cost structure | 30–35% of revenue, depending on whether gross contribution is at 45% or 50% | Medium-term, as categories scale |
| Spreads and Dips value growth | Value growth projected ahead of volume growth; gap to narrow to 2–3% in net sales per kilo | Q4 FY23 (gap narrowing); FY '24 (value ahead of volume) |
| Chocolates supply chain | Establish required supply chain for the category | Q4 FY23 |
| Chocolates, Spreads and Dips scale | Each category individually to reach ~INR 20–25 crores | "Next few years" |
| Manufacturing cost structure | Each category to approach INR 200 crores for right cost structure | As scale builds (no date) |
| A&P envelope | Managed within 7–8% of revenue | Ongoing |
| Capacity planning assumption | 30–35% growth across five categories | Ongoing planning basis |
| Land bank capacity | Can take company to ~$200–250 million turnover | Long-term (no date) |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Net sales (total company) | ₹225 cr |
| Foods revenue | ₹116 cr, +7% YoY |
| Aggregate gross contribution (total company) | 35% (₹78 cr) |
| Foods gross contribution | 45%, back to historical 45–46% level; peak previously crossed 50% |
| Staples gross contribution | 24% |
| Staples gross margin (year-to-date) | ₹53 cr, vs ₹55 cr in prior-year same period |
| Profit before tax | ₹9.3 cr |
| Profit after tax | ₹6.8 cr |
| Foods year-to-date revenue growth | 10% |
| Ready to Cook Snacks volume growth | ~5% or lower YoY |
| Ready to Eat Snacks volume growth | ~40% YoY |
| Ready to Eat Snacks value growth | ~50% YoY |
| Breakfast Cereals volume growth | 54% YoY |
| Breakfast Cereals value growth | 54% YoY |
| Premium Staples volume growth | -15% YoY |
| Premium Staples value growth | -10% YoY |
| A&P investment increase vs prior year | ₹2.6 cr |
| Advertising spend (last quarter) | 6–7% of revenue |