Key Takeaways
- Foods growth disappoints, but the drag is self-inflicted, not macro: Volume grew just 5% YTD, held back by ready-to-cook and spreads. Management pins the weakness on category-specific execution, not demand, because rural and small-town channels grew double digits while urban lagged.
- Spreads and ready-to-cook are the two problems being fixed now: Pricing resets, mid-size pack gains, and a new blister pack are expected to return spreads to positive volume by Q4. Instant popcorn growth is targeted to accelerate from 5% to 8% with higher media spend starting Q1 FY25.
- Gross margin expansion stalled this quarter on phasing and mix: Lower edible oil prices and a foods mix-shift should be tailwinds, but pass-through pricing, ready-to-cook price cuts, and competitive pricing in spreads absorbed the benefit. Management says the year-to-date trend still shows improvement.
- The chocolate bet is scaling up, with capacity and margin signals turning positive: New manufacturing lines with ₹100 Cr+ capacity are near completion, gift packs sold out, and category gross margins near 60% support the path toward a 48-49% company-level margin profile.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether spreads volume turns positive as guided, whether ready-to-cook value growth converges with volume growth when the prior-year pricing base resets, and whether the new chocolate lines ship without the production issues that held back the ₹5 pack.
The Foods Growth Problem: Self-Inflicted, Not Macro
- Two categories explain the miss: Ready-to-cook volume is stuck at 5-6% against an 8% target, and spreads volumes are negative. Together they dragged total foods volume growth to 5% YTD, well below the 16-18% algorithm management targets.
- Rural is outperforming urban: The super-distributor network serving semi-urban and rural markets grew revenue 11% and volume 13%, while direct-distributor urban channels grew revenue just 1% and volume 3%. The ₹5 and ₹10 portfolio is working in smaller towns.
- Ready-to-cook value lags volume because of a pricing hangover: Prices were raised last year and then brought back down, so value growth trails volume by 3-4 percentage points. That gap should close when the prior-year base resets at the end of Q4.
- Adjacencies are narrowing the gap: The sweet corn and pasta business had been down 49% at September-end; renewed focus has since shrunk that deficit.
- Breakfast cereals' -3% is an optical distortion: The decline is entirely due to the Masala Oats launch in the prior-year quarter, which sells at a much lower price point than center-filled cereals. Underlying products like Shells grew 9%.
Sachin Gopal: "the short answer to the question on why is the foods growth less than we like it to be it has nothing to do with the macros because if it is the macros then it will behave more similarly to other companies who reported that rural is dragging them down. That is not the case in our company"
Spreads: The Turnaround Bet
- The problem is competitive and concentrated in mid-size packs: HUL's entry brought heavy spending into modern trade. Sundrop's response, built around recipe-based Honey Roast Peanut Butter, is already gaining ground in mid-size packs, and general trade volumes turned positive at 3% in Q3.
- The ₹10 blister pack is a structural moat play: A new single-serve blister pack for peanut butter is settling in and generating significant monthly transactions. An on-the-go pack at the same price point starts production in February, and a dipper pack is ready to launch. Management argues its back-stack manufacturing network makes this format impossible for competitors to replicate economically.
- Volume is expected to turn positive by Q4: All necessary actions are in place, and the exit trajectory supports a ~10% volume growth target for FY25.
- Competitive spending is seen as unsustainable: Management believes HUL's current spending level relative to its revenues in the category cannot persist indefinitely, and that rationality will eventually return.
Sachin Gopal: "we are the only people honestly who can do it because we are the only people who sell peanut butter who have a huge network of back stack manufacturing facility so it is a significant competitive advantage"
Ready-to-Eat and Ready-to-Cook: Two-Speed Recovery
- Ready-to-eat is the bright spot: All popcorn formats, savory and sweet, are performing strongly. Sweet snacks surged 66%, though panned products need recipe changes to reduce fat content before they can push past a 10% share. Big packs appear to be reaching an inflexion point in both quick commerce and out-of-home channels like highway stops.
- Distribution is the ready-to-eat growth lever: Only about 500 customers are served directly for RTE snacks out of roughly 2,500 addressable outlets. Expanding penetration requires refining the supply chain, not building demand.
- Ready-to-cook's path to 10% growth is mapped: Instant popcorn moving from 5-6% to 8% volume growth, plus 200 bps from adjacencies, plus incremental media spend, gets the category to 10%. Higher media investment of roughly ₹4 crores begins in Q1 FY25, not this quarter.
- Value growth convergence is a Q1 FY25 event: Once the prior-year pricing base resets at end-Q4, revenue should grow in line with volume from Q1 onward.
Chocolates: Scaling with Margin Signals
- The ₹5 pack underperformed on size perception: Consumers appear to perceive it as smaller than competing wafer chocolates or larger brands like 5 Star. Work is underway to address the issue.
- Manufacturing is transitioning from pilot to scale: New lines with capacity of ₹100 Cr+ are very close to completion and will transition this quarter, addressing initial layout and production problems. A Paan variant has just started commercial production and will appear in the market in the next month or two.
- Gift packs exceeded expectations: The ₹100 pack sold out post-Diwali with close to zero inventory. Management deliberately targeted less than the market could absorb to avoid obsolescence, and plans a bigger figure next year with year-round availability.
- Category margins support the investment case: Average gross contribution for chocolates is about 60%, closer to personal care than to foods. That margin profile, if scaled, helps lift the company-level margin from 46% toward 48-49%.
Margins: Gross Headwinds, Operating Leverage Building
- Gross margin dipped this quarter on phasing, not structural erosion: Lower edible oil prices and a mix shift toward higher-margin foods should have expanded gross margin, but pass-through pricing on oils, price reductions on ready-to-cook, and competitive pricing actions in spreads absorbed the benefit. The year-to-date trend still shows improvement.
- Manufacturing cost per kilo is falling as volumes rise: Growth in ready-to-eat and breakfast cereals is driving operating leverage in the factory, though these categories carry a higher manufacturing cost percentage than ready-to-cook.
- Three cost buckets hold the key to 500 bps of margin expansion: Labour, energy, and obsolescence are the largest opportunities to reduce manufacturing cost. Obsolescence currently runs at 1.9%, and management would not like it to exceed 1%, though it will not come down to 0.5% in the near term. All three capex proposals recently put to the Board are cost-reduction projects, not capacity additions.
- SG&A allocation works against foods margins when oil prices fall: As edible oil revenue declines with lower prices, the notional SG&A allocation to foods rises mechanically, creating a headwind to reported foods margins even when underlying unit economics improve.
- The EBITDA margin target is 15-20%: Getting there requires reducing manufacturing cost by roughly 500 bps from current levels.
Competitive Dynamics and the Spending Environment
- Premium edible oil advertising has dropped to zero: Sundrop spent nothing on premium oils in Q2 and Q3. Agro Tech stopped spending from FY2019, and competition is now heading in the same direction.
- In chocolates, the competitive field is thinning: Hershey's dropped spending significantly in FY24, Ferrero does not really spend, Tata Soulfull reduced investments, and Saffola is spending less than the prior year. If both Hershey's and Ferrero stay quiet, Agro Tech's position strengthens.
- Spreads is the exception, and it is a direct fight with HUL: Management frames it as a contest between HUL's spending power and Sundrop's consumer franchise built on recipe-based products and the ₹10 blister-pack moat. The bet is that HUL's current spending level is not sustainable at its revenue base in the category.
Sachin Gopal: "Let us face it we are dealing with a situation we are competing with India's largest FMCG company, it is not a company to be tackled with they are reasonably smart people and they spend a lot of money but they have not made much progress so I think from that standpoint we have done the job and I think executed the best possible game plan that we could have chosen and now it is a matter of time we have to see how long they can keep spending."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Spreads volume recovery | Volume turns from negative to positive | By Q4 FY24 |
| Spreads volume growth | ~10% volume growth for the category | FY25 |
| Ready-to-cook volume growth | Instant popcorn accelerates from 5-6% to 8% | FY25 (media spend starts Q1) |
| Ready-to-cook value growth convergence | Revenue grows in line with volume as prior-year pricing base resets | Q1 FY25 |
| Total foods growth algorithm | Return to 16-18% growth, with half from advertising and half from innovation | FY25 |
| A&P spend | Total company ad spend rises from ~6.5% to 7-7.5% of revenue; incremental ~₹4 Cr for media | FY25 |
| Chocolate manufacturing capacity | New lines with ₹100 Cr+ capacity transition in | Current quarter (Q4 FY24) |
| Chocolate gift packs | ₹100 pack available year-round; bigger volume planned | FY25 |
| EBITDA margin target | 15-20% EBITDA margin, requiring ~500 bps manufacturing cost reduction | No date (cost-reduction capex underway) |
| Obsolescence ceiling | Management would not like obsolescence to exceed 1% (currently 1.9%) | No date |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Revenue gap | ~10% decline YoY; year-to-date over 8% decline |
| Foods volume growth (year-to-date) | ~5%, lower than desired |
| Foods gross contribution margin | ~46%, flat; best-in-class range is 48–52% |
| Year-to-date gross contribution | Up ~₹18 cr YoY |
| Year-to-date gross margin | Up ~₹9 cr YoY |
| Q3 gross contribution | Down ~₹3 cr YoY |
| Q3 gross margin | Down ~₹6 cr YoY |
| Q3 PBT | ₹3.4 cr |
| Q3 PAT | ₹2.5 cr |
| Year-to-date PBT | ~₹12 cr |
| Year-to-date PAT | ~₹9 cr |
| Raw material cost decline | ~315 bps YoY |
| Total company A&P spend | ~6.5% of sales; planned increase to 7–7.5% in FY25 |
| Ready-to-cook volume growth (year-to-date) | ~3% YoY; value growth 0% |
| Instant popcorn volume growth (year-to-date) | ~5% YoY; cumulative monthly growth 5–6% |
| Ready-to-eat volume growth | ~20% YoY; value growth 19% |
| Sweet snacks share of RTE | ~8%, up 66% YoY; had touched 11% in one quarter last year |
| Spreads & dips volume growth (year-to-date) | Down ~3% YoY; value down ~6% |
| Spreads general trade volume growth (Q3) | Up ~3% YoY |
| Peanut butter distribution | Just under 1 lakh stores |
| Breakfast cereals volume growth (Q3) | -3% YoY, an aberration due to Masala Oats launch in prior year; pricing delta ~900 bps |
| Shells (plain extruded cereal) growth (Q3) | 9% YoY |
| Total cereals distribution | 134,000 stores |
| Chocolates volume growth | ~17% YoY, roughly 20% overall; target was 35–40% |
| Chocolates distribution | 120,000+ stores |
| Premium staples volume growth (Q3) | Down ~6% YoY |
| Mass staples volume growth (Q3) | Up 9% YoY |
| Total staples volume growth (Q3) | Down 4% YoY |
| Oats and almonds estimated revenue | ₹10 cr+ |
| Obsolescence rate | ~1.9%; target is not to exceed 1% |
| Employee benefit increase (year-to-date) | ~₹2 cr in salaries; ~₹1 cr in travel |
| Instant popcorn distribution | ~295,000 stores, approaching 300,000 |
| Processed foods share of revenue | 55–60% |