Key Takeaways
- Portfolio pivot absorbed the shock: Foods revenue grew just 3% YoY in Q4 as post-COVID normalization hit Ready-to-Cook volumes, but Ready-to-Eat snacks surged ~40% and Spreads volume jumped ~22%, proving the multi-category model works.
- Gross margin recovered, not yet healed: Foods gross contribution hit 46%, fully reversing the commodity spike from H1, but still trails the 48–50% target management is working toward.
- Chocolates is the next big bet, supply chain nearly fixed: Machinery delays from Germany are ~80% resolved; in-store tests show chocolate sales equal to popcorn with zero advertising, and capacity is being built for ₹100 crores of revenue.
- RTC volume softness is a base-effect story, not structural: Jan–Feb was tough against a +20% prior-year base; with schools and offices reopened, management expects a return to growth by Q1–Q2 FY24.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether RTC volumes actually turn positive as the COVID base washes out, the pace of chocolate supply-chain closure, and any margin lift from the ₹10 nano-pack rollout in spreads.
Ready-to-Cook: The Base-Effect Hangover
- Q4 volume declined because the prior year's Jan–Feb was up almost 20% on a very big base, driven by Omicron and work-from-home tailwinds that have now reversed.
- Volume retention held at ~5% of the COVID-era elevation, meaning the business did not give back all the pandemic gains even as people returned to working outside the home.
- Recovery timeline tied to base normalization: schools reopened in July, work-from-home ended between April and September, so the tough comparables should fade by Q1–Q2 FY24.
- Interventions to minimize attrition included elevated media investments, distribution expansion, and effective use of the ₹15 pack along with retail demos.
- The company algorithm depends on it: RTC popcorn needs to grow at 8–10% for the overall ~20% growth algorithm to work, and management expects to get back to high single-digit to 10% growth.
Sachin Gopal: "We cannot tell you exactly in which month that will happen. But that should happen because last year by about May, June, the world had started returning to more normalcy."
Ready-to-Eat Snacks: The Conveyor Belt Delivers
- RTE snacks grew close to 40% in Q4, driven by RTE Popcorn doing very well, with clear all-India leadership in the category.
- Sweet Snacks share exited Q4 at 11% of RTE, up from sub-5% previously, and management is striving to exit FY24 between 15% and 20%.
- Profitability significantly enhanced by greater scale in RTE Popcorn, increased Sweet share, and a shift from a depot-based model to direct factory shipments, which improved overhead absorption.
- The six-plant network for RTE is now effectively in place, and learnings from popcorn will be applied to Tortilla chips and extruded snacks so each becomes a robust business.
- Snacking kits are being seeded with strong acceptance in select stores and good repeat business, but broad-based success is still pending; more resources will follow once popcorn growth returns.
Sachin Gopal: "This is something that used to worry us a lot, which is, you know, at the end of the day, this is the conveyor belt of the company. This is what our entire distribution expansion model is based on. And without it, you know, that expansion won't happen."
Spreads & Dips: Volume Surge, Margin Work Ahead
- Volume grew ~22% while value grew only ~8%, reflecting a price correction on larger packs executed toward the end of the prior year; the gap is expected to narrow as the base absorbs the price cut.
- Margin took a hit from the large-pack price reduction and mix shift; three actions are underway to fix it: ₹10 nano packs to expand distribution, protein-positioning work with gyms, and fixing the smaller-pack part of the business.
- ₹10 nano packs begin rolling out in Q1 FY24, and management believes competitors have a very low probability of entering this price point unless they manufacture and sell, giving ATFL a structural moat.
- Revenue-per-kilo uplift will come from migrating the mix toward Sweet peanut butter (₹350–₹500/kg) and, over time, chocolate spreads (>₹500/kg), plus new on-the-go consumption occasions.
- Any competitor category spending will disproportionately benefit ATFL as the market leader, and Kissan's continued advertising spend acts as a tailwind as nano-pack distribution expands.
Management: "We believe that it's very difficult for somebody to compete in these INR10 nano packs unless they are manufacturing and selling."
Chocolates: The Irrefutable Opportunity, Nearly Unlocked
- Q4 volume/value growth of 59%/69% was well below expectations because management expected chocolates to more than offset lower RTC volume; significant supply-chain issues caused delays in machinery receipt from Germany due to gas, labor, and internal supplier breakdowns.
- Recipe and manufacturing process changes are ~80% complete, and all supply-chain issues should be overcome by end of Q1 or Q2 FY24, after which the company will start to be aggressive.
- In-store tests prove the potential: in stores where chocolate is listed and displayed, sale is equal to popcorn, and those revenues came without advertising, only display investment.
- Capacity is being built for ₹100 crores+ of chocolate revenues per year, with most of the ~₹26 crores WIP capex dedicated to chocolates; the business is on track to be a significant contributor to growth in FY24.
- Store-visibility investment will start in Q2 FY24 post-summer, following a January test in ~100 stores that produced very good results; Q1 is avoided due to heat and moisture risks.
Management: "Our sale of chocolates in those stores is equal to the sale of our instant popcorn business. … That's a big statement because if it can happen in that store, that means we have a right to win and the ability to build that business nationally."
Breakfast Cereals: Building Walls, Chasing Kellogg's
- Strong performance driven by expansion of Center Filled Cereals and rollout of Value-Added Oats; the Cookie & Crème variant is doing "very, very well."
- ATFL out-distributes Kellogg's "by a mile" in small stores, but in large stores Kellogg's has a huge wall of product and ATFL's total Center Filled Cereals revenue was only one-third of Kellogg's.
- The own-wall strategy has begun: ATFL is building its own display walls next to the Kellogg wall in select stores across the country, with expansion planned during Q1 FY24; results so far are "very good."
- The Shells product (bottom-of-pyramid offering) has been reworked to address earlier hardness issues and is being rolled out now to enable multilevel wholesaling and broad indirect distribution.
- Operating leverage is the prize: capacity is significantly more than current sales, so more volume will bring down depreciation, manufacturing, labor, and resource costs per unit.
Margins: Operating Leverage Is the Entire Story
- Foods gross contribution recovered to 46% in Q4, fully reversing the commodity spike from the first two quarters, but still below the 48–50% desired range and the historical 26–27% total food gross margin.
- The margin dilution vs. history comes from RTC volumes not growing while other parts of the business have grown, diluting the mix, plus a Q1 impact; as RTC returns and overall volumes grow, gross margin should get back to 26–27% "very, very fast."
- Employee benefits at ~7% of revenues were held in check because salary increases were largely offset by the fact that performance incentive pay-outs did not happen, as profit was impacted for the year.
- Other expenses rose ₹13 crores YoY, with the largest chunks being restoration of travel (cut during COVID) and increase in freight, plus manufacturing and processing charges.
- ANP spending at 5.3% was lower than the desired 7–8% range but at an acceptable level; as margin improves, management will deploy even greater funds behind advertising.
Sachin Gopal: "Going forward, I would say on margins, look, it is going to come through operating leverage, 100%."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| RTC volume return to growth | High single-digit to 10% growth as COVID base normalizes | Q1–Q2 FY24 |
| Chocolate supply-chain resolution | All issues overcome, begin aggressive push | End of Q1 or Q2 FY24 |
| Chocolate capacity build | Capacity for ₹100 crores+ of annual revenue | FY24 |
| Sweet Share of RTE exit rate | Exit FY24 between 15% and 20% (from 11% in Q4 FY23) | FY24 exit |
| Spreads ₹10 nano-pack rollout | Begin expanding distribution via nano packs | Q1 FY24 |
| Breakfast cereals own-wall expansion | Build own display walls next to Kellogg's in large stores | Q1 FY24 |
| Chocolate store-visibility investment | Begin display investment post-summer | Q2 FY24 |
| Gross margin target | Reach 48–50% foods gross contribution | No date ("appropriate time") |
| Next ₹100-crore categories | RTE snacks and Spreads to nearly touch or cross ₹100 crores | FY24 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Foods revenue | ₹103 cr, +3% YoY |
| FY23 foods revenue | ₹437 cr, +9% YoY |
| Foods gross contribution | 46%, recovered to pre-COVID levels; target 48%–50% |
| Foods gross margin | ₹97 cr, higher than prior year |
| Staples gross margin | ₹77 cr, up from ₹75 cr in FY22 |
| Profit before tax | ₹20.4 cr, lower than prior year |
| Profit after tax | ₹15.1 cr, lower than prior year |
| Foods ANP spending | 5.3% of foods revenue, up ~₹3 cr vs prior year; desired range 7%–8% |
| Employee benefits | ~7% of revenues (~₹62 cr); salary increases offset by lower incentive payouts |
| Other expenses | +₹13 cr vs prior year, driven by restoration of travel and higher freight |
| Ready-to-Cook volume retention | ~5% last year; Jan–Feb base was up ~20% on prior year |
| Ready-to-Eat snacks growth | ~40% YoY |
| Sweet share of RTE | 11% in Q4 FY23, up from sub-5% earlier; exit target 15%–20% next year |
| Spreads & Dips volume growth | ~22% YoY; value growth +8%, gap due to price correction on larger packs |
| Chocolates volume growth | 59% YoY, well below expectations due to supply chain issues |
| Chocolates value growth | 69% YoY |
| Distribution reach | ~0.05 crore stores |
| Cumulative average foods growth rate | ~18%, down from 19% as last year was 10% |