Key Takeaways
- Double-digit topline, margin squeeze from international: Consolidated revenue grew 11% despite macro headwinds, but EBITDA margin fell 100 bps YoY as international inflation and currency pressure hit profitability.
- India foods is the growth engine: India foods surged 29%, led by salt, Sampann, and Tata Water Plus, while India beverages declined 2% on soft rural and lower-end tea volumes.
- International is the problem child: Revenue up 7% (6% constant currency) but EBITDA declined on US coffee cost inflation, UK volume softness, and a lag in pricing execution across both markets.
- Distribution and innovation bets are scaling: Direct outlet reach hit 0.14 Cr, e-commerce grew 40% to 9.2% of sales, and NPD contribution reached 11%, with the pace of new launches doubling.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether announced double-digit UK and US price increases land and start repairing international margins, and whether India tea volumes find a floor after the festive season.
India Business: Two-Speed Portfolio
- Beverages soft, but share held: India tea revenue fell 7% with volumes down 1%, cycling aggressive prior-year growth; management gained 20 bps of volume market share by giving up some pricing to protect volume momentum, particularly in semi-urban and rural markets.
- Rural stress concentrated at the bottom: Volume softness was very specifically in rural, semi-urban and at the lower end of the portfolio; TCPL's own semi-urban and rural growth is healthier than urban because it is building out distribution there, but industry-level growth in those markets is slower than expected, dragging TCPL down.
- Foods firing on all cylinders: India foods grew 29% on flat volumes, with 128 bps of market share gain; salt held share despite a >33% price increase over 12 months, Sampann grew 37% after a temporary prior-quarter setback from trading-term renegotiations, and Tata Water Plus roughly doubled.
- Growth businesses scaling fast: NourishCo grew 64%, Soulfull and Ready-to-Drink are on strong trajectories growing 50% consistently, and Starbucks same-store sales were up 24% versus pre-COVID with 25 new stores opened in the quarter.
- Premiumization a mixed story: Tata Tea Gold Care is at ~5% of total sales and gained volume but lost value as pricing was taken in line with softer tea prices to ensure volume momentum in semi-urban and rural markets. [4-5]
Sunil D’Souza: "I can start seeing green shoots but I would not declare victory. I think we have got to watch for some time."
International: Margin Damage Control Underway
- The margin hit is structural and lagged: International EBITDA declined because tea is bought in USD in Kenya and sold in GBP in the UK, creating a currency double-hit, while US coffee hedges rolling off at sharply higher prices and UK inflation compressed demand; price increases were taken but are coming into effect with a lag that will drag through the current quarter.
- UK pricing is aggressive and imminent: A "very, very significant double-digit price increase" has already been announced in the market, and management noted all competitors face the same Kenya-USD-GBP cost structure.
- US pricing round two underway: One more round of packaging-led pricing is being actioned on top of increases already taken; coffee commodity prices are stable in the 210-230 band with hedges in place.
- Cost restructuring is a two-phase plan: Phase one is done: an in-house offshore back office in Bangalore is already pulling work from international markets. Phase two will look at all other costs to make the international business a "much leaner machine" delivering significant double-digit EBIT growth. Structural cost actions already actioned will take three to four months to land.
- Market share holding up: In the UK, TCPL overtook Twinings to become the number three tea company in the last four weeks; in the US, coffee bag share was broadly maintained and share was gained in K-Cups.
- The commitment is explicit: Management intends to get both the US and UK businesses back into double-digit EBIT margins, but pricing will land firmly only in Q4 and the current quarter remains "choppy."
Sunil D’Souza: "Everyone buys tea from Kenya, all tea in Kenya is priced in dollars, and all the guys in UK sell it in pounds so I guess all of us are in the same hole."
Distribution & Channel Reach
- Direct outlet expansion ahead of target: Direct reach is at 0.14 Cr outlets, on track to beat the March 2023 target of 0.15 Cr; super stockists have been increased for semi-urban and rural reach.
- E-commerce accelerating: The channel exited FY2022 at ~7.5% of sales and is now at 9.2%, growing at 40%.
- Modern trade momentum: Modern trade grew 18% in the quarter.
- Distribution as the share-gain thesis: Management believes that given TCPL's very strong share of handlers, simply being distributed will deliver market share; semi-urban and rural distribution gaps still exist and are being targeted surgically, geography by geography.
- Bandwidth pilots for a growing portfolio: As the portfolio expands, TCPL is running pilots on creating extra distribution bandwidth through geographical segmentation or portfolio segmentation, including splitting geographies.
Sunil D’Souza: "I do believe given the fact that we have very, very strong share of handlers, if I am distributed, I will get shares."
Innovation & New Category Bets
- NPD engine accelerating: Revenue from innovation is up 16% YoY, the number of new products launched doubled versus the same quarter last year, and NPD contribution to e-commerce revenue from launches in the last three years reached 11%; the significance of launches in the last one year is significantly higher than prior years.
- RTE relaunched with conviction: The Ready-to-Eat business was fully revamped and relaunched under Tata Sampann Yumside in India and Tata Raasa internationally; management served only products from this range at a recent Board strategy meet and the Board could not distinguish them from fresh food.
- New categories entered: TCPL entered the Hing category and the health supplement space with GoFit, positioned at women with a probiotic-based digestion proposition; protein has been defined as a platform, with Tata Simply Better (alternate meat) launched as a first product.
- Sampann spices expanding geographically: Launched in Andhra Pradesh and Telangana, with blends ready to launch in Karnataka; management is looking at how quickly it can expand into other geographies.
- Shuddh by Tata Salt learning and iterating: Launched about a quarter ago in Andhra and Telangana, the product scores a win against competitors but packaging cues need modification to denote a more premium image; a modified-packaging rollout is expected in the next 30-60 days.
- Snacking still in strategy phase: Defined as one of the platforms in mini meals, breakfast and snacking, but management will not enter chips, bhujia or Kurkure equivalents; the strategy is to create a space that is not competitive, has a right to win, decent margins, ability to scale, and is a fast-growing category.
Sunil D’Souza: "In fact at a recent strategy meet for the Board we only served them products from this range and they could not make out the difference between fresh versus from this set so that is the product quality."
Structural Simplification & Capital Allocation
- NCLT process advancing: The Tata Consumer (Kolkata NCLT) hearing date is set for November 12th; a date from NCLT Bengaluru for Tata Coffee is awaited. Approvals have been received for swapping shares held by TEO from the UK parent holding company into India shares, which will remove all minority holdings from the UK holding company through which they will start the simplification process.
- Simplification will be EPS accretive: Once NCLT approvals come through, the process will take 90-120 days to be fully actionable and will deliver significant cost, dividend and tax optimization benefits.
- M&A discipline unchanged: Multiple discussions are always ongoing and the M&A and strategy teams have been beefed up, but management will not be in a hurry; both financial metrics and strategic screens must pass before any deal proceeds, with no timeline and no target set.
- Exceptional income booked: ₹147 crores was recognized from the sale of disputed, litigated land by Tata Coffee in Hyderabad, plus adjustments on international restructuring, driving group net profit up 36%.
Sunil D’Souza: "The catch is as I have consistently maintained we will not be in a hurry for anything. We will be very, very focused on making sure the financial metrics and the strategic screens both pass before we get it through."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Direct outlet reach | Beat March 2023 target of 0.15 Cr (already at 0.14 Cr) | By March 2023 |
| Tata Sampann value growth | 30% CAGR | Ongoing; "you can take it as given" |
| NPD as % of total sales | Exit this year at 3.5% to 3.8%; benchmark is to reach 5% | FY23 exit / medium-term |
| UK and US EBIT margins | Intent is to get both businesses back into double-digit EBIT margins | Pricing lands firmly in Q4; no date for full recovery |
| International cost restructuring | Phase one (offshore back office) done; phase two (all other costs) to make it a "much leaner machine" | Phase one actionable now; phase two timeline unspecified |
| NCLT simplification | 90-120 days to be fully actionable once approvals received | Presuming approvals in next 30 days |
| Shuddh by Tata Salt rollout | Modified packaging rollout in Andhra and Telangana | Next 30-60 days |
| India tea volume recovery | Hypothesis: good monsoon, MSPs, first unrestricted festive season should bring normalcy | Will wait one quarter before declaring growth has returned |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated revenue | ₹3,363 cr, +11% YoY |
| Consolidated revenue 3-year CAGR | 13% |
| Consolidated EBITDA growth | 4% YoY |
| Consolidated EBITDA margin | ~13%, down 100 bps YoY, primarily impacted by international business |
| Group net profit growth | 36% YoY, includes one-time gain on land sale and international restructuring adjustments |
| EPS growth | 22% YoY |
| Standalone revenue | ₹2,131 cr, +7% YoY |
| Standalone EBITDA growth | 25% YoY |
| Standalone PAT growth | 22% YoY |
| India business revenue growth | 9% YoY |
| India beverages revenue growth | -2% YoY, 3-year CAGR of 14% |
| India foods revenue growth | 29% YoY, 3-year CAGR of 22% |
| International business revenue growth | 7% (6% in constant currency) |
| India business EBITDA growth | 24% YoY |
| International business EBITDA | Declined YoY, impacted by higher commodity costs, inflation, and currency |
| Cash position | ₹2,000 cr+ |
| India tea volume growth | -1% YoY |
| India tea market share | +20 bps volume share gain |
| India foods volume growth | Flat YoY |
| India foods market share | +128 bps share gain |
| Salt price increase | >33% over 12 months (July 2021 to August 2022) |
| Growth businesses (RTD, Sampann, Soulfull) revenue growth | 50% |
| NourishCo revenue growth | 64% |
| Tata Sampann revenue growth | 37% |
| Tata Coffee revenue growth | 41% |
| US Coffee revenue growth | 25% (16% in constant currency) |
| International tea revenue growth | -4% |
| Canada revenue growth | 16% |
| Non-branded business growth | 30% |
| E-commerce as % of sales | 9.2%, up from ~7.5% at FY2022 exit |
| E-commerce growth | 40% |
| Modern trade growth | 18% |
| NPD contribution (e-commerce) | 11% of e-commerce revenue |
| Revenue from innovation growth | 16% YoY |
| A&P spend as % of sales (H1) | 6.4%, up from 6.1% in H1 FY22 |
| Direct outlet reach | 0.14 cr (0.14 crore), on track to beat March 2023 target of 0.15 cr |
| Starbucks store count | 300 stores, 25 opened in the quarter |
| Starbucks same-store sales growth | 24% vs pre-COVID period |
| Starbucks cities | 36 |
| Share of profit from JVs and Associates | ₹34 cr, up from ₹24 cr in Q2 FY22 |
| Exceptional income | ₹111 cr, largely from sale of a disputed land asset in Tata Coffee |
| India revenue share of consolidated | 72% |
| International revenue share of consolidated | 28% |
| India segment results share | 84% |
| Year-to-date consolidated revenue growth | 11% |
| Year-to-date consolidated profit growth | 37% |
| US market cumulative price increase (since Sep 2021) | ~22% |
| UK market previous price increase | 7% |
| UK market new price increase announced | Very significant double-digit increase |
| Tata Tea Gold Care as % of total sales | ~5% |
| India rural/urban revenue mix | ~1/3 rural, ~2/3 urban |