Key Takeaways
- Volume up 18%, value flat: Aggressive e-commerce discounting and soft-luggage liquidation wiped out the volume gain, compressing gross margin to ~45% from a ~51% three-year average.
- Inventory cleanup was unavoidable: Soft upright stock was cut from ~₹130 crore to under ₹100 crore; management calls the margin hit inevitable to avoid warehouse cost bloat and potential write-offs.
- BCG-led cost reset is underway: Two waves complete, benefits start in October; employee actions already taken in September; ₹40–50 crore of BCG savings expected in the P&L this year, weighted to Q4.
- Channel guardrails are coming: The company is negotiating written pricing floors for VIP and Skybag on portals, and is giving offline partners an additional warranty to ease channel conflict.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the promised Q3 margin recovery materialises, the pace of the remaining ~₹80 crore soft-luggage liquidation, and any sign that e-commerce salience is actually moderating as guided.
The Volume-Value Disconnect
- 18% volume, zero value: The divergence came from heavy discounting on e-commerce during Big Billion Day and GOAT sales, plus company-driven liquidation of slow-moving Aristocrat and Alfa soft luggage.
- E-commerce surged, offline bled: E-commerce volume grew 73% while modern trade de-grew 8%, reflecting both the channel shift and the competitive intensity from D2C players.
- Soft luggage was the problem child: The company deliberately sold below cost to clear ~₹130 crore of soft upright inventory, a one-time call that management says is not an ongoing strategy.
- Hard luggage pricing is reactive: Hard luggage pricing pressure is a response to D2C players with "enough money to burn," forcing VIP to play on price to defend share.
- The gap narrows in H2: Management expects the volume-value growth difference to shrink to 8–10% in H2, down from 18% in Q2, as liquidation tapers and new product launches lift realisations.
Neetu Kashiramka: "there are lot of D2C players which are coming into the market, and starting to sell, now all these players have enough money to burn, which we don't have, so that's where we are little bit playing on the pricing."
Gross Margin: The Damage and the Repair
- Gross margin collapsed to ~45%: The ~600 bps drop from the three-year average was driven by brand mix, channel mix, soft luggage discounting, and lower production at the Bangladesh unit.
- Sequential improvement has begun: Gross margin improved 80 bps from June to September, and employee costs were held flat sequentially as the first cost actions took effect.
- The 50% target is firm: Management reiterated that gross margin "should definitely be around 50%," with Q4 specifically targeted at 50% and FY26 at 55%.
- Product mix is the lever: New launches in VIP and Skybag, plus a push to sell VIP three-piece sets at ₹10,000 (vs Aristocrat at ₹7,000), are designed to lift realisations and margins from Q3 onward.
- Premium portfolio ambition: The company aims to move its premium and mid-premium mix from 54% to 60% over the next three to four quarters.
Neetu Kashiramka: "as I had promised, our gross margin should definitely be around 50%."
Inventory Cleanup: One More Quarter of Pain
- Soft upright stock down to under ₹100 crore: The reduction from ~₹130 crore in September was necessary; management said holding the inventory risked warehouse cost bloat and eventual write-offs.
- One more quarter to normalise: The heavy cleanup will take a maximum of two quarters, with the company trying to complete the bulk in Q3.
- Slow-moving inventory still ~₹180 crore: Per an analyst's math, the current quantum of slow-moving stock is around ₹180 crore, though management said it would reconfirm the figure.
- Warehousing costs stay elevated in Q3: Other expenses will remain high in Q3 due to inventory carrying costs, before declining in Q4 as BCG benefits flow through.
Neetu Kashiramka: "See this year, all this cleanup of inventory is a must because I can't hold it because my warehouse cost keep bloating if I keep this inventory, also if I keep this for a long there are chances of having to take some write offs, and therefore this was inevitable for me to take these calls at this point of time."
Channel Conflict and the E-Commerce Guardrails
- Portals set the aggressive prices, not VIP: Management clarified that the deep discounting on e-commerce is done by the portals themselves, and the company is now pushing back.
- Written pricing floors incoming: VIP is negotiating pricing guardrails for VIP and Skybag brands, below which portals cannot sell; the model mirrors what the mobile industry adopted three to four years ago.
- Offline partners get a sweetener: The company is offering an additional warranty to offline retailers to address the channel conflict while the guardrails are put in place.
- E-commerce salience to moderate: H1 e-commerce share hovered at 30–35% of overall sales; management wants to maintain that level, not grow e-commerce at the expense of other channels, and expects the share to come down in Q3 and Q4.
Neetu Kashiramka: "It will be a pricing guardrail for VIP and Skybag, which is our premium brand. They cannot sell below a particular MOP, a similar thing which had happened some three, four years back in the mobile industry, that's where we are heading towards, and we are already in talks with them to give this to us in writing before they sell going forward."
BCG-Led Cost Transformation
- Two waves complete, benefits start now: The first two waves of the BCG project are done, with benefits beginning in October; the third wave will impact Q4.
- ₹40–50 crore of savings this year: BCG initiatives will deliver that quantum into the P&L in FY25, weighted toward Q4.
- Employee costs already acted on: Headcount-related actions were taken in September, with results visible in December and January due to notice periods.
- Every cost line under review: Warehousing, logistics, fill rate, and people cost are all being addressed; management is targeting 12% EBITDA and revisiting the entire cost structure.
- A&P spend shifts next year: The company wants to improve marketing effectiveness by spending more on ATL rather than BTL, but that change will only happen in FY26.
Balance Sheet and Bangladesh
- Debt reduction on track: The company has already cut ₹35 crore and targets a minimum ₹100 crore reduction by March 2025 from a ₹580 crore base; management said it can do better.
- Year-end debt around ₹400 crore: Per an analyst's math, debt should be about ₹400 crore by FY25 end; management broadly agreed but noted investments could provide further cushion and did not fully confirm the number.
- Bangladesh turning profitable: The factory is now running full-fledged and will start showing profits from Q3 onward; capacities have been reduced and no wage cost increase is expected.
- Insurance claim trickling in: Small amounts have been received, with ₹5 crore more expected in Q3; the entire claim settlement is expected in 8–12 months, though the insurer has given no formal indication.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Gross margin recovery | Reach ~50% | Q4 FY25 |
| FY26 gross margin | 55% "quite possible" | FY26 |
| Q3 EBITDA margin | 3–4% | Q3 FY25 |
| Q4 EBITDA margin | 12% | Q4 FY25 |
| Volume-value gap | Narrow to 8–10% difference | H2 FY25 |
| Inventory normalisation | Complete heavy cleanup | Maximum two quarters (by Q4 FY25) |
| Debt reduction | Minimum ₹100 crore cut from ₹580 crore base | By March 2025 |
| BCG cost savings | ₹40–50 crore into P&L | FY25, weighted to Q4 |
| Premium portfolio mix | Reach 60% from 54% | Next three to four quarters |
| Bangladesh insurance claim | Full settlement | 8–12 months |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY25 |
|---|---|
| Revenue value growth | Flat YoY |
| Volume growth | 18% YoY; 14.4% for H1 |
| Gross margin | ~45%, down 1,000 bps YoY; up 80 bps sequentially |
| EBITDA margin | ~0% |
| Net result | Loss |
| Q4 FY25 gross margin target | 50% |
| Q4 FY25 EBITDA margin target | 12% |
| Q3 FY25 EBITDA margin expected | 3% to 4% |
| FY26 full-year gross margin target | 55% |
| Market share among three organized players | 40%, up from 36% two quarters ago |
| E-commerce channel share | 45% of revenue |
| General Trade channel share | 11% |
| Modern Trade channel share | 18% |
| E-commerce revenue growth | 54% YoY |
| E-commerce volume growth | 73% YoY |
| Modern Trade volume growth | -8% YoY |
| Institutional revenue growth | 40%+ YoY for Q2 and H1 |
| Overall sale volume | 44 lakh units (0.44 crore) |
| Premium portfolio share | 54%, aim to reach 60% over next three to four quarters |
| Inventory reduced in past six months | ₹174 crore |
| Slow-moving soft luggage inventory value | Less than ₹100 crore as of September, down from ~₹130 crore |
| Inventory liquidation in Q2 | ~₹40 crore |
| Debt level | ~₹500 crore |
| Debt as on March 2024 | ₹580 crore |
| Debt reduction target by March 2025 | Minimum ₹100 crore; ₹35 crore already done |
| Debt target by end FY25 | ~₹400 crore |
| BCG project total benefit to bottom line | ₹250 crore over 15 months |
| BCG benefit expected in P&L this year | ₹40 to ₹50 crore, more in Q4 |
| Bangladesh insurance claim expected in Q3 | ₹5 crore |
| Bangladesh claim full settlement timeline | 8 to 12 months |
| Other expenses in Q2 | ₹190 crore |