Key Takeaways
- A quarter under pressure, as expected: Management called the quarter "not very good" with continuous industry pain, driven by weak retail demand and falling yarn prices that compressed spreads to just $0.55–$0.60.
- Home textile leads a patchy recovery: Home textile utilization has improved materially over the last two months, helped by tourism, destocking completion and orders shifting from Pakistan. Woven fabric is improving, but denim remains stuck at 50–55% utilization.
- Spreads are still falling, and Q2 will be worse: Yarn prices have dropped from $4.50 to $3.10 per pound while cotton costs stay similar, so the spread keeps compressing month-on-month. Management expects Q2 spreads to be even a little lower than Q1.
- The growth engine is idling, not stopped: Two structural concerns (import duty on cotton and MSP) are holding back CAPEX decisions, but management is still open to expansion where demand exists and modernization spending is at its best level.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the fabric utilization improvement holds toward the 90%+ target, any sign that yarn prices have stopped falling, and whether festive-season demand actually materializes.
Demand & Utilization: A Patchwork Recovery
- Spinning running full, but at a cost: Spinning utilization is near full, with exports and domestic sales both active, but margins are under pressure because downstream fabric is not at 100% capacity.
- Home textile turned first: The segment that was first to decline is now first to recover. Utilization is far better than before across both sheeting and towel, driven by tourism recovery, brand restocking after destocking, and order shifts from Pakistan.
- Pakistan advantage may stick: Floods damaged Pakistan's cotton crop and political turmoil continues. Customers want supply-chain stability, so that part of the shift still favors India even as Pakistan's crop recovers.
- Woven fabric climbing back: Industry utilization had dropped to ~70%; Vardhman estimates it is close to 80% now and expects 90%+ within one to one-and-a-half months.
- Knitting improving, denim still deep in trouble: Knitting has moved from a worst of ~50% to 65–70%. Denim remains the weakest link at no more than 50–55% utilization.
- International demand was muted for two quarters: Brands carried excess inventory, feared recession and rising cost of living, and held back on orders expecting commodity prices to fall further.
- Inventory is near normal, but brands are cautious: Most brands' inventory is near long-term normal or even lower, but they are temporarily willing to live with leaner stocks to protect against recession or price falls.
Neeraj Jain: "This quarter as expected has not been very good and there has been a continuous pressure on the textile industry, which started about a couple of months back and I think some pain is still there even as of now also."
Spreads & Margins: The Compression Mechanism
- Spread defined, and why it is falling: Spread is the difference between cotton prices and yarn prices, not the margin on sales. Yarn prices have fallen from $4.50 to $3.10 per pound while cotton cost stays similar, so the spread compresses every month.
- Q2 will be worse than Q1: Management expects Q2 spreads to be even a little lower than Q1 because booked yarn prices keep coming down month-on-month.
- The math of recovery: To make 1 kg of yarn requires ~1.38 kg of cotton, adjusted for wastage sales. Spread will only improve when yarn prices start going up, which requires downstream industry to return to normal utilization.
- No near-term margin improvement visible: As of today's situation, there is no substantial improvement visible in the system. The last 2–4 weeks have seen good fabric demand, so if that continues it could change the picture.
- The $1 spread target: If demand improves worldwide, a spread of $0.90 to $1 can be achieved easily once things normalize, which would bring EBITDA margins back toward the historical 18–20% guidance range.
Neeraj Jain: "When we talk of spreads, we talk of the spread means the difference between the cotton prices and the yarn prices. That's the spread. It is generally talked on the textile or on the spinning side. I'm not saying in terms of spread means the margins on the sales, I was not saying that."
Raw Material & Cotton Dynamics
- Cotton prices finding a floor at MSP: When cotton prices approach Rs. 55,000 per candy (the minimum support price), buyers step in and prices start rising again.
- Crop estimate revised down, but still adequate: Original estimate of 3.3 crore bales has been cut by agencies to maybe not more than 2.9 crore bales; about 3.05 crore bales have already arrived.
- Next year's crop looks good: Sowing is good in most parts of the world; US likely to show better numbers; India sowing and rains are reasonably good. Next year's crop could be in the range of 3.2 to 3.4 crore bales.
- Closing stock likely higher: Overall closing stock of cotton is likely to be higher than this year's closing stock, with a possibility of a small increase in stocks.
- Australia FTA delivered zero advantage: The 50,000-ton duty-free cotton quota was allocated by the Australian government to their shippers, who increased their basis for India. Practically zero benefit flowed through.
CAPEX & Growth: Waiting on Policy
- Two structural concerns blocking decisions: Import duty forces a higher basis for Indian cotton versus international, and minimum support price creates a floor that distorts markets. Management is waiting and watching on both.
- Modernization spending is at its best: Despite the CAPEX hold on major expansion, the modernization, debottlenecking and augmentation budget for the year is one of the best.
- Not saying no to growth: Management is still open to expansion where demand is good or customers want to come in, even with the MSP and import-duty concerns unresolved. It may just take more time to decide.
- Excess spindle capacity is a near-term drag: Last year's expansion was 6.5–7% versus a normal 4–4.5%, adding ~2–2.5% excess capacity. Combined with lower demand, this has created issues. This year, 4–4.5% expansion will still happen as machinery makers deliver on old order books, but new orders are dropping off for next year.
- Maintenance CAPEX revised up: Earlier estimate of Rs. 250 crores per year is now personally felt to be Rs. 350–400 crores for both businesses together, accounting for bottlenecking, obsolescence and improvements.
Neeraj Jain: "I still have two concerns in my mind. One concern is the import duty, which will always force us to have a higher basis for the Indian cotton compared to the international because there you can't import... Second concern comes from the minimum support price."
China Plus One & Trade Policy
- Brand interest in India is real and consistent: Management visited the US 3–4 weeks back and met many big brands. Their thought process on China Plus One is good and consistent; they want to come to India.
- The supply-side risk: The concern is whether India can give brands what they want. If they keep coming, there could be a period of one to two years where things are continuously bad for Indian markets and 7–10% of capacity may go off as the industry restructures.
- Australia FTA benefit is indirect and slow: Australia will buy garments, not yarn or fabric. Advantage will come indirectly when garment exporters start exporting and need good fabric or yarn from Vardhman. That will take time.
- UK FTA timeline unknown: Management has no visibility on when it might conclude.
- MITRA Parks and PLI progress slow: MITRA Parks have been announced but land allocation is not really underway. State government involvement creates delays; land acquisition is not easy and is time-consuming.
- Quality Control Order deferred again: The government has deferred the QCO for another three months and will likely extend it further. Even if ginning mills can implement it, there are not enough labs to test material, and setting them up will probably take more than a year.
Neeraj Jain: "Our concern is if things are better and still India is not doing good because of the challenges we are creating for ourselves, then what happens."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Spinning volume growth | 10% to 15% volume growth possible | FY24 |
| Woven fabric utilization | Reach 90%+ (from ~80% currently) | Within 1–1.5 months |
| Fabric utilization (Q2) | 88% to 90% | Q2 FY24 |
| Fabric utilization (Q3) | 90%+ | Q3 FY24 |
| Spread recovery to normalized level | $0.90 to $1.00 achievable once demand normalizes worldwide | When downstream industry returns to normal utilization |
| EBITDA margin | 18% to 20% if $1 spread is achieved | Conditional on spread recovery |
| Maintenance CAPEX | Rs. 350–400 crores per year (revised up from Rs. 250 crores) | Ongoing annual run-rate |
| Quality Control Order | Deferred by 3 months; likely further 3-month extension; lab infrastructure needs 1+ year | Implementation likely 1+ year away |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | Not stated |
| EBITDA margin | 13%–14% |
| Cotton yarn spread | $0.55–$0.60, comparable to Q4 FY23; Q2 likely comparable or slightly lower |
| Spinning capacity utilization | Almost full |
| Fabric capacity utilization | ~70% in Q1; Q2 expected 88%–90%; Q3 expected 90%+ |
| Knitting capacity utilization | 65%–70%, improved from a worst of ~50% |
| Denim capacity utilization | Not more than 50%–55% |
| Spinning volume growth outlook (FY24) | 10%–15% possible |
| Yarn price (current) | $3.10 per pound, down from ~$4.5 a year ago |
| Cotton price (Indian, current) | ₹59,000–₹60,000 per candy, range during quarter ₹56,000–₹62,000 |
| Indian cotton crop estimate (current year) | 3.15–3.2 crore bales, original estimate ~3.3 crore bales |
| Other income | ₹93 cr, including ~₹47 cr other operating income (of which ~₹20 cr FX gain) and investment income |
| Maintenance capex outlook (annual) | ₹350–₹400 cr, up from earlier thought of ~₹250 cr |
| Spindle capacity added | ~100,000 spindles in March–April 2023 |
| Industry spindle capacity expansion (last year) | 6.5%–7% of installed capacity, vs normal 4%–4.5% |