Key Takeaways
- A uniquely brutal quarter for Indian spinning: Cotton prices above international parity, export volumes down ~70%, and global demand destruction forced pan-India capacity utilization to ~50%, pushing the industry into losses.
- Woven fabric was the lone bright spot: Post-COVID reopening drove woven fabric utilization to ~90%, partially offsetting spinning weakness.
- Management calls the worst over for India: Cotton price alignment with international markets is expected within weeks, which should lift domestic utilization from ~50% toward 75-80%.
- Expansion plans deferred, not abandoned: The 3-year capex plan is delayed 3-6 months to capture lower costs and better pricing; the 65,000-spindle Budhni plant still targets December commissioning.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether cotton price parity actually arrives and triggers the promised utilization recovery, the size of the Q3 inventory valuation hit, and whether brand orders resume once pipeline destocking completes in 3-6 weeks.
The Spinning Crisis: What Happened
- Cotton price dislocation: Indian cotton crop damage limited the harvest to ~2.3 crore bales, and customs duty blocked cheap imports, so Indian cotton traded at a ~2,400-2,500 premium to NY Futures, one of the highest gaps ever. Indian spinners lost all export competitiveness.
- Export volumes collapsed: India lost close to 70% of yarn exports, falling from ~1.1-1.2 crore kg/month to ~3.5-3.7 crore kg/month. Domestic demand could not absorb the diverted supply.
- Capacity utilization halved: Pan-India cotton consumption dropped to ~50% as spindles were stopped or converted to viscose and 100% polyester spun yarn, often at breakeven or small losses. Vardhman stopped 10-12% of capacity and diverted another 8-10% to non-cotton alternates.
- Global demand destruction: High inflation, interest rate increases, and the Ukraine war's gas price shock reduced disposable income in Europe and the US, hitting discretionary textile demand hard. Management estimates a 12-15% drop in worldwide cotton consumption.
- Inventory destocking compounded the pain: Last year, brands over-ordered due to supply chain uncertainty and rising prices. This quarter, supply chains normalized and brands cut orders to burn excess inventory, so even normal demand disappeared for 2-3 months.
- Quality headwinds: Last year's poor cotton crop forced spinners to take losses on realizations or yield to maintain yarn quality.
Jain: "This was a period which was kind of a very unique period where most of the spinning industry, not only in India but I think outside also is suffering as of now."
Where Vardhman Found Shelter
- Woven fabric surge: Post-COVID reopening of markets, offices, and schools created a demand surge for woven fabrics. Vardhman operated its woven fabric division at close to 90% utilization, a meaningful offset to spinning losses.
- Other segments remained weak: Home textiles operated at much lower capacity for the last six months; denim and knitting faced similar conditions.
- Current spreads near breakeven: Most products are at roughly breakeven as of today, with spreads close to about ¢70-75.
The Recovery Thesis: Why Management Says Worst Is Over
- Cotton price alignment imminent: Arrivals of the new crop are expected to pick up within a week, bringing Indian cotton into parity with international prices within 2-4 weeks. Once aligned, Indian spinners' gains or losses will track international markets rather than a domestic premium.
- Utilization should bounce: With raw material costs normalized, management expects stopped spindles (40-50% of idle capacity) to restart within a week or two. India could improve from ~50% utilization to ~75-80%, even if global demand stays subdued.
- Pipeline destocking nearly done: Brands' excess inventory is now almost vanishing; orders should start returning in 3-6 weeks as pipelines have emptied.
- India demand recovery expected: November-December, when cotton prices reach an affordable range and inventory correction is complete, domestic demand may return to a better level, though not yet normal.
- US demand could improve slightly: Demand in coming quarters could be slightly better, especially from the US market. Europe is likely to remain subdued because of energy prices and the war.
- China plus one still intact: The medium-term thesis holds: brands continue to look at India as a serious sourcing alternative. New customer flows from China-plus-one should start materializing from Q4 FY23, given a 3-6 month gestation for certification and sampling.
Jain: "It looks like from that perspective, utilization perspective the worst is over for India."
The Inventory Valuation Risk
- Q3 will carry a one-time inventory loss: Two forces converge: (1) cotton held in inventory will be revalued downward as yarn prices have already adjusted to future needs, and (2) once the new, much cheaper crop arrives, finished goods and WIP inventory will take a valuation hit. Management cannot quantify the impact yet.
- No stocking until alignment: Until Indian cotton prices align with international levels, nobody in the industry will add stock; only day-to-day buying to run existing capacity will occur.
- Stocking strategy undecided: Vardhman will take another 1.5-2 months to decide its cotton stockage policy, depending on quality, commercial future prices, and whether Indian cotton trades at a discount or premium to international.
Capex: Deferred, Not Derailed
- Budhni spinning plant: 65,000 spindles under commissioning, delayed by supply chain issues and electronics/machinery availability. Trial runs expected in the next month; full commissioning targeted by 31 December.
- Vardhman Yarn Cottex plant: 35,000 spindles already fully operational, included in the current 11.6 lakh spindle capacity.
- Broader expansion plan on hold: Management decided to defer expansion plans for a couple of months, then reassess once normalcy returns. The delay is 3-6 months, and the 3-year plan can still be achieved.
- Synthetic capabilities being built: Vardhman is gearing up for more synthetic-based products, especially polyester-cotton, investing in both soft knowledge and assets for synthetic processing.
Jain: "My belief is even if we delay it by 3 to 6 months' time, I'm sure the end times could still be achieved with a much lesser cost, with a better prices also. It's not going to give us any major disadvantage even by deferring that."
Competitive Position & Structural Outlook
- No Chinese dumping risk: Once Indian raw material costs normalize, India will be competitive. There is no concern about Chinese yarn being dumped in India.
- Bangladesh competition: Bangladesh is much more competitive than India in garmenting. If Bangladesh cannot take orders, India cannot take those orders either.
- Global spinning also suffering: Spinning worldwide is running at only about 70% utilization; the crisis is not India-specific.
- Cotton consumption estimate falling: Management's initial assumption of ~2.5 crore tons of cotton consumption this year may come down to ~2.3 crore or less. Cotlook has already dropped its estimate by 6-7% and will keep correcting.
Jain: "One is in the medium term, what I had mentioned earlier, I still have the same belief that all brands who are looking at India as a serious player continues. People want to look at China plus one, that continues. There's no fundamental change from that perspective even today also."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Cotton price alignment | Indian cotton to reach parity with or discount to international prices | Within 2-4 weeks |
| Utilization recovery | India spinning utilization to improve from ~50% to 75-80% | Starting within 1-2 weeks of price alignment |
| Brand order resumption | Pipeline destocking complete, orders to start returning | 3-6 weeks |
| Budhni plant commissioning | 65,000 spindles fully operational | By 31 December |
| Expansion plan deferment | 3-year capex plan delayed | 3-6 months; end targets still achievable |
| China-plus-one order flow | New customer orders to start flowing in | Q4 FY23 (gestation period 3-6 months) |
| Cotton stockage policy decision | Decision on inventory acquisition strategy | 1.5-2 months |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | Not stated |
| Operating margin | Not stated |
| Net profit | Not stated |
| Spinning capacity utilization | ~80% (10%-12% stopped, 8%-10% diverted to non-cotton) |
| Woven fabric capacity utilization | ~90% (process woven), grey weaving at 80%-85% |
| Cotton consumption (India) | ~50,000 bales/day, down from peak of 90,000-95,000 bales/day |
| Yarn exports (India) | 3.5-3.7 crore kg/month, down ~70% from 11-12 crore kg/month |
| Cotton price (international) | ~72 US cents/lb, down ~50% from peak of 140-145 US cents/lb |
| Cotton price (India) | 2,400-2,500 points premium to New York Future, one of the highest |
| Current spreads | ~¢70-75, breaking even |
| Cotton inventory | ~1.5 months as of 30 September, on reduced production base |
| Industry average cotton cost | ₹85,000 to ₹95,000 per candy |
| Total spindle capacity | 11.6 lakh spindles, with 65,000 more expected by 31 December |
| Global spinning capacity utilization | ~70% across China, Vietnam, Pakistan |
| Global cotton consumption estimate | 2.36 crore tons, down 6%-7% from 2.5 crore tons last year |
| Expansion plan deferment | 3 to 6 months |