Key Takeaways
- Flat quarter, no near-term catalyst: Results were in line with or slightly below Q1, with no major improvement in overall numbers. Spinning margins remain under pressure from oversupply and weak demand.
- Fabric is the bright spot, spinning the drag: Woven fabric hit full capacity utilization for the first time, while spinning margins are not improving and the next 1.5-2 months look challenging.
- Demand is normalizing, but pricing power is absent: Brands are buying 75-85% of normal volumes, up from much worse levels, yet yarn prices have been falling for six months and margin improvement is not likely as of now.[13-14]
- The import duty and MSP floor create a structural risk: If New York futures fall to 70 cents, Indian cotton cannot fall below the MSP floor of 86-87 cents and imports are blocked by duty, leaving Indian spinners uncompetitive. Management wants clarity before committing to big expansion. [14-15]
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the festive-season demand pickup in Indian retail materializes in the next 6-8 weeks, and whether fabric utilization stays at 100% long enough to justify capacity expansion.
Demand Environment
- Spinning demand still oversupplied: Yarn demand is not improving and an oversupply situation persists. Margins are not improving at all. Overall spinning utilization in India is estimated at 85-90%, with vulnerable SMEs cutting output while large players run full.
- Fabric demand recovering, led by formalwear: The return to offices is driving woven fabric demand. Vardhman's utilization has been "one of the best" in the last 1-2 months, crossing 90-95% and hitting full capacity for the first time since the line was implemented.
- Casual and denim segments weak: As people move back to offices, demand for informal and casual clothing is lower. Denim and knitting segments are not doing well, and this large segment is putting pressure on the spinning side.
- Geographic demand building: US market demand is building up. UK and European market demand is starting after a long time. Japan is reviving after never reviving since COVID. Indian retail remains subdued but the festive and marriage season was late this year, so demand is expected to pick up in the next 6-8 weeks.
- Inventory normalization complete: International brands had three concerns: inflation, fear of recession, and carried-over inventory. The first two remain, but inventory concern has normalized, with inventories back to near-normal levels barring a few brands.
- Local consumption under pressure: Knitters, denim manufacturers, weavers, and garment makers buying yarn in India and exporting products are seeing a reduction. Indian consumption looks lower.
Jain: "It may take three months more, it may take six months, nine months, 12 months. So that is really not a big concern to us as of now and we are very confident as the things will start improving, we will also start working well."
Segment Performance
| Segment | Trend | Commentary |
|---|---|---|
| Woven Fabric | ▲ Strong | Full capacity utilization for last 1-2 months; trend expected to continue based on orders and visibility. Doing better in both volume and profitability. |
| Home Textiles | ▲ Improving | Running full capacity for last 6 months; demand improving but yarn prices not increasing. |
| Spinning | ▼ Weak | Demand not improving, oversupply persists, margins not improving. Next 1.5-2 months quite challenging. |
| Denim & Knitting | ▼ Weak | Informal and casual clothing demand lower as people return to offices; large segments putting pressure on spinning. |
- Fabric H2 seasonality: H2 is better than H1 for the fabric business, which is largely spring for the international market and primarily cotton-based textiles. Sequentially better numbers are expected.
- Spinning drags overall margins: Fabric capacity utilization is crossing 90-95%, but spinning is still a significant part of the company. Unless spinning improves, overall margins may not improve significantly. [14-15]
Cotton & Raw Material Dynamics
- Last season's distortion: Initial crop estimate was 3.3 crore bales, but arrivals were very low initially as farmers calibrated supply. The entire chain understood imports could not happen due to duty, so cotton kept arriving slowly until September instead of February or March, keeping prices very high. The eventual crop was almost 3.2 crore bales.
- New season concerns: A pinworm attack in some areas may lower crop size. CAI estimates 2.95 crore bales versus consumption of 3.11 crore bales. If closing stock drops to 22-23 lakh bales, managing the entire system could be very difficult. Management still feels the crop is not less than 3.2 crore bales.
- Indian cotton uncompetitive at lower global prices: If New York futures fall to 75 cents, Indian cotton at 86-87 cents would be 1,000-1,200 basis points expensive. Vietnamese mills get contamination-free cotton at 900-1,200 basis points cheaper, a disadvantage for Indian industry.
- The MSP and import duty trap: With MSP at ₹7,020 (₹57,000 per candy, 86-87 cents) and import duty in place, if New York futures go to 70 cents, Indian cotton cannot fall below that floor and imports are blocked. Management sees this as a structural risk to spinning viability. [14-15]
- Cotton inventory at season change: India's cotton season ends September 30. Everyone holds bare minimum quantity, typically not more than 30-40 days in factory. New arrivals have started; the next 2-3 months should allow inventory building.
- Margin improvement not imminent despite lower cotton: Cotton prices have only started coming down in the last 2-3 weeks. Yarn prices have been continuously going down for the last six months. Even with lower cotton prices, margin improvement is not looking likely as of now. [13-14]
Jain: "Since the entire chain understood that the import cannot happen, so they calibrated the entire arrival of cotton and the old cotton kept coming till September against February or March as the farmer was bringing in only what is required on a daily basis, so they never allowed the mills to increase the stock and the prices kept remaining very very high."
Strategic Positioning & Opportunities
- China plus one gaining traction: Brands are increasingly focusing on sourcing from India. Concerns about Chinese cotton entering the supply chain are increasing. Sustainability and traceability practices are in focus. Vardhman has a natural advantage being 100% vertically integrated, with over 90% of yarn consumed for fabrics coming from within Vardhman.
- MMS readiness underway: Vardhman has geared up for blended yarn demand on the spinning side. On the fabric side, it already has good experience with blended and manmade fiber production. For 100% manmade fabrics, it has started evaluating technologies and studying options. As demand grows, it will add equipment for processing manmade fabrics more efficiently.
- Product mix shifting toward blends: As cotton prices keep going up, more brands will move to blended yarns. Vardhman is creating infrastructure and capabilities in segments where demand is increasing, moving its product mix to match.
- Customer-centric pricing models: Vardhman is open to various pricing models including season pricing, deal-to-deal, three-month, six-month, and even nine-month pricing for yarn, fitting into customer business models.
- FTA benefits are medium-term: UAE and Australia FTAs are a big support but benefits will come only in the medium term. These countries will buy only garments; India has to gear up for garmenting and home textiles. Spinners will get indirect demand from Indian counterparts exporting to these countries. Nothing will happen in six months to one year. [18-19]
Jain: "if you lose customer confidence, probably you will lose them forever"
Margins & Cost Structure
- Current margins below 9% are not structural: They are due to very high inflation in the US and Europe, high gas prices, and 5.5% interest rates in the US unseen in 20 years. Demand for textile products is less globally, and most of the textile industry worldwide is passing through the same time.
- Q3 margin outlook flat: Based on today's situation, no major change is likely from the first two quarters. The third quarter is likely aligned with or in line with the second quarter.
- Q4 margin dependency: Will have to wait for the Q4 number depending on how prices and cotton go.
- Spread determined solely by demand and supply: The spread between cotton and cotton yarn is affected only by demand and supply. Management declined to give any range beyond noting that industry talks of $1 as healthy.
- Import duty not the current margin issue: Today's cotton prices show no disadvantage to Indian spinners despite the import duty. The impact today is more from lesser demand. When demand improves, New York futures will also improve, and Indian concerns will not be there.
Capital Allocation & Expansion
- Modernization spend doubling: Instead of ₹150 Cr, Vardhman might spend ₹300 Cr on modernization this year, and maybe a similar amount next year, to create capabilities for better-margin products.
- Typical capex: About ₹300-350 Cr for spinning, about ₹100 Cr for fabric; totality could be ₹350-400 Cr.
- No big capacity expansion in spinning: Not in a bigger way in any case as of now.
- Fabric expansion contingent on sustained demand: Once sustainability of 100% utilization is seen for a couple of months, management will definitely look at expanding that business or adding something on the manmade side. Will wait for the next couple of months to see if demand is sustainable, then take a fresh view.
- Opportunistic acquisition possible: If a very nice plant becomes available at a dirt cheap price, Vardhman is in a position to take risk and take a call.
- Renewable power investment: Entered into an agreement with Renew Power for supply of solar and wind power to its MP unit. Implementation expected in the next 15 to 18 months. Vardhman will hold only 26% equity in the SPV. Exploring opportunities to expand solar and wind power; final view expected in next 2-3 months on whether via SPV or direct investment. [11-12]
Jain: "Tomorrow New York future goes down to 70 cents our cotton will not come down to below that. We will not be in a position to import because of the import duty so which means will be on a very very higher side so our concerns and questions are only that unless there is a clarity because if the import duty is not there then there is no issue."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Q3 margins | No major change likely from Q1 and Q2; Q3 aligned with Q2 | Q3 FY24 |
| Fabric H2 performance | Sequentially better numbers expected vs H1 | H2 FY24 |
| Woven fabric utilization | Full capacity utilization trend expected to continue based on orders and visibility | Near term |
| Indian retail demand pickup | Good demand expected in Indian retail sector | Next 6-8 weeks |
| Modernization capex | ~₹300 Cr (up from ₹150 Cr), similar amount possible next year | FY24 and FY25 |
| Renewable power SPV | Implementation of solar and wind power supply to MP unit | Next 15-18 months |
| Renewable power expansion decision | Final view on further projects, SPV or direct investment [11-12] | Next 2-3 months |
| Fabric expansion decision | Will take fresh view after watching demand sustainability | Next couple of months |
| Cotton quality assessment | Need to wait to assess overall crop, quality, arrivals | Another 2 months |
| Industry cycle normalization | Efficient players will start making good money once situation normalizes | 3 to 12 months |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | Almost in line with Q1 FY24, maybe a little lower |
| Operating margin | Single digit for yarn, mid double digits for fabric |
| Fabric capacity utilization | Crossing 90%, 95%, better than Q1; Q3 expected better than Q2 |
| Spinning industry utilization (India) | 85% to 90% |
| Global yarn industry utilization | Almost same as India |
| Cotton yarn spread realized | Not more than 50 to 60 cents, current spread also the same |
| Healthy spinning industry spread | $1 spread; currently industry working with 50 to 70 cents |
| India yarn exports | ~11-11.5 crore kg per month, back to normal from a low of 3-3.5 crore kg 7-8 months back |
| Indian cotton price | ₹56,500 to ₹57,000 a candy, equivalent to 86-87 US cents |
| New York futures | 80 cents, down from 87-88 cents range |
| Indian cotton premium over NY futures | 300-400 basis points (normal trend) |
| Cotton inventory | Not more than 30-40 days in the factory |
| FY24 modernization capex | ₹300 Cr, up from normal ₹100-140 Cr per year |
| FY24 total capex estimate | ₹350-400 Cr (spinning ₹300-350 Cr, fabric ~₹100 Cr) |
| Renew Power SPV equity stake | 26% held by Vardhman Textiles |