Key Takeaways
- Challenging quarter, structural margin reset: Management called 13-14% EBITDA the "new normal" for Indian spinners, citing a permanent 6-7 US cent cotton cost disadvantage that demand alone cannot fix.
- Fabric is the engine, spinning is the drag: Fabric ran at near-full utilization with strong export order visibility through January, while the spinning industry saw ~0.6 crore spindles permanently shut in two years.
- Raw material policy is the single swing factor: Margins will not improve unless the government removes the 11% cotton import duty or CCI aligns MSP pricing to international markets; management sees no other path.
- CAPEX stays on track but tilts away from spinning: The ~₹2,500 crore program proceeds as planned, but future expansion will favor fabric and manmade textiles if spinning economics stay broken.
- What to watch next quarter: CCI's procurement strategy and pricing in the next 1-1.5 months, any government movement on duty-free cotton imports, and whether New York Futures recover enough to lift yarn realizations.
The Cotton Cost Disadvantage
- Structural gap, not cyclical: Indian cotton trades at a 6-7 US cent discount to American cotton due to contamination and quality issues, but Indian spinners pay import-parity prices that include an 11% duty, creating a permanent cost penalty.
- Two policy asks, no resolution: The industry has asked government to either allow duty-free cotton imports or have CCI price its stocks at a normal markup over New York Futures rather than import parity plus duty. Neither has been granted.
- CCI's near-term role: CCI reduced prices when spinners stopped buying, but its mandate is to minimize losses on MSP operations. The next 1-1.5 months are critical as the new cotton season determines procurement volumes and market pricing.
- Manmade fiber is no escape: India's polyester and viscose prices are much higher than world markets, and BIS registration requirements block imports from most international producers, so a shift toward manmade fiber remains uncompetitive.
Neeraj Jain: "Indian cotton definitely is inferior to US cotton in terms of contamination, etc., and generally it is at a discount of 6 to 7 US cents compared to the American cotton. Since our costs are equal with the interior cotton, that's why we have this disadvantage of 6, 7 US cents per pound in India."
Margin Structure & Outlook
- The new normal: Management stated that 13-14% EBITDA margin is the new normal for Indian spinners given the structural cotton cost disadvantage, and margins will not improve until government policy changes.
- Yarn price headwinds: New York Futures started the quarter near 85 cents but declined to 67-68 cents, dragging yarn prices lower through the period. Yarn prices today are lower than Q1 or early Q2, and the spread for Indian spinners will not exceed 60 US cents.
- Raw material dominance: Raw material cost is ~60% of total cost, making it the overwhelming margin driver. Demand is not the binding constraint; fabric demand is full and export orders are strong.
- Fabric margins superior: Management declined to disclose fabric margins separately but confirmed they are "definitely much better than the average," and fabric's growing share of topline provides a mix benefit.
- Outlook declined: When asked for margin guidance, management called it "very, very speculative" and "very difficult" to comment, noting that cotton inventory is exhausted and fresh buying at new-crop prices has begun.
Neeraj Jain: "Considering the limitations that the industry has been given is what the two major factors of the cotton type, I think this is going to be new norm only."
Neeraj Jain: "If these two things doesn't happen, then in that case, there doesn't seem to be any reason where the market will improve as of now. Unless the yarn demand improves in a big way, which also is not looking possible as of now."
Fabric: The Growth Engine
- Near-full utilization: Most fabric products including printing and yarn-dyed are running at almost full capacity utilization, driven by export demand as major customers have dried up inventories.
- Order visibility strong: US demand is good, with 100% visibility of orders through January and even further. The domestic market has just passed the festive season and is awaiting customer response. [17-18]
- Brand business shift: The company is moving toward more brand business, which can deliver better margins but requires more robust shop loading to meet shorter delivery times. End products go to Europe and the US, with garmenting done across Asian countries.
- Manmade fabric initiative: A new manmade fabric initiative will increase fabric's share of topline relative to spinning. A 100% manmade fabric project targeting technical textiles aims to be operational around September-October next year.
- Capacity expansion underway: Solid-dyed fabric capacity expanding by 20%, yarn-dyed by around 20%, both operational in the next 14 months. A new digital print machine has just been added.
- Fabric share trajectory: Fabric currently ~35% of topline; management expects this share to continue growing as spinning expansion stays low if spinning economics do not improve.
Neeraj Jain: "I think personally, the share of fabric in the overall topline will continue to grow from today's level as well."
Spinning Industry Stress
- Capacity destruction: Industry estimates ~0.6 crore spindles have stopped permanently in the last two years, with another ~0.3 crore running on job-work or marginal basis that may not survive unless conditions improve.
- Organized players bifurcating: Most organized players are doing well on the fabric side, particularly knitted fabric, while unorganized spinners bear the brunt of the downturn.
- Knitted fabric import surge: Manmade-based fabric imports have surged from 50-70 tons per day three years ago to more than 1,000 tons per day, because Indian raw materials including fibers and yarn are expensive relative to global alternatives.
- Advanced authorization limitations: Even under the export-focused advanced authorization scheme, freight costs add a disadvantage versus China, Vietnam, and Korea. For domestic market sales, the scheme cannot work due to different duty structures and incentives. [13-14]
Garmenting: Structural Uncompetitiveness
- Labor cost doubles Bangladesh: Indian garment labor cost at $230-$240 per month is double Bangladesh's $120, and labor represents ~22-25% of garmenting cost in India versus ~10-11% in Bangladesh.
- Labor availability worsening: Migrant labor is neither available nor stable. Social schemes including MGNREGA and Ayushman Bharat make people prefer staying in villages, reducing willingness to migrate to cities for factory work.
- State subsidies ineffective: State labor subsidies of Rs. 5,000 per month target local laborers who are either unavailable or untrained. Companies bringing workers from outside do not qualify, and even central PF subsidies for two years do not change the economics. [12-13]
- No big garmenting push: The company's small garment unit is expanding from 6,000 to 10,000 shirts per day and runs profitably, but management may take another 1-2 years to decide on a large-scale expansion. Textile material production and garmenting are "two different businesses."
- Domestic market unprotected: Brands in India have started importing garments from Bangladesh due to insufficient tariff protection for domestic garment manufacturing.
Neeraj Jain: "In the garmenting industry, the overall labor cost is always in the range of about 22% to 25% and the cost is double. We are talking about the Bangladesh cost are in the range of about maybe 10% to 11% of garmenting, we will be at (+20%). So, we will never be competitive even on the debt cost also, because our labor cost is going to be very, very expensive."
Sustainability & Recycling
- Recycling line running full: The company's first recycling line of 6 tons per day is running at full capacity, and a second line of another 6 tons per day has been ordered. The product is well established and accepted by multiple good brands.
- European regulation as tailwind: Europe has passed a law effective 2025 banning landfilling of garments, mandating recycling. Western recycling capacity is increasing exponentially, though this trend has not yet reached India and China.
- Demand displacement risk: Recycling of used garments in the Western world may reduce demand for virgin textile production as older garments are resold in Europe and the US. Growth that was earlier expected may not continue until the first recycling cycle completes.
- Green energy push from brands: The company targets moving from 4-5% green energy to at least 25% in two years, possibly crossing 40% in 2-3 years. This is driven by brand requirements, not purely ROCE considerations: customers do not want coal or conventional electricity in the supply chain.
Neeraj Jain: "First of all, all these thoughts which we are having is not purely from the ROCE perspective. I think most of the customers or most of the brands are talking to us about the green energy where they do not want us to consume coal, they do not want us to use the conventional electricity... So, these issues basically coming from the brands where they are pushing or they are suggesting us to do this."
CAPEX & Capacity Expansion
- ₹2,500 crore program on track: Total CAPEX announced for this financial year and next is proceeding as planned, with most expected to complete by the March-to-June quarter next year.
- Fabric-led expansion: Solid-dyed and yarn-dyed capacities each expanding ~20%, operational in the next 14 months. A digital print machine has been added.
- Technical textiles entry: A 100% manmade fabric project targeting technical textiles aims to be operational around September-October next year. Management sees potential for 25-30% margins in some technical textile replacement segments, though base polyester segments may earn average margins. [15-16]
- Spinning expansion contingent: If the spinning situation does not improve, expansion on the spinning side may be low; growth will continue on the fabric side instead.
- Volume guidance declined: When asked how much volume the CAPEX would add at full utilization, management deflected: "Our efforts are for the same. Let's see how the market goes."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Fabric capacity expansion | Solid-dyed +20%, yarn-dyed +20% | Operational in next 14 months |
| Technical textiles project | 100% manmade fabric facility | Operational around Sep-Oct next year |
| CAPEX completion | Most of ~₹2,500 crore program | Complete by Mar-Jun quarter next year |
| Green energy share | Move from 4-5% to at least 25%, possibly 40% | Next 2-3 years |
| Recycling capacity | Second line of 6 tons/day ordered | No timeline given |
| Garmenting capacity | Expand from 6,000 to 10,000 shirts/day | No timeline given |
| Margin improvement | Conditional on government removing cotton import duty or CCI aligning MSP to international prices | No timeline; "not looking possible as of now" |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY25 |
|---|---|
| Revenue split (spinning vs fabric) | 65:35 in favor of spinning |
| Raw material cost as % of total cost | ~60% |
| Yarn-cotton spread | ~60 US cents, down from 75-80 US cents in Q1 |
| New York cotton futures | ~70-72 US cents, down from ~85 US cents at start of quarter |
| Indian cotton price | 84-85 US cents, comparable to American cotton delivered to Vietnam/Indonesia |
| Indian cotton premium over NY futures | 1,200-1,400 basis points, historically 4-5 cents |
| Total CAPEX plan | ~₹2,500 cr to be executed over FY25 and FY26 |
| Net cash on balance sheet | ~₹2,300 cr, debt ~₹1,000 cr |
| Fabric capacity utilization | Near full across most products including print, yarn dyed, solid dyed |
| Fabric capacity expansion (solid dyed, yarn dyed) | ~20% each, operational in next 14 months |
| Technical textiles project, Phase 1 capacity | 15 lakh meters per month, operational by Sep-Oct 2025 |
| Technical textiles projected PBDIT margin | 25-30% |
| Recycling line capacity | 6 tons per day running full, second line of 6 tons per day ordered |
| Green energy share of total energy | ~5%, target at least 25% in next 2 years |
| Indian spinning industry spindles permanently stopped | >0.6 crore, with another ~0.25-0.3 crore on job or marginal basis |