Key Takeaways
- Margin recovery stalled by structural cotton costs: EBITDA margin stayed flat QoQ at ~13% because the company is still working through cotton bought at ₹53,000-₹54,000 a candy, while Indian raw material costs run 12 US cents above international parity.
- Spinning industry in a capacity reset: An estimated 0.6-0.65 crore spindles (~15% of India's capacity) have permanently stopped, and no expansion is happening, but the remaining players still are not making money.
- Fabric is the bright spot: The fabric division is running at full utilization with strong profitability, and a new cotton-focused production line is due by September.
- ₹3,400 cr CAPEX is on track, but one project is stuck: Work on ~₹2,800 cr is proceeding as scheduled for completion by November-December, while a ₹400-₹500 cr open-end project awaits government approvals.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether New York Futures moves toward 74-75 US cents, any budget action on the 11% cotton import duty, and the pace of CCI's cotton procurement, which has already absorbed 45% of market arrivals.
Margin Structure & the Cotton Disadvantage
- Q3 margin walk: Cotton cost was unchanged from Q2 at ₹53,000-₹54,000 a candy because inventory was bought a year back, so the better spot spreads did not flow through. Yarn prices also softened during the quarter, offsetting any benefit.
- Q4 outlook flat: No change in raw material cost is expected over the next three months versus the last six, so no major margin improvement is likely unless New York Futures rises or yarn prices recover.
- The structural gap: Indian cotton costs 12 US cents more than New York Futures (80 vs 67-68 US cents), which is why Vietnamese spinners are still making money while Indian mills struggle. Three factors have turned against Indian spinning since pre-COVID: NYF fell from 75-80 cents to 68 cents, MSP rose 18%-20% over three years, and an 11% import duty imposed in 2021 blocks cheaper imports.
- Synthetic yarn is no escape: Polyester and viscose imports are blocked because the government is not registering overseas factories for BIS approval, so Indian prices run 10%-15% above Vietnam or China, making Vardhman uncompetitive on blended yarn exports too.
- Cotton yarn spread: The Q3 spread was about 70 US cents per kg, similar to Q2. The benchmark 321 spread used to be about $1; at that level the company would make enough to expand spinning capacity.
Neeraj Jain: "The situation will not improve by demand and supply only till the time our raw material prices comes down to normal. And this is the reason our margins are low. The moment our raw material price comes in line with international markets, I think the margins would improve immediately after that."
CAPEX Programme
- Total envelope: ~₹3,400 cr announced across multiple projects. Work on ~₹2,800 cr is proceeding on schedule, with completion expected by November-December this calendar year.
- One project on hold: An open-end project of ~₹400-₹500 cr is awaiting government approvals and is not moving forward until those come through.
- Breakdown of active projects: Normal CAPEX of ₹850 cr (completion by June), ₹350 cr synthetic filament, ₹600 cr green power, ₹400 cr fabric processing fourth line, and another ₹400 cr, all expected within this calendar year. The remaining ₹2,800 cr (excluding the open-end project) within 8 to 10 months.
- Fabric expansion: A new cotton-focused production line is planned for the fabric plant, expected around September.
- Modernization CAPEX disclosed: Normal maintenance CAPEX runs ~₹150 cr per year; this year's ₹1,200 cr for yarn and fabric modernization was large enough to warrant a stock exchange disclosure.
- Future spinning CAPEX limited: Going forward, normal or replacement CAPEX in spinning should not exceed ₹150-₹200 cr per year.
- Revenue contribution: Only the 4.5-4.6 crore meter fabric capacity expansion will add topline, at ~₹150 per meter. Spinning and green power projects do not increase revenue.
Demand, Supply & Industry Structure
- Demand is okay, supply is shrinking: Overall demand is steady both internationally and domestically. On the supply side, an estimated 0.6-0.65 crore spindles have permanently stopped in India, roughly 15% of total capacity, which is helping the demand-supply balance.
- No expansion, no modernization: Machinery manufacturers are running at 40%-50% utilization. Most of the spinning sector is not modernizing, and no new capacity is being added.
- Export volumes holding, margins hurting: Indian yarn exports are steady at ~10 crore kg per month with no reduction in volume, but margins remain under pressure.
- Bangladesh is not a demand problem: Bangladesh conditions are okay; there is no reduction in Indian yarn flowing there, and Vardhman is running full capacities.
- Bangladesh as a competitor: Bangladesh's garment exports have reached $40-42 billion versus India's $15 billion, driven by duty-free EU access and a $100 labour cost advantage (India: $200). Management sees Bangladesh potentially reaching $75-80 billion in 5-6 years. If the situation there deteriorates, India could participate, but that is not visible now.
Neeraj Jain: "So, I think as of now, there seems to be a concern till the time the government decides on the basic raw materials."
Cotton Crop & Procurement
- Crop size stable: Cotton cultivation area fell 7-8% last year, but favourable weather kept the crop comparable at ~3.1 crore bales.
- CCI is the market: Prices are below MSP, but farmers are insulated because CCI is buying. Out of 1.7 crore bales that have come to market, 45% (0.75 crore bales) has been procured by CCI, signalling the market is unwilling to buy at these prices.
- Vardhman's buying: The company has started buying slowly from the October-November season and expects to be close to its typical 6-7 month inventory position by 31st March.
Fabric & Synthetic Diversification
- Fabric division performing strongly: The fabric business is doing very well on both utilization and profitability, and the company is expanding capacity despite the difficult spinning environment.
- Synthetic project raw material strategy: The company plans to source from both local and import bases, exploring Taiwan, China, Korea, and Japan, while also working with domestic players to develop products that may not be available locally.
- Synthetic product focus: Woven synthetics will target outerwear (jackets, wind sheeters) for a mix of domestic and export markets.
- Synthetic margin potential: Technical textiles can deliver margins of 25%, 30%, even 35%, but it will take time to learn, develop products, and create the market. Basic synthetic products would likely carry margins in line with the existing fabric apparel business.
Neeraj Jain: "On the technical textiles, definitely margins can be 25%, 30%, 35% as well, but it will take us some time to learn it, develop it, create the market for that and it's only beyond that."
Margin Recovery Path
- Four levers for cotton yarn spread improvement: (1) New York Futures rising to 74-75 US cents; (2) rupee strengthening below ₹90 and cotton prices falling in US cent terms; (3) government allowing duty-free cotton imports; (4) overall demand improving materially. Management sees a 500-600 bps improvement in NYF as the most doable near-term trigger.
- CAPEX-driven margin lift: Modernization CAPEX is expected to improve EBITDA by 2%-3%, with margins moving from the current ~13% to ~15% by FY27. The 200 bps from replacement is "surely possible," but market forces could make the outcome better or worse.
- Timeline: Margin improvement should start in FY27.
Neeraj Jain: "Prerna, that's a guess. I can't really comment on that what would happen with the market forces... 200 is surely possible. But what will happen to the market? We can't really comment on that. It can be better; it can be worse also. So, that's beyond our control."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| CAPEX completion (active projects) | ~₹2,800 cr of projects completed | November-December 2025 |
| Normal CAPEX completion | ₹850 cr (yarn, fabric modernization) | June 2025 |
| Fabric expansion line | New cotton-focused production line | September 2025 |
| Cotton inventory | Close to 6-7 month stock position | 31 March 2025 |
| EBITDA margin improvement | From ~13% to ~15% | FY27 |
| Future spinning CAPEX | Normal/replacement not exceeding ₹150-₹200 cr per year | Ongoing from FY27 |
| Open-end project | ₹400-₹500 cr project | On hold pending government approval |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY25 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | Not stated |
| Standalone EBITDA margin | ~13% (per an analyst's math) |
| Cotton yarn spread | ~70 US cents per Kg, comparable to Q2 |
| Yarn realization | ~$3 per Kg, down from ~$3.25 six months ago |
| Fabric capacity utilization | ~100% |
| Total CAPEX announced | ~₹3,400 crores |
| Ongoing CAPEX | ~₹2,800 crores, expected completion within calendar year 2025 |
| CAPEX on hold (pending govt approval) | ~₹400-500 crores |
| Fabric capacity addition (weaving) | 3.1 crore meters per annum (cotton line) |
| Fabric capacity addition (synthetic) | 1.5 crore meters per annum |
| Indian cotton price | ₹54,000 a candy, equivalent to 80 US cents |
| Company's average cotton cost | ₹53,000-₹54,000 a candy, similar to last season |
| New York Futures | 67-68 US cents per pound |
| Indian yarn exports (country level) | ~10 crore Kg per month, no reduction |
| CCI cotton procurement (season to date) | 0.75 crore bales, 45% of 1.7 crore bales arrived |
| India cotton crop estimate (current season) | 2.98-3.1 crore bales, comparable to last year |