Key Takeaways
- Acquisition quality over quantity: Customer additions fell to 2.28 lakh from 3.59 lakh QoQ, a deliberate pivot to chase only customers with fast payback periods while overall market participation stayed subdued.
- Cost discipline drove profit surge: A 10% QoQ cost reduction lifted PBT 68% QoQ and PAT margins from 5% to 9%, even as total income dropped 5% on weaker exchange turnover.
- Derivatives share is rising structurally: Derivative turnover grew >11% QoQ, nudging market share to 3.14%, while the revenue mix shifted from ~55% to ~60% derivatives YoY as cash turnover kept declining.
- Fixed-cost investment cycle is largely done: Hiring for product and technology, infrastructure upgrades, and the data center build-out are "more or less done," so incremental fixed costs should stabilize from here.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether customer acquisition cost retreats from the Q1 spike of ₹895 as management promises, and whether the fixed-cost-to-income ratio begins its promised decline.
Customer Acquisition: Quality Over Volume
- The deliberate pullback: Acquisitions fell to 2.28 lakh from 3.59 lakh in Q4 and 4.05 lakh in Q3 because management made a conscious call over the last two quarters to improve customer quality, retracting spend when payback periods or customer profiles were unsatisfactory. Muted overall market participation contributed but was not the sole driver.
- Quality defined by payback: A good-quality customer is one where the cost to acquire is recovered fast against internal standards; if the recovery period stretches too long, the customer is deemed bad quality and acquisition spend is pulled.
- Revenue resilience validates the strategy: Despite acquisitions falling from ~4 lakh to 2.2 lakh, the revenue impact was muted, which management says proves the focus is on customers who translate into revenue.
- No downward trend expected: Management does not see acquisitions falling further from the Q1 level of 2.28 lakh, though it declined to put a number on upside growth.
- Channel economics undisclosed: Management declined to share channel-wise acquisition data, payback periods by channel, or which sub-source delivers the best revenue per customer, calling such comparisons difficult.
Gagdani: "It will be difficult right now for me to put a number, but obviously, the focus is on quality, so we know if we get a good quality customer, with even double the run rate, we will definitely chase that."
Customer Acquisition Cost: The Q1 Spike
- The headline move: Cost per acquired customer rose to ₹895 from ~₹768 QoQ, an increase of ₹130–140 that management characterized as a "one-time blip."
- Fixed cost spread over fewer acquisitions: HR and OPEX in the acquisition department rose from ₹196 to ₹250 per customer because the cost base is largely fixed and was spread over a smaller acquisition volume.
- Paid media mix shifted up: The share of paid media channels (Google, social media) increased in the mix; these are higher-cost but deliver better-quality customers, adding to the per-customer cost.
- The promised reversal: Management is targeting a reduction in the HR/OPEX component from ₹250 back to ₹196 or lower over the next two to three quarters, and is confident the overall CAC spike will reverse in subsequent quarters.
Gagdani: "I see that the acquisition cost will come down over next two to three quarters because obviously on the HR and OPEX costs, we're taking steps to improve and bring down from Rs.250 which is right now to Rs 196, which was there earlier and even reduce it further."
Revenue & Market Structure
- Total income dipped 5% QoQ: The decline was driven by a fall in exchange turnover and muted retail participation, particularly in the retail cash market where NSE turnover fell 14% QoQ.
- Brokerage income tracked order volumes: Brokerage income declined ~4% QoQ, directly correlated to a ~4% decline in the number of orders processed, attributed to market sentiment and the cash market downturn.
- Cash-to-derivatives shift is structural: After the 100% implementation of upfront and peak margin rules, trading volumes moved from cash to derivatives, especially options. Delivery volume now predominates in the cash segment.
- Derivatives market share inched up: Derivative turnover grew >11% QoQ versus the exchange's ~10% growth, lifting market share from 3% to 3.14%.
- Revenue mix reflects the shift: The derivatives share of revenue moved from ~55% to ~60% YoY, with cash (intraday plus delivery) at ~40%.
- Cash market share held steady: At ~3%, the company maintained its position despite the broader cash market downturn.
- Margin funding book flat: The book remained almost flat at ₹316 crores versus ₹322 crores QoQ because of the adverse market environment.
- Cross-sell revenue dipped: Cross-sell revenue declined from ₹5.93 crore to ~₹5.1 crore QoQ because subscription income (the largest cross-sell product) and other products like mutual funds, digital gold, and insurance are tied to market conditions; a bounce-back is expected with market recovery.
Gagdani: "So, after 100% implementation, typically the trading volumes have moved from cash segment to derivative segment, especially in the options part of it."
Cost Structure & Margin Path
- The Q1 cost reset: Overall costs dropped 10% QoQ because of optimization efforts, which had a direct positive impact on PBT.
- Other expenses broke down: The sharp decline was driven by a ~₹1.5 crore fall in professional expenses (CDSL/NSDL costs tied to lower acquisition volume) and a ~₹1.2 crore fall in IT costs due to optimization.
- IT cost reduction is sustainable: Management expects only a 5% to 10% increase in IT costs over a year and does not see costs jumping back up soon.
- Staff cost growth contained: Staff cost growth is expected to be broadly in the range of 5% to 10% for FY23.
- Fixed cost to income ratio rose: The ratio increased QoQ because of prior investments in hiring product and technology talent, upgrading infrastructure, and software costs, compounded by the 5% revenue dip. Management expects this ratio to reduce over the next two to three quarters.
- The target cost structure: Management's ultimate target is a 50% fixed cost, 25% PBT, and 25% variable cost ratio.
- PBT margin ambition: Management is on a path to move from a 12% PBT margin to a 25% PBT margin, though the timeline is open-ended: it could take two quarters or three to four quarters, with achievement expected in the "next foreseeable future."
Gagdani: "on the fixed cost side, we will not see much increase from here on, it will stabilize"
Product & Infrastructure Build-Out
- Investment cycle largely complete: The investment in building infrastructure, technology, and hiring tech and digital talent is almost done; the incremental impact on fixed costs from product, infrastructure, and technology will now be less.
- Digital onboarding at 85% straight-through: 85% of customers are now onboarded digitally without any intervention, completing account opening in a single flow, a result of completed technology investments post-fundraise.
- Derivative terminal in development: The company is building an entire derivative-based terminal to provide information for traders.
- FinTech partnerships executed: Partnerships have been signed with FinTech players providing research, advisory, or algos for traders.
- New mobile app version launched: A new version of the mobile app was released with features added for trader simplicity.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Customer acquisition cost reduction | HR/OPEX component to reduce from ₹250 to ₹196 or lower | Next 2–3 quarters |
| Fixed cost to income ratio | Ratio to reduce from current elevated level | Next 2–3 quarters |
| Customer acquisition floor | No downward trend or degrowth expected from Q1 level of 2.28 lakh | Ongoing from Q2 FY23 |
| Incremental fixed cost stabilization | No material increase in fixed costs from here onward | Immediate |
| IT cost growth | Only 5–10% increase over a year | FY23 |
| Staff cost growth | Broadly 5–10% range | FY23 |
| PBT margin target | Move from 12% to 25% PBT margin | "Next foreseeable future" (2–4 quarters) |
| Cross-sell revenue recovery | Bounce back expected | When market recovers |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Total income | Down 5% QoQ, driven by fall in exchange turnover and muted retail participation |
| PBT | Up 68% QoQ, highest ever, driven by cost optimization |
| PAT margin | 9%, improved from 5% QoQ |
| Brokerage income | Down ~4% QoQ, reflecting a similar decline in number of orders processed |
| Revenue mix (derivatives:cash) | 60:40, compared to ~55:45 in Q1 FY22 |
| Cross-sell revenue | ~₹5.1 cr, down from ₹5.93 cr QoQ, a drop of ₹70–75 lakh |
| Total customer base | ~29.6 lakh, with 2.28 lakh customers acquired in Q1 |
| Customer acquisition cost (CAC) | ₹895, up from ₹768 QoQ; increase of ~₹130–140 |
| Cash market share | ~3%, stable for the last two quarters |
| Derivatives market share | 3.14%, improved from 3% QoQ |
| Margin funding book | ₹316 cr, almost flat vs ₹322 cr QoQ |
| Cash ADTO | ~₹800 cr, down from ~₹950 cr QoQ |
| Derivatives ADTO | ~₹1.3 lakh cr, up from ~₹1.2 lakh cr QoQ |
| Straight-through processing (digital onboarding) | 85% of customers onboarded digitally without intervention |
| Cost optimization | Total cost down 10% QoQ; other expenses declined by ~₹3 cr (₹1.5 cr from lower CDSL/NSDL costs, ₹1.2 cr from IT cost optimization) |