5paisa Capital Ltd Q3 FY2023 Concall Summary

Source transcript PDF: https://assets.stockscans.in/docs/qmjbljxj0i3k953v8q5z4f8x.pdf

Key Takeaways


Revenue Stagnation & the Quality Pivot

Gagdani: "We realized that acquisition, just for the sake of acquisition is not enough because a lot of customers are not trading, so we changed gears. Now whenever you change your gear from a very high acquisition trajectory to a low acquisition trajectory, it has an impact on your revenue."

IIFL Securities Online Retail Business Acquisition


Customer Metrics & the Active-Client Debate

Gagdani: "I feel that the active client was anyways not a great matrix to see, because that's the only industry data which is publicly available, it's obvious that we draw reference to that, but I think it is not a right number to look at. What we should look at is the income growth, the turnover growth and the profitability growth."

Unit Economics & Margin Trajectory

Gagdani: "Digital businesses across always command a high PBT margin in a steady state... my target for the foreseeable future is to be in the range of around 35% to 40% PBT margin."

Product & Platform Build-Out


Brokerage Rate Outlook & Competitive Dynamics

Gagdani: "The kind of regulatory changes that we are seeing is pushing cost of operating business higher with every quarter. Now with the changes, I see that the rates for the discount brokers, at some point will definitely increase. Whether it will happen in the next 2 quarters or maybe by the end of next year, that's something that we need to see."

Guidance & Commitments

CommitmentSpecificsTimeline
Customer acquisition run rate1.5–2.5 lakh accounts per quarter, or 7.5–8 lakh to ~0.1 crore annually (excluding IIFL Securities acquisition)Ongoing quarterly
CAC range₹500–₹600 per clientComing quarters
Payback period targetReduce to 5–6 months, driven by customer quality and revenue improvementNo date (internal target)
PBT margin targetSteady-state 35–40%4–5 quarters
Active-client metric stabilizationStabilize and then increase as statistical base effect normalizes2–3 months
IIFL Securities acquisition effective date1st April 2023Subject to regulatory approvals (8–12 months from filing)
IIFL Securities acquisition income impact18–20% income growth, high translation to profitability given existing infrastructure capacityPost-acquisition close
Margin penalty reversalWill not recur; one-time itemFrom Q4 FY23 onward
Brokerage rate increase“Very high chance” of upward move; magnitude uncertain, depends on regulatory changesNext 2 quarters to end of next year (conditional)

Key Metrics

MetricQ3 FY23
Revenue₹83.8 cr, +4% QoQ
9M FY23 Revenue₹248 cr, +18% YoY
PAT₹11 cr, +3% QoQ
9M FY23 PAT₹29.1 cr, +213% YoY
Profit margin13%
Adjusted PBT margin26%, excluding one-time margin penalty reversal of ₹7.09 cr
One-time expense (margin penalty reversal)₹7.09 cr, refund of penalties from Oct '21 to Sep '22
ADTO₹2.05 lakh cr, +21% QoQ from ₹1.69 lakh cr
Derivative market share3.2%, up from 3.1–3.14% QoQ
Cash market share2.7–2.8%
Customer base~33 lakh
NSE active customers~10.75–11 lakh
Customer acquisition1.62 lakh in Q3; run-rate expected 1.5–2.5 lakh per quarter
CAC₹525, down from ₹574 QoQ; expected range ₹500–₹600
Payback period7–7.5 months, improved from 8–9 months
Marketing costs₹11.6 cr, down from ₹12.2 cr QoQ
Branding expenditure₹7.5 cr, up from ₹4.3 cr QoQ
Allied broking income₹27 cr; MTF income ₹15.3 cr, up from ₹13.3 cr QoQ
Client funding book (average)₹280 cr, up from ₹246 cr QoQ
Other operating income₹15.8 cr; ~90% is interest income on float
Employee count700–725
Employee cost₹14.9 cr, flat vs ₹14.6 cr QoQ
Cash turnover decline3–4% QoQ
Revenue mix (derivatives vs cash)65–70% from derivatives, balance from cash
Active-to-gross-client ratio~33%, declined from ~60% over last couple of quarters
IIFL Securities acquisition: customer addition~0.15 cr, boosting base by ~40%
IIFL Securities acquisition: expected revenue growth18–20%
IIFL Securities acquisition: deal structureAll-equity, 50:1 share ratio; ~60 lakh shares to be issued
Promoter shareholding post-acquisition32.45%, decline of 0.24% from 32.69%