Key Takeaways
- Consumption slowdown hit hard: Discretionary demand weakened post-festive and continued through Q1, compressing EBITDA via subdued sales, high fixed costs, and accelerated marketing investments.
- Pantaloons bore the brunt: The value segment saw the first and deepest slowdown, especially in lower-tier towns, with margins squeezed by adverse operating leverage on a large fixed-cost network.
- Premium resilience cracked: The premium end, resilient for 12-18 months, began to soften this quarter, compounded by fewer wedding dates that hurt the ethnic and designer portfolio.
- TMRW and acquisitions weigh on debt: Consolidated margin was further lowered by aggressive growth investment in subsidiaries, mainly TMRW, and debt rose to INR2,000 cr, with a year-end target of INR2,800 cr after the TCNS stake purchase.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the promised H2 demand recovery materializes after the delayed festive period, the pace of Pantaloons’ margin improvement, and any concrete turnaround plan for TCNS once the acquisition closes.
Demand Environment
- Broad-based slowdown: The consumption slowdown in discretionary categories that started post-festive last year persisted, affecting both value and, increasingly, premium segments.
- Value segment deepened: The challenge in the value segment, first observed in lower-tier towns, has deepened over the last couple of quarters, impacting Pantaloons and Forever 21.
- Premium insulation cracked: After 12-18 months of resilience, the premium end is no longer fully insulated, with muted growth in Lifestyle brands linked partly to a shift in wedding dates.
- Athleisure correction: The athleisure part of the innerwear business, after 2-2.5 years of rapid growth from work-from-home, is showing a slowdown in the last 2-3 quarters, causing excess inventory.
- Wholesale a bright spot: Wholesale business continued to grow, driven by a lower base recovery in department stores last year, Centro coming back into business, and space additions.
Ashish Dikshit: "So there is 2 parts to the question. When do we expect the demand to recover I think definitely not before the festival period. The extent of recovery after that will be both a function of -- because this time, as you know, the festivals have also got pushed a little bit later into the year."
Pantaloons: Pressure & Strategy
- Dual hit to margins: Pantaloons’ margin was affected by lower sales creating adverse operating leverage on a large, largely fixed-cost network, and by yarn price increases that impacted the entire industry’s private label pricing.
- Price-value equation improving: With yarn prices settling down, private label prices have been corrected, improving the price-value equation, though management clarified this was not a material wholesale price reduction.
- Sequential margin improvement: Margins improved from Q4 to Q1, reflecting a large part of cost-saving efforts, but management noted a limitation to how much costs can be brought down given the high fixed rental base.
- Expansion moderating: Store expansion will moderate from 63 new stores last year to an indicated 35-40 stores this year, as management does not want to dramatically alter long-term lease projects for one quarter’s performance.
- Strategy confidence intact: Management expressed confidence in the private label strategy, citing strong consumer feedback and good margins in FY20 and the first nine months of FY23 before the post-Diwali slowdown.
Sangeeta Pendurkar: "I think we feel very confident of our strategy and our proposition. Private label portfolio continues to improve significantly. I think we hear that feedback from consumers all the time."
Portfolio Health: Brands & Segments
| Business | Trend | Commentary |
|---|---|---|
| Lifestyle Brands | ▬ Margin improved | Margins improved despite negative LTL, driven by cost reduction initiatives and preparation for a quarter with fewer wedding dates. |
| Pantaloons | ▼ Underperformance | Value-segment slowdown and yarn price impact; margin improvement from Q4 driven by cost savings. |
| Ethnic Wear (incl. Tasva) | ▼ Losses | Compounded by fewer wedding dates; Sabyasachi’s largest Mumbai store launch carried a one-time large marketing investment. |
| Innerwear | ▼ Loss-making | Further from profitability; price increases taken last year affected premium-end demand; suitable price adjustments now happening. |
| Forever 21 | ▼ Loss-making | Has not reached profitability and is affected by the value end of the market. |
| Reebok | ▲ Breakeven | Fully integrated and just at breakeven; expected to become profitable on a full-year basis going forward. |
| Wholesale | ▲ Growth | Continued to grow on lower base recovery, Centro’s return, and space additions in department stores. |
- Innerwear gross margin recovery expected: Gross margin shrunk in the previous year primarily due to higher raw material prices; margins are expected to come back going forward.
- Innerwear scale: Management stated the business is about INR500 crores in sales last year, positioning it as the only other player besides the market leader at the premium end.
Ashish Dikshit: "As a large player in the premium market, we are the only other player other than the market leader, which is more than INR500 crores of sales at the premium end of the market. And remember, we are even more premium on an average than any other player in the segment."
Strategic Initiatives & Investments
- TCNS acquisition on track: The board-approved acquisition of a 51% stake in TCNS Clothing is under progress; the company received regulatory approvals and is commencing the open offer. Management declined to discuss turnaround plans, calling it premature.
- TMRW investment and losses: Half of the committed investment has been consumed so far, with the entire amount factored into the closing debt number; full-year losses for TMRW are expected in the range of INR80-100 crores.
- TMRW fund raise on agenda: Management will look at a fund raise towards the end of the year or around that time.
- Style Up concept scaling: A new value-segment proposition with 15-16 compact stores currently, targeting 30-35 stores by year-end.
- Luxury partnership: A new company was incorporated for a partnership with Christian Louboutin, part of the broader Galeries Lafayette project, with INR5 crores initial capital.
Costs, Debt & Balance Sheet
- Debt increase drivers: The difference between opening debt of INR1,420 cr and quarter-end debt of INR2,000 cr went into capex, a small part into working capital, and to some extent losses for the quarter.
- FY24 closing debt target: INR2,800 crores, after considering payments for the 51% stake in TCNS.
- Depreciation to stay elevated: The increase is a function of new store additions, capitalization, and Ind AS treatment of stores as owned; it will continue in this range or increase, as the first half of a store’s 5-year life is heavy on depreciation.
- Marketing investments accelerated: EBITDA was impacted by accelerated marketing investments, including a one-time large investment for the Sabyasachi Mumbai store launch.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Demand recovery | Recovery not before the delayed festive period; extent of recovery a function of festival timing. | H2 FY24 (post-festive) |
| Pantaloons margin improvement | Margins to improve as the market recovers. | H2 FY24 |
| Pantaloons store expansion moderation | 35-40 new stores vs. 63 last year. | FY24 |
| TMRW full-year losses | INR80-100 crores. | FY24 |
| TMRW fund raise | On agenda, to be explored towards year-end or around that time. | End of FY24 / undated |
| Reebok profitability | Expected to become profitable on a full-year basis. | FY24 |
| Tasva store additions | 40 stores, reaching ~100 stores by end of full second year. | FY24 |
| Tasva breakeven | Likely period for breakeven. | FY26-FY27 |
| Innerwear/athleisure breakeven | Towards end of next year or early year after. | FY25 / early FY26 |
| Innerwear size at breakeven | Around INR750-800 crores. | At breakeven |
| Reebok store additions | 15-20 stores per quarter; 170-200 stores by year-end exit. | FY24 |
| Style Up store target | 30-35 stores. | FY24 |
| FY24 closing debt | INR2,800 crores after TCNS stake payment. | FY24 end |
| TCNS acquisition | Open offer commencement in process. | Under progress |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated revenue | ₹3,196 cr, +11% YoY |
| Standalone revenue | ₹2,987 cr, +8% YoY |
| Consolidated EBITDA | ₹353 cr, margin 11% |
| Standalone EBITDA margin | 14.2% |
| Consolidated PAT | -₹162 cr, includes negative impact of IndAS 116 |
| Net debt | ₹2,100 cr as on 30 June |
| FY24 closing net debt guidance | ₹2,800 cr, after payments for 51% stake in TCNS |
| Store network | 4,000+ stores, 1.09 cr sq ft retail space |
| E-commerce sales growth | +12% YoY |
| Lifestyle brands segment revenue | ₹1,594 cr, +5% YoY |
| Lifestyle brands EBITDA margin | 18.3%, +80 bps YoY |
| Lifestyle retail channel growth | +2% YoY |
| Lifestyle wholesale channel growth | +20% YoY |
| American Eagle revenue growth | +49% YoY |
| Reebok revenue growth | +43% YoY, 11% L2L |
| Pantaloons quarterly sales | ₹1,030 cr, EBITDA margin 13.4% |
| Pantaloons SSG | -8% |
| Pantaloons store count | 434 stores, 3 new stores added |
| Innerwear retail L2L | +3% |
| Innerwear trade outlets | 32,700 |
| Collective and super premium brands growth | +16% YoY, 16% L2L |
| Ethnic businesses revenue | ₹134 cr, +33% YoY |
| Tasva store count | 58 stores across 30+ cities |
| TMRW full year expected losses | ₹80–100 cr |
| Reebok store count | 120–125 stores, targeting 170–200 by year-end |
| Style Up store count | 15–16 stores, targeting 30–35 by year-end |