Key Takeaways
- Record revenue, premium-led divergence: Highest-ever quarterly revenue was driven by aggressive expansion and strong EOSS, but the premium end (Lifestyle brands) showed far greater buoyancy than the inflation-hit value end (Pantaloons).
- Innerwear ambition doubled mid-flight: The innerwear business is scaling rapidly and will easily cross ₹500 crores this year, prompting management to double the target to ₹1,000 crores within two to two-and-a-half years, funded by deeper investments starting in H2.
- Tasva is the current P&L drag: Most of the investment-phase losses sit in Tasva, where organizational build-out and a new marketing campaign are front-loaded; management expects this deep-investment phase to run for a couple more quarters before revenue scales to absorb it.
- Pantaloons margin lever delayed: Private label share is stuck at ~62%, short of the 70% goal, and management admits this is the next margin lever they have not yet pulled; new brands are still in early stages.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the Innerwear margin profile begins to shift as the next growth leg kicks in, the pace of Tasva’s store rollout toward 70, and any sign that Pantaloons’ private label mix is finally moving.
Revenue & Channel Dynamics
- Offline comeback sustained: The solid return to offline channels continued in Q2, indicating a strong return of the market to pre-COVID conditions.
- E-commerce resilience: Strong e-commerce performance was sustained even as offline rebounded, a testament to the omni-channel capability built over recent years.
- Lifestyle brands growth drivers: Growth was driven by premiumization, casualization across all brands, and rapid channel expansion.
- Premium vs. value divergence: Greater buoyancy was visible at the premium end of the market, where consumers are less affected by the inflationary environment; this recovery trend is consistent with the previous quarter.
- Pantaloons’ tougher environment: Pantaloons operated in an environment where its consumers were more affected by inflation, creating a more difficult business situation.
- Wholesale channel gap: The Lifestyle wholesale channel remains about 20% below pre-COVID levels, a gap that is primarily a function of the exit from the large Central account rather than underlying weakness; business with other department stores and traditional trade is strong.
Dikshit: “We have built a business model which is resilient enough to withstand this kind of thing. And that's reflected in the last 6 months. If you look at Ali, the inflation in textile value chain is perhaps one of the highest in the last 10, 15 years, that's been experienced. So Pantaloons has absorbed a very high pressure on its cost and yet deliver the kind of quality of profitability, which is very, very strong.”
Segment Profitability
- Lifestyle margins near pre-COVID: EBITDA margins for the Lifestyle segment were 17%, almost the same level as Q2 FY20 (17.4%); the marginal difference is largely from a shift in channel mix as e-commerce share grew, partially compensated by strong retail channel growth.
- Pantaloons profitability trajectory: Pantaloons has delivered consistent, solid improvement in profitability versus both pre-COVID and the prior year, continuing a profitability improvement journey that has run for four to five consecutive years.
- Pantaloons growth quality: Management is not chasing growth at disproportionate cost; the growth is organic, high quality, and reflects strong profitability, even if it means a marginal loss of potential top-line growth.
- Pantaloons markdown discipline: Markdowns were kept under check despite it being a full EOSS quarter, which helped improve profitability.
- Other businesses margin decline: EBITDA margin for businesses other than Lifestyle in the Madura segment dropped from about 10–11% to about 2% this quarter, primarily driven by the Innerwear business as it scales up investment.
- Pantaloons margin lever delayed: The next lever to shift Pantaloons’ margin trajectory is an increase in private label share, currently at ~62% versus a 70% goal; management admits they were short of what they wanted to do on that account, and new brands need time to play out.
Dikshit: “I don't think you should be concerned about margins for Lifestyle. I want to first start with that. Because if you look at the reported margins for -- EBITDA margins for Lifestyle segment, they're almost same level as Q2 of FY '20, 17% versus 17.4%. So I think we don't need to be concerned about that.”
New Business Investments
- Innerwear scaling rapidly: The innerwear business is scaling up fast and started a kids wear category this quarter, now offering products for the entire family.
- Innerwear ambition doubled: The first goal of ₹500+ crores revenue will be easily crossed this year; management is stepping up ambition from ₹500 to ₹1,000 crores in the next two to two-and-a-half years, with investments going up in H2 and part of next year.
- Innerwear margin trajectory: In another 6 to 12 months, Innerwear will start to chase the next step of growth from ₹500–600 crores to about ₹1,000 crores, which will shift the margin profile of the segment.
- Tasva investment phase: Most of the current-quarter losses in the other businesses segment sit in Tasva; the nature of expenses is building an organization for scale, and the advertising campaign just launched is not fully factored in Q2 results.
- Tasva store expansion: The aim is to end the year with 70 stores; 25 are already launched, with another 40–45 to be launched in the remaining part of the year.
- Tasva investment trajectory: Deeper marketing investment will continue in Q3 and Q4 as the wedding season arrives; the strategy is deep investment followed by a quick ramp-up, with the brand expected to be at scale by the end of next year.
- Tasva ambition raised: Management previously indicated ₹500 crores in five years; they now feel more confident and are looking at that number in a shorter period of time.
- Ethnic portfolio completeness: The ethnic portfolio is largely played out: four designer brands (Sabyasachi, Tarun, Shantanu & Nikhil, Masaba) at the high end, plus pret brands and Jaypore.
- Ethnic quarterly run rate: The current ₹100 crores a quarter run rate will quickly move to ₹150–200 crores a quarter going forward, with some of that visible in Q3.
- Reebok India takeover completed: The takeover of Reebok India operations was completed, which will help build a strong play in the sportswear market; management control effectively moved to ABFRL from 1st October.
- TMRW D2C subsidiary: The D2C subsidiary named TMRW is looking to invest in about 8 to 10 early-stage digital-first brands by the end of this year, taking majority stakes; investments will be much smaller compared to existing businesses.
Dikshit: “the whole strategy is deep investment, quick ramp-up to establish a brand which by the end of next year should be...”
Balance Sheet & Cash Flow
- Net debt increase inventory-led: The increase in net debt (excluding GIC money) is largely inventory-led; in a fast-growing business, September is the point where inventory needs to be fully loaded for the rest of the season.
- Strong cash flow generation: The Madura business is generating strong EBITDA and cash flow to fund its own capital and growth, leaving something for other businesses; Pantaloons cash flow generation is good enough to fund its own growth, with exceptional industry-leading net working capital turns.
- GIC investment: The first tranche of investment from GIC was received in the first half; the next round of money is due in March 2024.
Strategic Updates & New Launches
- Masaba LoveChild launch: Masaba launched the brand LoveChild, catering to the Beauty and Personal Care segment, in line with strategic objectives while collaborating with House of Masaba; the brand is already available across major marketplaces.
- Sabyasachi New York store: An exclusive Sabyasachi store was opened in New York, spanning 5,500 square feet.
- American Eagle record quarter: American Eagle delivered its highest-ever quarterly revenue, driven by strong product positioning in the denim segment, robust e-commerce performance, and a continued expansion trajectory.
- Youth/Super Premium e-commerce: E-commerce revenue in the youth and super-premium segment grew 100%, led by strong traction on the website and encouraging acceptance on marketplaces.
- Style Up pilot: A new value format called Style Up is in a pilot phase, targeted at a truly value segment distinct from Pantaloons, which has premiumized; it will be in large towns and, over time, in small towns as well.
- Pantaloons 25th anniversary: Pantaloons is celebrating its 25th anniversary and has become a 400-plus store network serving customers across 195 cities.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Overall revenue | More than ₹12,000–12,500 crores (vs. ₹8,000 crores last year) | FY23 |
| Long-term revenue | North of ₹21,000–22,000 crores, nearly tripling from ₹8,000 crores | 3–3.5 years |
| Innerwear revenue target | Step up from ₹500 crores to ₹1,000 crores | Next 2–2.5 years |
| Innerwear margin shift | Margin profile to shift as growth leg from ₹500–600 cr to ₹1,000 cr kicks in | 6–12 months |
| Tasva store count | 70 stores | By end of FY23 |
| Tasva brand at scale | Brand established at scale, investments balanced by revenue | By end of next year |
| Tasva revenue ambition | ₹500 crores, now targeted in a shorter period | Shorter than 5 years |
| Ethnic quarterly run rate | Move from ₹100 cr to ₹150–200 cr per quarter | Going forward, some visible in Q3 |
| Pantaloons store openings | 60–70 stores, hope to be closer to 70 | FY23 |
| Advertising spend range | Branded side 4–5% for a short period; Pantaloons up to 2.5–3%; overall range 3–4% | Next couple of quarters |
| Strategy update | Fresh strategy update to investor community | Sometime in Q4 of the coming year |
| D2C (TMRW) update | Clearer update on where TMRW stands | Maybe another quarter or so |
| GIC second tranche | Next round of money due | March 2024 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated revenue | ₹3,075 cr, 50% above same quarter last year |
| Consolidated EBITDA | ₹418 cr, 24% growth over last year |
| Consolidated PAT | ₹29 cr, almost 6 times last year level |
| H1 FY23 revenue | ₹5,949 cr, 108% growth versus last year |
| H1 FY23 EBITDA | ₹918 cr, 375% growth over last year |
| H1 FY23 PAT | ₹124 cr versus net losses of ₹347 cr last year |
| H1 FY23 EPS | ₹1.44 per share |
| H1 FY23 ROCE | over 30% on operating capital employed of ₹1,922 cr |
| Net debt | ₹243 cr as of 30th September, versus ₹504 cr in March 2022 |
| Lifestyle brands revenue | ₹1,680 cr, 45% higher than last year |
| Lifestyle brands EBITDA | ₹286 cr, 52% increase over last year |
| Lifestyle brands L2L growth | 27% over last year |
| Lifestyle brands e-commerce share | 16% of quarterly segment revenue |
| Pantaloons revenue | ₹1,094 cr, 64% growth over last year |
| Pantaloons EBITDA | ₹176 cr versus ₹125 cr last year |
| Other business segment revenue | ₹307 cr, 31% growth over last year |
| Innerwear revenue growth | 27% over last year |
| Innerwear trade outlets | 30,400 at end of quarter |
| Innerwear exclusive business outlets | 111 stores |
| American Eagle revenue growth | 70% over last year, highest ever quarterly revenue |
| Forever 21 revenue growth | 40% over last year |
| Super Premium brands revenue growth | 35% over last year |
| Ethnic business quarterly run rate | ₹110 cr |
| Sabyasachi revenue growth | 60% over last year |
| Jaypore revenue growth | almost 80% over last year |
| Shantanu & Nikhil revenue growth | 48% over last year |
| Tasva stores | 21 at end of quarter, aiming for 65–70 by year-end |
| Branded stores added during quarter | 85, including 13 ethnic stores |
| Pantaloons net store additions | 21 stores, highest quarterly expansion in five years |
| E-commerce annual run rate | ₹1,300 cr, 40% higher than last year |
| E-commerce revenue growth (QoQ) | 41% versus previous quarter |
| Pantaloons e-commerce revenue growth | 20% over last year |
| Youth and Super Premium e-commerce growth | 100% over last year |
| Marketing investments in quarter | approximately ₹100 cr |
| Full-year revenue expectation | more than ₹12,000 cr to ₹12,500 cr |
| Full-year capex expectation | closer to ₹700–750 cr |
| H1 FY23 capex | around ₹300 cr |
| Pantaloons private label contribution | around 62% for last 3–4 quarters |
| Innerwear revenue run rate | ₹500–600 cr, targeting about ₹1,000 cr |
| Tasva revenue ambition | ₹500 cr in five years, now looking at shorter period |
| D2C subsidiary TMRW planned investments | 8 to 10 investments by end of year, parent investing ₹400–500 cr |