Key Takeaways
- Top line muted, bottom line conviction intact: Revenue declined in Consumer Durable and Electronics, but management is explicit that the structural shift from finished goods to components will expand margins, and bottom-line growth will continue.
- RAC insourcing is a margin story, not a demand story: Two more OEMs are expected to start in-house assembly, which will further reduce finished-goods revenue but lift component margins; management expects two more quarters of top-line fluctuation before normalcy.
- Electronics division reset, then doubling: An 8% Q3 decline from PCB inventory pile-up and delayed customer approvals has cleared; approvals came in February, and the division is guided to double revenue in two years with margins reaching 7–7.5%.
- Railway and PCB acquisitions set the next growth leg: The Sidwal-Titagarh JV adds an ₹850 cr order book, Ascent Circuits opens the bare PCB market, and the Korea Circuit MoU targets advanced substrates; all are expected to pay off from H2 FY26.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the two remaining OEMs actually start in-house RAC facilities, the pace of new-customer revenue conversion in Electronics, and any anti-dumping duty notification on bare PCBs.
The RAC Transformation: Insourcing, Margins, and the Top-Line Trough
- The structural shift: OEMs are moving assembly in-house, which replaces finished-goods orders (starting late October, including pass-through compressors and gases) with component orders (starting January–February). This timing mismatch and inventory liquidation after unseasonal Q1 rains drove a 5% Q3 and 3% 9M revenue decline in Consumer Durable.
- Two more customers pending: Two OEMs expected to start in-house facilities this quarter did not; they may now begin in Q1, Q2, or Q3. Once they do, the component strategy kicks in, and management says the "complete dust will settle" on the insourcing vs outsourcing shift.
- Margin expansion is the trade: The shift from finished goods to components is expected to expand margins; the division is guided to touch 7%+ margin next year. RAC value share is maintained at 28–29%.
- Revenue mix transformation: RAC has fallen from 72% of revenue (2018) to 38% now and is expected to reach 28–30% in two years. Other businesses carry better margins, so consolidated margins should improve even as RAC top line stays muted or flattish for two to three quarters.
- Normalcy timeline: Post-Q3 basis (H2 FY25), whichever brand had to put up a facility will be done, and normality should return.
Jasbir Singh: "we are the first one to get impacted and the last one to rise when it comes to inventory level management at the brand level."
Electronics Division: A Reset Quarter, Then a Doubling
- What drove the 8% Q3 decline: Air conditioner PCB business suffered from inventory pile-up at brands after unseasonal rains; new customer approvals in smart metering and auto were expected by Q3 but arrived only in the first week of February; one new customer initially opted for job-work basis rather than sales.
- The reset is now complete: AC PCB inventory at brands has been exhausted, approvals are in hand, and the customer is on track. New product categories added include hearables, wearables, telecom products, and smart meters. Approvals for defense, aerospace, and industrial business are expected in FY25.
- Doubling commitment: Management foresees the division doubling revenue in the next two financial years, with EBITDA margin reaching 7–7.5% for PCBA and bare PCB board combined.
Railway Subsystems: Sidwal, the Titagarh JV, and the 4–5x Ambition
- Q3 subdued on customer-side delays: Railway Subsystems revenue was slightly below Q2 because of unforeseen delays at the customer's end; the division currently caters to only 5% of the BOM of rolling stock, so customer readiness directly impacts the supply chain.
- Sidwal's growth trajectory: Acquired in May 2019 at ₹167 cr revenue and 15% EBITDA, Sidwal is likely to touch ₹475–480 cr this year with 22% EBITDA. Management sees potential to reach 4–5x that level or more in the next four years.
- The Titagarh JV (Shivalik): A 50:50 JV with Titagarh Rail Systems, with each party investing ₹120 cr, to enter train components and subsystems in India and Italy. The SPV will also invest in Titagarh Firema SPA in Italy, where Invitalia is investing €17 million with in-principle approval. An order book of about ₹850 cr for doors, gangways, and air conditioners for Vande Bharat, Pune Metro, and Surat Metro is already added.
- Capacity expansion underway: A new Greenfield facility in Faridabad (5-acre plot approved by HSIIDC) will expand existing product capacity; two more facilities are planned through the SPV, one for interiors and one for couplers, gears, and pantographs. Total Sidwal CAPEX is guided at ~₹200–225 cr over the next two financial years.
- Vande Bharat ramp: Very few Vande Bharat Express deliveries are expected next year; numbers go up the year after, and by FY27 they rise exponentially. Railway revenues will move in line with Indian Railways' requirements.
- The competitive pitch: The railway subsystems space has been dominated by highly profitable multinationals (Knorr-Bremse, Faiveley) running ~30% EBITDA businesses. Management's thesis is to bring a Make in India story to all these sectors.
Jasbir Singh: "Sidwal we acquired in May of 2019 when top line of Sidwal was Rs.167 crores and it was a 15% EBITDA company. This year we are likely to touch about Rs.475-480 crores or maybe little more than that, with again 22% of EBITDA. This number has a potential to go to at least 4-5x or maybe more in the next four years' time."
Ascent Circuits and the Bare PCB Opportunity
- Acquisition structure: Amber Group acquired a 60% stake in Ascent Circuits through IL JIN Electronics for ₹311 cr, gaining capabilities in single-sided, double-sided, multi-layered, and RF PCBs for applications across aerospace, defense, medical, energy, automotive, telecom, data centers, and consumer electronics.
- Korea Circuit MoU: Ascent signed an MoU with Korea Circuit (part of the YoungPoong Group, a $12 billion South Korean conglomerate specializing in HDI boards) to manufacture Flex, HDI, semiconductor substrates, and PCBs.
- Expansion plans: 12 acres have been allotted by ELCOT (Tamil Nadu government) about 6 km from the current facility for portfolio expansion; the investment amount is yet to be determined, and YP Group will infuse equity. Clarity on CAPEX and which sectors for the first phase is expected in the next 15–20 days to a month.
- Anti-dumping tailwind: The DGFT has recommended a 30% anti-dumping duty on bare PCB boards (single-layer to six-layer); notification is expected by March. India imports $3.7 billion of bare PCBs annually, though management has not yet specified which part of that market it will target.
- Near-term growth: Ascent Circuits is expected to grow 15–20% next year. Captive-use approvals for Ascent boards are expected in the next six months.
Margins, ROCE, and the PAT Loss
- PAT loss drivers: The bottom-line loss was driven by higher depreciation from CAPEX incurred and higher finance costs from increased debt and a higher cost of finance.
- ROCE confidence: Management is confident of maintaining ROCE in the 19–21% range over the next three years, through FY27.
- Divisional margin profiles: Consumer Durable is guided to 7%+ margin next year; Electronics (PCBA plus bare PCB) to 7–7.5% EBITDA margin going forward. Management declined to give a consolidated margin number, noting all divisions are at different margin profiles.
- Interest and depreciation absorption: By next year, the absorption of interest cost and depreciation from recent investments will start to show.
New Initiatives and the Payoff Timeline
- Noise JV: Bose has invested in Noise, and the JV is moving toward the premium segment; the facility will start by mid-April and is expected to begin with about ₹800–1,000 cr revenue in the very first year.
- Semiconductor optionality: Semiconductor and OSAT factories getting ready by FY27 would open up an opportunity, though no specific plans have been disclosed.
- Execution year: FY25 is characterized as a year of execution and customer approvals for new initiatives in PCB and railway businesses; all initiatives are expected to start paying dividends from the second half of FY26 onward.
- Top-line guidance withheld: Management declined to give revenue growth guidance, citing the difficulty of predicting top line given sub-assembly variations and similar trends in electronics.
Jasbir Singh: "as we are undergoing this transformational journey, a couple of quarters may witness fluctuations in top line. However, we are very strongly confident of maintaining our growth trajectory in our bottom line in the next financial year and years to come."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| ROCE range | Maintain 19–21% | Through FY27 |
| Electronics division revenue | Double from current level | Next two financial years |
| Electronics division EBITDA margin | Reach 7–7.5% (PCBA + bare PCB combined) | Going forward |
| Consumer Durable division margin | Touch 7%+ | Next year |
| Sidwal revenue potential | Grow to 4–5x current level (~₹475–480 cr) | Next four years |
| Sidwal CAPEX | ~₹200–225 cr total | Next two financial years |
| Ascent Circuits growth | 15–20% revenue growth | Next year |
| Noise JV revenue | ~₹800–1,000 cr | Very first year of operations |
| New initiatives payoff | All initiatives (PCB, railway) start paying dividends | H2 FY26 onward |
| RAC normalcy | Fluctuations settle post-Q3 basis | H2 FY25 |
| RAC revenue share | Reduce to 28–30% of consolidated revenue | Next two years |
| Anti-dumping duty on bare PCBs | 30% duty recommended by DGFT; notification expected | By March |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated revenue | ₹1,295 cr, vs ₹1,348 cr in Q3 FY23 |
| 9M FY24 consolidated revenue | ₹3,924 cr, flat YoY |
| Operating EBITDA | ₹82 cr, vs ₹89 cr in Q3 FY23 |
| 9M FY24 operating EBITDA | ₹285 cr, +5% YoY |
| 9M FY24 operating EBITDA margin | 7.3%, vs 6.9% in 9M FY23 |
| PAT | Loss of ₹1 cr, vs profit of ₹15 cr in Q3 FY23 |
| 9M FY24 PAT | ₹40 cr, vs ₹56 cr in 9M FY23 |
| 9M FY24 CAPEX | ₹262 cr at consolidated level |
| Consumer Durable division revenue | ₹932 cr, -5% YoY |
| Electronics division revenue | ₹241 cr, -8% YoY |
| Railway Subsystems division revenue | ₹122 cr, +11% YoY |
| Railway Subsystems order book | ₹1,160 cr plus LoI of ~₹850 cr, visibility ~₹2,000 cr |
| Room AC contribution to total revenue | 38%, down from 72% in 2018 |
| RAC sector value share maintained | 28% to 29% |
| Railway Subsystems division 9M FY24 operating EBITDA | ₹76 cr, vs ₹71 cr in 9M FY23 |
| Electronics division 9M FY24 operating EBITDA | ₹36 cr, vs ₹30 cr in 9M FY23 |
| Consumer Durable division 9M FY24 operating EBITDA | ₹174 cr, vs ₹170 cr in 9M FY23 |
| Ascent Circuits 9M FY24 revenue | ₹206 cr |
| Ascent Circuits 9M FY24 EBITDA | ₹42 cr, ~19% to 20% EBITDA margin |
| Ascent Circuits order book | ~₹800 cr for the next two years |
| Sidwal FY24 estimated revenue | ₹475–480 cr, with 22% EBITDA margin |
| Sidwal expansion CAPEX planned | ₹200–225 cr over next two financial years |
| Electronics division revenue doubling guidance | Double revenue in next two financial years |
| Ascent Circuits expected growth | 15% to 20% in FY25 |
| Noise JV expected first-year revenue | ₹800–1,000 cr (not consolidated) |
| Railway and metro addressable market | ₹75,000–80,000 cr over next 5–6 years |
| Sidwal target share of addressable market | ~20% |
| Vande Bharat wallet share target per coach | ₹2–2.5 cr out of ~₹6–6.5 cr BOM |
| Railway subsystems margin range | 20% to 22% |
| Consumer Durable division margin | ~7.2% |
| Electronics division margin expected | 7%+ by next year |
| ROCE guidance | 19% to 21% range by FY27 |