Key Takeaways
- Conductor margins hit a historic peak: EBITDA per metric ton reached ₹49,942, driven by a structural mix shift toward premium products (44% of revenue) and higher-margin exports to developed markets.
- Base oil price crash was brutal: Oil division margins compressed as a fire sale in base oil, triggered by absent Chinese demand and surplus public-sector supply, proved worse than management had anticipated.
- Cable business is scaling rapidly: EBITDA margin expanded to 11.8% on the back of surging elastomeric exports and a B2C distribution push that doubled revenue to ~₹200 Crores.
- A multi-year capex cycle is starting: A ~₹300 Cr investment over 15 months, plus a new Greenfield site, aims to build surplus capacity ahead of demand, with management targeting an 18–20% ROE through the expansion.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the base oil normalization materializes as guided, the pace of conductor margin moderation toward the ₹24,000–25,000 sustainable range, and any update on the US nearshoring manufacturing investigation.
Conductor Division: The Margin Inflection
- Historic peak: EBITDA per metric ton hit ₹49,942 in Q3, a level management attributes to a structural shift in product mix rather than a transient spike.
- Premium mix driving profitability: 44% of conductor revenue now comes from high-efficiency and copper premium products, while exports to developed markets (US, Australia, Latin America) command higher realizations than the intensely competitive domestic market.
- Domestic market quality gap: Realizations in the domestic market remain poor because EPC players set very low standards, whereas developed markets demand much higher supplier qualifications, yielding better netbacks.
- Structural floor established: Management explicitly ruled out a return to the old ₹12,000–14,000 per metric ton range, citing the permanent shift away from conventional conductors sold in the domestic market.
- Tailwinds aiding the quarter: Reduced steel prices and container freight costs falling to pre-COVID levels provided additional, though secondary, support to margins.
- Short-term vs. long-term guide: Near-term EBITDA per ton is expected to stay elevated around ₹30,000, while the sustainable long-term base is guided at ₹24,000–25,000 as conditions normalize.
- US infrastructure cycle: A multi-decade replacement cycle is underway as transmission infrastructure built between 1945 and 1970 has exceeded its 30–35 year design life, with many assets now past 50 years.
- Competitive insulation: Management does not expect a sudden shift in Chinese competition, noting that many strategic buyers have clear procurement policies that would be difficult to change dramatically.
Kushal Desai: "No, I do not think we will go back to the 12000 to 14000 because if you also look at the product mix that existed in that 12000 to 14000 period, it was largely a) conventional conductors and b) it was being largely sold in the domestic market, which is very competitive. So right now, there is a structural shift in terms of the mix of product..."
Oil Division: The Base Oil Shock
- Margin compression: EBITDA post-Forex fell to ₹1,646 per KL, in line with guidance for lower profitability, as the division absorbed a rapid and severe decline in base oil prices.
- The fire-sale mechanism: Chinese demand collapsed due to COVID disruptions persisting into January, while Indian public-sector refineries dumped surplus base oil into the market because of soft retail lubricant demand and record production.
- Worse than expected: Management had anticipated some price correction, but the speed and severity of the crash were more brutal than envisaged.
- Inventory clean-out drag: Apar runs roughly 70% of its purchases on longer-term contracts, so the inventory clean-out took longer than it would for just-in-time buyers, prolonging the margin hit.
- Normalization expected: The situation is already improving in Q4, with management expecting conditions to approach normal by March, supported by an industry view that Chinese demand may return stronger.
- Long-term growth capped: Specialty oil segment growth is guided at 5–7%, with transformer oil potentially growing faster on capacity additions, while white oil and automotive lubricants face headwinds from EV adoption.
Kushal Desai: "We were expecting a little bit of that to happen, but what actually ended up happening was much more brutal than had been envisaged."
Cable Division: Scaling Margins and Reach
- Margin expansion: EBITDA margin reached 11.8%, up from 8.7% a year ago, driven by a significant increase in high-margin elastomeric product sales and exports.
- Elastomeric advantage: These specialized cables carry higher margins, and Apar is one of the few vertically integrated players that formulates and mixes its own insulation polymers.
- Export transformation: Exports contributed 49% of Q3 cable sales, up from 35% a year ago, with nine-month exports at roughly 52% of sales.
- Renewable energy exports beginning: Elastomeric cable exports, which were purely domestic until two quarters ago, have now started, with increased capacity for wind and solar cables enabling the shift. More export of renewable cables is expected in FY2024.
- B2C distribution scaling rapidly: Revenue from light-duty, distribution-based cables doubled from ~₹100 Crores to ~₹200 Crores, with distribution expanding from 5 southern states to include UP, West Bengal, and Bihar. Distributor count grew from ~20 to ~100, and retail counters from 275 to ~1,550.
- B2C target: Management is targeting ₹350 Crores in revenue from light-duty cables in FY2024.
- Growth guidance maintained: The cable business is expected to grow at a 25–30% CAGR, with export sales growing faster than domestic.
- Long-term margin target: Sustainable double-digit EBITDA margin of approximately 10% is the long-term expectation for the cable division.
Capex and Capacity: Building Ahead of Demand
- ~₹300 Cr capex program: To be deployed over the next 15 months, with the lion’s share allocated to cables, some to conductors, and very little to oil. The aim is to put surplus capacity in place ahead of demand.
- Greenfield cable site: A new 40-plus acre site is being set up to provide room for future machinery additions as the business grows.
- Conductor land acquisition: Land adjacent to the Silvassa plant has been acquired for conductor capacity expansion, with machinery being installed. Silvassa is favored for exports due to better logistics via Gujarat ports and an ICD taken over by Adani Logistics.
- Rod capacity in Orissa: Additional rod-making capacity is being added in Orissa, while conductor-making capacity is concentrated in Silvassa.
- Capex output ratio: Management estimates a 1:4 or 1:5 ratio in terms of product output per unit of capex invested.
- Funding approach: Some borrowings will be taken for the expansion, while retained earnings will fund working capital needs. ₹50 Cr of long-term debt was repaid in the quarter.
- US nearshoring investigation: Management is actively investigating setting up a manufacturing facility nearer to the United States, with Mexico and Colombia under consideration, to service the US and Latin American markets.
- No local manufacturing threat: Management sees no emphasis on local procurement from the US because there is simply not enough local manufacturing capacity, and India’s unit cost of production is much cheaper.
Kushal Desai: "prudent we believe to actually put the capacity a little bit ahead of time so we look at a new Greenfield site for cable, and in conductors, we have acquired some land right adjacent to one of our plants at Silvassa area and machineries are going in there. So about 300 Crores odd over the next 15 months is what we expect the Capex to be in. That should help keep the momentum going in terms of growth both with cables and conductors... delivery times have gone up substantially... we need to invest a little bit ahead of the curve."
Capital Allocation and Returns
- ROE target through expansion: Management aims to keep ROE in the 18–20% range through all expansions, acknowledging that short-term drops are possible as new capital blocks take a few quarters to ramp up.
- Three ROE drivers: Revenue to gross block (always very good), revenue to working capital (generally on the higher side), and improving EBITDA margins on conductors and cables.
- Dividend policy: The board will decide, but the current ratio is between 25% and 30%, with a bias toward reinvesting given the clear growth opportunity both domestically and overseas.
- Interest cost modeling: Q3 interest cost levels are a good approximate going forward, barring further rate hikes, with receivables and inventory days reasonably steady.
- Working capital management: Receivables are secured by letters of credit, and management works both sides of payables and debtors. Interest costs for extended credit days are factored into product pricing.
Kushal Desai: "Every time you have a capital block going on, you can have a short-term drop because it takes a few quarters to ramp up the production and realize the full volumes. But I think we are at a momentum today where it is possible to be in that 18%, 20% range through all the expansions, etc."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Conductor EBITDA per ton (short-term) | ~₹30,000 range | Next couple of quarters |
| Conductor EBITDA per ton (sustainable) | ₹24,000–25,000 per metric ton | Long-term structural base |
| Cable business growth | 25–30% CAGR | Next several years |
| Cable EBITDA margin (sustainable) | ~10% | Long-term |
| Light-duty cable revenue | ₹350 Crores | FY2024 |
| Capex deployment | ~₹300 Cr | Next 15 months |
| ROE through expansion | 18–20% | Through all expansions |
| Base oil normalization | Situation closer to normal | By March (end of FY2023) |
| Specialty oil segment growth | 5–7% | Long-term |
| Conductor growth momentum | Good momentum, clear visibility | At least next 2–3 years |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated revenue | ₹3,942 cr, 77% higher YoY |
| Export revenue share | 49% of overall revenues, vs 35% a year ago |
| EBITDA | ₹349 cr, up 174% YoY, margin 8.8% |
| Profit after tax | ₹170 cr, 210% higher YoY, margin 4.3% vs 2.5% a year ago |
| Nine-month consolidated revenue | ₹10,270 cr, 63% higher YoY |
| Conductor division revenue | ₹1,912 cr, up 103% YoY, volume growth ~99% |
| Conductor EBITDA per metric ton (post Forex) | ₹49,942, historic high |
| Conductor order book | ₹4,885 cr, 44% from premium products |
| Conductor sustainable EBITDA per ton guidance | ₹22,000–₹24,000 per metric ton long-term, ~₹30,000 short-term |
| Cable division revenue | ₹921 cr, up 89% YoY |
| Cable EBITDA margin (post Forex) | 11.8%, vs 8.7% a year ago |
| Cable long-term sustainable EBITDA margin guidance | ~10% |
| Oil division revenue | ₹1,245 cr, up 38% YoY, volume growth 9% |
| Oil division EBITDA per KL (post Forex) | ₹1,646 |
| Lubricant revenue | ₹238 cr, volume 17,063 KL |
| Interest-bearing acceptances | ~₹3,400 cr as of December end |
| Long-term debt | ~₹200 cr, current maturities ~₹50 cr |
| Capex plan | ~₹300 cr over next 15 months, lion's share for cable division |
| ROE (nine months) | 21% |
| B2C cable revenue | ~₹200 cr this year, targeting ₹350 cr in FY2024 |
| Cable distributors | ~100 as of Dec 2022, vs ~20 in Mar 2022 |
| Retail counters | ~1,550 as of Dec 2022, vs 275 in Mar 2022 |
| Conductor business revenue growth guidance | 15%–20% between this year and the coming year |
| Cable business revenue growth guidance | 25%–30% |
| Oil business revenue growth guidance | 5%–7% |