Key Takeaways
- Revenue masked by metal prices: Consolidated revenue grew only 2% despite volume growth, because aluminium prices were ~11% lower YoY, depressing the topline.
- US destocking hit cables hard: Flattish cable revenue and lower export mix stemmed from US customers working down 9–10 months of inventory versus a normal 2–3 months; ex-US global sales grew 17.2% in Q3.
- Margins expanded on mix and exports: EBITDA margin improved to 10.8% from 8.9% YoY, driven by a richer product mix of premium conductors and a higher share of exports to better-margin countries.
- AL-59 is reshaping the conductor industry: The alloy has become the default product in India, reducing competitive intensity because players without alloying capability have shut down or scaled back.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the US inquiry-to-order pipeline converts into deliveries from March–April as guided, and whether Red Sea freight costs begin to rationalize.
US & Export Demand: The Destocking Cycle
- De-inventorization is the core drag: US customers overstocked cables during prior supply chain disruptions, holding up to 9–10 months of inventory versus a normal 2–3 months; current deliveries are only makeup products to complete existing orders, while new project site deliveries are being deferred.
- Inquiry revival is underway: The "silence" in inquiries has broken, and quoting activity is now increasing against new inquiries, with orders expected to convert into deliveries from late Q4 FY24 and into Q1 FY25.
- Europe is following the same script: Distributors like LAP and Heliu Cable held larger inventories, but their positions have substantially improved; management expects deliveries to start picking up as summer approaches.
- Enel contract delayed, not lost: Enel accumulated cable inventory because certain components like junction boxes were delayed; as that backlog clears, deliveries on the new contract will start from April and May onwards.
- Non-US markets are filling the gap: Ex-US global sales grew 17.2% for cables in Q3, and Australia has been "quite steady right through this period."
- US remains a strategic growth market: The US imports $19 billion worth of cables; Apar's FY23 revenue there was a little over ₹1,000 crores, leaving substantial room to grow independent of macro conditions.
Kushal Desai: "So today, what products we are delivering is really the makeup product. If you require 4 or 5 different types to go to a site then whatever is missing to deliver an order, that is what they're placing and asking for immediate delivery. New project site deliveries are getting deferred by a little bit."
Conductor Margins: The AL-59 Structural Shift
- AL-59 is now the default: The Central Electricity Authority has made AL-59 an option to bid against for EPC players, and it is becoming the standard because of its weight-to-current-carrying-capacity advantage, making it a "no-brainer" on a cost-of-ownership basis.
- Competitive intensity has fallen: Many players without alloying capability have become irrelevant and either shut down or reduced their conductor business, especially on the transmission side.
- Margin tailwinds are compounding: EBITDA per metric ton of ₹41,530 came from a good product mix of premium products, a higher share of AL-59 conductors, and a higher export mix to better-margin countries, a trend that has been consistent for over a year.
- Long-term guidance has been raised: The long-term EBITDA guidance has been gradually increased from ₹8,000–₹10,000 per metric ton a couple of years ago to around ₹28,500 plus tailwinds, because opportunities are getting established and confidence in products and markets is growing.
- Capacity is being added a year ahead: New properties have been acquired (cable manufacturers in Silvassa that shut down) for installing new equipment, and equipment ordering has already started based on lead times.
Kushal Desai: "The competitive intensity has reduced because many players who have not invested in alloying capability and technology where today are not relevant and they either shut down their businesses or reduced the amount of business that they do in conductors, especially on the transformation side."
Cable Business: Margin Inflection Ahead
- Margins held despite US headwinds: Cable EBITDA continued at double-digit margins of about 11.5% even as the US, which was ~16% of FY23 revenues, underwent destocking.
- Growth target is ambitious: The cable business is expected to grow at about 20–25% CAGR for the next few years, with a margin profile that should reach the early teens, around 12–13%.
- Wind sector revival is a specific catalyst: The government's scheme to upgrade old wind farms (replacing 2–50 kW or 500 kW windmills with 3.5 MW turbines) will result in a substantial increase in wind capacity, and Apar is "by far the big daddy" in cables that go into wind towers.
- US approvals are expanding the addressable market: Apar can serve the entire building wire segment, has UL approval for all low-voltage range, recently got medium-voltage approval up to ~40,000 volts, and holds over 20 UL approvals with more being added based on customer demand.
- Red Sea disruption is a manageable friction: Transit times have increased by 15–18 days due to diversion around the Cape of Good Hope, and customers are increasingly giving DDP requirements, so Apar manufactures 3 weeks ahead and ships earlier to compensate.
Ramesh Iyer: "And that should also help our margin profile to come to early teens, 12%, 13% level."
Oil Division: Volatile Quarter, Steady Trajectory
- Q3 margin spike was partly transitory: EBITDA per KL of ₹8,157 was higher than last year and previous quarters due to slightly better pricing, a lower cost profile, and a delay in base oil shipments from S-OIL in Korea that made the weighted average cost of inventory lower through most of the quarter, adding incremental profitability.
- A reversal is built in: Because SAP accounting uses weighted average cost, the effective raw material cost was lower through most of the quarter and increased only in December, so higher-priced product carries forward into January and February, causing a reversal.
- Trailing twelve-month margins tell the real story: Trailing 12-month margins have been better than the same period previous year, and the business has already gone beyond the mean based on 9-month performance.
- Transformer oil is the lead growth product: As transformer oil grows in the oil division, it is the lead product for the vertical, with double-digit growth guided and strong demand across both power and distribution transformers globally.
- Long-term EBITDA guidance is ₹5,000–₹6,000 per KL: Management stresses a 12-month horizon because quarterly volatility is inherent; some quarters may see ₹8,000–₹9,000 per KL while others may see ₹1,000–₹3,000 per KL.
Ramesh Iyer: "That is why we have been guiding this INR5,000 to INR6,000 per KL in terms of EBITDA because in some quarters, you may see margins going to about INR8,000, INR9,000 per KL, whereas in some quarters, we would actually see INR1,000 to INR3,000 per KL also. Therefore, we need to see this on a long-term 12-month horizon and that's where the guidance of average of INR5,000 to INR6,000 per KL comes."
Domestic Transmission & BharatNet Opportunity
- Q4 transmission line additions expected higher: Pro-rata addition in the January–March quarter is expected to be higher than the previous 9 months due to the best climatic conditions for project execution.
- AL-59 transition has years to run: The upgrade from ACSR to AL-59 alloy has started and the full effect will play out over the next few years; all interstate lines and longer intra-state lines will move towards AL-59 as a base in India.
- BharatNet tender is at an advanced stage: Multiple rounds of industry discussions and feedback have happened; 4 mega packages and 4 smaller packages are being proposed, and guidelines have been shared; the tender is racing against time due to impending elections but is at a really advanced stage.
- Transformer demand is broad-based: Growth is seen across both power and distribution transformers, with larger power transformers offering higher market share and a better differentiating story for Apar; order books at transformer manufacturers globally are very solid.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Conductor volume growth | 15% plus per annum | Next year and the year after |
| Conductor long-term EBITDA | ₹28,500 per metric ton plus tailwinds | 3 to 5 years |
| Cable revenue growth | 20–25% CAGR | Next few years |
| Cable margin profile | Early teens, 12–13% level | Not dated |
| Transformer oil growth | Double-digit | Not dated |
| Oil division EBITDA per KL | Approximately ₹5,000 to ₹5,500 (long-term average) | 12-month horizon |
| Lubricant volume growth | 5% to 7% | Not dated |
| Annual capex run-rate | ~₹300 crores on average | Annual, to maintain turnover level |
| US export quarterly run-rate | Cross ₹150 crores in a quarter | Next couple of quarters |
| US demand revival | 2024 will definitely be better than how 2023 ended | Through 2024 and into 2025 |
| Europe supply increase | Increased supplies should take place | From March–April onwards |
| Enel contract deliveries | Deliveries on new contract to start | April and May onwards |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated revenue | ₹4,013 cr, 2% higher than same period previous year |
| EBITDA | ₹432 cr, up 24% YoY; margin 10.8% versus 8.9% a year ago |
| Profit after tax | ₹218 cr, 28% higher than previous year; PAT margin 5.4% versus 4.3% a year ago |
| Export mix | 39% of consolidated revenue versus 50.2% in the year-ago period |
| Global sales growth ex-US | 17.2% in Q3 |
| 9-month consolidated revenue | ₹11,711 cr, up 14% YoY |
| 9-month EBITDA | ₹1,174 cr, up 42% YoY; margin 10% versus 8% a year ago |
| 9-month PAT | ₹589 cr, up 49% YoY; PAT margin 5%, 120 bps higher than 9 months of last year |
| Conductor division revenue | ₹1,985 cr, up 4% YoY; volume grew 14% |
| Conductor EBITDA per metric ton | ₹41,530 post forex adjustment |
| Conductor order book | ₹6,081 cr, with about 40% from premium products |
| Conductor volume growth guidance | 15% for the year ahead |
| Oil division revenue | ₹1,244 cr |
| Oil EBITDA per KL | ₹8,157 post forex adjustment |
| Transformer oil volume growth | 16% YoY |
| Cable division EBITDA margin | 11.5% |
| Cable business growth guidance | 25% CAGR for the next few years |
| Acceptances (LC) on books | ₹4,100 cr |
| Capex spent as of December end | ₹225 cr of over ₹300 cr planned for FY24 |