Key Takeaways
- PVC price collapse drove a loss-making quarter: Resin prices crashed 25% in Q2, triggering panic destocking and a ₹4.8 crore net loss despite the second-highest quarterly sales volume ever.
- Volume engine stayed on: Sales volume hit 15,465 MT, with H1 volumes up 20% YoY, as the company pushed volume to keep gaining market share through the carnage.
- Inventory write-down was the hidden hit: Operating EBITDA spreads were ~10%, but reported EBITDA collapsed to 1.5%-2% after an estimated ₹15-20 crores in inventory write-downs and extra channel discounts.
- The restocking bet is binary and undated: Management expects a "massive restocking" and sharp profit recovery the moment PVC prices stabilize, but the industry is not yet convinced prices have bottomed.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether PVC prices stabilize enough to trigger channel restocking, the pace of distribution expansion once sentiment returns, and the magnitude of Q3 inventory losses relative to Q2's hit.
The PVC Carnage & Its Mechanics
- Price collapse: Resin prices fell 25% in Q2 and another 12% in Q3 to date, after crashing ~35% from peak to June 30, 2022; management stated "we have not seen such situation in our history."
- Destocking spiral: Traders and distributors destocked to prevent stock losses, compressing realizations even as underlying demand stayed strong.
- Volume-revenue disconnect: Q2 revenue fell 1% YoY to ₹207.0 crores despite 6.5% YoY volume growth, because lower PVC prices flowed straight into lower realizations.
- Inventory write-down bridge: At the manufacturing level, EBITDA spreads were 12%-13%; after extra discounts to push material into the channel, operating EBITDA was ~10%; reported EBITDA was 1.5%-2%, with the ~₹15-20 crore gap attributed to inventory write-down.
- Q3 inventory loss outlook: If the PVC price drop sustains at ~₹10,000/ton so far in Q3 (vs ~₹30,000/ton in Q2), inventory losses will be much lower than Q2.
- Finished goods inventory elevated: Finished goods rose to ~65 days (₹167 crores) because the company expected higher volumes and had to maintain serviceability as it expands its SKU range; industry average is 60-70 days, and there is room to improve to ~60 days by shifting more toward raw material.
Sameer Gupta: "The PVC industry is witnessing a carnage. The resin prices collapsed 25% in Q2 and 12% in Q3 till date. This is after the fact that the prices crashed almost 35% from their peak till 30th June 2022. We have not seen such situation in our history."
Volume & Market Share Gains Through the Downturn
- Volume resilience: Q2 sales volume of 15,465 MT was the second-highest quarterly volume ever; H1 volumes up 20% YoY, driven by strong agri demand and building materials momentum.
- Agri demand strong: Monsoon on expected lines and falling prices made high-grade PVC pipes more affordable for farmers.
- Building materials now half the business: 50% of sales now from building materials, up from 45% last year; the segment is doing well and driving market share gains.
- CPVC breakout: CPVC growing at 70%-80% in H1 FY23, indicating market share gains in the value-added segment.
- Value-added mix steady: Value-added products (building materials PVC, CPVC, fittings, bath fittings, water tanks, plus HDPE from agri) held at ~60% of mix; commoditized agri pipes at ~40%.
- Where growth comes from: Growth has not come at the cost of established top brands; the focus is the unorganized sector, which still forms ~40% of the industry.
- Imports reduced: Imports pulled back due to market volatility; the company is catering to demand through local purchases as material is available locally, and will maintain normal import levels going forward.
Anubhav Gupta: "Our growth has been highest in the last four years, five years and it has not come at the cost of any established top brand. Where we have focused is the unorganized part of the industry, which still forms a very major part, which is like 40%..."
The Restocking Bet
- The trigger: Management expects that once PVC prices stabilize, the channel will see "massive restocking," lifting sales to significantly higher levels with sharp recovery in profitability.
- The wait: Industry restocking has not started because the industry is not convinced PVC prices have bottomed out; international prices keep dropping weekly, so the trade is waiting.
- Price bottom optimism: Management is optimistic that prices are near bottom or bottoming out, noting current PVC price levels are way below pre-COVID levels given 15% dollar appreciation, and a correction may be adjusted soon.
- FY23 revenue bridge: The company expects to be around ₹1,000 crores for FY23, assuming normalized PVC prices; the second half could see restocking if PVC prices stabilize and start rising, making up for the Q2 shortfall, with Q4 being a strong quarter.
Sameer Gupta: "Actually, industry is not actually convinced regarding the prices to be bottomed out here, because every month or every week year we are witnessing a drop in the prices even in the international market... So right now, that convincing is not there in the industry."
Distribution & Brand: Paused, Not Abandoned
- Distributor addition stalled: Addition of new distributors has been low in the last 6-7 months because market sentiments have been too weak; it is not the right time to ask for new distributorships when existing businesses are booking losses.
- Existing partners sticking: Direct channel partners stand at ~600 and are growing; distributors see value in the full product range the company offers, which is why they are sticking through the downturn.
- Retail touch points: Currently at ~25,000, with a target to expand to 40,000-45,000 in the next 2-3 years.
- Distribution catch-up plan: The company will try to make up for distribution expansion losses once prices stabilize and sentiments return; the target remains 700-800 distributors in the next 2-3 years.
- Brand spend pulled back: Some below-the-line promotional activities were pulled out in H1 because of low profitability; a campaign with Tiger Shroff was launched to communicate with end customers, supported by social media branding.
- Brand spend going forward: Will continue at ~1%-2% of top line; management is happy with the budget in hand for the next 2-3 quarters.
Anubhav Gupta: "Today is not a time to go and ask for a new distributorship with any new client because right now, the sentiments are too weak... The idea is to hit new distributors to approach new distributors when at least, they are not afraid of any kind of losses which they are booking with their existing business."
Capacity, New Products & Capex
- H1 capacity addition: 6,000 tons added in H1, majorly value-add in existing plants, taking annual capacity to 131,200 metric tons.
- Greenfield plant underway: A new plant in North India, 100% dedicated to value-added products, is under construction; ₹37 crores spent in Q1, ₹8 crores in Q2 toward full-year capex guidance of ₹60 crores; first production expected to start toward end of Q2 FY24, barring COVID disruptions.
- New plant capacity: The greenfield plant will add an incremental 15,000 tons, taking total capacity to ~145,000-150,000 tons.
- PPR segment entry: Entered the PPR segment, currently at a run rate of ~₹1 crore per month; the product is more superior than existing products in the Indian market and is highly profitable; efforts to promote in markets beyond Jammu have started slowly.
- Future capex: May want to put one plant in West India after the current plant is done, to penetrate deeper into the Western market; minor brownfield expansions will continue; expects to spend ₹30-40 crores annually on brownfield, debottlenecking, and value addition, with no new greenfield expected over the next 10-15 months.
- Employee expenses: Rose marginally due to average increments and expansion of the sales force and production team to support 20%-25% growth targets.
Margin Structure & Recovery Path
- H1 EBITDA collapse: H1 EBITDA down 48% YoY to ₹22.5 crores; margins fell 726 bps to 5.3%, driven by lower realization and higher input costs.
- Working capital improvement: Working capital cycle improved to 66 days in H1 FY23 from 73 days in H1 FY22.
- Blended EBITDA target: Management targets taking blended EBITDA beyond ₹18,000/ton, with room to improve to ₹20/kg, given top brand players are making such numbers.
- Value-added mix as margin lever: Target to reach 70% value-added, 30% commodity (with the non-agri portion going to 75%) by FY25, up from ~60% currently.
- Value-added products are not Tier-1-city dependent: Water storage tanks, for example, see more demand in Tier 2 and Tier 3 towns.
Anubhav Gupta: "I don't think this is a correct conclusion that the value-added products can only be sold in Tier 1 cities. Right. Water storage tanks, for example, it's value-added for us. Now the demand for water storage is more in Tier 2, Tier 3 towns."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue CAGR | 25% CAGR revenue growth | Till FY25 |
| Volume CAGR | 20%-25% volume CAGR; rest from realization improvement via value-added mix | Till FY25 |
| FY23 revenue | Around ₹1,000 crores, assuming normalized PVC prices | FY23 |
| Market share | From ~2%-2.5% to 3.5%-4% | By FY25 |
| Value-added product mix | Reach 70% value-added, 30% commodity (non-agri to 75%) | By FY25 |
| Blended EBITDA | Beyond ₹18,000/ton, with room to reach ₹20/kg | Undated |
| Total capacity | ~145,000-150,000 tons after greenfield plant completion | Greenfield first production end of Q2 FY24 |
| Distributor count | 700-800 distributors | Next 2-3 years |
| Retail touch points | Expand from 25,000 to 40,000-45,000 | Next 2-3 years |
| Annual capex | ₹40-50 crores every year on brownfield, debottlenecking, value addition | Ongoing; no new greenfield for 10-15 months |
| Inventory days | Improve from 65-66 days to ~60 days | Undated |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Sales volume | 15,465 metric tons, +7% YoY vs 14,518 metric tons |
| Revenue from operations | ₹207.0 crores, -1% YoY vs ₹208.02 crores |
| EBITDA | ₹2.5 crores, vs ₹26 crores in Q2 FY22 |
| Net profit / loss | Net loss of ₹4.8 crores, vs profit of ₹14.1 crores in Q2 FY22 |
| Depreciation | ₹7 crores, vs ₹6.2 crores in Q2 FY22 |
| Finance cost increase | Higher by ₹1.5 crores during Q2 |
| Inventory write-down impact | ~₹15–20 crores (per an analyst's math), from PVC price collapse and destocking |
| PVC resin price decline in Q2 | ~25% collapse in Q2; ~₹30,000 per ton drop |
| PVC resin price decline in Q3 (till Nov 14) | ~12% drop; ~₹10,000 per ton drop so far |
| CPVC growth | 70%–80% YoY in value, H1 FY23 |
| Bath fittings growth | Sub 50% YoY in value |
| Value-added product mix | 55% of revenue, same as last quarter |
| Normalized EBITDA per ton | ₹16,000–₹17,000 per ton (₹17 per kg) |
| Net debt | ₹45.6 crores |
| Annual capacity | 1,31,200 metric tons, increased by 6,000 tons during H1 |
| Working capital cycle | 66 days in H1 FY23, improved from 73 days in H1 FY22 |
| Capex spent in Q2 | ₹8 crores; full year guidance ₹60 crores |