Key Takeaways
- Loss-making quarter, driven by project mix and one-offs: PAT swung to a loss of INR 5.45 cr from a INR 10.87 cr profit YoY, dragged by lower-margin project deliveries and one-time costs of INR 3.62 cr.
- Pre-sales guidance held at INR 2,000 cr: Management reaffirmed the FY25 target despite a Q1 that saw negative sales adjustments in two projects, citing a strong Bhiwadi uptick and upcoming launches.
- Strategic pivot to senior living accelerates: Senior living is now the primary focus for business development, viewed as a less cyclical segment with higher barriers to entry and fewer speculative buyers.
- Pricing power prioritized over velocity in key launch: For the upcoming Amarah Phase 4, management is willing to accept slower sell-out to maximize pricing, a deliberate shift from the strategy used in earlier phases.
- What to watch next quarter: The booking conversion rate for Amarah Phase 4 and ONE44 Phase 2, the extent of the guided Q2 loss, and any progress on closing a senior living land deal in Bengaluru.
Financial Performance & Project-Level Drags
- Revenue flat, profit negative: Total revenue was nearly flat at INR 128.51 cr vs INR 129.29 cr YoY, while the bottom line swung to a loss of INR 5.45 cr. The loss was driven by revenue recognition from the lower-margin Ashiana Shubham 4A project in Chennai, a one-time staff incentive of INR 2.7 cr, and INR 92 lakhs in interest paid to Shubham customers for delayed delivery. The prior year's Q1 also included a one-off profit of INR 4.23 cr from the sale of a school in Bhiwadi.
- Ashiana Shubham’s margin structure was flawed from the start: The project, signed in 2015, carried an unusually high revenue share to the landowner to secure a quick entry into a new city on a developed parcel. This was compounded by unexpected cost overruns from environmental compliances, delayed approvals, and the learning costs of operating in a new city. Management stated these learnings have been factored into newer Chennai projects.
- Newer Chennai projects should carry structurally better margins: Ashiana Vatsalya is expected to have a much lower land cost as a proportion of revenue and lower construction costs relative to Shubham. For Shubham’s own later phases (4B and 5), the margin problem should ease because selling prices have increased substantially.
- Negative sales in two projects were a cleanup, not a demand signal: The negative sales in ONE44 were due to a 30-day cancellation policy for Q4 bookings and a deliberate halt of Phase 1 sales to redo the show flat. In Ashiana Surbhi, the company cancelled old bookings from investors who had bought multiple units during a prior boom and were not paying.
- Quarterly revenue lumpiness is structural: Management cautioned that quarterly delivery variations are inherent to the business, with deliveries bunching up in certain quarters. Q3 and Q4 of this year are bunched up for delivery, while Q2 will be loss-making because only one small delivery is planned. Internally, the company focuses on year-on-year numbers and economic profit, not reported quarterly revenue.
Varun Gupta: "we tend to look at year-on-year numbers internally, we look at economic profit numbers instead of reported revenues because the reported revenues are also sort of reflecting operating decisions that were made about 2-3 years ago. But that said, quarterly variations will remain a part of this business."
Launch Pipeline & Sales Strategy
- Two launches executed in Q1: The third phase of Ashiana Ekansh in Jaipur (premium homes) and the second phase of Ashiana Advik in Bhiwadi (senior living) were launched during the quarter.
- Two critical Q2 launches are now live: Phase 4 of Ashiana Amarah in Gurugram is collecting Expressions of Interest with a RERA in hand, and booking conversion is expected by end of August or early September. ONE44 Phase 2 in Jaipur launched over the weekend with a slight price hike, during a government flood alert; management said it was comfortable with the response given the circumstances.
- Amarah Phase 4 pricing strategy marks a deliberate shift: Unlike earlier phases where the goal was a complete sell-out at launch, management is now willing to accept lower velocity to maximize pricing. They are ambivalent about a full sell-out and are prepared to sell remaining inventory over a few months if needed.
- Bhiwadi market shows a comforting uptick: Without a new project launch and with nothing to sell in Gurugram during Q1, achieving INR 235 cr in overall sales was considered very good, with Bhiwadi’s contribution being the most encouraging sign. The company was able to increase prices in both senior living and regular housing there.
- Supply-side dynamics remain favorable: Management noted that supply is constrained because few developers have strong balance sheets or access to funding, with NBFC and FDI taps largely shut and AIF money remaining small.
Varun Gupta: "We are comfortable to live with having a few unsold stock in Phase 4 as compared to Phase 3. We are hoping that we'll sell out completely, but we have done it in a manner, we are okay to now sell it over a few quarters if required as well or a few months, not a few quarters."
Strategic Pivot to Senior Living
- Senior living is now the primary BD focus: Management stated that more and more business development will happen in senior living, which is seen as less cyclical with fewer players, higher entry barriers, less chance of oversupply, and less speculative buying compared to regular housing.
- The segment is expected to move the needle materially: After Gurugram, the biggest bets are on Vatsalaya, Amodh, and Advik. Management expects senior living to contribute significantly to growth going forward.
- Bengaluru land deal is in progress: Two term sheets were executed for senior living in Bengaluru; one fell through at the diligence stage, while one active term sheet remains. The company hopes to conclude that transaction, then apply for approvals and launch.
- Ashiana Swarang fills a product gap in Chennai: This project is positioned to bridge the gap between Ashiana’s current offering and high-end senior living products like Max Antara. A launch is planned but no specific date was given.
- Land search for senior living is active in Panvel: Management confirmed they are looking for senior living land in Panvel, but not in Jamshedpur, where a different project has been signed.
Market Cycles, Competition & Land
- Real estate cycles are decoupled across cities: Management observed that when NCR was in trouble, Ahmedabad was peaking, and Bhiwadi was in a bad situation despite its proximity to Gurugram. Today, Bhiwadi is moving after the price differential with Gurugram widened, while Ahmedabad is reportedly seeing some delay.
- Land price stabilization is expected: Input costs in construction have not increased substantially, and the input cost that had risen the most, land, is now stabilizing. Management does not expect the kind of land price increases seen previously to continue.
- Competition for land is a bigger concern than competition for sales: New entrants from Mumbai and Bengaluru entering the Gurugram market worry management more on the land acquisition side, specifically whether land prices will get overbid.
- Next Gurugram land parcel targets a premium bracket: Management hopes to reach the INR 3 cr to INR 3.5 cr price bracket for the next Gurugram parcel, but the final decision will depend on market conditions at the time of launch.
- Greater Noida and Jamshedpur add optionality: Earnest money has been deposited for some Greater Noida auctions, and a project in Jamshedpur has been signed, though it is not yet captured in the investor deck.
Balance Sheet, Leverage & Capital Allocation
- Inventory risk is structurally lower this cycle: At the peak of the last downturn, the company held 11 lakh sq ft of completed stock, which was a major drag on the balance sheet. This time, out of 68 lakh sq ft launched, 54 lakh sq ft has been sold, leaving only 14 lakh sq ft to sell, of which 9 lakh sq ft is in projects completing in FY27.
- Willing to take on modest leverage: Management is comfortable taking on a little more leverage than today but will remain cash-rich and keep debt-to-equity low relative to the industry. No QIP is needed right now, and there is no need to manage debt.
Varun Gupta: "So Manu last time, we peaked at about 11 lakhs square foot of completed stock and that was a big drag on the balance sheet for the longest time. This time... if you look, we launched 68 lakhs square foot and we sold 54 lakhs out of this, so we have only 14 to sell and of that 9 lakhs square foot is of projects that will get completed in FY '27."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Pre-sales target | Maintain pre-sales of INR 2,000 crores | FY25 |
| Q2 profitability | Anticipate reporting a loss due to lower planned deliveries | Q2 FY25 |
| Full-year profitability | Second half expected to be healthy in terms of deliveries, leading to reported profits | Full year FY25 |
| Amarah Phase 4 booking conversion | Convert Expressions of Interest to bookings, exact date to be concluded by ~20th August | Before Shradh (Aug/Sep 2024) |
| Amarah Phase 5 launch | Would like to launch | End of CY2024 |
| HSIIDC land parcel launch | Launch slipped due to approval delays | Q1 FY26 |
| Bengaluru senior living deal | Conclude active term sheet, then apply for approvals and launch | No date (hoped to conclude soon) |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY25 |
|---|---|
| Total revenue | ₹128.51 cr, vs ₹129.29 cr in Q1 FY24 |
| PAT | Negative ₹5.45 cr, vs positive ₹10.87 cr in Q1 FY24 |
| Pre-tax operating cash flow | ₹74.92 cr, vs ₹83.15 cr in Q1 FY24 and ₹92.9 cr in Q4 FY24 |
| Area booked | 4.43 lakh sq ft, vs 10.60 lakh sq ft in Q4 FY24 |
| Value of area booked | ₹235.32 cr, vs ₹862.54 cr in Q4 FY24 |
| Area constructed | 4.91 lakh sq ft, vs 6.97 lakh sq ft in Q4 FY24 |
| Area handed over | 2.14 lakh sq ft, of which 2.07 lakh sq ft was Ashiana Shubham Phase 4, Chennai |
| FY25 pre-sales guidance | ₹2,000 cr, maintained |
| Unsold area to sell | ~14 lakh sq ft, of which 9 lakh sq ft completes in FY27 |
| Saleable area pipeline to launch (ex-Milakpur) | ~84-85 lakh sq ft |
| Completed stock (operating) | ~3 lakh sq ft per quarter |
| Amount to collect from ongoing projects | ₹1,700 cr |
| Remaining construction to do | 35 lakh sq ft |
| One-time staff incentive (Q1 distortion) | ₹2.7 cr |
| Interest paid to Shubham customers for delayed delivery (Q1 distortion) | ₹92 lakh |