Key Takeaways
- Strong quarter driven by deliveries and mix: Revenue recognition jumped as Ashiana Daksh Phase 1 was delivered ahead of schedule, while a higher contribution from Gurugram projects lifted average realizations.
- Construction volumes hit by seasonal and launch delays: Slower-than-expected construction in Q3 stemmed from the annual NCR ban, delayed launches, and the growing weight of NCR in the portfolio.
- Land market correction is the key unlock: Management sees clear signs of land prices plateauing and stabilizing, with Gurugram plotting markets slowing down, which could enable land acquisition to scale up again over the next 12 months.
- Margin expansion story is multi-year: Gross profit margins have started improving and management expects to break the 30% blended barrier, but only 2–3 years from now when projects launched this year are delivered.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the two planned Q4 launches execute on time, the pace of land acquisition as markets cool, and any concrete Board-level decision on capital return.
Quarterly Performance & Construction
- Revenue recognition spike: The bulk of revenue in the quarter came from the delivery of Ashiana Daksh Phase 1 in Jaipur, which was completed and handed over ahead of its originally planned Q1 FY24 timeline.
- Realization uplift: A large contribution from Gurugram projects drove the increase in average realizations, as Gurugram had a very large role in both area booked and value of area booked overall.
- Construction volume drag: Three hurdles slowed construction in Q3: the annual NCR construction ban (impact felt more now because the NCR spread in Gurgaon and Bhiwadi has become a larger part of the portfolio), launches getting delayed versus plan, and a third unspecified hurdle.
- Pune traction: Management is fairly satisfied with Ashiana Malhar; 1.20 lakh sq. ft. sold since the Q2 launch, with Q2 being very heavy due to the launch but the current pace on track.
- Operating cash flows: FY21 and FY22 both had great cash flows; FY23 was a little slow because of one blip in a quarter where cash flows were front-loaded for construction before launches and for advertising.
Launches & Project Pipeline
- Q3 launches executed: Ashiana Advik (senior living, Bhiwadi), Phase 3 of Ashiana Anmol (kid-centric, Gurugram), the last phase of Ashiana Umang (kid-centric, Jaipur), and the last phase of Ashiana Dwarka in Jodhpur.
- Ashiana Amarah fully sold on launch: The central Gurugram project saw complete sell-out at launch. RERA has been received for Phase 2 of Amarah.
- Q4 FY23 launches planned: Two fresh projects: Ashiana Ekansh in Jaipur and Ashiana Prakriti in Jamshedpur.
- FY24 launch pipeline: Five new projects planned: two in Jaipur (land in Bhankrota and Murlipura, Jagatpura), Senior Living in Chennai (one at Mahindra World City, another at Nemili), and Ashiana Amodh in Pune (Senior Living). Phase launches will be over and above this.
- Ashiana Amodh progress: In the final leg to get launched; planned sanctions and environmental clearances obtained; in the process of obtaining RERA. Management expects it to have a much bigger dent for the company in Pune.
- Delivery schedule: Generally on track to reported schedule; slippage of a quarter could happen where something planned in March slips to April, technically a quarter slippage but really 15–30 days.
- Near-term deliveries: Q4 FY23 expected at about 6–6.5 lakh sq. ft.; Q1 FY24 at 6.5 lakh sq. ft. across 3 deliveries. Ashiana Daksh Phase 2 could potentially deliver in Q4 FY23 itself; Ashiana Aditya could slip to Q1 FY24.
Varun Gupta: "I think we made a mistake like this of launching the very high side phases earlier when market momentum was high. And then we got stuck with unsold build inventory, which took a bit. So we just want to be careful around that."
Land Market & Business Development
- Land price correction underway: Management senses clear signs of correction; the plotting markets in Gurugram have slowed down considerably, prices have flattened and plateaued, and volumes have started reducing. An oversupply situation on the plot side is expected to help land markets cool off.
- Acquisition posture: The company will continue to keep quoting in the land market but will not be very aggressive on pricing. Land markets are showing signs of collection, plateauing and flattening out; hopefully over the next 12 months the company will be able to add more inventory.
- Geographic focus: Get more work in Gurugram and Jaipur; look at senior living projects elsewhere in the country to expand to more locations. Exploring land parcels for Gurugram and Jaipur, and also exploring other big cities for senior living.
- Scaling condition: Land prices were worrying management and still do; the sense is that prices have started plateauing and stabilizing, and it might be an opportune time to start looking at transactions again. If that happens, the company can scale up further.
Varun Gupta: "I think good news is that on the land front, I can sense some signs of corrections are there. One clear sign is that the plotting markets in Gurugram has slowed down considerably. Prices have flattened and plateaued volumes have started reducing the oversupply situation on the plot side that I see coming, which I think should help land markets cool off a little bit."
Senior Living Strategy
- Absolute target: A 3–4 year view to get senior living value area booked north of ₹300–₹400 crores, with higher overall margins compared to non-senior living.
- Margin ambition: Aiming for gross profit margins about 3%–5% points higher than general housing.
- Cyclicality reduction: Senior living expansion is expected to reduce cyclicality in operations, which management views as more important than reported-number cyclicality driven by accounting norms.
- Geographic expansion: Senior living projects being explored in Chennai (two projects in FY24 pipeline) and Pune (Ashiana Amodh), alongside the existing Bhiwadi presence.
Varun Gupta: "Absolutely, we would like to reduce - more than the cyclicality in the reported numbers, cyclicality in the operations. Reported numbers have some cyclicality driven by accounting norms. That's not the bigger worry. The bigger thing is the cyclicality in the real estate cycle itself and how we can protect ourselves from it."
Margins & Profitability
- Margin expansion zone: Management expects to be in a margin expansion zone; gross profit margins have started improving and should break the 30% barrier on a blended average basis, possibly 2–3 years from now when projects launched this year are delivered.
- Phase-level margin uplift: Later phases of projects like Ashiana Amantran Phase 3 and Ashiana Umang Phase 6 will have better gross profit margins because prices in later phases have been higher.
- Reported profitability lumpiness: From a reported perspective, consistent profitability is difficult because deliveries can get bunched up; management looks at operating cash flows as the metric for operational positivity.
- Pre-sales growth expectation: 20–25% pre-sales increase expected to be imported as senior living and deeper market penetration play out.
Varun Gupta: "My view and expectations are that we are in a margin expansion zone. And gross profit margins have started improving and will, I think, continue to improve and we should break that 30% barrier on a blended average basis. Not now, but it may be 2 - 3 years from now when we deliver some of the projects which have been launched in this year."
Capital Return & Shareholder Discussions
- Capital return under discussion: A few discussions have been held at Executive Board member levels on buybacks, dividends, and capital return thought processes; not yet at full Board level.
- Described as a process: Management is discussing, deliberating, and trying to wrap up their heads around it; no timeline or specific structure has been decided.
Varun Gupta: "We are discussing and deliberating and trying to wrap up our heads around it. I think it's a process..."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Construction trajectory | 20–25 lakh sq. ft. zone annually | From next year onwards (FY24) |
| Q4 FY23 launches | Two fresh projects: Ashiana Ekansh (Jaipur) and Ashiana Prakriti (Jamshedpur) | Q4 FY23 |
| FY24 new project launches | Five new projects: two in Jaipur, two Senior Living in Chennai, one Senior Living in Pune | FY24 |
| Q4 FY23 deliveries | About 6–6.5 lakh sq. ft. | Q4 FY23 |
| Q1 FY24 deliveries | 6.5 lakh sq. ft. across 3 deliveries | Q1 FY24 |
| Blended gross profit margin | Break the 30% barrier | 2–3 years from now |
| Senior living value booked | North of ₹300–₹400 crores | 3–4 year view |
| Senior living margin premium | Gross profit margins 3%–5% points higher than general housing | Over the medium term |
| Land acquisition | Add more inventory as land markets cool | Over the next 12 months |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Total revenue | ₹135.31 cr, up from ₹91.72 cr in Q2 FY23 |
| Total Comprehensive Income | ₹9.29 cr, improved from negative ₹1.31 cr in Q2 FY23 |
| Pre-tax operating cash flows | ₹35.6 cr, versus negative ₹1.05 cr in Q2 FY23 |
| Area booked | 9.03 lakh sq. ft. |
| Total sales value (Apr–Dec 2022) | ₹877.62 cr |
| Area delivered | 3.6 lakh sq. ft., up from 2.07 lakh sq. ft. in Q2 and 2.11 lakh sq. ft. in Q1 |
| Area constructed | 3.42 lakh sq. ft., down from 4.38 lakh sq. ft. in Q2 FY23 |
| Gross profit margin (underwritten) | 30%; older projects averaging 27%–28% |
| Selling costs | 4%–4.25% on average, range of 2%–8% across projects |
| Gurugram share of area sold | More than half of total square footage sold in the quarter |
| Senior living value area booked (FY23 expected) | ₹150 cr |
| Senior living gross margin target vs general housing | 3%–5% points higher than general housing |
| Unsold inventory (as of 31 Dec 2022) | 20 lakh sq. ft., with sales value of about ₹15 cr (management stated "₹15 crores and 20 lakhs sq. ft. to sell") |
| Land available for future development | ~50 lakh sq. ft., with sales value of about ₹1 cr (excluding Bhiwadi, Milakpur, Kolkata) (management stated "₹1 crores about 50 lakh square foot to sell") |
| Q4 FY23 expected deliveries | 6–6.5 lakh sq. ft. |
| FY24 planned launches | 30 lakh sq. ft. (0.3 cr sq. ft.), split roughly 10–15 lakh sq. ft. new projects and 10–15 lakh sq. ft. new phases |
| Units sold (Apr–Dec 2022) | ~1,200 units, average ticket size around ₹70 lakhs |