Key Takeaways
- Pre-sales target doubled, stretched but backed by launches: Management set an aspirational FY'23 pre-sales target of ₹1,100 Crores, nearly double the ₹573 Crores achieved in FY'22, supported by a pipeline of 25–30 lakh sq ft in phase launches.
- Land price inflation is now the primary constraint: Land prices have doubled in many markets over 12 months, making new projects unviable without unreasonable assumptions; management calls this a bigger challenge than capital availability.
- Profitability pivot underway, but reported ROE lags: The company is shifting focus from top-line growth to achieving a 15% return on equity; double-digit reported ROE is targeted for FY'23, but teens on a reported basis remain "a little further away."
- Gurgaon emerges as a growth engine, Pune remains a worry: Gurgaon is expected to contribute over a quarter of FY'23 sales value as group housing supply tightens; Pune projects have not yet broken ground and remain a drag on returns.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the three RERA-filed projects launch on schedule in Q2 FY'23, the pace of land acquisitions against the ₹200 Crore budget, and any sign of demand softening if home loan rates cross 8.5%.
The FY'23 Pre-Sales Ambition
- Target jump: The internal stretched target of ₹1,100 Crores compares to ₹573 Crores in FY'22, with management confident of crossing at least ₹1,000 Crores given the positive environment and available inventory.
- Launch pipeline: 25–30 lakh sq ft of phase launches planned, split between ~12 lakh sq ft of new phases in existing projects and 15–20 lakh sq ft of first phases in new Greenfield projects.
- Gurgaon's weight: Two Gurgaon projects together are expected to contribute more than a quarter of total sales value, with the new Greenfield project being a large contributor and Ashiana Anmol expected to improve on its FY'22 performance.
- Price lift: Average sales price is expected to cross ₹4,500 per sq ft in FY'23, up from ₹3,883 in FY'22, driven by price increases and a mix shift toward higher-priced Gurgaon inventory.
- Launch timing risk: Three projects with RERA applications filed (Pune, Gurgaon, Bhiwadi) are expected to launch in Q2 FY'23 but may carry forward to Q3.
Varun Gupta: "So, the company is looking at crossing about the Rs. 1,000 Crores mark and we are looking at Rs 1,100 Crores pre-sale number this year as compared to Rs. 573 Crores that we did in FY'22. So, that is the internal target, they are a little stretched, but I think right now the environment is very positive and we have inventory to sell."
Land: The Real Constraint
- Price surge: Land prices have doubled in many places over the last 12 months; Chennai land prices are up 1.5x–2x, and the plotted layout market is driving increases across Jaipur, Gurgaon, and Jamshedpur.
- Viability squeeze: Management states that doubled land prices make new projects unviable unless assumptions become unreasonable, calling land price navigation a much bigger challenge than capital.
- Competitive pressure: High competition from plotted layout players in Jaipur, Gurgaon, and Jamshedpur is bidding up land, though competition from developers wanting to do construction is lower.
- Acquisition strategy: FY'23 planned spend on land acquisitions is ~₹200 Crores, with a preference for JV structures to keep the balance sheet capital-light; one new Jaipur transaction (~6.5 lakh sq ft) closed about ten days ago.
- Land bank flexibility: Management may work with a lower threshold of ~4x annual sales (vs historical 5–7x), will not go below 4 or above 8, and will be more flexible year-to-year.
- Scouting priorities: Actively scouting for 1–2 more transactions in Jaipur (where plotted market is "behaving irrationally and very frothy"), plus more in Jamshedpur and Gurgaon.
Varun Gupta: "The land prices in the last 12 months have gone beyond double - they have doubled up in a lot of places and that just makes new projects unviable unless and until we start looking at assumptions which are not reasonable. So, I think navigating that is a much bigger challenge than capital."
Profitability & Margin Trajectory
- ROE pivot: Management thinking has moved from top-line focus to needing a 15% return on equity; double-digit reported ROE is targeted for FY'23, but teens on a reported basis are deferred.
- Margin expansion phase: In older projects being reported, increased prices and increased costs are more or less covered; projects sold this year or this quarter have better margins than they would have had a year or two ago.
- New project gross margins: Hoping for ~30% blended gross margins on new sales; JV revenue-share deals may compress that to 24–27% because capital employed is lower.
- Reported margin lag: On a reported basis, the full benefit of better-margin new sales is still about three years away.
- Cost levers: Finance costs have come down and are decreasing quarter-on-quarter; non-selling SG&A expected to grow 15–20% next year; selling expenses pegged at ~4.5% of revenues going forward.
- Senior Living margin advantage: Senior living projects carry less competition, a differentiated product, and better gross margins, contributing to margin expansion.
Varun Gupta: "I think the thinking in the company has moved around is moved from just thinking top line to thinking we need 15% return on equity. Let us figure out how to get there."
City-Level Scorecard
| Location | Status | Commentary |
|---|---|---|
| Gurgaon | ▲ Turning positive | Was not doing well; now opening up. FY'24 onwards expected to hit minimum profitability and return thresholds on an internal economic basis. Group housing supply is becoming a rarity after being heavily over-supplied ~4 years ago. |
| Chennai | ▲ Performing | Has hit minimum profitability and ROCE targets; more capital deployed to take it to the next level. |
| Pune | ▼ Worry | Projects not off the ground yet; Ashiana Malhar RERA application filed, hoping to kick off. Focus is on how long to get to minimum ROCE threshold. |
| Jaipur | ▬ Core, frothy land | Core market but plotted market is frothy and irrational; scouting for 1–2 more transactions where land prices make sense. |
| Bhiwadi | ▲ Senior Living opportunity | Senior Living opportunity becoming very large; RERA filed for Ashiana Advik Phase-1. |
| Jamshedpur | ▬ Fringe | On the fringes in scale; will consistently attempt to get some volume, though not to Jaipur's extent. |
| Jodhpur | ▼ Lacks depth | Lacks market depth; limited opportunities. |
| Kolkata | ▼ Stalled | No updates; difficult situation. |
| Milakpur | ▼ Status quo | Working to free up capital by selling land, but difficult to execute. |
| Ranchi | ✕ Exited | Decided not to explore Ranchi as a market right now. |
Varun Gupta: "The kind of projects we are looking to do is group housing, it is a rarity right now in launches in Gurgaon, so the kind of product we want to do, which was heavily over supplied about four years ago, I think it is getting into an under supply scenario now."
Capital & Balance Sheet
- Capital adequacy: Substantial liquidity available; no additional capital requirements in the short-term; IFC line in place with a little still to be disbursed.
- Growth funding capacity: Enough capital to lock in another 50 lakh sq ft today, or 60–70 lakh sq ft if on JV terms; improving ROEs will throw in profits to fund growth.
- JV trade-off: JV structures keep the balance sheet capital-light but revenue-share ratios compress margins and ROEs, a challenge management acknowledges.
- Stuck capital: Capital stuck in underperforming projects (Milakpur, Kolkata) is expected to be released, though execution remains difficult.
- Peer capital constraint: Availability of capital remains a constraint limiting new construction supply across the industry; new developers are entering with clean balance sheets but capital remains the biggest constraint for peers.
Demand Environment & Cycle View
- Affordability peak: Management believes the cycle is turning from compression to expansion, with best-ever affordability for home buyers as the cycle of unit price increases and size compression reverses.
- Rate sensitivity threshold: Comfortable with home loan rates up to ~8.5%; demand would start slowing down beyond that. Across tier 1 and tier 2 cities, demand is expected to be agnostic to rate increases of 1.5%–2%.
- Commodity cost mitigation: Minimal impact on projects where construction was quick (Ashiana Daksh, Ashiana Aditya) because the time gap between sale price lock-in and construction cost incurrence was short; hurt felt in Ashiana Amantran Phase-II where Phase-II was sold a year before full-fledged construction started.
- Construction speed as a moat: Management runs projects on tight schedules, so the problem of locked-in sales prices with far-longer construction timelines does not hurt them the way it hurts many players.
Varun Gupta: "I think, the cycle is just turning the other way around where we are seeing best ever affordability for people to buy homes and the cycle is turning."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Pre-sales value | Cross ₹1,000 Crores, aspirational ₹1,100 Crores | FY'23 |
| Phase launches | 25–30 lakh sq ft total (~12 lakh sq ft existing phases, 15–20 lakh sq ft new Greenfield first phases) | FY'23 |
| Average sales price | Cross ₹4,500 per sq ft | FY'23 |
| Reported ROE | Double-digit | FY'23 |
| Economic basis ROE | Teens | FY'23 |
| Greenfield project launches | Three in H1, three in H2; three RERA-filed projects (Pune, Gurgaon, Bhiwadi) expected Q2, may carry to Q3 | FY'23 |
| Land acquisition spend | ~₹200 Crores, lower if JV structures used | FY'23 |
| Senior Living contribution | 6–8 lakh sq ft per year | Ongoing target |
| Chennai, Gurgaon, Pune area mix | ~40% of area contribution, higher on revenue | Ongoing target |
| Gurgaon profitability | Hit minimum threshold of profitability and return on internal economic basis | FY'24 onwards |
| Sales run rate | Expand from minimum 0.2 Cr sq ft to 0.25–0.3 Cr sq ft per annum | Ongoing target |
| Gross margin on new sales | ~30% blended (JV deals 24–27%) | On new sales, reported benefit ~3 years out |
| Home loan rate comfort | Demand slows beyond 8.5% | Condition-based |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY22 |
|---|---|
| Total revenue | ₹78.28 cr, up from ₹54.19 cr in Q3 FY22 |
| Total Comprehensive Income (TCI) | ₹9.22 cr, versus negative ₹3.28 cr in Q3 FY22 |
| Area booked | 4.53 lakh sq ft, up from 4.21 lakh sq ft in Q3 FY22 |
| Average sales price | ₹4,093 per sq ft, above ₹4,000 run rate for second consecutive quarter |
| Equivalent Area Constructed (EAC) | 5.07 lakh sq ft, versus 3.73 lakh sq ft in Q3 FY22 and 3.90 lakh sq ft in Q4 FY21 |
| FY22 total revenue | ₹233.59 cr, down from ₹259.31 cr in FY21 due to lower deliveries |
| FY22 Total Comprehensive Income | negative ₹6.56 cr, versus positive ₹4.08 cr in FY21; includes ₹4.26 cr provision for misappropriation of funds |
| FY22 area booked | 14.76 lakh sq ft, versus 14.97 lakh sq ft in FY21 |
| FY22 value of area booked | ₹573.25 cr, up from ₹534.68 cr in FY21 |
| FY22 average sales price | ₹3,883 per sq ft, up from ₹3,571 per sq ft in FY21 |
| FY22 handovers | 8.86 lakh sq ft, versus 8.55 lakh sq ft in FY21 |
| FY22 pretax operating cash flows | ₹165.05 cr, versus ₹171.65 cr in FY21; positive in all four quarters |
| FY22 Equivalent Area Constructed | 16.2 lakh sq ft, versus 11.66 lakh sq ft in FY21 |
| FY23 pre-sales target | ₹1,100 cr (aspirational), versus ₹573 cr in FY22; will definitely cross ₹1,000 cr |
| FY23 expected average sales price | crossing ₹4,500 per sq ft |
| FY23 phase launches planned | 25–30 lakh sq ft total; ~12 lakh sq ft new phases of existing projects, 15–20 lakh sq ft first phases of new Greenfield projects |
| New land parcels acquired in FY22 | 6 parcels, total potential salable area ~61 lakh sq ft: Gurgaon (22.1 acres, Kid Centric), Pune Varale (11.93 acres, Senior Living), Jaipur (8.6 acres, Comfort Homes), Jamshedpur (3.96 acres), two in Chennai |
| FY22 spend on new acquisitions | ~₹250–260 cr (own equity, IFC line, deposits to landowners) |
| FY23 planned spend on land acquisitions | ~₹200 cr, lower if JV structures used |
| Total saleable inventory | ~1 cr sq ft, with sale value of ~₹5,000 cr at ₹4,500 per sq ft average |
| Senior Living target contribution | 6–8 lakh sq ft per year |
| Chennai, Gurgaon, Pune target mix | ~40% of area, ~45% on revenue framework |
| Average flat area sold | ~1,350–1,400 sq ft, up ~10% from 1,200–1,250 sq ft a few years ago |
| FY22 standalone SG&A (employee + admin) | ~₹66 cr, of which ₹18–20 cr is selling expenses |
| FY22 finance costs | ₹60–65 cr, declining quarter-on-quarter; expected to come down significantly |
| Comfortable home loan interest rate threshold | ~8.5%; demand agnostic to rate increases up to 1.5–2% |