Key Takeaways
- Record pre-sales, volume and price both up: FY23 pre-sales hit a company-high ₹1,313 crores, with area booked rising 75% YoY and average sales price climbing 31% YoY, driven by 5 new launches and a mix shift toward higher-priced projects.
- Base-case realizations have structurally reset: Management now treats ₹4,000/sq ft as the new normal, up from ₹3,300–₹3,400/sq ft two years ago, a 15%–20% portfolio-wide step-up that it believes is sustainable.
- Gurgaon is now the value engine: The city contributed 40% of FY23 booking value on lower volumes but much higher prices, and a newly acquired HSIIDC land parcel plus brand establishment at Amarah position it as a key growth driver.
- Margins and returns are inflecting from a depressed base: EBITDA margins were compressed by low volumes against a fixed overhead base; with scale returning, management targets 30% blended gross margins on new projects and expects economic ROE to cross 15% in FY24.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the ₹1,500 crore FY24 pre-sales target stays on track as quarterly lumpiness continues, the pace of land bank replenishment given management’s view that plot prices are plateauing, and progress on non-core asset cleanup.
Pre-Sales & Realizations
- Volume and price both contributed: Area booked rose 75% YoY to 25.86 lakh sq ft while average sales price increased 31% YoY to ₹5,080/sq ft, reflecting both price hikes across projects and a changing mix toward higher-priced locations like Gurgaon.
- Q4 was launch-driven: Q4 FY23 area booked of 8.59 lakh sq ft was propelled by new launches at Ashiana Prakriti (Jamshedpur) and Ashiana Ekansh (Jaipur), plus sustained sales in older projects such as Ashiana Anmol Phase 3 (Gurugram) and Shubham Phase 4 (Chennai).
- The ₹4,000/sq ft reset: Management stated the base-case realization has shifted from ₹3,300–₹3,400/sq ft to ₹4,000/sq ft, a 15%–20% increase over 24 months, and expects this level to hold across the portfolio.
- Pricing outlook is deliberately not forecast: Management declined to give a year-on-year price increase outlook, noting it would not have predicted the last two years’ rise and cannot call it going forward.
- Like-for-like pricing is untracked: When asked for like-for-like pricing improvement excluding project mix, management said it does not do such tracking because projects differ across years and weighted averages become problematic.
Varun Gupta: "I think, ₹4,000 per square foot is our new normal. So normal earlier was, I think, ₹3,300-₹3,400 square foot to operate on like a base case scenario. I think that base case scenario has shifted to ₹4,000 per square foot."
Project Launches & Land Pipeline
- Five launches drove the record year: FY23 saw greenfield or new-phase launches at Ashiana Amarah (Gurugram, kid-centric, Phase 1 and Phase 2), Ashiana Prakriti (Jamshedpur), Ashiana Advik (Bhiwadi, senior living), Ashiana Malhar (Pune), and Ashiana Ekansh (Jaipur), together adding 29.46 lakh sq ft of saleable area.
- Two Jaipur land parcels acquired: Ashiana Nitara (Bhankrota, ~6.5 lakh sq ft saleable) and Amaltas by Ashiana (Jagatpura, ~5 lakh sq ft saleable) were added in FY23, deepening the company’s presence in a market where it has high pricing confidence.
- Gurgaon HSIIDC plot secured: The transaction closed in March 2023; management expects a 12–18 month timeline to launch after design and approvals, and then 5–7 years to fully consume the project depending on phasing.
- Active negotiations for ~20 lakh sq ft: Two new projects are under discussion, one in Jaipur and one elsewhere, which would add meaningfully to the land bank if closed.
- Land price view is turning cautious: Management observed that plot prices, which were “fundamentally off the charts,” have started plateauing or falling in a few markets, and it is waiting for more conducive pricing before adding aggressively.
- Senior living pipeline expanding: A pre-launch process has been activated for a senior living project in Talegaon (Pune), and management sees a large part of senior living growth coming from Chennai and Pune, where the market has increased substantially.
Varun Gupta: "I think they have started correcting now. I think plot prices are either plateaued or started falling a little bit in a few markets. I think they were fundamentally off the charts."
Margins, Profitability & Returns
- EBITDA margins were volume-depressed, not structurally broken: Overheads were structured for a much larger set of operations; when square footage volumes declined, margins got hurt. With volumes now recovering, operating leverage should reverse.
- 30% blended gross margin is the target: Projects signed off after 2015 are expected to maintain 30% or more; the five projects launched last year carry a blended average gross margin expectation above 30%. Older projects like Ashiana Anmol will not reach that threshold even at current prices, and JV projects are acceptable at 27–29%.
- PAT margin guided at 13%–15%: Management expects to operate in this range, dependent on blended gross profit margin and sales and marketing costs, which are running at 4%–4.5% on new projects and trending downward.
- ROE crossed double digits, 15% is the near-term target: Economic ROE improved year-on-year in FY23 into double-digit territory, and management expects it to begin crossing the 15% threshold from FY24, using a thumb-rule approach rather than complex IRR models.
- Growth is calibrated to ROE: Management targets mid-to-low teens growth, approximating 15% ROE minus a couple of percentage points for dividend, absent any capital raise.
Varun Gupta: "We don't really do IRR calculations. We don't run very complex excel sheets to do IRR calculations, we have very thumb rule mathematics. And in thumb rule of mathematics at the company level, we are looking for a 15% return on equity at the portfolio company level, including uninvested capital at any point in time."
Market Position & Competitive Dynamics
- Supply-side consolidation is a tailwind: Management’s view is that the number of developers left is very low and supply has not increased materially, leaving the road “empty” and allowing surviving players to press the accelerator.
- Design is treated as the competitive moat: Management acknowledged that Ashiana takes a long time to design because design is its “winning edge,” a deliberate trade-off that delays launches but supports pricing and brand.
- Gurgaon brand establishment is paying off: Phase 1 of Amarah helped establish the brand in Gurgaon; Phase 2 pricing improved as the brand got better recognized and market prices rose due to lack of supply. Gurgaon will play a very key role going forward.
- Geography focus is consolidating: Outside senior living, the company will concentrate on existing geographies. In NCR, the focus has shifted to Gurgaon. For senior living, it is evaluating a couple of additional cities.
- Base-scale ambition is a doubling in five years: Management would ideally like to change the base scale of the company to twice what it is within a five-year threshold; in an up-cycle, base scale would be about 25–30 lakh sq ft, and it believes the real estate cycle is still in its early years.
Varun Gupta: "According to me, there is still not a lot of increase in the supply side. It is to be said that all the developers are pressing the accelerator because the number of developers left is very less. So, the road is empty because there is no traffic, so everyone has kept the accelerator pressed."
Financial Position & Governance
- Revenue grew on higher deliveries: Total revenue increased to ₹425.19 crores in FY23 from ₹233.59 crores in FY22, supported by 10.51 lakh sq ft of deliveries versus 8.86 lakh sq ft in the prior year.
- Comprehensive income turned positive: Total comprehensive income was ₹28.78 crores in FY23 compared to a negative ₹6.56 crores in FY22, reflecting improved operational performance.
- Operating cash flows declined: Pre-tax operating cash flows fell to ₹84.84 crores in FY23 from ₹165.05 crores in FY22, a point to monitor as launches scale.
- Internal controls were strengthened: The company changed its internal auditor to Grant Thornton, migrated accounting systems to Farvision ERP (a real estate industry standard), and brought more seniority and experience into the finance team. Management described internal controls as sufficient but stopped short of calling them bulletproof.
- Non-core asset cleanup is underway: One McDonald’s property on rent was disposed of last year; other non-core assets, including legacy Calcutta projects, are being considered for disposal. The hotel in Bhiwadi will not be sold.
Varun Gupta: "Sir, I can't say it is bulletproof. I am not 100% sure. According to me, that is not a view I can take that it is bulletproof. But our internal controls are sufficient."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| FY24 pre-sales target | ₹1,500 crores value of area booked, growth over FY23 | FY24 |
| FY24 deliveries | ~26 lakh sq ft | FY24 |
| Blended gross margin on new projects | 30% or more on projects signed after 2015; older projects and JVs may fall short | Ongoing, project-life |
| PAT margin | Operate at 13%–15% | Ongoing |
| Economic ROE | Cross 15% threshold | FY24 onward |
| Growth rate | Mid-to-low teens, approximating 15% ROE minus dividend, absent capital raise | Ongoing |
| Gurgaon HSIIDC project launch | Launch after design and approvals | 12–18 months from March 2023 deal close |
| Base scale ambition | Double the company’s base scale | Within 5 years |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Total revenue | ₹116.94 cr, vis-a-vis ₹135.31 cr in Q3 FY23 |
| Total comprehensive income | ₹10.51 cr, versus ₹9.29 cr in Q3 FY23 |
| Area booked | 8.59 lakh sq ft, compared to 9.03 lakh sq ft in Q3 FY23 |
| FY23 total revenue | ₹425.19 cr, versus ₹233.59 cr in FY22 |
| FY23 total comprehensive income | ₹28.78 cr, vis-a-vis negative ₹6.56 cr in FY22 |
| FY23 pre-sales (value of area booked) | ₹1,313.43 cr, highest ever |
| FY23 area booked | 25.86 lakh sq ft, up 75% from 14.76 lakh sq ft in FY22 |
| FY23 sales price | ₹5,080 per sq ft, versus ₹3,883 per sq ft in FY22, an increase of 31% YoY |
| FY23 handovers (deliveries) | 10.51 lakh sq ft, against 8.86 lakh sq ft in FY22 |
| FY23 pre-tax operating cash flows | ₹84.84 cr, versus positive ₹165.05 cr in FY22 |
| FY23 equivalent area constructed | 16.73 lakh sq ft, versus 16.20 lakh sq ft in FY22 |
| FY24 pre-sales guidance | ₹1,500 cr value of area booked |
| FY24 planned deliveries | ~26 lakh sq ft |
| FY23 economic ROE | double digits, directionally targeting 15% |
| Target gross margin on new projects | 30% blended across projects |
| Booked but not recognized stock | ~₹2,100 cr |
| Remaining land bank sales value potential | ~₹5,500 cr blended |
| Ashiana Amarah Phase 2 pricing | ₹7,700 per sq ft average, versus ₹6,100 per sq ft in Phase 1 |
| Ashiana Amarah Phase 2 sales value | ~₹283 cr, all 224 units converted on 17 April 2023 |
| Ashiana Prakriti Phase 1 sales value | ₹163 cr, 162 units, entire Phase 1 sold at launch |
| New land parcels acquired in Jaipur (FY23) | 2 parcels: Ashiana Nitara ~6.5 lakh sq ft saleable area; Amaltas by Ashiana ~5 lakh sq ft saleable area |
| FY23 value of area booked from Gurgaon | 40% of total |
| Base scale of company in a down cycle | 14–15 lakh sq ft and roughly ₹700–₹750 cr sale |