Key Takeaways
- Record sales value, margin story still unfolding: FY24 sales value hit a record ₹1,798.22 crores, but quarterly margins swung sharply depending on which project delivered, and management expects a multi-year margin expansion arc from here.
- Guidance is deliberately conservative: The FY25 pre-sales target of ₹2,000 crores assumes buoyant markets and on-schedule launches, yet management builds in a buffer because "Murphy's law" applies and projects can underperform or slip.
- Senior living is the strategic center of gravity: Management sees larger opportunities, less competition, and better returns in senior living, and plans to allocate a rising share of capital there over the next 2-3 years, targeting 900-1,000 units annually in the medium term.
- Land acquisition is returns-first, not growth-first: The company will accept cyclically off years rather than chase volume, waiting for the right parcels on the right terms, with two Bangalore term sheets in play but a 50% failure rate acknowledged.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the two Bangalore senior living term sheets convert, the launch of Ashiana Amarah Phase-4 and Phase-5, and any progress on the Sector 80 Gurugram project approval.
Sales Performance & Drivers
- Record year: FY24 sales value of ₹1,798.22 crores was the highest ever, driven by rising prices across projects and a mix shift toward higher-priced projects.
- Price realization jump: Per sq ft price improved 34% YoY, reflecting both price increases and the changing project mix.
- Q4 bookings mix: The quarter was driven by Ashiana Amarah Phase-3 in Gurugram, One44 in Jaipur, and Vatsalya in Chennai.
- Revenue doubled: Total revenue more than doubled due to higher deliveries and the mix shift toward higher-price projects.
- Launch cadence: FY24 saw 10 project launches (4 Greenfield, 6 new phases) totalling 23.19 lakh sq ft, including two fully-booked phases of Ashiana Amarah and new senior living projects in Pune and Chennai.
Margin Dynamics
- Quarterly swings are project-driven: Q3 margins were healthy due to delivery of Ashiana Nirmay (senior living, Bhiwadi) with good margins from historical land cost and premium pricing; Q4 margins compressed because deliveries came from joint venture projects (Aditya, Dwarka, Amantran) with heavier land costs and cost overruns that ran a little above expectations.
- Annual margins stable: Annual margins compared to last year are very similar or actually better; the quarterly variation is a function of which project gets delivered in which quarter.
- Construction cost inflation is manageable: Costs are rising from general inflation (a few percentage points) and from moving into higher-spec projects with basements, taller buildings, and upgraded common areas, but as a percentage of sales price, gross profit margin is expected to expand.
- No material cost overruns: Management sees no noticeable cost overruns in any important projects and expects margins to improve going forward.
- Multi-year margin expansion promised: Management expects margins to improve in FY25, with FY26 better than FY25 and FY27 better than FY26; gross profit margins are expanding and indirect cost as a percentage of revenues should be lower in FY27 than FY24, though FY25 indirect expenses as a percentage may be slightly higher because the revenue mix will not change that much.
Varun Gupta: "I think as the cycle keeps going, we probably get to after tax profit margins and the TCI margins closer to 17%-18% gradually as we go ahead."
Senior Living Strategy
- Capital allocation tilting toward senior living: Management sees larger overall opportunities in senior living, a space with relatively less competition that allows differentiation and better margins and returns; senior living will play a larger mix going forward.
- Scale ambition: Medium-term target of 900-1,000 units a year, up from 354, implying 2x-2.5x growth in the next 3-4 years; the business could be 3x in 4-5 years with price expansion.
- Geography pipeline: Evaluating Bangalore (two term sheets signed), a closer-to-Mumbai location, and Greater Noida and Gurugram for NCR.
- Premium positioning: Management wants to do more premium senior living, agnostic to location as long as value can be created, and needs larger-scale parcels (acreage) to deliver a differentiated lifestyle.
- Full-project commitment, no hybrids: The company will not mix senior living towers within normal projects; it will only do full senior living projects because hybrid projects do not create the value a senior living consumer wants.
- Term sheet reality: Two term sheets in Bangalore are in play on a revenue-share basis, but management acknowledges roughly a 50% failure rate on term sheets.
- J-curve timing is unknowable: Management admits it cannot predict when the senior living J-curve will inflect, though it expects things to change "sooner rather than later."
Varun Gupta: "We don't think hybrid projects are the way to go. We don't think they create the value that a senior living consumer wants… We want to do a full senior living projects wherever we want to go. And so therefore our commitment to the sector is very different than just doing 2 towers of senior living in a particular project."
Guidance & Pre-Sales Outlook
- FY25 pre-sales target of ₹2,000 crores: An internal target that assumes the market remains buoyant and phases launch as scheduled; heavily dependent on Gurugram.
- Conservative by design: Management takes a conservative view of the market and builds in buffer because projects may underperform, launch delays may occur, and "Murphy's law" applies.
- Key launch assumptions: Ashiana Amarah Phase-4 and Phase-5 are hoped to launch in this financial year; the Sector 80 Gurugram project is hoped to launch in Q4 of this year, or if not then Q1 of next year, with approvals underway and an EC applied for.
- Management declined to split the pre-sales target by geography when asked, and deflected a question on whether the ₹2,000 crores figure looks conservative excluding Ashiana Amarah.
Varun Gupta: "In my experience in life, there has been only one law that is always applied and that's been Murphy's law. So, we are conservative in that front."
Capital Allocation & Returns
- Returns-first philosophy: Management will focus on returns on capital more than growth, accepting that some years may be cyclically off, and will take calculated risks only where opportunities are seen.
- ROE target of 15%: May not be hit this year due to lumpy deliveries, but FY26 will definitely hit 15% ROE if things go as per plan; economic ROE crossed the 15% threshold in FY24 and there is a 12-24 month lag, so if not this year then next year.
- Cash flow confidence: Management expects to continue enjoying very good cash flows and profits from existing stock, more than previously thought.
- Buyback vs dividend: Buybacks are expensive to execute for small amounts due to fixed costs and make sense only when distributing a larger amount of cash; at this point the company wants more cash for acquisitions, so a dividend was given instead, and buybacks will not happen every year.
- Land acquisition posture: No broad target for new land purchases or geographies; the approach is to keep things moving and wait for opportunities until something bigger comes, enjoying the up cycle while focusing on returns on capital.
Varun Gupta: "We will try to focus on returns on capital more and growth less. So, we might have years that might be cyclically off and I think we, as a management team, have decided that we should be comfortable with those and take calculated risks where we see opportunities."
IFC Platform & Project Updates
- Platform one nearly complete: Ashiana Daksh is effectively complete with only a few connections and last expenses remaining; Ashiana Amarah and Ashiana Vatsalya are launched and under construction.
- Platform two undeployed: Yet to deploy any capital, actively engaging on projects.
- Chennai Swarang structure: A 50-50 partnership with Arihant Group where land was bought at cost together, a fee covers administrative costs, and profit is shared 50-50; the project's ROE is effectively the company's ROE.
- Jamshedpur term sheet executed: A term sheet has been executed for a land parcel in Jamshedpur.
- Mumbai-adjacent term sheet slipped: The term sheet for a senior living project near Mumbai (Panvel) slipped through.
- IFC debenture structure: Management declined to explain the financial payout structure for Ashiana Amarah's listed debenture on the call, citing complexity and urging analysts to review the debenture documents directly.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Pre-sales target | ₹2,000 crores, assumes buoyant market and on-schedule launches | FY25 |
| Margin expansion | After-tax profit margins and TCI margins closer to 17%-18% | Gradually, no specific year |
| ROE target | 15% ROE | FY26 (if not FY25) |
| Ashiana Amarah Phase-4 and 5 launch | Both phases to launch | FY25 |
| Sector 80 Gurugram launch | Project launch, subject to approvals | Q4 FY25, or Q1 FY26 if delayed |
| Senior living unit scale | 900-1,000 units annually (2x-2.5x from 354) | Next 3-4 years |
| Senior living business scale | 3x from current | Next 4-5 years |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Sales value (FY24) | ₹1,798.22 cr, highest ever, vs ₹1,313.43 cr in FY23 |
| Sales price per sq ft (FY24) | ₹6,811, up 34% YoY from ₹5,080 |
| Area booked | 10.6 lakh sq ft, vs 3.35 lakh sq ft in Q3 FY24 |
| Total revenue (FY24) | ₹966.52 cr, more than doubled from ₹425.19 cr in FY23 |
| Total comprehensive income (FY24) | ₹84.24 cr, vs ₹28.78 cr in FY23 |
| PAT margin (FY24) | ~9% |
| Area handed over (FY24) | 24.78 lakh sq ft, vs 10.51 lakh sq ft in FY23 |
| FY25 pre-sales target | ₹2,000 cr (internal target) |
| FY25 construction target | 25-26 lakh sq ft |
| Launched area remaining for construction | 34 lakh sq ft (out of 62 lakh sq ft launched) |
| Future launch pipeline (ex-Milakpur) | 80-90 lakh sq ft between future phases and land banks |
| Target GP margin on JV projects | 27% to 30% |
| Senior living unit target (medium-term) | 900-1,000 units/year, up from ~354 units/year; 2x-2.5x in 3-4 years |
| Ashiana Amarah Phase-3 sale price | ₹11,600/sq ft |
| Ashiana Amarah remaining saleable area | 0.91 cr sq ft (Phase-4 and 5) |