Key Takeaways
- ROA defense is the central story: Management laid out a multi-lever plan to defend 1.6% ROA despite rising cost of funds, with a deliberate pivot toward high-yield assets and branch efficiency.
- Merger integration is on a fast track: The Fincare merger closed in just 4.5 months, and the combined entity is already aligning rates and cross-selling products, with integration expenses largely absorbed.
- Credit card remains a deliberate drag: The business is a 27 bps drag on ROA and will stay unprofitable for at least two more years, but issuance is being capped and the cost structure restructured.
- NIMs face sustained pressure: Elevated rates and deposit competition will keep margins under pressure, with another 40-45 bps cost of funds increase expected in FY25.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the 75% high-yield disbursement target materializes in the numbers, the pace of CA build-out in branches, and any stabilization in credit card early delinquencies.
The ROA Defense Playbook
- Four levers identified: Management is targeting (1) higher retail asset ROA via Wheel, MBL, and microfinance, (2) branch banking efficiency through CA build-out, (3) commercial banking shift to high-yield businesses, and (4) eventual treasury gains when rates fall.
- High-yield pivot is structural: Wheel, MBL, micro finance, gold finance, NBFC funding, and REG business all deliver north of 3% ROA. The bank plans to shrink the proportion of affordable housing and commercial banking, which carry lower returns.
- 75% disbursement target: Management estimates three-quarters of this year's disbursement will come from these 3%+ ROA businesses, up from a current mix already around 70%.
- Yield already moving: Competitive intensity allowed a mid-Q4 rate increase; Wheel yields rose 27 bps QoQ, AHL up 20 bps QoQ, and March saw record disbursement with at least a 10-15 bps yield uplift across retail assets.
- MBL gets a South push: The Fincare unit brings an MBL team in South India doing ~18% yield, and the bank will focus MBL growth there since the North market is more competitive.
- Cost of funds headwind: A 30 bps cost impact is expected from higher cost of funds, partially offset by Fincare's high-yield book and passing on some cost to borrowers in Wheel and MBL.
Sanjay Agarwal: "the idea is to build more disbursement from this business from this year onwards. So, the proportion of disbursement of affordable housing or commercial banking or maybe low ROA businesses will come down"
Merger Integration & Fincare
- Fastest approval in the sector: Regulatory clearance came in just 4.5 months, and interest rates were aligned across savings and fixed deposits from 1 April.
- Cross-sell engine starting: Fincare customers will gain access to AU's flagship deposit products and digital offerings within Q1 this year, with asset products like Wheel to follow in coming quarters.
- Integration costs largely absorbed: Of the ~Rs. 300 crores in merger expenses, Rs. 77 crores was stamp duty, Rs. 50-60 crores is BAU, and the balance was already taken by Fincare, which built extra buffers in Q3 and Q4 to avoid future one-offs.
- Rebranding nearly done: 138 urban branches are being transitioned, with nearly 90% already rebranded; necessary compliance and stakeholder communication is complete.
- Capital benefit: The merged entity gains roughly 50 bps in Tier-1 and Tier-2 capital from the MFI book, with net worth around Rs. 2,550-2,570 crores post-merger.
- Priority Sector surplus: After the acquisition, the bank no longer needs to buy Priority Sector requirements and may have a surplus, eliminating a prior drag.
Sanjay Agarwal: "I wish to express my deep gratitude to all stakeholders for this merger, and more specifically to the regulatory bodies for one of the fastest merger approvals to the Indian banking sector, received in just 4.5 months."
Credit Card: Controlled Pain
- 27 bps ROA drag: The credit card business is a material headwind, and management has gone back to the drawing board to recalibrate the entire operation.
- Issuance capped: Card issuance will be held to around 6 lakh cards this year, the same level as last year, to control upfront acquisition costs.
- Cost structure restructured: Video banking and QR code have been repositioned from standalone products to lower-cost acquisition channels supporting branch banking. The Mumbai video banking center will be relocated to Jaipur or elsewhere in 2-3 years, with no further investment in the Mumbai setup.
- Profitability distant: Management is explicit that the business will not be profitable for the next two years, and beyond that visibility is clouded by variables including cost of interest, RBI norms, and credit cost stabilization. A final view on the path to profitability will be taken in 2-3 years.
- Operational cost improvement underway: With only 11,000 cards added QoQ, sourcing costs are elevated relative to the base, but as the book grows (~Rs. 400 crores incremental), operational cost ratios should improve over 3-4 quarters.
Sanjay Agarwal: "difficult to assess when it will become profitable or when we'll achieve the breakeven. But I think one thing is sure that for next 2 years, it's not getting profitable. And beyond 2 years, the visibility is not there because it has lot many variables"
Deposit Franchise & Branch Efficiency
- Deposits grew 26% YoY to cross Rs. 87,000 crores, described as "phenomenal performance." CASA rose 10% QoQ, contributing 33% of deposits, with CASA plus retail term deposits at 64%.
- Current account is the efficiency lever: CA stands at only ~5% of deposits, and management stressed that even a 1% increase saves significant money. The aspiration is to reach at least 7.5% by FY27.
- CA build-out has lagged: Platform limitations and excessive competition have held back the current account franchise. The strategy is being reworked, with the newly operationalized AD1 business (trade-forex, revised CA-led QR code) expected to enhance the proposition.
- Branch profitability target: The bank aims to make around 65% of branches that were live as of December 2023 profitable by FY27, leveraging credit card, wealth, insurance, and AD1 products within the branch network.
- Branding investment calibrated: Building a national deposit franchise requires visibility, and the Fincare acquisition has helped. Expenses are built into projections and will not be "very high."
Sanjay Agarwal: "The second lever, which I strongly believe is that the branch banking has to be more efficient and profitable by building CA, because our CA is around 5%, right? And even if we increase it by 1%, right, it saves us a lot of money."
Margins & Asset Quality
- NIM walk: Last quarter's reported margin had a one-off boost from securitization income taken for an additional month due to the matching principle. Adjusted for that, the base was 5.3%; adding 10 bps and a short-term quarter impact yields 5.14%.
- Sustained pressure ahead: Elevated interest rates and heightened competition for low-cost deposits will keep NIMs under pressure, with no significant near-term rate reduction anticipated.
- Cost-to-income elevated: The ratio will remain raised in the near future and should start tapering off in 2-3 years as integration and branding investments normalize.
- Asset quality intact: Gross NPA improved 26 bps to 1.57% from 1.83% in Q3, driven by strong collection efforts. No asset quality challenge is seen in the near term.
- MFI provisioning: An incremental 1% to 1.5% credit cost will be provided in FY25 to take MFI credit cost to 3% on the Rs. 8,000 crores portfolio.
- Securitization to decline: The requirement will come down in coming years; the bank may still securitize for CD ratio and other reasons but optically prefers not to due to cost.
Fee Income & Other Businesses
- Fee income stabilizing: Third-party insurance and organic service incomes have stabilized. The wealth product is being firmed up, and the newly launched AD1 product has seen strong initial feedback. Sustainability is "already on the table."
- Growth trajectory positive but slower: Fee income will not grow 70% next year but should grow in line with the balance sheet.
- AD1 operationalized: The trade-forex and revised current account-led QR code business is live, with CAPEX of ~Rs. 20 crores on application and hardware already incurred. Only AMC and operational costs remain.
- Election impact contained: Some business continuity disruption is expected in Q1 due to multiphase elections, but the impact will not be material to annual FY25 performance.
- Universal bank ambition: Management is keen to become a complete universal bank and is strictly following regulatory guidance, noting many advantages are already in place with the AD1 license. [5-6]
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Balance sheet growth | ~25% annual growth | Next 3 years |
| ROA defense | Defend 1.6% ROA | FY25 |
| Cost of funds increase | Another 40-45 bps on average basis | FY25 |
| High-yield disbursement share | 75% of disbursement from 3%+ ROA businesses | FY25 |
| Credit card issuance cap | Not more than 6 lakh cards | FY25 |
| Credit card profitability | Not profitable | Next 2 years |
| Current account ratio | Increase to at least 7.5% of deposits | By FY27 |
| Branch profitability | ~65% of Dec-23 live branches profitable | By FY27 |
| MFI credit cost | Incremental 1-1.5% provision to reach 3% | FY25 |
| Merger integration BAU expenses | Rs. 50-60 crores | Next 18-30 months |
| Video banking relocation | Move out of Mumbai to Jaipur or elsewhere | Next 2-3 years |
| Cost-to-income ratio | Start tapering off | In 2-3 years |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY24 |
|---|---|
| ROA (gross of merger exceptional items) | 1.6% for Q4 and FY24; reported ROA around 1.5% |
| Gross NPA | 1.57% of gross loan portfolio, improved 26 bps from 1.83% in Q3 |
| Deposits | ₹87,000+ cr, +26% YoY and +9% QoQ |
| Gross loan portfolio | ~₹82,000 cr, +28% YoY; net of securitization ~₹74,000 cr |
| CASA ratio | 33% of deposits; CASA + retail term deposits at 64% of deposits |
| CASA growth | +10% QoQ |
| Cost of funds (exit) | 6.98% in Q4; FY24 average 6.80% |
| Expected cost of funds increase in FY25 | 40–45 bps on an average basis |
| Net interest margin (standalone, adjusted) | 5.14% in Q4, vs 5.3% adjusted in Q3 (per an analyst's math) |
| Other income growth | ~69–70% YoY for FY24 |
| Credit cost (standalone, normalized ex-MFI) | ~70 bps on average advances |
| Steady-state credit cost (merged entity) | ~1.0–1.1% on overall advances, ~0.75% on total assets |
| Balance sheet growth target | ~25% annually over next 3 years |
| High-yielding assets target by FY27 | 70–75% of portfolio, up from ~70% currently |
| Current account target by FY27 | At least 7.5% of deposits, from ~5% currently |
| Branch profitability target by FY27 | ~65% of branches live as of Dec '23 to be profitable |
| Credit card issuance guidance for FY25 | Not more than 6 lakh cards, flat YoY |
| Credit card credit cost (initial feedback) | 6–6.5% on an average basis for the full year |
| Microfinance portfolio (Fincare) | ₹8,000 cr; incremental provision of 1–1.5% in FY25 to reach 3% total credit cost |
| Microfinance lending rate | ~25% |
| Merger integration expenses (remaining) | ₹50–60 cr over next 18–30 months, treated as BAU |
| Merged net worth | ₹2,421 cr (effectively ₹2,550–2,570 cr deal) |
| Tier-1 capital (merged, approx.) | ~19–20%; total Tier-1 capital ~₹14,981 cr |
| Combined customer base (post-merger) | ~1.1 cr |
| Combined employee strength | Over 46,000 |
| Physical touchpoints (post-merger) | 2,383 across 21 states and 4 union territories |
| Overall disbursement yield change | +8 bps QoQ for the full quarter |
| Wheels incremental yield | +27 bps QoQ from Q3 to Q4 |
| Affordable home loan incremental yield | +20 bps QoQ from Q3 to Q4 |