Key Takeaways
- Subdued quarter, festival shift: Value growth was just +0.5% as festival purchases moved from September into October, while volume grew 4% on a mix shift toward larger, lower-priced packs.
- Rural stress is the core drag: Rural share fell from >50% to 48%, driven by food inflation that spiked to ~10% in Q2; sachets and smaller ADHO packs struggled, and management sees only "green shoots" of recovery, not a broad rebound.
- NPD portfolio is scaling, but margin mix is adverse: New products are gaining real traction with secondary sales now matching primary, yet their lower price points and higher mix pulled gross margin down by over a percentage point.
- ADHO investment is rising, not shifting: 75% of ADHO spend stays on conventional TV, with digital up to 25% from 5-10%; total conventional spend rose double digits, so the company is adding digital on top, not reallocating.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the October demand uptick sustains through the festive season, whether the December price increase on ADHO larger packs sticks, and whether rural volumes turn decisively positive.
Demand & Channel Dynamics
- Festival timing masked underlying demand: Abhyang Snan in Maharashtra can lift ADHO sales 10x in a single month; that spike shifted from September into October, making Q2 look weaker and setting up a Q3 benefit.
- Rural weakness is food-inflation-led: Food inflation ran at 10.7% and 9.9% in Q2 versus 3.3-4.6% in Q1, compressing discretionary spend in rural markets; management described rural volume as "just about marginally positive" without giving a specific figure.
- Urban markets are holding up: Urban demand continues to outperform rural, and wholesale channels have bounced back, doing better than retail for the first time across key urban markets.
- Competitive intensity has risen: Subdued market demand has drawn more competitive activity; the company says it is reacting "both strategically as well as tactically" and has done good work in certain channels to thaw competition on ADHO.
Nandi: "The competitiveness, given that the market demand is subdued, the competitive intensity has gone up, and you will have to react both strategically as well as tactically."
ADHO: The Core Franchise Under Pressure
- Volume-value gap tells the story: ADHO value growth lagged volume because saliency is down (new products carry lower price points than ADHO), pack mix tilted toward larger packs, and product mix tilted toward new products.
- Sachet weakness is a rural story: Larger ADHO packs did well, including an exclusive 750 ml for Flipkart and a 700 ml with a better price proposition for GT; sachets and smaller packs struggled, and management expects improvement only as rural markets recover.
- Market share is stable with a slight tailwind: MAT market share is more or less unchanged year-on-year, with a slight improvement from the coconut variant addition across modern trade and e-commerce.
- Pricing actions are surgical: A price increase was taken in October across ADHO larger packs, with more planned for December; one specific smaller SKU with high rural penetration will take a price drop because its indexation versus competition is too high.
- Long-term ambition intact: Management aims to take ADHO's contribution from current levels to 50-70% over the long term, implying the franchise remains central even as the portfolio diversifies.
Nandi: "ADHO actually goes up 10x in the month itself. So, some of this has shifted into instead of September into October."
New Product Portfolio: Scaling, But at a Margin Cost
- Traction is becoming real: Unlike last year, when GTM pipeline numbers inflated primary sales, secondary offtake for NPD is now matching primary, signalling genuine consumer pull.
- The approach has changed: After the coco onion experience (heavy spend, then a proposition rethink), the company now launches, tests traction, invests to scale what works, and returns to the drawing board for what does not.
- Serum, Henna, and extensions are the bright spots: The serum story is starting to take hold, Almond Drops extensions (shampoo, conditioner, body lotion) are comfortable, and Henna is giving traction; Coconut and Amla form an evolving portfolio.
- Gulab Jal is the next test: Launched in September with GTM happening in October-November; two more power products are in the pipeline for Q4 or Q1, with the pace set by how Henna and Gulab Jal perform.
- No near-term pricing pressure on new launches: Lotion, shampoo, and conditioner were just launched; management will watch how the market behaves before taking any pricing calls.
Nandi: "Some of them will, as you see new products in FMCG mainly in consumer category, will always have to be fast to try out and fast to fail and decide what you want to do."
Margins: Volume Leverage Is the Thesis
- Gross margin took a mix hit: NPD mix being higher in Q2 pulled gross margin down by over a percentage point; LLP prices were range-bound, RMO prices deflated with abundant edible oil, PET bottles saw downward movement, and glass bottles moved up.
- The path to 18-20% runs through volume: Management expects 1-1.5% upside in EBITDA margin from volume-driven fixed-cost leverage alone, taking margins to about 19-19.5% if everything else stays constant; the near-term target is closer to 18% for the full year.
- ADHO recovery is the swing factor: Margins should return to the 18-20% band as the ADHO business comes back from what management called its "possibly worst situation for demand/rural."
- Cost structures are deflating: Structural cost reduction continues through spec optimization, vendor base development, and alternate packing materials; management said EBITDA margin is not expected to go down despite the gross margin mix impact because cost structures will deflate.
- The mix-adverse question was not directly answered: When an analyst asked about the path to 20% margin on a 3-4 year horizon given new products carry lower margins, management pointed to volume leverage and ADHO recovery but did not address the structural mix challenge.
Nandi: "The 18% to 20% is how we stated the near term. So, we are anyway looking at closer to 18% ending this year."
Distribution & Strategic Choices
- Direct reach expansion is long-term: The aspirational number of ~10 lakh direct reach outlets is a long-term goal; near-term focus is on quality of distribution in West and East, with some Southern states starting first and the larger South in the longer term.
- Worli capex is on hold: The company has decided to spend money into its own business rather than proceed with the Worli building project, and is looking at options for the asset.
- International business saliency is rising: Management expects the saliency of international business to keep moving up in the near term, though it deflected a question about whether international would be higher-margin at the EBITDA level once it reaches 10-20% salience, saying only that in initial stages it "may not have a huge impact on our consol EBITDA."
Nandi: "We have decided that at this moment, we'll spend our money more into our own business and look at the options that we have."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| EBITDA margin | Closer to 18% for the full year, driven by volume leverage of 1-1.5% | FY24 exit |
| Volume growth | High single-digit to double-digit aspiration | H2 FY24 |
| Volume growth | At least double-digit | Next year (FY25) |
| ADHO pricing | Price increase taken in October; more planned for December across larger packs | Oct / Dec 2023 |
| One small ADHO SKU pricing | Price drop planned due to high indexation vs competition | Not specified |
| New product launches | Two more power products in pipeline; will not launch in Q3 | Q4 FY24 or Q1 FY25 |
| Ethnic range expansion | A few more products in the ethnic range | Coming quarters |
| ADHO contribution | Long-term aim to take to 50-70% | Long-term |
| Direct reach | Aspirational ~10 lakh outlets | Long-term |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Stand-alone sales | ₹228.7 cr, 0.5% value growth and 4% volume growth YoY |
| H1 FY24 stand-alone sales | ₹488.4 cr, 4% value growth and 7% volume growth YoY |
| Gross margin | 54.5%, expanded 280 bps YoY |
| EBITDA | ₹38.8 cr, 22% growth YoY; margin at 17%, up 300 bps YoY |
| PAT | ₹38.4 cr, 21% growth YoY |
| H1 FY24 EBITDA | ₹86.9 cr, 26% growth YoY; margin at 17.8%, up 318 bps YoY |
| H1 FY24 PAT | ₹83.8 cr, 29% growth YoY |
| A&P spend | ₹38.1 cr, 16.7% of sales |
| Hair oil portfolio growth | 4% during the period |
| ADHO growth in H1 FY24 | Single-digit growth |
| ADHO contribution to sales | 81%, down from 86% in Q1 FY24 and 87% in Q2 FY23 |
| New product initiatives growth | 37% |
| Modern trade growth | 19% YoY in the quarter, 27% in H1 FY24 |
| E-commerce growth | 28% in H1 FY24; B2C e-commerce grew 55% |
| International business growth | 21% in H1 FY24 |
| Rural share of total business | 48% rural, 52% urban |
| Organized trade plus canteen contribution | Above 23–24% |
| Debtor days | 20 days, moved from 18 days |