Key Takeaways
- Resilient quarter in a falling market: Sales were flat YoY at ₹225.5 Crores while the overall hair oil market declined 4.4% by volume, a performance management calls "fairly good" given the macro.
- Portfolio diversification is working: New product sales doubled and now contribute 13% of revenue, with modern trade growing 41% and e-commerce 84% YoY, building a credible second engine beyond ADHO.
- Gross margins are the central tension: Margins fell 240 bps YoY to 53% as LLP prices stayed 32% higher, but sequential improvement of 120 bps QoQ and softening raw material costs signal the worst may be past.
- Rural distress is concentrated, not universal: The 7.5% rural volume decline is driven almost entirely by five Hindi-speaking states (UP, Bihar, MP, Chhattisgarh, Jharkhand), while western, eastern and southern markets grew.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the sequential gross margin recovery continues into Q4 as LLP and RMO prices soften, and whether the "green shoots" management sees in troubled HSM markets translate into actual demand normalization.
Demand Environment
- Market contraction: The hair oil category shrank 4.4% in both volume and value YoY, with rural markets down 7.5% and urban down 2.1%, driven by unprecedented inflation eroding disposable income and consumer spending.
- Rural pain is geographically narrow: The sharp decline is concentrated in five states (UP, Bihar, MP, Chhattisgarh, Jharkhand) where Nielsen data shows UP down 12% and MP down 10%. The northern HSM belt (Delhi, Punjab, Haryana, Rajasthan) and western, eastern and southern markets continue to perform well.[13-14]
- Downtrading without participation: Competitive intensity has increased at the low end, with a surge in ₹10 and ₹20 amla products that yield volumes but erode gross margins drastically. The company consciously chose not to play at that level, sacrificing topline for margin integrity.
- No near-term rural catalyst: Management sees no clear directional improvement in rural demand and does not expect Q4 to show a huge improvement over Q2 or Q3. Urban markets are doing decently well and expected to continue.
Nandi: "I do not think there is a very, very clear near sight of that the rural demand is going to be much better than what it has been in Q2, Q3, so Q4 I do not think there will be a huge improvement."
Portfolio Transformation
- NPD doubled, now 13% of sales: New product sales doubled in Q3 FY2023, with the portfolio now covering about 85% of the overall hair oils market in terms of product offering. The long-term aspiration is 40% contribution from post-COVID launched products within 3-4 years, up from the current ~15%.
- Channel transformation accelerating: Modern trade grew 41% YoY (now ~9% of sales, 2X over two years) and e-commerce grew 84% YoY (now 7% of sales, 4X over two years). Retail delivered double-digit growth on loyalty programmes, while wholesale has revived and turned positive.
- Almond Drops as a category play: The company aims to build Almond Drops into a 10-15 product extension category over three to five years, leveraging the Bajaj house brand equity. Almond Plus Argan Oil and Serum with Oil are already live on e-commerce and entering modern trade.
- International gaining traction: Consolidated international business grew 36% YoY, driven by new channel partners in Middle East and Africa. Nepal saw muted growth due to macro conditions; rest of world performed well on new geographies and portfolio introductions.
- Most NPD is already contribution-positive: Except for products receiving disproportionately high media investments, most new products are EBITDA positive on a net contribution basis. The company is rationalizing SKUs to maintain this discipline.
Nandi: "Almond Drops extension category is something that we want to develop as a 10 to 15 products over a period of three to five years which we want to push and I think that category of Almond Drops which is where we feel that we have some ownership that we want to proliferate across consumers..."
ADHO: The Core Franchise Under Pressure
- Mid-single digit value decline: ADHO registered a mid-single digit value decline due to weak demand in key HSM rural markets. Over a 3-year period, however, it has close to 3% value growth with volumes more or less flat.
- Market share steady at 63-65%: Share held because the overall LHO market itself declined substantially (~8.6%). The amla portfolio share remains steady in mid single digits at the all-India level.
- Conscious defocus on low-margin packs: In Q3, management took a deliberate decision to defocus on ₹10 and ₹20 amla packs because margins were not viable given LLP and RMO costs. Larger packs continue to do well.
- Urban and new channels as growth levers: ADHO is performing well in urban markets and gaining traction through modern trade and e-commerce in markets beyond its traditional HSM strength. The new Kiara Advani campaign ('Daro Nahi Dare Karo') registered 1.3 Crore views and lifted Almond SOV from 8% to 17%.
- Long-term volume potential intact: If demand conditions normalize and discretionary spending returns, management believes 4-5% volume growth in ADHO is "easily doable" over the long term.
Nandi: "We actually took a conscious call in Q3 this year end of Q2 and Q3 this year where Rs.10 and Rs.20 packs of amla that we defocused on because there was no money to be made. You would have got topline growth, margins would have collapsed further..."
Margins: The RM Squeeze and the Recovery Path
- Gross margin walk: Q3 gross margins at 53% were down 240 bps YoY, with ~4.2-4.3% from raw material price inflation (LLP up 32% YoY) and ~1.2% from deliberate product mix shift toward new products with decent but lower gross margins. Sequentially, margins improved 120 bps QoQ as material costs softened.
- LLP dynamics: LLP prices surged post Russia-Ukraine war on crude price spikes, INR depreciation and refining capacity tightening. Sequentially, prices corrected 8% on demand weakness, and management expects further softening with a good RMO crop.
- The mix shift is permanent and accepted: The ~1.2% gross margin dilution from product mix is a deliberate, conscious call that will not flow back. Management is comfortable with this as the cost of portfolio diversification.
- A&P spend elevated, path to normalization: A&P spend was 18.9% of sales in Q3 (up 6.4% absolute YoY) and 18.6% on a nine-month basis (up 26% absolute). The intent is to hold at 18-20% through next year, then gradually bring it down to ~16% as the business scales.
- EBITDA and PAT: Q3 EBITDA was ₹34 Crores at a 15.1% margin; PAT declined 15.8% YoY to ₹33.7 Crores. Nine-month EBITDA was ₹102.9 Crores at 14.8%; PAT was ₹98.8 Crores.
Nandi: "That 1.2% is a deliberate conscious call and we are comfortable with that."
Competitive Dynamics & Strategic Choices
- Downtrading without chasing: The surge in low-end amla products (₹10, ₹20 packs) reflects consumer downtrading and down-purchasing. These products yield volumes but erode gross margins drastically, so the company decided not to play strongly at that level.
- Pricing premium not yet a problem: Management does not believe the pricing premium is currently hurting the brand, though it may consider action on one or two packs once raw material prices stabilize. [19-20]
- B2C focus over B2B push: The company has been "very, very conscious" not to push the B2B part of modern trade and e-commerce, focusing instead on B2C where new-gen customers are connecting via digital marketing.
- New launch discipline: Going forward, only products with decent or high gross margins will be launched, a discipline reinforced by the recent margin experience.
Nandi: "They are clearly not margin making products. They do yield volumes but they obviously will erode your gross margins quite drastically so we have decided not to play very strongly at this level."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Gross margin recovery from RM | 4.2-4.3% dilution from RM prices will flow directly back to EBITDA if RM prices decline; further stabilization expected in Q4 and Q1 if spot price trends hold | Q4 FY23 and Q1 FY24 |
| A&P spend normalization | Hold at 18-20% through next year, then gradually bring down to ~16% as business scales | Reduction begins after next year |
| NPD contribution target | 30% "clearly doable," 40% aspirational from post-COVID launched products (vs ~15% currently) | Within 3-4 years |
| Almond Drops category build-out | Develop into 10-15 products; one or two more products expected in coming quarters | Over 3-5 years |
| ADHO volume growth | 4-5% volume growth "easily doable" if demand conditions normalize and discretionary spending returns | Conditional on demand recovery |
| Amla LUP re-entry | Will "definitely forecast into" the ₹10, ₹20 amla segment if RMO and LLP stabilize | Conditional on RM stabilization |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ₹225.5 cr, flat YoY |
| 9M revenue | ₹696.8 cr, +7.3% value and +4.2% volume YoY |
| Gross margin | 53.0%, down 240 bps YoY; up 120 bps QoQ |
| 9M gross margin | 53.1%, vs 57.6% in 9M FY22 |
| A&P spend | 18.9% of sales, up 6.4% in absolute value YoY |
| 9M A&P spend | 18.6% of sales, up 26% in absolute value YoY |
| EBITDA | ₹34 cr, margin of 15.1% |
| 9M EBITDA | ₹102.9 cr, margin of 14.8% |
| PAT | ₹33.7 cr, down 15.8% YoY |
| 9M PAT | ₹98.8 cr |
| ADHO revenue contribution | 85% of total company revenue |
| NPD revenue contribution | 13% of total company revenue, doubled YoY |
| ADHO market share | 63–65% in light hair oil segment |
| Modern trade growth | +41% YoY, now ~9% of total sales |
| E-commerce growth | +84% YoY, now ~7% of total sales |
| International business growth | +36% YoY |
| Retail growth | ~15% for the quarter; 20%+ on 9M basis |
| LLP price change | +32% YoY; –8% QoQ |
| Hair oil market volume decline (Nielsen) | –4.4% YoY; rural –7.5%, urban –2.1% |
| Cash and investments on balance sheet | ~₹700 cr |