Key Takeaways
- Transformation is building slowly, not a one-quarter event: Q4 showed broad-based channel growth (GT +6%, MT +51%, E-com +63% YoY) but management admits nothing specific changed versus Q2/Q3; the multi-year portfolio shift is just starting to gain momentum.
- Portfolio diversification is diluting margins by design: New products doubled to ₹113 crores (12% of sales) but shaved ~1 percentage point off overall margins; management accepts this as the cost of reducing ADHO dependence from near-100% toward a 60% long-term target.
- Gross margin squeezed 210 bps YoY to 54%: LLP prices rose 9% YoY while the company took no price corrections in hair oil; management now targets 17–18% EBITDA near-term and 20% mid-term, calling 18% the bare minimum.
- The buyback was a promoter confidence signal, not a return-of-capital event: ₹100 crores spent extinguishing 49 lakh shares with promoters staying out; management says this showcased promoter faith, though an analyst questioned whether a tender offer or direct market purchase would have been more convincing.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the Q4 channel momentum sustains into FY24, progress on the third new product range contemplated for this year, and any sign that rural demand is recovering beyond the sequential improvement already noted.
The Portfolio Transformation
- ADHO still the engine, but deliberately being rebalanced: ADHO grew 11.4% YoY in value with SOV rising from 17% to 23%, yet management wants its saliency to fall from near-100% to ~80% near-term and ~60% long-term as new ranges scale.
- New products doubled to ₹113 crores in FY23: Almond Drops Extensions (soaps, Argan variant, serum) are gaining distribution and repeat orders; Coconut and Amla portfolios are building consumer offtake; digital-first brands Bajaj 100% Pure and Natyv Soul are scaling on e-commerce platforms.
- Natyv Soul is being rationalized after overreach: Management admits going "a little too overboard" with multiple hero ingredients; the brand is now consolidated around Argan Oil-based products with focused marketing spends, and a slow push into Modern Trade is planned.
- A third product range is in the works for this year: Management disclosed another range being contemplated that carries higher gross margins than the current portfolio, with progress expected in the next 1–2 quarters.
- The 30% NPD target has no timeline: Management aspires to move NPD contribution from 12–13% to 30% but concedes it "may not happen organically" in two years and declined to give a specific timeframe.
Nandi: "The corrections that we are making are a little more mid to long-term in nature and you would not see short-term results."
Channel Performance
| Channel | Q4 YoY Growth | Commentary |
|---|---|---|
| General Trade | ▲ +6% | High-teen urban growth offset rural decline; wholesale loyalty programs restored confidence after uniform pricing eliminated cross-border inflows. |
| Modern Trade | ▲ +51.4% | Now ~9% of sales, scaled 2.2x in two years; Republic Sale Week footfalls strong; visibility and on-ground execution driving gains. |
| E-commerce | ▲ +63% | Now ~7% of sales, more than doubled in FY23; instrumental in scaling premium NPD portfolio; growth from both digital-only brands and digital listings of existing brands. |
| International | ▲ +151% | Consolidated Q4 growth; new channel partners in Middle East and Africa; local manufacturing commenced in Bangladesh; full-year growth at 56%. |
- Rural remains subdued but improving sequentially: HSM markets saw high mid-teen declines become single-digit or low double-digit from Q3 to Q4; management is not spending heavily on rural now, waiting for full recovery before targeting it.
- E-commerce inventory gaps flagged by an analyst: Products including Almond Drops, Coco Onion, and Castor oil were reported unavailable on Amazon 5–6 times during the quarter; management called it an aberration and promised to investigate.
Margins & Cost Structure
- Gross margin fell 210 bps YoY to 54%: LLP prices up 9% YoY (though down 7% sequentially), RMO prices down 22% YoY; the hair oil industry's inability to take price increases, unlike soaps, was the primary driver.
- Portfolio mix itself cost ~1 percentage point of margin: As management crunched the numbers, the shift toward lower-margin new products diluted overall profitability by roughly a percentage point, separate from raw material pressure.
- New products now have a gross margin floor of 40–45%: Management instituted a policy that no product launches below that threshold; products closer to ADHO's gross margin are the target, and zero-to-5%-margin business will be avoided even if distribution penetration falls.
- Cost-saving initiatives are providing structural relief: Continuous implementation of various initiatives helped reduce natural cost on average; further cost structure optimization beyond gross margins is targeted to reach the 20% EBITDA mid-term goal.
- A&P spend held at 17.2% of sales in Q4: Absolute spend flat YoY and sequentially; FY23 full-year at 18.2% of sales, up 18.9% in absolute terms due to NPD and digital investments; digital share of A&P scaling from ~25% toward 30%.
Nandi: "Below 18% is something anywhere we're never looking at it."
Competitive & Pricing Strategy
- No price corrections taken in the past year: Management stated any future price corrections will only be northward; as demand improves, the company expects to pass on past input cost increases to consumers.
- Competition on Almond is acknowledged but not reacted to: Management noted that in places where competitive Almond products have appeared, ADHO has also grown well; the company will not react to competition on its flagship brand.
- Wholesale confidence restored through structural changes: The company stopped short-term top-up schemes 1–1.5 years ago, took a market beating, but now has uniform Almond Drops pricing across the country with few cross-border inflows, restoring wholesaler confidence in the loyalty program.
Nandi: "Reacting to competition, especially on flagship brand is clearly not a path for us."
Buyback & Capital Allocation
- ₹100 crores (with tax) spent on open market buyback: 49.14 lakh shares extinguished, equity base now 14.26 crores; promoter holding rose to 38.04% as promoters stayed out of the buyback.
- Promoter absence was deliberate signaling: Management said the promoter remaining away was a way to report confidence in the company and showcase that to the market, responding to prior questions about promoter commitment.
- An analyst challenged the buyback structure: The analyst suggested a tender offer would have been more effective, or that the ₹100 crores could have funded dividends or A&P; management cited the large treasury (₹700+ crores), no debt, and no immediate capex needs, calling it a learning cycle.
- Buyback window closed for 12 months: The next discussion on buybacks opens only in April 2024; management acknowledged the analyst's point that open market buyback is "the real story going on" and there won't be other options for any company going forward.
Nandi: "It is also a promoter remaining away from the buyback that was also another way to just report some confidence of the promoter in the company and showcase that to the market."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| EBITDA margin | 17–18% near-term, 20% mid-term; 18% is bare minimum floor | Near-term / mid-term (undated) |
| ADHO saliency reduction | Near-term ~80%, long-term ~60% | Near-term / long-term (undated) |
| New product gross margin floor | No launches below 40–45% gross margin | Effective immediately |
| A&P spend | Absolute spend maintained; percentage to fall as sales scale | Ongoing |
| Price corrections | Only northward; pass-through expected as demand improves | Conditional on demand recovery |
| International expansion | Further thrust in FY24; country teams established | FY24 |
| New Almond Drops extensions | Graded launches planned in FY24 | FY24 |
| Third product range | Higher gross margin range contemplated; progress in 1–2 quarters | Next 1–2 quarters |
| Buyback | Window closed; next discussion opens April 2024 | April 2024 |
| Sustainable growth target | Double-digit YoY growth for next five years | 5 years |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Standalone revenue | ₹241 cr, +11.7% value growth and +9.9% volume growth YoY |
| FY23 standalone revenue | ₹938.1 cr, +8.4% value growth and +5.6% volume growth YoY |
| Consolidated revenue growth (FY23) | +9.5% YoY; international business grew 56% |
| Gross margin | 54%, lower by 210 bps YoY, improved 110 bps sequentially over Q3 FY23 |
| EBITDA | ₹43.3 cr, +12% in absolute terms YoY |
| EBITDA margin | 17.9%, increase of 280 bps sequentially over Q3 FY23 |
| PAT | ₹40.7 cr |
| FY23 EBITDA | ₹146.2 cr |
| FY23 PAT | ₹140 cr |
| A&P spend | 17.2% of sales, absolute spend ~₹42 cr, flat YoY and sequentially |
| FY23 A&P spend | 18.2% of sales, +18.9% in absolute terms YoY |
| ADHO value growth | +11.4% YoY, +10.4% sequentially over Q3 |
| ADHO volume growth | +9% YoY |
| ADHO share of overall sales | ~86%, down from ~93% earlier |
| New product sales (FY23) | ₹113 cr, doubled YoY, now 12% of overall sales |
| General trade growth | +6% YoY, ~7% sequentially |
| Modern Trade growth | +51.4% YoY, contributes ~9% of total sales |
| E-commerce growth | +63% YoY, more than doubled in FY23, contributes ~7% of total sales |
| Consolidated international business growth | +151% YoY in Q4; +56% for full year |
| Direct distribution coverage | ~8.5 lakh outlets via van sales, direct coverage ~6.5 lakh |
| Urban vs rural mix | Urban 52%, rural 48% (reversed from 48%/52% last year) |
| Buyback | ₹80.88 cr of stock bought back, 49.14 lakh shares extinguished, equity base reduced to 14.26 cr shares |
| Promoter holding | 38.04%, increased post-buyback |