Key Takeaways
- Cyclone and port disruption wiped out a week of production: Operations at Bhuj were suspended for five days and Mundra Port disruptions choked exports through June, making Q1 a supply-shock quarter before demand weakness is even considered.
- Demand remains challenging, no recovery timeline offered: Management sees recessionary fears in both Americas and Europe across agri and OTR, and explicitly declined to put a date on a return to 75,000–80,000 volume levels.
- Realization is sliding by design: ASP fell 1.5% sequentially as raw material cost declines were passed to customers, with full-year ASP guided to ₹300–305 on the lower side by year-end.
- Margins held up despite the volume hit: Management is "quite confident" of closing FY24 at 23%+ EBITDA margins, with gross margins sustained at Q1 levels and high-cost inventory now fully adjusted.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the Q1 dispatch spillover materializes into Q2 volumes, the pace of raw material price stabilization, and any signal on heat wave impact duration on agri demand.
Volume & Supply Shock
- Cyclone Biparjoy halted Bhuj for five days: Production suspended from late evening 13 June to 19 June 2023, and Mundra Port disruptions choked export dispatches for all plants through month-end.
- Q2 gets the spillover, but it is the weakest quarter: Dispatches that could not happen in Q1 will shift into Q2, but monsoon always depresses domestic demand, so the net effect is not "normal quarter plus spillover."
- Heat waves are now a demand-side problem: Soil too hot for agriculture work hits end-user income and crop, and the impact has already started being seen; management called it "difficult to indicate which quarter or how long the impact will be there."
- Retail destocking has normalized: End-customer off-take from distributors has been stable over the last three quarters, so the channel is no longer a drag.
- Q2 volumes guided "more or less similar to Q1": Management declined to speculate a specific number but offered this directional view.
Poddar: "As I mentioned in my commentary, the challenges for this quarter continue. We are still not out of the woods, so we forecast challenging times."
Demand Environment
- Recessionary fears span both geographies and segments: Weakness is present in Americas and Europe, and across both agri and OTR, with no near-term catalyst identified.
- Domestic business is the bright spot: New business wins in India are reflected in domestic numbers, and management expects sustainability over the long term, though quarters may fluctuate with weather and rain.
- OEM market share gains expected to continue this year: Management sees the trend holding through FY24.
- No volume guidance for the full year: Management cited challenges and will take it quarter by quarter; India remains strong but export visibility is too low to commit.
- Second half typically better, but no number offered: The seasonal pattern is acknowledged, but weather, recession and other fears make it a wait-and-watch situation.
Poddar: "We cannot put a date to it. We would like it to come as soon as possible. We are ready from infrastructure point of view to cater to that but we will wait and watch."
Realization & Raw Material
- ASP down 1.5% QoQ on raw material pass-through: Benefit from lower input costs was passed to customers, and the freight component in ASP has already been fully rolled back.
- Full-year ASP guided to ₹300–305 on the lower side by year-end: Driven by continued raw material pass-through and pricing competition.
- Raw material prices expected to stabilise: No further commodity benefit is anticipated in coming quarters based on current prices, and prices are not likely to go up much.
- High-cost inventory fully adjusted: Current inventory is at current cost, removing a margin overhang.
- Gross margins to sustain at Q1 levels: Management looks to hold the Q1 gross margin run-rate going forward.
Margins & Costs
- EBITDA margin confidence at 23%+ for the full year: Management is "quite confident" despite the volume headwinds.
- Other expenses fell sequentially on lower volumes and freight rates: Marketing expenses were stable and did not contribute to the reduction.
- Employee expenses declined YoY with volumes: Majority of workforce is contractual labour, giving the cost base flexibility.
- Path back to 26–28% normalized margins runs through volume: Volume growth, efficiency, hedge rates and product mix are the biggest drivers; domestic business carries lower margins but overall stays at the blended level.
- Debt repayment on track: Long-term debt will be repaid per schedule; short-term borrowing adjusts with business needs.
Capex & Market Share Ambition
- FY24 capex pegged at ₹550–600 Crores: ₹250–300 Crores is routine maintenance; the balance goes to new product development (rubber tracks, giant solid tires), brand building and marketing to widen the product basket.
- 10% market share target in four to five years: Currently at 5–6% global share, leaving 94–95% of the market available; the next capex cycle is the enabler, with announcements to come when planning is done.
- Capex rationale is long-term: Current issues are not expected to persist long-term, and new products will open new revenue areas.
Poddar: "We have about 5% to 6% of the global share so that is a 94% to 95% market yet available and we are focusing on that in our product basket and in our category of premium players so that is where our focus is and that is what we are trying to do."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Capex spend | ₹550–600 Crores total; ₹250–300 Crores maintenance, balance for new products and brand building | FY2024 |
| Full-year ASP | ₹300–305 on the lower side by year-end | FY2024 |
| EBITDA margin | "Quite confident" of closing at 23%+ | FY2024 |
| Gross margins | Sustain at Q1 levels going forward | Ongoing |
| OEM market share | Gaining trends to continue | FY2024 |
| Q2 volumes | "More or less similar to Q1" | Q2 FY24 |
| Market share target | Reach 10% global share | 4–5 years |
| Long-term debt repayment | As per repayment schedule; no issue seen | Ongoing |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Standalone revenue | ₹2,115 cr, degrowth of 22% YoY |
| Standalone EBITDA | ₹487 cr, margin of 23% |
| Profit after tax | ₹312 cr |
| Other income | ₹66 cr, includes mark-to-market impact on forex and treasury of about ₹60–65 cr |
| Net forex gain | ₹38 cr, comprising realized gain of ₹5 cr and unrealized gain of ₹33 cr |
| Gross debt | ₹2,861 cr as of 30 June 2023, about 75% working capital debt |
| Cash and cash equivalents | ₹2,245 cr |
| Total sales volume | 67,209 metric tonnes |
| Domestic sales volume | 21,012 metric tonnes, growth of 19% YoY |
| Production loss from cyclone and port disruption | 4,000–5,000 metric tonnes |
| Realization change | 1.5% lower sequentially, raw material pass-through |
| ASP guidance | ₹300–305 per kg expected towards end of FY24 |
| Sales mix: Europe | 45% of sales |
| Sales mix: India | 31% of sales |
| Sales mix: Americas | 15% of sales |
| Channel mix: Replacement | 72% of sales |
| Channel mix: OEM | 26% of sales |
| Category mix: Agricultural | 59% of sales |
| Category mix: OTR / industrial construction | 38% of sales |
| Carbon black plant utilization | 85% to 90% |
| Hedge rate for FY24–FY25 | ₹87 and ₹88 for the full year |
| Interim dividend | ₹4 per share |
| FY24 capex guidance | ₹550–600 cr, of which routine maintenance capex ₹250–300 cr |
| Global market share | 5% to 6%, with goal of reaching 10% in four years post next capex cycle |