Key Takeaways
- 80% headline growth is misleading: Q1 FY23 was supply-chain depressed, so the real run-rate growth is ~30%. Management kept its 30–35% CAGR guidance intact, framing the print as normalization, not acceleration.
- Travel gear came of age: The segment hit ~60% of sales as supply chains healed, and EBO like-to-like growth exceeded 35% in Q1. The company is now building its own hard-luggage manufacturing capacity.
- New brands are live but not yet material: UCB and Aeropostale products reached the market, and a 68,000-piece Aeropostale corporate order doubled as a brand-awareness event. Revenue impact from new brands is expected from Q2 onward.
- Margins dipped on deliberate spend: Operating margin compressed as marketing spend stepped up to 4–5% of revenue and the new corporate-sales channel carried structurally lower gross margins. Management aims to maintain, not expand, margins while growing.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the two newly signed brands (launching FH ’24) are named, the pace of the 15–18 planned store openings, and whether Q2 can sustain the ~30% run-rate growth against a seasonally weak quarter.
The Q1 Growth Print: Normalization, Not a Step-Change
- Supply-chain recovery flatters the YoY: Last year’s Q1 was muted because supply chains were still exiting Omicron disruptions and China was not sorted; this year’s 80% YoY compares against that depressed base. Against the average run rate from Q2/Q3 onward, growth is about 30%.
- Seasonality held: Q1 is traditionally the biggest quarter for travel gear because April–June is summer holiday and travel season. Management expects the usual waveform: Q1 big, Q2 subdued, Q3 highest, Q4 muted.
- Volume and same-store strength: EBO like-to-like growth exceeded 35% in Q1, and growth was seen across every channel. Management tracks volume at the category level because ASPs differ between luggage and backpacks.
- The aspiration to beat the curve: Management wants to beat the seasonality pattern for a year or two before the business grows sizable, acknowledging that Safari has done so through growth momentum.
Abhinav Kumar: "I'm digging my own grave by saying that I would love to beat that because, but that's what my wishlist is."
Travel Gear & Manufacturing: The Core Engine
- Travel Gear is now the largest segment at ~60% of sales, having previously missed opportunities due to supply-chain issues. Management says the segment has now “come of age.”
- Hard-luggage manufacturing capacity is being built and will be managed by the same IFF Overseas team. The company sees huge potential in hard luggage.
- IFF Overseas is targeting ₹60–65 crores this year with double-digit EBITDA margins. Backpack capacity will not be expanded; instead, the focus is on optimizing the existing business so that efficiencies lift output from 60 to 66 or 70 next year.
- Third-party manufacturing continues for brands like Samsonite, but the long-term perspective is to occupy as much capacity as possible for the company’s own business.
- The IFF Overseas merger was approved by the Board with an effective date of 1 April 2024; the high-cost debt on IFF’s balance sheet was paid off before proceeding. The process starts in the next 10–15 days, with the registered office moved from Bombay to Indore to avoid filing with two NCLTs.
Abhinav Kumar: "The reason for merger is not that whether I wanted to capitalize on their balance sheet or whether the debt also that you had mentioned. So whatever high cost debt was there was paid off already."
New Brands & Licensing: Early Innings
- UCB and Aeropostale products are in the market with an initial response described as “quite good.” Most categories and lines should be rolled out by Q3 end or calendar year end, and material traction is expected from that point.
- A 68,000-piece Aeropostale corporate order served as brand exposure: management called the recipients “walking billboards” for the brand.
- Two additional brands have been signed, with the first products rolling out by FH ’24. Preparation happening today is for next year; it takes at least two to three quarters from signing to launch.
- Benetton small leather goods aims to be in more than 200 points of sale by next month.
- Tommy Hilfiger renewal is principally agreed, but a few points in the draft language remain under discussion; the contract expires in December 2023.
- Brand-signing discipline: Management is clear it will not over-commit, saying “you should not bite more than you can chew.” The concentration this year is on increasing distribution for existing brands and rolling out products quickly.
Abhinav Kumar: "I don't say that I'm going to add five, seven brands, because you should not bite more than you can chew."
Channels: Corporate Sales, Stores & E-Commerce
- Corporate institutional sales became a separate division this year with its own targets. These are strategic, repetitive placements, not one-off sales, and management expects the channel can reach a double-digit percentage of revenue on an annual basis.
- Corporate margins are structurally lower at 5–10% because there is no inventory holding, the payment cycle is advance, and clients demand better pricing. Management views this as a fair trade for the strategic benefits.
- Store openings are guided at 15–18 this year, with key mall and key-location stores run as COCO and Tier 2/Tier 3 cities through franchisees. The best-case mix is 50:50 COCO:FOCO. One store was lost (Quest Kolkata) when the mall did not give permanent space after 15 months.
- Baglineindia.com is seeing good traction and servicing a decent volume of orders. However, management has “dissonance” about allowing other brands onto the platform and has made no decision on a multi-brand strategy.
Abhinav Kumar: "There's a dissonance in my mind. So till the time I am very, very clear on exactly what should we do... I wouldn't want to make exact comments on that."
Margins & Investments: Spending for the Future
- Operating margin dipped for two reasons: marketing spend stepped up to a budgeted 4–5% of revenue (from 2.5–3% last year), and the new corporate-sales channel carries lower gross margins than retail. From a PBT perspective, the result is in the same region as the guidance given.
- Marketing push is deliberate: a first-ever celebrity endorsement campaign is planned to break during the World Cup, which management calls “the biggest, highest-decibel event of the country.”
- Management declined to guide to margin expansion, saying the aim is to maintain margins while growing. Operating leverage will come in, but other factors will play. The company would not stop at 30% growth if there is room for more.
- Tax rate rose because there are no carry-forward losses left; deferred tax assets make the calculation unpredictable. This quarter landed around a 31% tax bracket, which affected PAT.
- A ₹15 crore preferential round has been raised and is awaiting BSE and NSE approval. Funds are earmarked for new projects, not primarily for working capital. Further capital needs will be met through a mix of bank debt, term loans, and equity, matching long-term needs with long-term sources.
Abhinav Kumar: "I wouldn't want to stop only at a 30%, if I see a room for more, why will I not jump for more, right?"
Positioning & Optionality
- Segment focus is mid-premium to super premium: management will not enter mass or luxury, calling both extreme ends. The company operates in mid-premium, premium, bridge-to-luxury, and super premium.
- Own brands (Vertical, Sugarush) are price fillers and category fillers, private labels on which the company is not betting large sums. Some traction is visible, but no specific growth plans were shared.
- A Product Management Service division is being started within Brand Concepts to offer product design, development, manufacturing, and merchandising services to other brands. This is not third-party contract manufacturing per se.
- International expansion is not shelved but will happen “in its due course of time”; India is keeping management fully occupied. Category experiments with a few more accessory lines may happen, but the company will not bet heavily on them.
- Promoter stake decline was driven by the IFF Overseas stake sale last year plus a small 3-lakh-share liquidation this quarter. No further promoter stake sales are planned, and the stake should be stable.
Abhinav Kumar: "Mass and luxury, both extreme ends I would not like to enter. So all in between I would, so mid-premium, premium, bridge to luxury, super premium... I don't think we are ready or geared for that."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue CAGR | 30–35% CAGR; cross ₹500 crores | Next 3–4 years |
| Store openings | 15–18 new stores, mix of COCO and FOCO | This fiscal year |
| IFF Overseas revenue target | Cross ₹60–65 crores with double-digit EBITDA margin | This fiscal year |
| New brand product rollout (UCB, Aeropostale) | Most categories and lines rolled out; good traction expected | By Q3 end / calendar year end |
| Two newly signed brands | First set of products rolling out | FH ’24 |
| Benetton small leather goods | Launch in more than 200 points of sale | By next month |
| Celebrity endorsement campaign | First campaign to break during the World Cup | Fall Winter (World Cup timing) |
| IFF Overseas merger process | Process to start; documents submitted, merchant banker on board | Next 10–15 days |
| Promoter stake | No further sales planned; stake should be stable | Ongoing |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Revenue growth | ~80% YoY, against a previously guided 30% |
| Revenue run-rate growth | ~30% over the average quarterly benchmark of last year |
| Revenue CAGR guidance | 30–35% for the next three to four years, aiming to cross INR 500 crores |
| EBITDA margin | Not stated; management aims to maintain margins while growing, not guiding an increase |
| Marketing spend | 4–5% of revenue budgeted for FY24, up from 2.5–3% in FY23 |
| Tax rate | ~31% for the quarter |
| Store count | 32 stores, one high-performing store lost (Quest, Kolkata) |
| Store opening guidance | 15–18 new stores planned for FY24 |
| COCO store investment | ₹30–40 lakhs per store, including ₹20–25 lakhs for furniture and fixturing |
| EBO like-to-like growth | >35% in Q1 |
| Travel Gear sales mix | ~60% of overall sales, up from 43–44% historically |
| Small leather goods sales mix | ~30–35% of overall sales, down from 47–48% historically |
| Women handbags sales mix | 5–7% of overall sales |
| Tommy Hilfiger sales share | >80% of total sales |
| Corporate institutional sales margin | 5–10% lower than regular retail margins |
| IFF Overseas FY23 turnover | ~₹48 crores |
| IFF Overseas FY24 target | ₹60–65 crores |
| Supplies sourced from IFF | <10% of overall supplies |
| Preferential fundraise | ~₹15 crores raised, awaiting exchange approval |
| Promoter stake | 51.24% in Q1 FY24, down from ~60% in June 2022 |