Key Takeaways
- ARPU up 3.8% QoQ to ₹190, but still below 2015 levels: Up-trading, smartphone upgrades and data monetization drove the lift, yet management stressed that a tariff correction is the only remedy for an 8.5% ROCE it calls unsustainably low.
- 5G launched with no pricing premium, costs loading now: Airtel 5G Plus is live in key cities at 4G-equivalent pricing; management sees a premium as an ARPU illusion and will decide pricing in 6–9 months, while 5G opex begins to weigh on the P&L immediately.
- Churn spiked to 3.3% on SIM arbitrage, not tenure loss: A market-wide gap between new-SIM acquisition cost and existing-plan price is driving switching; management is piloting fixes and calls the dynamic a menace.
- Digital services annualised at ₹960 crores, Payments Bank profitable: The fintech arm crossed 5 crore monthly transacting users with industry-high take rates, while digital revenues grew double digits sequentially.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the full SUC benefit (~₹250 crores incremental) flows through, whether churn pilots begin to bite, and any signal on tariff repair timing.
ARPU & the Tariff Imperative
- ARPU walk: The ₹7 sequential lift came from four levers: more sophisticated acquisition targeting lifting intake quality, feature phone to smartphone upgrades (0.5 crore 4G net adds vs ~0.4 crore last quarter), prepaid-to-postpaid premiumisation, and data monetisation via contextual triggers that sell 1-day, 3-day or 7-day top-ups when a customer exhausts their core allowance.
- Smartphone upgrade recovery is tentative: A 30% industry-wide drop in feature-phone-to-smartphone upgrades over the last 6–8 months reflects entry-level smartphone prices moving from ~₹6,500 to ₹8,500–₹10,000 on semiconductor costs; this quarter improved sequentially but is not yet good enough.
- Postpaid net adds of 300K: Management says Airtel is now the decisive leader in postpaid, a segment it sees as a near-term share-gain opportunity while one competitor is financially pressed.
- ROCE at 8.4% frames the whole tariff argument: Management calls this level very low for a business that takes risk and deploys substantial capex, noting the money could earn a similar return in a bond. The only remedy, it argues, is a tariff correction, but timing is not in Airtel’s hands alone: if it moves and competition does not follow, there is a problem.
Gopal Vittal: "At Rs.190 ARPU, while we do have the highest ARPU in the industry. The fact is that this ARPU was actually higher 7 years ago, it was almost Rs.200."
5G: Launch, Costs & Monetisation Bet
- Launch posture: Airtel 5G Plus commenced in key cities at the same price as 4G; data is treated as data, so any customer with a 5G device gets 5G service automatically. Device readiness is progressing: Xiaomi, Oppo, Vivo and RealMe are ready, Samsung and OnePlus within weeks, Apple by mid-December.
- Why no premium now: Management observed in other markets that pricing 5G at a 10–20% premium produces low take rates, making the headline ARPU an illusion (a small numerator over a large denominator yields little revenue). The real monetisation lever, it argues, is lifting the entire tariff table. A pricing decision will be taken in 6–9 months.
- Cost loading begins immediately: 5G will certainly load additional costs on the P&L; unless tariffs improve, this is an incremental cost. Mitigation comes from the War on Waste programme: further diesel elimination, solar in rural areas, and digitisation to reduce cost-to-serve.
- Network strategy: A specific mode on 3.5 GHz delivers 100 metres more on the downlink vs the 2.3 GHz TDD band, giving good indoor experience without immediate densification. Management does not expect to build more towers for 5G in the next 2–3 years; densification may be needed 5–7 years out. By March 2024, the rollout should cover all urban towns and key rural areas.
- Spectrum refarming flywheel: As the 5G network builds out, a significant part of existing 4G data traffic will migrate to 5G, allowing gradual movement of more spectrum to 5G.
Gopal Vittal: "The 5G will certainly load on additional costs, and unless there is an improvement in tariffs, this will be an additional cost on the P&L."
Churn & the SIM Arbitrage Menace
- Monthly churn elevated at 3.3%: Management is not happy. The large driver is poor acquisition quality, not churn of tenured customers (more than 9–12 months).
- Root cause is a market-wide pricing arbitrage: A new SIM is available for a lower effective price (because of channel commissions) than an existing plan, creating an incentive to switch SIMs. Management calls this a menace that has worsened in recent months.
- Fix in progress: Many pilots were run in the last 30–40 days to improve acquisition quality; some are expected to roll out in coming weeks and months. Separately, the Payments Bank provides a structural churn defence: churn drops by almost 50% the moment a customer’s bank account number matches her mobile number.
Homes, DTH & Digital Services
- Homes broadband accelerating: Present in 1,060 cities through own infrastructure and the LCO model; added 417K customers with ~7% sequential revenue growth. Management sees a market potential of 4–4.5 crore homes against a current base of ~0.52 crore and aims to capture a significant share, though no timeframe was given.
- DTH declined 2.6%, but a turnaround bet is placed: The strategy of doubling down on the largest cable markets (South, Maharashtra, Bengal), simplifying pricing, and bundling OTT/linear content with broadband and mobile is showing early traction; August, September and October showed growing momentum. A customer-definition harmonisation now applies the same stringent 30-day revenue-earning test used in Mobile.
- Digital services annualised at ₹960 crores: Up sequentially at well over double digits, built on digital capabilities that also help the core business. Management declined to break out enterprise vs consumer or specific drivers, calling the streams nascent and volatile.
- Payments Bank is a quiet profit engine: Crossed 5 crore monthly transacting users, take rates at 0.61% (highest in the industry), annual revenue run rate of ₹1,233 crores, and the only profitable fintech player in the industry.
Airtel Business & B2B Runway
- Sequential growth of just under 7%: Airtel Business cemented its position as the largest listed B2B player in the country and gained revenue market share. Management attributes this to trust, privacy, focus on emerging businesses (CPaaS, security, data centers, cloud, IoT), and go-to-market execution.
- Voice is the shrinking piece, making underlying growth faster: Voice revenue within B2B has become smaller in relative contribution and is the one part not growing; connectivity is gaining share, and non-connectivity adjacencies are virgin markets where every deal is incremental.
- IoT/M2M connections almost doubled YoY to ~1.3–1.4 crore: Driven by fleet management, cars, ATMs, meters and government electronic metering plans. Individual SIM ARPU is very low, but consumption is also very low; billing is corporate and aggregated. The business was moved under B2B reporting ~3–4 years ago but is now called out in the investor pack for comparability with peers who report postpaid including M2M/IoT.
- Deepening the portfolio: Management is building a replicable toolkit spanning connectivity to beyond-connectivity (CPaaS, cloud, cybersecurity, data centers), citing case studies of doubling or quadrupling revenue by going deep with the full portfolio.
- SME headcount jump: A significant increase in headcount reflects in-sourcing more than 1,000 people in the SME segment who were earlier off-rolls, to serve SME in a more standardised and elevated manner.
Margins, Costs & the SUC Tailwind
- India EBITDA margin improved to 51.8%: Benefited from continued cost control and the SUC benefits that were part of the seminal telecom reforms of the prior year.
- SUC benefit only half-realised: The SUC reduction was rolled out mid-August 2022, so only half the benefit hit this quarter; the remaining half (~₹250 crores) carries forward to the next quarter.
- SG&A elevated on growth investment: Expenses are significantly up due to multiple initiatives: driving the homes business go-to-market team, rolling out new outlets, and a certain amount of market aggression pushing up channel commissions.
- Voice minutes declined: Possibly seasonal, or possibly people reaching a point of not seeing value in speaking more.
Capital Allocation & the Debt Question
- Capex may be elevated and pulled forward: FY24 could see some advancement of capex from FY25, driven by simultaneous 5G rollout and rural expansion. Radio investments can be turned on or off in 30–60 days, so the company will stay flexible and watch uptake and data-science model results to determine the ultimate level.
- Rural expansion designed for lower cost: Leaner towers for rural areas reduce dependence on diesel at much lower operating cost than current network costs on fuel and rental. Sub-GHz footprint will provide a good proposition; data-science models and field work determine where to go.
- Free cash flow confidence, no guidance: Management is comfortable that operating cash flow can fund all capex requirements even if elevated and pulled forward, plus pay down some debt and spectrum dues. It declined to forecast a specific FCF number for next year, calling it tantamount to guiding the entire business model.
- Debt reduction timeline depends on four variables: EBITDA (tariff cycle, 5G utilisation), capex (whether brought forward), ability and incentive to prepay debt (interest rate cycles), and dividend policy. Management says FCF is building up and sustainable, confidence is high, but cannot say whether net debt reduction to ₹1 lakh crore takes 24, 36 or 48 months. The next 2.5 years of spectrum/AGR moratorium provides extra cash in the system to pay down debt.
Harjeet Kohli: "Arguably, this FCF is building up and is sustainable, confidence is high, but how these variables play out and whether it takes 24 months, 36 months, 48 months, cannot say today."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| 5G rollout coverage | Cover all towns in urban India and key rural areas | By March 2024 |
| 5G pricing decision | Decide on 5G pricing strategy | In 6–9 months |
| SUC benefit realisation | Full-quarter benefit of SUC reduction (~₹250 crores incremental vs Q2) | Next quarter (Q3 FY23) |
| DTH turnaround | Hope to report a better outcome following recent strategy changes | Next quarter (Q3 FY23) |
| Rural coverage gap | Bridge a substantial part of the coverage gap vs the leading player | No date (expansion underway) |
| Capex elevation | Possible short-term elevation of capex, fundamentally an advancement from FY25 to FY24 | FY24 |
| Nxtra renewable energy | Achieve 50% of power requirements through renewable sources | Next 12 months |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated revenue | ₹34,527 cr, +5.3% QoQ |
| India EBITDA margin | 51.8%, benefited by cost control and SUC benefits |
| India & South Asia ROCE | 8.4% |
| Mobile ARPU | ₹190, up from ₹183 QoQ |
| Mobile revenue growth | 4% QoQ |
| 4G net adds | 0.5 cr, recovery from 0.4 cr in Q1 |
| Postpaid net adds | 300K |
| Monthly churn | 3.3% |
| Airtel Business revenue growth | just under 7% QoQ |
| Homes broadband revenue growth | about 7% QoQ |
| Homes broadband customer adds | 417K |
| DTH revenue growth | -2.6% |
| Digital services annualised revenue | ₹960 cr, growing sequentially at well over double digits |
| Payments Bank annualised GMV | $25 bn |
| Payments Bank annual revenue run rate | ₹1,233 cr |
| Payments Bank monthly transacting users | 5 cr |
| Capex run rate | ₹23,000–24,000 cr per year |
| Free cash flow | close to ₹3,500 cr in Q2 |
| Net debt | ₹1.7 lakh cr |
| SUC benefit carried forward to Q3 | ~₹250 cr |